•   
  •   
  •   

OpinionThe real problem of Trump's citizenship question

01:00  05 july  2019
01:00  05 july  2019 Source:   cnn.com

Reopened Legal Challenge to Census Citizenship Question Throws Case Into Chaos

Reopened Legal Challenge to Census Citizenship Question Throws Case Into Chaos The battle over whether to add a citizenship question to the 2020 census was thrown into turmoil on Tuesday, just as the Supreme Court was expected to issue a ruling on the dispute this week. By allowing a district judge to reopen a case related to the origin of the question, a federal appeals court raised the prospect that the federal government might be unable to meet a deadline for completing census questionnaires that include it, regardless of the Supreme Court’s ruling. New hearings in the reopened case would stretch well beyond July 1, which is the deadline for printing the questionnaire and other forms.

The real problem of Trump's citizenship question© Mark Wilson/Getty Images North America/Getty Images WASHINGTON, DC - MAY 14: U.S. President Donald Trump waves as he walks toward Marine One before departing from the White House on May 14, 2019 in Washington, DC. President Trump is traveling to Louisiana. (Photo by Mark Wilson/Getty Images)

Editor’s note: The opinions in this article are the author’s, as published by our content partner, and do not represent the views of MSN or Microsoft.

Even by the chaotic standards of the Trump administration, the battle of whether to include a citizenship question on the 2020 census has become bizarre.

Trump says he'll attempt to 'delay the Census' after Supreme Court decision on citizenship question

Trump says he'll attempt to 'delay the Census' after Supreme Court decision on citizenship question President Donald Trump said on Thursday afternoon that he would attempt to delay the 2020 census following a Supreme Court decision.

The Supreme Court last Thursday temporarily barred the addition of the controversial question. In response, the President tweeted that he asked government lawyers if they can delay the census "no matter how long." But on Tuesday, the government announced that it was going ahead with printing the census forms without the question, basically rendering the issue moot.

Case closed, right? Nope. On Wednesday, Trump tweeted that news reports about the Commerce Department "dropping its quest to put the Citizenship Question on the Census is incorrect, or to state it differently, FAKE!" He said the government was moving ahead with its case to add the question, a position later confirmed by a Justice Department official.

And on Thursday, Axios reported that administration sources said the President is considering issuing an executive order to add the citizenship question. If he did that, it's unclear whether the Supreme Court would affirm that use of his executive power.

Inslee: Trump made 'right decision' to dump citizenship from Census

Inslee: Trump made 'right decision' to dump citizenship from Census The Trump Administration's decision to abandon a hot-charged citizenship question on the 2020 U.S. Census, decision drew qualified praise from Gov. Jay Inslee, who is seeking the Democratic nomination to run against President Trump next year. 

Although Monday was the deadline by which the administration was supposed to have given the go-ahead to printing the census forms, for now the Trump administration seems to be recommitted to further gumming up the decennial count of who is in the United States.

Logistically and legally, it would be problematic to delay the census. Trump's apparent willingness to do so underscores his disregard for our Constitutionally-mandated national count and his politicizing of what should be a nonpartisan exercise.

Each census has an enormous impact on everyone living within our borders. Census data is used to decide congressional districts and how much money state and local governments get for infrastructure, social services, education, and housing. The proposed citizenship question has been controversial because experts and Latino advocacy groups have been united in their belief that it would result in an undercount of the Hispanic population. The Trump administration maintained that citizenship data was necessary to help enforce the Voting Rights Act.

Justice Department Reverses Course on Citizenship Question on Census, Citing Trump’s Orders

Justice Department Reverses Course on Citizenship Question on Census, Citing Trump’s Orders A day after pledging that the 2020 census would not ask respondents about their citizenship, the Justice Department reversed course on Wednesday and said it was hunting for a way to restore the question on orders from President Trump. Officials told a federal judge in Maryland that they thought there would be a way to still add the question, despite printing deadlines, and that they would ask the Supreme Court to send the case to district court with instructions to remedy the situation.

Before the Supreme Court ruled on whether the citizenship question could be added to the census, the Trump administration had insisted that July 1 was an important deadline. "The Census Bureau must finalize the census forms by the end of June 2019 to print them on time for the 2020 decennial census," wrote US Solicitor General Noel Francisco in a court brief filed in January. However, NPR reporting notes that since the court made its ruling, administration officials have not spoken about the census with such urgency. So, what changed?

The only thing that has changed is a Supreme Court decision the administration did not like. The high court ruled that the administration's basis for adding the question was "pretextual" and failed to provide a legitimate reason for including it. The majority held that the administration could try to come up with another rationale and submit it to the court for review. The problem is, that all takes time.

While it is unclear how the Justice Department will proceed with its apparent mandate to pursue the citizenship question issue – it could go back to the lower courts or perhaps make a special appeal to the Supreme Court again – the census is still a pressing matter. Consider that about 600 million documents need to be printed, and then organized to be sent to 130 million households. The first forms are slated to be sent in January to rural Alaskans.

‘Are you proud to be an American?’ Why Trump’s 4th of July was a tale of three different celebrations

‘Are you proud to be an American?’ Why Trump’s 4th of July was a tale of three different celebrations Donald Trump's role in the 4th of July created three different events: a protest, campaign rally and a holiday for families to enjoy fireworks.

If the administration dallies on moving ahead with the census, the timetable for the count could be at risk. Former Census Bureau Director John Thompson has warned that delaying the census would cost more money and would likely increase the chances of errors.

Delaying the census could also put the administration at risk for breaking the law, as Title 13 of the US Code mandates that the decennial census of population take place every 10 years, 'as of the first day of April.'"

Trump has shown himself to be ignorant of what is at stake here. "I think it's very important to find out if somebody is a citizen as opposed to an illegal," he said on Monday. "There's a big difference to me between being a citizen of the United States and being an illegal."

In fact, the proposed citizenship question on the census does not inquire about immigration status. It only asks if a person is a US citizen. A person who answered "no" is not necessarily an undocumented immigrant – he or she could be a green card holder or a foreign national on a work or student visa. How telling it is that Trump apparently equates all non-US citizens present in the country as "illegal."

True, some people think the US should have a count of how many citizens are living here. But the government can get that information from the American Community Survey.

Sadly, the ongoing controversy over the citizenship question -- coupled with Trump's increased immigration enforcement actions -- means that damage has already been done among immigrant communities. Fear of this administration will likely keep many Latino and immigrant families from responding to the census anyway.

The government should not make matters worse by slow-walking the process. Nor should Trump be giving the public political whiplash by making policy decisions by tweet because the more confusion that is sowed over the census, the more likely it is that some people opt out.

The 2020 census is not Trump's census, it is our census. It is by and for the American people, and it must be carried out without further delay.


Read More

Claims That Obama ‘Yanked’ Citizenship Question From Census Are False.
What Was Said “The real controversy here is who took the citizenship question off of the census, and why? Why is it controversy wanting to know who among us happens to be a citizen and who isn’t? Why is that controversial? It would seem to me that this kind of attention should have been asked when somebody in the Obama regime decided to get rid of it.” — Rush Limbaugh, a conservative commentator, on Friday “Why can’t we just ask the question the way it was asked for 50 years before the Obama administration yanked it out of there?” — Kellyanne Conway, the White House counselor, on Tuesday False.

Topical videos:

usr: 1
This is interesting!