•   
  •   
  •   

Opinion Can Bernie Sanders Solve the Democrats’ Medicare for All Dilemma?

20:55  05 december  2019
20:55  05 december  2019 Source:   nymag.com

Bernie Sanders condemns MLB proposal to cut 42 minor-league teams

  Bernie Sanders condemns MLB proposal to cut 42 minor-league teams United States Senator and Democratic presidential candidate Bernie Sanders is urging Major League Baseball and commissioner Rob Manfred against potentially cutting more than 40 minor-league teams. "I am writing to urge you and the owners of Major League Baseball franchises not to eliminate any of the 42 Minor League Baseball clubs that have been put on the chopping block," Sanders wrote in an open letter Monday. "Shutting down 25 percent of"I am writing to urge you and the owners of Major League Baseball franchises not to eliminate any of the 42 Minor League Baseball clubs that have been put on the chopping block," Sanders wrote in an open letter Monday.

Editor’s note: The opinions in this article are the author’s, as published by our content partner, and do not necessarily represent the views of MSN or Microsoft.

a man wearing a suit and tie: Mr. Incremental Health Reform? Scott Heins/Getty Images© Scott Heins/Getty Images Mr. Incremental Health Reform? Scott Heins/Getty Images

In the fond hopes of those who consider some sort of single-payer health-care system essential, 2020 once looked like the year that would give their movement a giant leap forward. Initially no fewer than 13 Democratic presidential candidates (Cory Booker, Pete Buttigieg, Bill de Blasio, Julián Castro, Tulsi Gabbard, Kirsten Gillibrand, Kamala Harris, Tim Ryan, Bernie Sanders, Tom Steyer, Eric Swalwell, Elizabeth Warren, and Andrew Yang) said they favored some sort of single-payer plan. Booker, Gillibrand, Harris, and Warren were original cosponsors of Bernie Sanders’s signature Medicare for All bill, an uncompromising version of single-payer, while Gabbard, Ryan, and Swalwell had co-sponsored the House counterpart bill.

Sanders, Buttigieg surge in New Hampshire as Biden, Warren slip: poll

  Sanders, Buttigieg surge in New Hampshire as Biden, Warren slip: poll White House hopeful Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.) surged to the lead in New Hampshire's first-in-the-nation primary, followed by South Bend, Ind., Mayor Pete Buttigieg in second place, according to a new Emerson College poll released Tuesday. © Greg Nash Sanders, Buttigieg surge in New Hampshire as Biden, Warren slip: poll Sanders led the Democratic primary field with 26 percent support among primary voters, trailed by Buttigieg at 22 percent. Former Vice President Joe Biden and Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.) each had 14 percent, while no other candidate broke double digits.

But as the invisible primary segment of the 2020 cycle proceeded with its debates and fast-changing rivalries, support for Sanders-style M4A splintered, and public support for it declined significantly, too. The latter erosion of once-robust majorities favoring Sanders’s approach was likely attributable to a combination of relentless attacks from the health-care industry, and to a growing public understanding that “Medicare for All” really meant single-payer health-care, with no room for the private insurance policies that, after all, about 40 percent of Medicare beneficiaries had chosen through the Medicare Advantage option.

Sanders: Scripture calls for renewed focus on justice in US

  Sanders: Scripture calls for renewed focus on justice in US Democratic presidential hopeful Bernie Sanders says Scripture calls for a renewed focus on justice. He also tells a church congregation in Columbia, South Carolina, that the US needs “a nation and government that works for all of us, not just wealthy campaign contributors.” The Vermont senator also tells a church congregation in Columbia, South Carolina, that the United States needs “a nation and government that works for all of us, not just wealthy campaign contributors.

Partly thanks to debate moderator interest in sowing conflict among the Democratic candidates, hair-splitting over the details of various Medicare for All and then Medicare for Most proposals became and remained a prominent part of intraparty conflict. And before long, supporters of progressive candidates were using the health-care postures of their opponents to paint them as corporate sell-outs, while supporters of moderate candidates scored M4A as a general election loser. Far from ushering in a consensus for a big leap toward universal health coverage, the M4A debate has unsettled the Democratic Party on the one issue they think they “own” against Republicans. At least one major candidate, Kamala Harris, arguably ran a promising campaign right into the ground via feckless efforts to take and explain a more nuanced position.

