Politics Kavanaugh, in a speech, lauded Rehnquist for dissenting in Roe vs. Wade and supporting school prayer

02:33  12 july  2018
02:33  12 july  2018 Source:   latimes.com

Santorum on Kavanaugh: Trump bowed to Washington elite

  Santorum on Kavanaugh: Trump bowed to Washington elite Rick Santorum said Monday that President Donald Trump "bowed to the elite in Washington" by picking Judge Brett Kavanaugh as his Supreme Court nominee. "Well, I think that Donald Trump said he was going to energize the base with this pick. I don't think he did that," the Republican former Pennsylvania senator and CNN political commentator told Chris Cuomo on CNN's "Cuomo PrimeTime." Kavanaugh has been dubbed a Washington insider, having worked in both Bush administrations, and is currently a judge on the US Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia circuit.

Judge Brett M. Kavanaugh , President Trump’s Supreme Court nominee, gave a revealing speech last fall in which he lauded former Chief Justice William H. Rehnquist for having dissented in Roe vs . Wade and for rejecting the notion of “a wall of separation between church and state.”

William Rehnquist was appointed Associate Justice of the U.S. Supreme Court in 1971, became Chief Justice in 1986, serving in that capacity until his death in 2005. He and Justice White were the only two Justices to dissent in Roe and Doe.

Lindsey Graham wearing a suit and tie: Judge Brett Kavanaugh meets with Senator Lindsey Graham (R-SC) July 11, 2018 on Capitol Hill in Washington, D.C. © Olivier Douliery/Abaca Press/TNS Judge Brett Kavanaugh meets with Senator Lindsey Graham (R-SC) July 11, 2018 on Capitol Hill in Washington, D.C.

WASHINGTON - Judge Brett M. Kavanaugh, President Donald Trump's Supreme Court nominee, gave a revealing speech last fall in which he lauded former Chief Justice William H. Rehnquist for having dissented in Roe vs. Wade and for rejecting the notion of "a wall of separation between church and state."

He also praised the late chief justice's unsuccessful effort to throw out the so-called "exclusionary rule," which forbids police from using illegally obtained evidence.

Donald Trump says he did not discuss abortion with Brett Kavanaugh

  Donald Trump says he did not discuss abortion with Brett Kavanaugh President Donald Trump praises Supreme Court nominee Brett Kavanaugh, while Democrats plan to oppose him over the abortion issue."No, I haven't, I really haven't," Trump told reporters as he left the White House for a week-long trip to Europe.

Supreme Court nominee Brett Kavanaugh lauded late Chief Justice Rehnquist for dissenting in Roe vs . Wade and supporting school prayer .

Roe v . Wade , 410 U.S. 113 (1973), is a landmark decision issued in 1973 by the United States Supreme Court on the issue of the constitutionality of laws that criminalized or restricted access to

All three of areas of law - abortion, religion and police searches - are likely to be in flux if Kavanaugh is confirmed and joins the Supreme Court this fall.

Kavanaugh's comments are significant because they were in a speech, not a court opinion in which he was bound by precedent, said David S. Cohen, a law professor at Drexel University in Philadelphia.

"He is not writing as a judge. This is him telling us his own views. And while he doesn't come out and say 'the dissent is right,' it is pretty clear he agrees with Rehnquist," Cohen said. Agreeing with the dissent, however, would not necessarily mean that Kavanaugh would now vote to overturn a long-standing precedent.

In the speech, Kavanaugh said Rehnquist "was my first judicial hero," noting that he started law school at Yale in 1987, a year after President Ronald Reagan had elevated Rehnquist to be chief justice. Rehnquist had been the court's lone true conservative for many years, and Kavanaugh said he felt much the same at Yale.

Brett Kavanaugh likely to bring pro-business approach to Supreme Court

  Brett Kavanaugh likely to bring pro-business approach to Supreme Court In his years on a federal appellate court, Judge Brett M. Kavanaugh tended to side with business on cases involving the environment, technology and consumer protection.In his dozen years as a federal appellate court judge, Judge Kavanaugh has tended to side with business interests in resolving regulatory issues and employment disputes in cases involving the environment, consumer protection and technology.

He was the swing vote in support of Roe . A new justice with a different view would tip the balance against abortion rights. In an admiring speech , he said, “For judges In his dissent in Garza, Judge Kavanaugh did recognize that Roe was a precedent that bound him as an appellate judge.

Trump's Supreme Court justice pick, Brett Kavanaugh , has a history of dissenting against abortion rights, so serving in the hightest court should be no different. See all Editor's Picks →. Here’s how Brett Kavanaugh could undo Roe v . Wade .

