Opinion Learning the right lessons from Afghanistan

22:05  27 october  2021
22:05  27 october  2021 Source:   thehill.com

Pentagon, State Department square off on Afghanistan accountability

  Pentagon, State Department square off on Afghanistan accountability Lawmakers on both sides of the aisle say constant finger-pointing between the Pentagon and State Department is making it difficult to get a full accounting of the messy withdrawal from Afghanistan.Recent hearings on Afghanistan have left members of Congress frustrated as top officials from the State Department and Department of Defense (DOD) lay blame on the other at congressional hearings on Afghanistan."When the State Department is here and we asked them a question they say, 'Well, you have to ask the Defense Department that," Sen. Roger Wicker (R-Miss.) said at a recent hearing. "And now today, again, Defense Department people are before us.

President Biden's speech in the wake of the U.S. withdrawal from Kabul was intended to put the seal on a painful chapter in our nation's history. In it, the president attributed the debacle in Kabul and the two decades of war that preceded it as an inevitable result of "nation building" - a pithy epithet that seemed to resonate with his audience.

a group of people in uniform: Learning the right lessons from Afghanistan © The Hill Learning the right lessons from Afghanistan

In truth, the United States has had great success at nation building in the not-so-distant past. It was the same nation, after all, that devised the Marshall Plan, ensuring that a Europe devastated in the aftermath of World War II would experience an unprecedented period of peace and prosperity.

Taliban agree to new polio vaccination across Afghanistan

  Taliban agree to new polio vaccination across Afghanistan ISTANBUL, Turkey (AP) — U.N. agencies are gearing up to vaccinate all of Afghanistan’s children under 5 against polio for the first time since 2018, after the Taliban agreed to the campaign, the World Health Organization says. For the past three years, the Taliban barred U.N.-organized vaccination teams from doing door-to-door campaigns in parts of Afghanistan under their control, apparently out of suspicion they could be spies for the government or the West. Because of the ban and ongoing fighting, some 3.3 million children over the past three years have not been vaccinated.

More recently, though on a much lesser scale, it was the U.S. that implemented Plan Colombia, which ended a 50-year civil war, led to a drastic drop in illicit drug production and enabled the Colombian government to exercise rule of law throughout the country. The real distinguishing features of both these successful attempts at nation building (though that was not the term used in either case at the time) was that they were both - as their titles suggest - actual plans.

It is important to make this distinction lest policymakers draw the wrong lessons from Afghanistan. A common understanding about what went wrong will - one hopes - help the administration design more coherent policy going ahead.

Sadly, the prospect of reaching such an understanding seems a long way off. Weeks of congressional hearings on the war have ended with no such consensus. Instead of making a determined effort to reveal underlying causes, all questions have followed a partisan narrative, while the answers, in an effort to avoid blame, have dissolved into an unseemly spectacle of mutual finger pointing between the Pentagon and the State Department. "I would try to take the politics out of it," commented one frustrated representative to The Hill, a suggestion as sensible as it is utterly implausible.

Russia Sending Humanitarian Aid to Afghanistan As Nation Hosts Taliban for Talks

  Russia Sending Humanitarian Aid to Afghanistan As Nation Hosts Taliban for Talks Members of the political delegation from the Afghan Taliban's movement attended talks in Moscow on Wednesday.Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov said, "forming a really inclusive government fully reflecting the interests of not only all ethnic groups but all political forces of the country" is necessary to achieve a stable peace in Afghanistan.

But if this were to happen - if the hearings did come up with a sense-making narrative about what went wrong with U.S. policy in Afghanistan - I imagine that it would look something like this:

The problem in Afghanistan wasn't that the U.S. embarked on a campaign of nation building. If only that had been the case. In reality, there was no discernible campaign at all, but instead a patchwork of disjointed efforts across the coalition and various departments and agencies of the U.S. government. An absence of clear objectives, a failure to use leverage to drive towards political reform and an over-reliance on a behemoth but futile military effort created the conditions that allowed the Taliban to flourish. An endless discussion about troop levels distracted policymakers from ensuring that they answered the most important question: "To what end?"

