Opinion Democratic candidates' payroll tax hikes will hamper the economy

21:35  13 february  2020
21:35  13 february  2020 Source:   washingtonexaminer.com

Can Bernie Sanders tackle the question of electability?

  Can Bernie Sanders tackle the question of electability? With the Iowa caucus just four days away, the Democratic presidential candidates are making a last-ditch appeal to “future former Republican voters,” as Pete Buttigieg described them. These are the voters still on the fence, the centrists that could be swayed by the right candidate. require(["medianetNativeAdOnArticle"], function (medianetNativeAdOnArticle) { medianetNativeAdOnArticle.getMedianetNativeAds(true); }); As November approaches, these voters will become even more important, and so will electability.

Editor’s note: The opinions in this article are the author’s, as published by our content partner, and do not necessarily represent the views of MSN or Microsoft.

Elizabeth Warren, Bernie Sanders are posing for a picture© Provided by Washington Examiner

The recent debates over how to fix growing budget deficits, recently highlighted by President Trump's fiscal year 2021 budget proposal and the latest Congressional Budget Office report, have motivated major Democratic presidential candidates to propose tax changes to the federal government’s funding of Social Security and Medicare, the major federal entitlement programs driving much of the projected budget deficit over the next 10 years. Unlike proposals that rely on spending cuts to ensure that the budget deficit is closed, these tax proposals would raise payroll tax rates and expand the payroll tax base for high earners.

Buttigieg Pulls Ahead in Iowa’s National Delegate Count, AP Says

  Buttigieg Pulls Ahead in Iowa’s National Delegate Count, AP Says Pete Buttigieg has pulled ahead of Bernie Sanders in delegates to the Democratic National Convention after the Associated Press updated its tally Friday. © Brian Snyder Campaign signs for Democratic presidential candidates Pete Buttigieg and Bernie Sanders stand in the snow in Manchester, New Hampshire, on February 7, 2020. Buttigieg now has 13 delegates to Sanders’ 12. Other candidates receiving delegates: Elizabeth Warren, 8; Joe Biden, 6, and Amy Klobuchar, 1.Buttigieg and Sanders had been tied at 11 delegates each in the AP count.

These Democratic candidate payroll tax proposals, while helping to close the budget gap driven by entitlement spending, would harm economic growth and would need to be paired with other reforms to ensure the budget shortfall is closed.

Currently, employees and employers both contribute 6.2% of employee wages for Social Security up to a wage cap, set at $137,700 in tax year 2020. This means that wages above $137,700 are not taxed for the Social Security payroll tax. In addition, employees and employers contribute 1.45% of wages to Medicare, totaling 2.9%. This amount is not capped, meaning all wages are subject to the Medicare payroll tax.

AP FACT CHECK: Examining claims from the Democratic debate

  AP FACT CHECK: Examining claims from the Democratic debate Seven Democratic presidential candidates sparred Friday night in a wide-ranging debate held in the pivotal days before the New Hampshire primary. A look at how some of their claims from Manchester, New Hampshire, compare with the facts: ANDREW YANG, tech entrepreneur: “We have record high corporate profits in this country right now.” THE FACTS: Corporate profits are high, but they’re not at record levels. Companies earned $1.84A look at how some of their claims from Manchester, New Hampshire, compare with the facts:

Workers with wages above $250,000 when filing jointly ($200,000 single) are also subject to a 0.9% additional Medicare tax on wages above that threshold for a combined payroll tax rate of 3.8%.

The payroll tax is typically considered a regressive tax, as lower-paid workers face a combined payroll tax rate of 15.3%, while higher earners pay marginal tax rates of up to 3.8% on wages above the Social Security wage cap. This regressivity is offset by the progressive nature of Social Security benefits, which provide greater benefits to lower earners when compared to the tax paid into the program.

The top five Democratic candidates coming out of Iowa all want to increase the amount of wages subject to the payroll tax. For example, former Vice President Joe Biden proposes to impose the 12.4% Social Security payroll tax on wages over $400,000.

Sen. Bernie Sanders, Sen. Amy Klobuchar, and former South Bend, Indiana, Mayor Pete Buttigieg propose a similar change, applying the 12.4% tax on wages over $250,000. Finally, Sen. Elizabeth Warren would levy a 14.8% payroll tax on wages over $250,000, raising the Social Security payroll tax rate on higher earners. This creates a so-called “donut hole” in the tax base between $137,700 and $250,000.

Don’t count Joe Biden out yet

  Don’t count Joe Biden out yet Things are looking rough for Joe Biden. But don't count him out of the 2020 race yet. After last week’s Iowa caucuses ended in unmitigated disaster, Friday night’s Democratic presidential debate in New Hampshire was the most important debate so far for the 2020 candidates. It was a pivotal opportunity for candidates to calm the rising sense of uncertainty among Democratic voters who are looking for a candidate they believe can both beat President Trump and excite a diverse and varied party.

Each of these proposed changes would make the tax code more progressive by raising marginal tax rates on the wages of higher earners. These changes come at the cost of lower economic growth and fewer jobs. For example, the Tax Foundation estimates that Warren’s plan would lower long-term economic growth by 0.41% and cost about 530,000 jobs. Higher payroll taxes lower economic growth because they lower employee wages, reducing the return to working and making leisure more attractive. In the long run, this reduces how much is produced in the economy as people work fewer hours and are less productive.

Each proposal would raise revenue to support Social Security’s solvency, ranging from about $650 billion over 10 years from Biden’s proposal to just over $1.5 trillion raised over that time period from Warren’s payroll tax plan. These changes alone would not put Social Security completely in the black, but would extend the program’s solvency over the next 30 years.

Policymakers and presidential candidates should consider the trade-offs of raising payroll tax rates or the payroll tax base. Higher payroll taxes come at the cost of economic growth and job creation, with the benefit of helping to make our entitlement programs more sustainable. Payroll tax changes, if implemented, should be combined with other reforms to entitlement programs. This ensures that the programs are fiscally sound and minimize the impact on economic growth.

Garrett Watson is a senior policy analyst at the Tax Foundation, where he conducts research on state and federal tax policy.

Gillibrand PAC, End Citizens United launch effort to boost female candidates .
Sen. Kirsten Gillibrand's (D-N.Y.) political action committee is partnering with the group End Citizens United to bolster female candidates in the 2020 elections who advocate for campaign finance reform. © UPI Photo Gillibrand PAC, End Citizens United launch effort to boost female candidates The joint effort by End Citizens United and Gillibrand's group, Off the Sidelines, is slated to kick off later this month with a voting rights-focused roundtable in Los Angeles, the groups announced on Thursday.

—   Share news in the SOC. Networks

Topical videos:

usr: 2
This is interesting!