"His opinions made a lot of sense to me. In class after class, I stood with Rehnquist. That often meant in the Yale Law School environment of the time that I stood alone. Some things don't change," he said at a Constitution Day address delivered at the American Enterprise Institute in Washington in September 2017.

He cited five areas - "criminal procedure, religion, federalism, unenumerated rights and administrative law" - where Rehnquist stood fast against the liberals and moved the law to the right.

He "would be the first to say that he did not achieve full success on all the issues he cared about. But it is undeniable, I think, that he brought about a massive change in constitutional law and how we think about the Constitution," Kavanaugh said.

Kavanaugh noted that Rehnquist joined the Supreme Court in 1972, only a few months before the justices heard a challenge to a Texas law that made all abortions a crime, except those done to save the life of the mother. In Roe vs. Wade, along with Justice Byron R. White, Rehnquist "ultimately dissented from the court's 7-2 holding recognizing a constitutional right to abortion," Kavanaugh said.

Pence: 'I do' still want Roe v. Wade to be overturned

  Pence: 'I do' still want Roe v. Wade to be overturned Vice President Mike Pence said Tuesday that he still wants Roe v. Wade to be overturned, but declined to say if President Donald Trump's Supreme Court nominee Brett Kavanaugh will comply with the campaign promise to do away with the landmark ruling that legalized abortion nationwide. Kavanaugh has not expressed outright opposition to Roe v. Wade, but abortion rights activists are alarmed that it could be on the chopping block if he is confirmed. During the 2016 campaign, Pence said that he hoped to see the ruling end up on "the ash heap of history," while Trump predicted that Roe v.

Kavanaugh will be the fifth vote to kill Roe v . Wade . We know this because Kavanaugh said pretty explicitly that he hates Roe v . Wade . In that speech , Kavanaugh discussed Rehnquist ’s dissenting opinion in Roe and the late Chief’s majority opinion in Washington v. Glucksberg, which upheld a

He has praised, you know, William Rehnquist in a very lengthy speech just recently, including Rehnquist ’s dissent in Roe v . Wade . Part 2: “It’s a Very Scary Time for Women”: Cecile Richards on Brett Kavanaugh and the Future of Roe v . Wade .

The Bill of Rights did not include an explicit right to abortion, and Rehnquist believed a new, "unenumerated" right should gain constitutional status only if it was "rooted into the traditions and conscience of our people. Given the prevalence of abortion regulations both historically and at the time, Rehnquist said he could not reach such a conclusion about abortion," he said.

Rehnquist's dissent in Roe vs. Wade said "the states had the power to legislate with regard to this matter," he added.

Later, as chief justice, Rehnquist tried, but failed by one vote, to overrule the abortion decision in the 1992 case of Planned Parenthood vs. Casey. Kavanaugh did not mention it, but Justice Anthony M. Kennedy cast a decisive vote to preserve the right to abortion in that case.

"It is fair to say that Justice Rehnquist was not successful in convincing a majority of justices in the context of abortion, either in Roe itself or in later cases such as Casey," Kavanaugh said. "But he was successful in stemming the general tide of free-wheeling judicial creation of unenumerated rights that were not rooted in the nation's history and tradition."

Kavanaugh works Capitol Hill, Dems warn of rightward tilt

  Kavanaugh works Capitol Hill, Dems warn of rightward tilt Supreme Court nominee Brett Kavanaugh returns to Capitol Hill Wednesday for a round of meetings with key Republican senators as Democrats ramp up their efforts to block his confirmation. Kavanaugh, the conservative appellate court judge President Donald Trump chose to replace retiring Justice Anthony Kennedy, is set to meet separately with Republican Sen. Orrin Hatch of Utah, Sen. Lindsey Graham of South Carolina and other senators.Democrats, as the Senate minority, have few options to block Kavanaugh.

Kavanaugh gave a speech just last year praising the dissent in Roe v . Wade . Large circle with a triangle inside. We already know that Trump said he’ll only pick judges who’d overturn Roe v . Wade and outlaw abortion.

And he name-dropped liberal Justice Elena Kagan, who as dean of Harvard Law School hired Kavanaugh to teach. From top to bottom, the speech The repeated allusions to the women in his life were undoubtedly an attempt to allay any concerns about how he may rule on Roe v . Wade .

As an example, he cited the 1997 decision in Washington vs. Glucksberg, which rejected a right to assisted suicide for those who are terminally ill.

Turning to religion, Kavanaugh said Rehnquist had maintained that the "wall of separation between church and state" was a misleading metaphor "based on bad history."