As Vox’s Ezra Klein explains, M4A has become almost entirely a symbolic issue:

Biden says AOC doesn’t represent views of most Democrats: You 'got it all wrong'

  Biden says AOC doesn’t represent views of most Democrats: You 'got it all wrong' Former Vice President Joe Biden, an in interview to air this week, said that Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez is out of step with the mainstream of the Democratic Party, and that media outlets reporting that the party has moved to the left have misjudged the political situation. © Provided by FOX NewsBiden was asked in an interview with “Axios on HBO” what he thought of “Medicare-for-all” plans being pushed by 2020 presidential rivals Sen. Bernie Sanders, I-Vt., and Sen. Elizabeth Warren, D-Mass. While Biden has called for health care reform, he has warned against a full-blown government-run takeover.

In Democratic Party politics, Medicare has become a which-side-are-you-on test. Are you with Sanders and the left, and against insurance companies, squishy moderates, commodified health care, and a politics of preemptive compromise? Or are you afraid that Sanders and the left are going to scare the country into reelecting Donald Trump and set health care reform back for a generation?

This is a fundamentally political question, and splitting the difference through complex acts of technocracy ends up alienating both sides.

That was definitely true of Kamala Harris’s proposal, and Elizabeth Warren’s transition plan to M4A was quickly attacked by hardcore single-payer fans as a sell-out. But as Klein notes, there’s an air of unreality about all these arguments, because M4A simply isn’t happening in the near-term:

The ferocity of this debate is at odds with the legislative reality. Even if a Democrat wins, Medicare-for-all will not pass the House and it will not pass the Senate. “I’m not a big fan of Medicare for All,” House Speaker Nancy Pelosi said. When I interviewed the key Senate Democrats who will write the next health reform bill, none of them supported Medicare-for-all or believed it could pass.

Bernie Sanders promises ‘high-speed internet for all’ through publicly-owned broadband service

  Bernie Sanders promises ‘high-speed internet for all’ through publicly-owned broadband service Sen. Bernie Sanders rolled out an ambitious plan Friday that would categorize internet service as a public utility as part of his 2020 presidential campaign. The proposal would provide $150 billion worth of grants and aid to help local governments build broadband internet infrastructure. Sanders’ plan also pledges to break up the large corporations that dominate internet and cable service.© Provided by Geekwire Sen. Bernie Sanders (Facebook Photo / Bernie Sanders) “High-speed internet service must be treated as the new electricity — a public utility that everyone deserves as a basic human right,” the proposal says.

So are Democrats doomed to fight each other over M4A right up to and beyond the 2020 elections, feeding Republican attack lines on them as both feckless and socialistic?

Klein suggests a sort of Nixon-to-China solution: Anoint Sanders the nominee (or at least the chief Democratic spokesman on health-care, I suppose) as the one candidate with the progressive street cred to gently explain to single-payer advocates that compromise will be necessary:

Sanders also has a unique level of credibility with the party’s more ideological left wing. His commitment to Medicare-for-all is sufficiently steadfast that leftists will believe him if and when he has to convince them that the compromised bill Congress is prepared to pass is the best bill they’re going to get. He wrote the damn bill; he might be the only one who can cut the damn deal. And if Sanders was able to get an ambitious Medicare-for-more plan through Congress and make it look like a compromise, it’d be a tremendous legislative coup.

This does make some sense, because Sanders either has — or will have to — develop a Plan B when the pixie-dust “political revolution” he has claimed will suddenly sweep Congress toward M4A fails to materialize. But in the mean time, of course, making M4A official party gospel will expose the party to a multi-billion-dollar “no socialized medicine” campaign during the general election.

Perhaps it would be best for Democrats to muddle through the primaries while trying to keep differences on health-care policy from appearing as vast as the gulf between virtually all Democrats and virtually all Republicans. But if they do win, whether he’s president of the United States or simply a very distinguished U.S. senator, Bernie Sanders may still be called to the patriotic duty of explaining that the “political revolution” has its limits.

Coalition of more than 50 progressive groups to endorse Sanders .
The Center for Popular Democracy announced it was endorsing Sen. Bernie Sanders in the Democratic presidential primary race. © The Hill Sen. Bernie Sanders received 75 percent of the coalition's vote.Sanders received 75 percent of the votes cast by groups in the coalition's network to pick a candidate to back in the organization's first-ever presidential endorsement, the group said. require(["medianetNativeAdOnArticle"], function (medianetNativeAdOnArticle) { medianetNativeAdOnArticle.

—   Share news in the SOC. Networks

Topical videos:

usr: 0
This is interesting!