Opinion Trump and Erdogan Are Only Increasing the Odds of an ISIS Comeback
Erdogan, Trump to meet next month in Washington amid Syria tensions: Turkey
President Trump and his Turkish counterpart Recep Tayyip Erdoğan have agreed to meet in Washington in November amid tensions over Syria, Reuters reported Sunday.The agreement came during a phone call Sunday where the two leaders discussed a "safe zone" east of the Euphrates River in Syria from which Kurdish fighters would be withdraw, Ankara reportedly announced.The Hill has reached out to the White House for comment.Conflict between the U.S. and Turkey over Kurdish fighters in Syria has been brewing for years.America is allied with the Syrian Kurdish YPG militia, which the U.S.
Editor’s note: The opinions in this article are the author’s, as published by our content partner, and do not necessarily represent the views of MSN or Microsoft.
Three days after President Donald Trump’s
White House says Turkey's Syria operation is imminent, US troops won't be present
The White House on Sunday night said Turkey will soon be launching a military operation in northeastern Syria and that U.S. troops will no longer be "in the immediate area" when it happens."Turkey will soon be moving forward with its long-planned operation into Northern Syria. The United States Armed Forces will not support or be involved in the operation, and United States forces, having defeated the ISIS territorial 'Caliphate,' will no longer be in the immediate area," White House press secretary Stephanie Grisham said in a statement.
CNNthat so far, Turkish airstrikes have largely hit military targets, but the Kurdish-led Syrian Democratic Forces (SDF) claimed warplanes were also hitting civilian areas. “There is a huge panic among people of the region,” SDF spokesman Mustafa Bali said. The streets in norther Syria are choked with civilian fleeing the area, unsure of how extensive the Turkish operation will be.
Despite Erdogan’s claim that his goal is “to bring peace” to the region, the assault seems likely to do the exact opposite — even beyond the immediate horrors inflicted on our Kurdish allies.
There was never going to be a good time for a move like this, but Trump and Erdogan may have chosen a particularly bad one. (Not that the decision, which apparently came, was made with much geostrategic forethought on Trump’s part.) Everyone from to has raised concerns that in abandoning the SDF and leaving them at the mercy of the Turkish military, the U.S. will inadvertently strengthen the remnants of the Islamic State. Critics have also warned that the move could benefit the tyrannical regime of Syrian president Bashar al-Assad and his Iranian puppet masters.
Trump defends Syria move: The Kurds 'didn't help us' in Normandy
President Trump on Wednesday criticized the Kurds, saying they didn't help the United States during World War II and that they were only fighting for their land in Syria during the battle against ISIS."The Kurds are fighting for their land," Trump told reporters at the White House during an event in the Roosevelt Room."And as somebody wrote in a very, very powerful article today, they didn't help us in the second World War, they didn't"The Kurds are fighting for their land," Trump told reporters at the White House during an event in the Roosevelt Room.
Fear of an ISIS resurgence has underpinned the continued U.S. presence in Syria after the much-toutedby U.S.-backed local militias over its ultra-violent, theocratic pseudostate earlier this year. Trump first ordered a from Syria last December, claiming that the war was won, but was forced to walk back that decision after his defense secretary resigned over it and the Republican-controlled Senate rebuked him. The defense establishment’s perspective on the fight against ISIS is that destroying the caliphate was the first phase, while the endgame would entail wiping out the extremist group’s residual presence and creating conditions in which it cannot reestablish itself. The general consensus is that U.S. forces still have a role to play in securing the Middle East against such a regrouping.
There is logic to this vigilance. The Pentagon believes there are still approximately 18,000 Islamic State insurgents in the Syrian and Iraqi deserts, who continue to carry out terrorist attacks against military, government, and civilian targets, and the Iraqi military is havingcleaning up these holdouts, who reportedly carried out almost 100 attacks in the first three weeks of September. The group’s globally distributed network of terrorist affiliates continue to plot and carry out large-scale attacks like the Easter Sunday in Sri Lanka.
