•   
  •   
  •   

Opinion Trump tax returns are not just good for gossip. Here are 3 reasons voters should care.

16:30  29 september  2020
16:30  29 september  2020 Source:   usatoday.com

In North Carolina, Black voters' mail-in ballots much more likely to be rejected than those of any other race

  In North Carolina, Black voters' mail-in ballots much more likely to be rejected than those of any other race North Carolina's disparity, similar to gaps in other states, raises concerns about systemic racism and voter disenfranchisement tainting elections.RALEIGH, North Carolina — Sandra Cosby is no stranger to the election process — or to voting by mail.

The revelations about President Donald Trump 's taxes have been described as a jolt to the US election Richer people should be paying more than poor people and similarly situated people should be It was just he paid very little in taxes . Good for him." Mr Solene, a former business owner, paid

There are all sorts of reasons why a person like Trump whose true economic income is very high might show a much lower income on a tax return . These explanations are not mutually exclusive — Trump has led a lot of businesses that have ended in bankruptcy in the past; some of his financial

Why do we care about President Donald Trump's tax returns? Is it just because they offer us another episode of reality TV, a window into the lives of the rich and famous?

I would argue there are at least three things we learned from the president's returns that should concern us as voters, not just as voyeurs. First, we learned that it is possible he has not been honest with the IRS, and may even face potential criminal liability for his dishonesty. Presidents demand sacrifices from citizens and from public servants. Some of us are asked only to pay taxes; others are asked to face death to defend us all. A president who will not even pay his fair share cannot lead.

Battleground voters not buying Trump's tough talk on China, new poll shows

  Battleground voters not buying Trump's tough talk on China, new poll shows Voters in 12 battleground states see pandemics as a bigger concern than China, a new survey shows.Terrorism — long top of mind in the years after the attacks of Sept. 11, 2001 — has faded as a predominant concern. It has been usurped by worry about global pandemics, according to a survey by Democratic pollster Geoff Garin of voters in 12 states most likely to determine control of the White House and the Senate.

Once Trump 's tax returns are revealed, will people hate him more? Was there any president besides Trump who did not reveal their tax returns ? shows 62% of voters think it’s either very important or somewhat important to them that candidates release their returns …”

Trump said his business organization files more than 100 pages of information from its various companies for its tax returns each year, and those documents will be much more revealing. The lesson from the NYT Trump tax piece is apparently paying US taxes is just for losers and suckers.

a statue of a man and a woman standing in front of a building: In front of the U.S. Supreme Court July 9, 2020 in Washington, D.C. © Alex Wong/Getty Images In front of the U.S. Supreme Court July 9, 2020 in Washington, D.C.

While that is a troubling possibility, it is not certain that Trump paid any less than he owed. It is difficult to judge the honesty of a tax return without examining the surrounding facts.

Start the day smarter. Get all the news you need in your inbox each morning.

Was Trump honest with the IRS?

Still, there are red flags that trained IRS investigators know to look for, and several of those red flags are waving in The New York Times report on the president’s returns. One of them is using a family business’ money to pay for personal or other family expenses. Trump has run into trouble for doing just that before; a New York court dissolved the Trump Foundation in part because Donald Trump converted its assets to his own use.

A family business is not like a foundation, in that its assets belong to the family. It’s totally legal to take money from a business you own. But when you do, you have to report that money as taxable income. In the case of a partnership, such as the Trump Organization, that income might not be taxed until a later year, but it still must be reported at the time it is withdrawn.

A 2016 video of Hillary Clinton attacking Trump for his low tax bill is resurfacing after an NYT report showed he paid $0 for years

  A 2016 video of Hillary Clinton attacking Trump for his low tax bill is resurfacing after an NYT report showed he paid $0 for years Speaking at the first 2016 presidential debate, Donald Trump told Hillary Clinton that if he paid no federal income taxes: "That makes me smart."Clinton, speaking at the first presidential debate on September 26, 2016, made the claim after moderator Lester Holt asked why Trump was first candidate in decades not to release his tax returns.

Should your tax returns be released to your neighbors without your consent? After your private information from your tax returns is released without your consent, what else, that is The president should have the right to privacy just the same as you and I. No one but himself has the right to show

Nope, trump supporters just don't care about this. If that makes you mad, not their problem. Tax avoidance is legal (whereas tax evasion is not ) and it's not a crime to be in debt or to use losses As a tax accountant, what Trump did was actually masterful. All the smart people avoid taxes as much

A common trick that tax-evading business owners use is to have the business buy things for them directly, and then not report the purchase as income for the owner. In my time as a federal prosecutor, I saw small businesses pay for their owners’ “home office” renovation — actually a lavish kitchen remodel — or for “compensation” for love interests of the owner that were actually just big gifts.

So when we read that the president claimed deductions for hair styling, private jets and big parties at his home, we are seeing behavior typical of expenditures investigators see in tax-evading family businesses. Sometimes these expenses are legitimate. No, you can’t deduct your hair stylist expenses. But for many questionable business expenses, an IRS auditor would have to give the taxpayer a chance to prove that, say, his mansion really is an investment property, not a playground for his adult children.

