Opinion: Pete Buttigieg's disingenuous attack on Medicare-for-All - - PressFrom - US
  •   
  •   
  •   

Opinion Pete Buttigieg's disingenuous attack on Medicare-for-All

09:41  16 october  2019
09:41  16 october  2019 Source:   theweek.com

Democrat Buttigieg floats plan to slash rising drug costs

  Democrat Buttigieg floats plan to slash rising drug costs Democrat Buttigieg floats plan to slash rising drug costsButtigieg, the mayor of South Bend, Indiana, said his plan would cut out-of-pocket prescription drug costs for seniors on the Medicare government insurance program by at least 50% by the end of his first term and cap costs for out-of-pocket prescription drug costs for anyone who chooses his public insurance plan at under $250 per month.

Pete Buttigieg Pushes Gun Safety at SXSW - Продолжительность: 1:53 Bloomberg TicToc 5 456 просмотров. Stephen Colbert Grills Tulsi Gabbard for Rejecting the U. S . Empire' s Propaganda - Продолжительность: 11:03 The Humanist Report 78 479 просмотров.

What are Pete ' s Views on Medicare for All . You might be surprised to find he is very prudent in the way he answers for a good reason.

Editor’s note: The opinions in this article are the author’s, as published by our content partner, and do not necessarily represent the views of MSN or Microsoft.

Elizabeth Warren, Peter Buttigieg are posing for a picture: warren pete© Photo by Win McNamee/Getty Images warren pete

In the Democratic presidential debate Tuesday night, once again Medicare-for-All was a major focus of discussion. Once again, Bernie Sanders and Elizabeth Warren defended the plan against all comers — most especially Pete Buttigieg, who had a number of slick arguments about how universal Medicare would be a disaster.

There's just one problem: None of Mayor Pete's arguments are true.

Buttigieg leveled two main attacks. First, along with the moderators, he pressed Warren to admit that she would raise taxes on the middle class to pay for her Medicare-for-All plan. After the New York Times' Mark Lacey asked her if she should "acknowledge" she would raise taxes, she partly dodged the question, saying: "So the way I see this, it is about what kinds of costs middle-class families are going to face. So let me be clear on this. Costs will go up for the wealthy. They will go up for big corporations. And for middle-class families, they will go down."

Florida mayor raised $5 in latest quarter of long shot presidential bid

  Florida mayor raised $5 in latest quarter of long shot presidential bid Miramar, Florida, Mayor Wayne Messam raised just $5 for his presidential bid in the third quarter of 2019. © Provided by MediaDC: Washington Newspaper Publishing Company, Inc.Messam received only one contribution totaling $5 and spent $0 on his campaign in this quarter, according to his Federal Election Commission filing. Because he didn’t spend any money on his campaign, the mayor still has $31,151 on hand from the previous quarter, including his first-quarter haul. The dismal fundraising effort puts Messam in last place of the major Democratic candidates who have announced.

Pete Buttigieg Flips on Medicare For All , Still Pretends to Support It - Продолжительность: 14:47 The Humanist Report 17 313 просмотров. Pete Buttigieg Climbs In The Polls - Продолжительность: 5:05 Rebel HQ 31 042 просмотра.

South Bend Mayor Pete Buttigieg , a declared 2020 presidential candidate, on Sunday said a single-payer health care system is "the right place for us to head as Buttigieg responded to questions from ABC host George Stephanopoulos about whether Medicare for all means an end to private insurance.

Buttigieg pounced: "Well, we heard it tonight, a yes or no question that didn't get a yes or no answer. Look, this is why people here in the Midwest are so frustrated with Washington in general and Capitol Hill in particular."

It's very obvious why Warren refuses to say this outright, and it is arguably more accurate for her to do so. In the hegemonic neoliberal framework of American political rhetoric, taxes are always a net cost by definition — something that is taken from the American citizenry and spent on government boondoggles or welfare for poor people. Warren doesn't want to hand Donald Trump any attack lines about how she will raise taxes by focusing on what matters — namely, net costs for average people.

And as HuffPost's Arthur Delaney notes, Medicare-for-All critics are leveraging this framework.

Democratic candidates go after Elizabeth Warren over how much her Medicare for All plan will cost at Ohio debate

  Democratic candidates go after Elizabeth Warren over how much her Medicare for All plan will cost at Ohio debate Mayor Pete Buttigieg framed Sens. Elizabeth Warren and Bernie Sanders' single-payer plan as "Medicare for all, whether you want it or not."Buttigieg kicked off the spirited discussion by accusing Warren of not releasing details on how she'd play for a single-payer health program, which would cost the federal government tens of trillions of dollars.