Instead of a clear answer to that question, there was much vague talk about maintaining pressure on the Taliban to give Afghan political leaders breathing space - without anyone noticing that the air in that space was too noxious to support real progress.

From exile, female former Afghan leader keeps fighting

  From exile, female former Afghan leader keeps fighting NEW YORK (AP) — Two months after the Taliban seized power in Afghanistan, one of the country’s once-prominent female leaders — a former parliament member, candidate for president and a nominee for the Nobel Peace Prize — is visiting the United Nations, not as a representative of her government but as a woman in exile. In an interview with The Associated Press, Fawzia Koofi called for humanitarian aid sent to Afghanistan to be contingent on the participation of women in its distribution, as well as free and safe travel for Afghans into and out of the country.

U.S. military leadership was not without responsibility for the lack of direction. A succession of commanders, for whom Afghan command was a strong resume builder, implemented plans that failed to add up to a sustained strategy, all the while offering repeated assurances of success.

Meanwhile, military units on the ground fought the war in 12-month increments, at the end of which they would invariably congratulate themselves for leaving their part of the country in so much better shape than they had found it. And who could blame them for wanting to derive some meaning from the grinding effort and steady stream of casualties?

But no one appears to have been keeping a close watch on the Taliban - or trying to answer the question of why an organization that should have been feared and disliked by the rural population was instead steadily gaining their support.

By 2017, the two sides in Afghanistan had fought each other to a standstill: The Taliban held the countryside while the government held the cities - a situation that remained fairly stable until a few months ago. From the perspective of the United States, it was a sustainable stalemate, a light footprint at a cost of relatively few casualties.

After the US military evacuations stopped, this group got an 80-year-old grandmother out of Afghanistan

  After the US military evacuations stopped, this group got an 80-year-old grandmother out of Afghanistan The U.S. military stopped evacuating vulnerable people out of Afghanistan at the end of August, but volunteer groups have continued to see who they can save. © Provided by Washington Examiner Task Force Argo features Department of Defense personnel, active duty service members and veterans, special operators and intelligence analysts, coming together with one goal in mind: “To bring home from Afghanistan every U.S. citizen and legal permanent resident, the immediate and extended family members of U.S. citizens and LPRs, and our Afghan allies and partners.

This wasn't the situation, however, presented to the American public by two successive presidents who, choosing political expediency over strategic patience, had turned the meaningless phrase "No more Forever Wars" into a campaign slogan. The result was the greatest single loss of American and Afghan life in Afghanistan in over a decade, and perhaps irrevocable damage to America's standing in the world. Not to mention the intangible but profound sense of loss felt by many Afghan veterans who have seen their former allies deserted, and the cause for which they fought abandoned in such haste.

These were the mistakes of Afghanistan - none of which highlight an inherent flaw with the concept of "nation building," but provide instead an implicit admonition to the United States to simply be more competent. To take the time to frame foreign policy problems in their wider context, and to design and implement policies with unambiguous objectives, discernible milestones and a clearly defined allocation of effort and resources. To understand the real meaning of terms such as risk and strategic patience. To take an approach that involves all components of national power, not just a massive and directionless military effort; an approach that learns from the lessons of the past, rather than the parochial slogans of the present.

Andrew Milburn, a retired U.S. Marine Corps colonel, is the author of "When the Tempest Gathers." He is on the adjunct faculty of Joint Special Operations University, where he teaches classes on leadership, planning, ethics, mission command, risk, special operations, irregular warfare and command and control at U.S., Canadian and UK military schools. He is also a director of the Irregular Warfare Initiative, run by the Modern War Institute.

Afghan families are selling their children so they can eat as the economy crumbles .
Parwana Malik, a 9-year-old girl with dark eyes and rosy cheeks, giggles with her friends as they play jump rope in a dusty clearing. © Hoshang Hashimi/AFP/Getty Images Men sitting at a camp for internally displaecd people in Qala-i-Naw, Badghis province, on October 17. But Parwana's laughter disappears as she returns home, a small hut with dirt walls, where she's reminded of her fate: she's being sold to a stranger as a child bride.The man who wants to buy Parwana says he's 55, but to her, he's "an old man" with white eyebrows and a thick white beard, she told CNN on October 22.

usr: 1
This is interesting!