ISIS prisoners: 'Huge concerns' thousands may escape as Turkey invades Syria
Fears are growing among American officials that thousands of ISIS fighters may escape from prisons in Syria as the Kurdish personnel guarding them gear up for a fight with Turkey, which launched a military offensive in northeastern Syria on Wednesday. Turkey's assault has already had a "detrimental effect" on American counter-ISIS operations, which have "effectively stopped," a senior US defense official told CNN on Wednesday.
Trump’s decision to finally fulfill his campaign promise to get out of Syria has won over some opponents of U.S. intervention in the Middle East. Senator Rand Paulit as “fulfill[ing] his promises to stop our endless wars and have a true America First foreign policy” and Trump against the “Neocon war caucus” within their party that was roundly criticizing him. While noting the recklessness of the president’s sudden policy shift, The Week’s Damon Linker Trump’s critics to defend the merits of the alternative: an open-ended mission to make sure Syria can’t become a terrorist haven again — not unlike what we’ve been trying and failing to do in Afghanistan for nearly two decades.
For his part, Trump has argued that whatever leftovers of the Islamic State remain in Iraq and Syria, they are thousands of miles away and can be dealt with by the countries more immediately affected by their presence, unless or until they become a threat to the U.S. again. As the presidentAmericans on Twitter: “We are 7000 miles away and will crush ISIS again if they come anywhere near us!”
Trump defends Syria withdrawal amid reports of atrocities and ISIS supporters escaping
Turkey's invasion of northeastern Syria began Wednesday after Trump ordered U.S. troops to pull back from the area.The U.S. is evacuating 1,000 U.S. troops from the region "as safely and quickly as possible" in the face of Turkey's rapid military advance against the Kurds, Defense Secretary Mark Esper told CBS' "Face the Nation" Sunday. Esper said the troops would not leave Syria completely.
There are some merits to the argument that the U.S. has no business trying to fix these broken countries beyond whatever level of engagement our national security demands. Yet setting aside the big-picture questions of morality and realpolitik in U.S. foreign policy, there are a few specific reasons why a U.S. drawdown in northeastern Syria now, and a Turkish invasion of the region, might improve the chances of ISIS reforming in its home base.
First, the White House withdrawal announcementthat Turkey will take responsibility for the thousands of former Islamic State fighters being held prisoner along with tens of thousands of their relatives in camps there — already hotbeds of radicalization and new recruitment for the group. An orderly hand over of the camps from the SDF to Turkey is difficult to imagine; instead, the Kurds may scale back or abandon these detention operations as they divert resources to defending against the Turkish invasion, while there is no guarantee that Turkey will take on these detention obligations or carry them out effectively.
Our Kurdish proxies in Syria did most of the frontline dirty work in the campaign against the Islamic State, in which they say they lost over 10,000 soldiers. Like the Iraqis, theyISIS militants, who have carried out hundreds of attacks in northeastern Syria this year. Cut off from U.S. support, the SDF won’t be able to fight Turkey and maintain its counterinsurgency role against ISIS at the same time, giving the militants breathing room. Coupled with prison breaks from the unguarded camps, this could offer the Islamic State its best opportunity yet to regain its strength.
Turkey's Erdogan says alternatives to F-35 jets ready, receiving offers
Turkey's alternatives for the U.S. F-35 stealth fighter jets are ready and "offers are coming in", President Tayyip Erdogan was cited as saying by broadcaster NTV on Tuesday. © Reuters/Djordje Kojadinovic Turkish President Tayyip Erdogan attends a joint press conference with Serbia's President Aleksandar Vucic after their meeting in Belgrade Ankara and Washington have clashed over Turkey's purchase of Russian S-400 missile defenses, which the United States says are not compatible with NATO defenses and pose a threat to Lockheed Martin Corp's F-35 stealth jets.
Meanwhile, Erdogan’s plan to resettle Syrian refugees in the border region isto contribute to instability there. The Turkish president has presented his demand for a “safe zone” in northern Syria as a humanitarian effort, but his ulterior motive is to stymie nationalist ambitions in the Kurdish-majority parts of Syria by flooding them with mostly non-local Arab refugees: what Nicholas Heras, a specialist on Syria and ISIS at the Center for a New American Security, “just dressed-up ethnic cleansing.” At the same time, the Turkish incursion into Syria may tens of thousands of newly displaced people, who would likely flee into Iraqi Kurdistan.