Democratic presidential candidate Pete Buttigieg weighed in on his opponents' plans to implement " Medicare for All " and free college tuition, calling them "questionable on their merits" and "pretty far out from where Americans are.".

Buttigieg is correct that the Sanders and Warren plans would eliminate private health insurance for everything that Medicare for All covers, which is pretty much everything that private health insurance covers. But Buttigieg ’ s plan, while it would greatly expand access to coverage, would not necessarily

The tax question is a trap, premised on the idea that raising taxes is always bad politics. The moderator already knows the candidate's position. Both the moderator and the candidate believe that answering with a simple “yes” would launch a thousand Republican attack ads. Not answering doesn't work either. After the September debate, TV analysts and the Republican National Committee bashed Warren for not disavowing taxes and not embracing them. [HuffPost]

What really matters here is that, while Medicare-for-All would require some additional taxes on the middle class, those increases would be more than compensated for by zeroing out premiums, co-pays, and deductibles. As economist Gabriel Zucman explains:

Now, one could take a different view on the best way to respond to this type of question. Bernie Sanders forthrightly admits that Medicare-for-All would require some additional taxation on the average citizen, but that would be more than compensated by reduced cost: "Under the Medicare-for-All bill that I wrote, premiums are gone. Co-payments are gone. Deductibles are gone. All out-of-pocket expenses are gone … the overwhelming majority of people will save money on their health care bills. But I do think it is appropriate to acknowledge that taxes will go up."

Second, Buttigieg claimed that Medicare-for-All would cost trillions: "No plan has been laid out to explain how a multi-trillion-dollar hole in this Medicare-for-All plan that Senator Warren is putting forward is supposed to get filled in." On the specifics, Buttigieg is wrong — actually, the Sanders Medicare bill (which Warren supports) has a lot of funding mechanisms outlined.

Democrats Get Bogged Down In Same Gotcha Tax Question At Every Debate

  Democrats Get Bogged Down In Same Gotcha Tax Question At Every Debate Despite repeated demands by a moderator and her Democratic presidential opponents, Sen. Elizabeth Warren of Massachusetts refused to take the bait on a question about tax hikes on the debate stage Tuesday night in Ohio. Despite repeated demands by a moderator and her Democratic presidential opponents, Sen. Elizabeth Warren of Massachusetts refused to take the bait on a question about tax hikes on the debate stage Tuesday night in Ohio.

Democratic presidential candidate Pete Buttigieg unveiled a health care proposal Friday that would offer " Medicare for all who want it” while maintaining the current system of private health insurance. Buttigieg says he wants to “make progress toward universal health care” by building on the

Buttigieg calls his plan “ Medicare for All Who Want It,” and the governing idea is that it’ s transitional—a compromise that could pave the way for a true Medicare for All system. If Mayor Pete wanted Medicare for All in America, he would make it a policy priority instead of promoting a

But on a deeper level, Buttigeig's argument is even more deceptive. He was likely referencing the study from the libertarian Mercatus Center about how much additional tax revenue would be needed to finance Medicare-for-All — just over $30 trillion, as Joe Biden said later. What that figure leaves out is that total health care spending under universal Medicare would go down by some $2 trillion over a decade.

And what it further leaves out is that the Mercatus Center is a hack propaganda shop whose work is heavily biased against progressive policy. As I have previously explained in detail, what Medicare-for-All would cost depends entirely on how much policymakers want to crack down on waste and fraud, and squeeze down the prices of providers. Indeed, we could have universal Medicare without a dime in additional taxes if we crushed prices down to Canadian levels.

These savings would come from eliminating duplicative administration and the price-setting power over providers that universal Medicare would provide. Those savings would necessarily be less in more fragmented systems which would preserve private insurance — like the one proposed by Pete Buttigeig. In other words, Mayor Pete's plan would be more expensive than Medicare-for-All. He would "pay for that" by keeping more of the cost burden on the shoulders of individual Americans.

I, for one, have had quite enough of Buttigieg's glib turbo-wonk shtick. He simply is not being straight with the American people.

Democrat Buttigieg used marijuana 'a handful of times' .
LAS VEGAS (AP) — Democratic presidential candidate Pete Buttigieg said Wednesday that he's used marijuana "a handful of times a long time ago," and that it's time for the U.S. to legalize marijuana. Buttigieg, speaking to reporters after touring a legal pot dispensary in suburban Las Vegas, was asked about whether he'd ever used marijuana. "I have. A handful of times a long time ago," he said. He added that he knows people whose lives have been "shaken" by its criminalization and the so-called "war on drugs."Buttigieg said people still have an image of the marijuana industry and dispensaries that's based on outdated stereotypes.

—   Share news in the SOC. Networks

Topical videos:

usr: 2
This is interesting!