Consider the consulting expenses the Trump Organization reportedly claimed for payments that lined up with payments reported by an entity controlled by the president’s daughter Ivanka. If these were fair payments for valuable services rendered, they'd raise no tax issues.

Bring it on: Trump wants to run on his record. We hope he does. It's been a disaster for America.

President Donald Trump and Joe Biden brace for vicious match-up in first presidential debate in Cleveland

  President Donald Trump and Joe Biden brace for vicious match-up in first presidential debate in Cleveland Analysts expect a bruising first presidential debate hinged on personal attacks as the Biden and Trump face off for the first time in Cleveland.President Trump dismisses a New York Times report alleging years of tax avoidance

Trump says his tax returns reveal nothing that is not already disclosed on his official candidate financial disclosure, called Form 278e. As ethics counsels to the past two presidents, we dealt with both their tax filings and their Form 278's and so we know that Trump is wrong.

Trump insists he ‘paid a lot’ in taxes after an investigation reveals new details about his personal The Manhattan district attorney has demanded access to the president’s tax returns for more than two That moment is now. And the voters , in my view, are not going to stand for this abuse of power.

But this is also quite similar to the transactions the president’s father, Fred Trump, used several decades ago to avoid taxes, as also reported in The Times. The elder Trump reportedly set up shell companies, owned by his children, and had these place-holder businesses overcharge him for services. In effect, Fred Trump gave gifts to his children, without paying income taxes on the value he took from his business or estate taxes on the money he passed to his heirs.

Was the president inspired by his father to set up businesses, overpay them and then use them to route money tax free to his kids? To know for sure, we’d need to learn more about what Ivanka’s company did, and whether experts think it charged a fair price for those services.

Often this kind of investigation is difficult and expensive, making it challenging for the IRS to discover wrongdoing. Most experts think the IRS is badly understaffed. And small business owners know both these things. By some estimates, the IRS collects less than 50% of the taxes owed by America’s self-employed.

Trump could be a security risk

So whether Donald Trump underpaid or not, a second lesson the president’s returns teach us is how broken our tax system has become. By the  admission of the IRS itself, it can no longer afford to audit significant fractions of our wealthiest citizens. When it discovers what it thinks is wrongdoing, it often is outgunned by taxpayers’ lawyers and experts.

If his returns don’t clearly reveal he did anything wrong, why is President Trump so aggrieved about the revelation? He has reneged repeatedly on promises to reveal his tax returns, fought tooth and nail in court to protect them, even secured the appointment of a business associate of his tax lawyers to be chief counsel of the IRS. We can’t be sure what he finds so embarrassing, or so damaging. Maybe it’s the simple fact that he owes about $400 million to persons or powers unknown.

'You have the power': Kamala Harris urges voters to oppose Trump, Senate GOP over Supreme Court nominee

  'You have the power': Kamala Harris urges voters to oppose Trump, Senate GOP over Supreme Court nominee Sen. Kamala Harris, the Democratic vice presidential nominee, urged voters to oppose President Trump and GOP senators over their Supreme Court nominee.Harris blasts Barrett over Roe

Report: Paper obtains Trump tax returns in election bombshell. Amy Coney Barrett: what will she mean The Trump administration has not just appointed (probably) three supreme court justices But if there is one person connected to Trump who should be doing victory laps right now it is Don

The re-emergence of Trump 's tax history as an election issue - in 2016 he broke a decades-old tradition of presidential nominees releasing their tax returns when seeking the White House - offers Biden another avenue of attack Tuesday evening. The former vice president is trying to turn the tables

Trump and the election: Ignore the strongman fantasies. If Trump loses the election, he'll lose his job. Period.

But that brings us to our last lesson. When public officials engage in very aggressive tax planning, right or wrong, that planning itself can be a security risk. For whatever reason, the president did not want us to know what was in his returns. And that means those who held bits of that information — his creditors, the folks who worked with Ivanka’s maybe-consulting company, even his hairdresser — had potentially valuable information. Do we know what they wanted in exchange for keeping it to themselves?

That’s the kind of compromising situation that usually prevents federal job applicants from obtaining security clearance. As voters, we all have to pass judgment on whether this president should have clearance to govern for another four years.

Brian Galle, a law professor at Georgetown University specializing in economics and tax law, spent three years as an attorney in the Criminal Appeals and Tax Enforcement Policy Section of the U.S. Justice Department's Tax Division. Follow him on Twitter: @BDGesq

You can read diverse opinions from our Board of Contributors and other writers on the Opinion front page, on Twitter @usatodayopinion and in our daily Opinion newsletter. To respond to a column, submit a comment to letters@usatoday.com.

This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: Trump tax returns are not just good for gossip. Here are 3 reasons voters should care.

Trump tax returns: Conflicts of interest and national security threats plague this presidency .
We need to know if Trump's income, debts and financial ties have influenced his decisions, and require future presidents to divest business interests.I testified before Congress early last year, and wrote with my colleagues in this newspaper, that the president’s tax returns could shed light on whether he paid his fair share of taxes, whether he could have been involved in tax fraud, and whether the IRS has appropriately reviewed his tax files, as well as crucial issues ranging from his income from foreign sources to financial ties that could create conflicts of interest.

—   Share news in the SOC. Networks
usr: 3
This is interesting!