Speaking of which, Iraq is in a particularly bad position to deal with such a crisis on its border right now. For the past week, the country has been experiencing a wave of unrestby the firing of a popular general who played a major role in routing the Islamic State there, but fed by the mounting frustrations of a generation of young Iraqis who have grown up in an atmosphere of violence, corruption, poverty, and inequality. Iraqi security forces have over 100 protesters and injured more than 6,000. The internet has been shut down, journalists threatened and media outlets raided.
The Iraqi demonstrators are calling for “the downfall of the regime” of Prime Minister Adel Abdul Mahdi — and they might get their wish. The collapse of the government or an escalation in its violent response to the protests could destabilize Iraq in a way that also hinders the hunt for Islamic State remnants and opens up more safe havens and recruiting opportunities for the group. With Turkey destabilizing northern Syria and Iraq reeling from the consequences of poor governance, ISIS could soon be looking at its first real chance for a comeback.
Trump's Syria letter reportedly made Erdogan so angry, he threw it in the trash .
Trump's letter attempting to convince Erdogan not to attack U.S.-allied Kurds in Syria drew both condemnation and ridicule from critics in Washington. But it apparently angered no one more than the recipient himself, according to the official, who recounted the incident to a Turkish newspaper on Thursday."The letter was written on 9 October. Erdogan rejected the offer of mediation and it was thrown into the trash. The clearest answer to this letter was the reply given at 4pm on 9 October. This is was the start of Operation Peace Spring," the official told local newspaper Yeni Safak.
Syria Pullout Shows US No Longer Predictable: Richard Haass | Morning Joe | MSNBC
The Morning Joe panel discusses the fallout from President Trump's decision to withdraw U.S. forces from the northern border of Syria and allow a Turkish ...
PBS NewsHour full episode October 8, 2019
Tuesday on the NewsHour, the White House blocks a key player in the Ukraine affair from appearing before House lawmakers. Also: The Supreme Court hears ...
Tuesday, 22 october 2019
A president who has long ignored criticism is suddenly giving in, reversing course on the G7 summit and withdrawal from Syria.Donald Trump’s administration has beat a hasty retreat from the mountains of “Get over it” to the deserts of “Never […]
Monday, 21 october 2019
Everything Trump does is designed to turn all criticism of himself into a socialist-liberal-radical conspiracy.The Fifth Avenue Murder Theory now faces its toughest […]
Monday, 21 october 2019
Circumstances change; core principles do not. The country’s oldest foreign-policy tradition still finds its home on the right.Underneath all of the day-to-day tumult, for both critics and supporters the Trump presidency has come to represent nothing less than a resurgence of American […]
Monday, 21 october 2019
For weeks Donald Trump and his defenders have insisted that his decision to hold up aid to Ukraine was not dependent on that nation investigating Trump’s political opponents in the United States. They all insisted that there was no quid pro quo. But, last week the acting White House chief […]
Monday, 21 october 2019
We face a terrible choice, but leaving him in office is the worst alternative.No one has worked more aggressively to trigger impeachment than the president. You may remember that, during the campaign, then-candidate Donald Trump suggested that, should he win, he might become one of the […]
Tuesday, 22 october 2019
The 2020 election is not about capitalism or socialism; it’s not about Ukraine or Syria or Joe Biden or even Donald Trump. The vote in November of next year will be about personal freedom.The 2020 election is not about capitalism or socialism; it's not about Ukraine or Syria or Joe Biden […]
Tuesday, 22 october 2019
She proposes to lock in high-earning, highly taxed Americans, penning them in order that they may be shorn and milked as though they were livestock.Editor’s note: The opinions in this article are the author’s, as published by our content partner, and do not necessarily represent the views […]
Monday, 21 october 2019
Before she enters the 2020 race, Hillary Clinton should review what voters are saying about another run. A recent Rasmussen poll shows that fully 71 percent of voters say she should not run, including 58 percent of her own party. That’s not a great starting point. Though Hillary is quite […]