Thomas Jefferson as president used this phrase in a letter in 1802 to describe the First Amendment's twin clauses - one banning an "establishment of religion" and other protecting the "free exercise" of religion. The Supreme Court adopted the metaphor in a 1947 opinion.

Scholars and judges have continued to disagree over whether the Constitution should be interpreted to forbid religious symbols on government property or religious invocations at government meetings.

As chief justice, Rehnquist failed to win a majority to uphold prayers and invocations at public school events, mostly because of Justice Kennedy, who cast crucial votes with the court's liberals to reject prayers at school in 1992 and 1999.

"Rehnquist was central in changing the jurisprudence and convincing the court that the wall metaphor was wrong as a matter of law and history," Kavanaugh said.

"Throughout his tenure and to this day," he added, the court has "sought to cordon off public schools from state-sponsored religious prayers. But Rehnquist had much more success in ensuring that religious schools and religious institutions could participate as equals in society and in state benefit programs."

Liberals attack Brett Kavanaugh for 'frat boy' name

  Liberals attack Brett Kavanaugh for 'frat boy' name The latest line of attack from liberals against Brett Kavanaugh, President Trump’s nominee for the Supreme Court, is knocking the judge for his “frat boy”-sounding first name. “We'll be D***ED if we're going to let five MEN—including some frat boy named Brett—strip us of our hard-won bodily autonomy and reproductive rights,” the influential pro-choice organization NARAL tweeted Tuesday.Comedian Stephen Colbert of CBS’ “The Late Show” also mocked Kavanaugh’s name.“Now I don’t know much about Kavanaugh, but I’m skeptical because his name is Brett,” Colbert said during the monologue on his show Tuesday.

KAVANAUGH : Senator, on the question of Roe v . Wade , if confirmed to the DC Circuit, I would follow Roe v . Wade faithfully and fully. In a speech last year to the American Enterprise Institute, Kavanaugh praised then-Associate Justice William Rehnquist ’s dissent in Roe at length.

But as a private attorney, he waded into several religious liberty cases involving schools . In an amicus brief, Kavanaugh wrote that it was unconstitutional to treat a religious group differently from others. And last year, he delivered a lecture praising William Rehnquist , the late chief justice, for

In 2002, he noted, Rehnquist wrote the court's opinion upholding a state law that gave parents tax money to pay for sending their children to religious schools. And just last year, the court upheld a Missouri church's claim that it had a right to receive state funds to pay for a new school playground. "There again, the Rehnquist legacy was at work," Kavanaugh said.

As Kavanaugh said, Rehnquist was most interested in criminal cases.

He "fervently believed the Supreme Court had taken a wrong turn in the 1960s and 1970s... in a number of sweeping rulings of the Warren Court" that expanded rights for criminal defendants, Kavanaugh said. He cited as examples the 1961 decision in Mapp vs. Ohio, which called for excluding evidence that arose from an illegal search, and the 1966 decision in Miranda vs. Arizona, which said police must warn suspects of their right to remain silent and to consult with a lawyer.

"Perhaps his most vehement objection... concerned the exclusionary rule," Kavanaugh said. "This judge-created rule, in Rehnquist's view, was beyond the four corners of the Fourth Amendment's text and imposed tremendous costs on society." He did not succeed in overruling it, Kavanaugh noted, and not many are calling for a change today, "given its firmly entrenched position in American law."

Nonetheless, he said, "Rehnquist dramatically changed the law of the exclusionary rule" in a 1984 ruling that said evidence should not be excluded if the police relied in "good faith" on a flawed search warrant.

In 2009, four years after Rehnquist died, the court did not overturn the exclusionary rule but came close. By a 5-4 vote in Herring vs. United States, the justices upheld evidence from an illegal police stop in Alabama. Chief Justice John G. Roberts Jr., a former law clerk for Rehnquist, said evidence from an illegal search should not be excluded unless the police misconduct was "deliberate, reckless or grossly negligent." Justice Kennedy was in the majority after indicating earlier that he was unwilling to overturn the entire exclusionary rule.

Visit the Los Angeles Times at www.latimes.com

On abortion and other issues, Kavanaugh’s heroes are more conservative than Kennedy .
Trump’s Supreme Court nominee has described conservative chief justice Rehnquist as his “first judicial hero.”But when Kavanaugh last September was asked to give a Constitution Day speech, he chose to celebrate his “first judicial hero,” the late Chief Justice William H. Rehnquist, noting Rehnquist’s dissent in Roe v. Wade and his rejection of the idea of a “wall of separation between church and state.

—   Share news in the SOC. Networks
This is interesting!