Politics: The Long Run: Pete Buttigieg Fired South Bend’s Black Police Chief. It Still Stings. - PressFrom - US
  •   
  •   
  •   

PoliticsThe Long Run: Pete Buttigieg Fired South Bend’s Black Police Chief. It Still Stings.

02:25  21 april  2019
02:25  21 april  2019 Source:   nytimes.com

2020 Dems: Buttigieg leapfrogs Warren, Harris, O’Rourke to No. 3

2020 Dems: Buttigieg leapfrogs Warren, Harris, O’Rourke to No. 3 Newly minted 2020 Democratic presidential candidate Pete Buttigieg has surged to third in a new national survey, jumping over more established candidates in just one month. He sits at 9 percent in the latest Emerson Poll out Monday. That puts him at third, behind Sen. Bernie Sanders and former Vice President Joe Biden. They are ahead by a wide margin, with Sanders at 29 percent and Biden at 24 percent. In the same poll a month ago, the South Bend, Ind., mayor was in sixth place, with just 3 percent of the Democratic vote. He was behind Biden and Sanders, tied in first, then Sen. Kamala Harris, former Rep.

Mr. Buttigieg ’ s firing of popular black police chief Darryl Boykins unleashed a blizzard of claims, counterclaims, lawsuits and anguish in the minority community. Supported by. The Long Run . Mayor Pete Buttigieg held a news conference about Darryl Boykins, the police chief , in South Bend

Peter Paul Montgomery Buttigieg ( /ˈbuːtədʒədʒ/ BOO-tə-jəj; born January 19, 1982) is an American politician and former Naval Intelligence Officer who has served as the mayor of the city of South

SOUTH BEND, Ind. — Pete Buttigieg had been mayor just 13 weeks when he faced a leadership crisis.

2020 hopeful Pete Buttigieg says he and husband want a child soon

2020 hopeful Pete Buttigieg says he and husband want a child soon Running for president may delay that a bit, he added.

It Still Stings . Mr. Buttigieg ’ s firing of popular black police chief Darryl Boykins unleashed a blizzard of claims, counterclaims, lawsuits and anguish in the minority community . . .

After a speech surfaced with Pete Buttigieg saying "All Lives Matter" in 2015, racial issues in the South Bend ’ s Black Lives Matter movement chapter did not respond to a request for comment on Hackett, who filed a complaint against two South Bend police chiefs , told CityLab that he is running

It was March 2012, and 300 residents of South Bend, Ind., solemnly marched to the Martin Luther King Center to protest the killing in Florida of a black teenager, Trayvon Martin.

A prominent figure at the demonstration was Darryl Boykins, South Bend’s first black police chief. Admired for teaching tennis and boxing to young people, he had been promoted to chief five years earlier after winning the respect of both black and white officers in a department that sometimes divided along racial lines.

Sign Up For the Morning Briefing Newsletter

Mr. Buttigieg addressed the protesters, but seemed not to interact with Mr. Boykins. What no one in the crowd knew was that the police top brass were in turmoil — shaken by allegations that Mr. Boykins had improperly taped phone calls of senior white officers who were said to have used racist language, including about him.

From ‘adorable’ to ‘plausible’: Buttigieg gauges his progress in the presidential race

From ‘adorable’ to ‘plausible’: Buttigieg gauges his progress in the presidential race The youthful Democratic contender acknowledged in a television interview that he still needs to build credibility with voters.

Shortly after South Bend Mayor Pete Buttigieg took office in 2012, he made what he calls his “first serious mistake as mayor.” Boykins had served in the police force since 1984 and in 2007 had become the first black man in South Bend to head the force.

On Wednesday morning, Pete Buttigieg formed a 2020 exploratory committee -- a near-certain precursor to a presidential bid for the Democratic nomination. Here' s what we DO know about Buttigieg : He' s the mayor of South Bend , Indiana.

With federal prosecutors scrutinizing Mr. Boykins, the 29-year-old mayor fired the veteran police chief just before the Trayvon Martin protest. No action was taken against the officers. Precisely what they said on the tapes of their department phone calls is unknown to the public: Mr. Buttigieg has refused to release them, saying the matter is still being resolved in court.

[Sign up for our politics newsletter and join our conversation about the 2020 presidential race.]

In the weeks, months and years that followed, the removal of Mr. Boykins unleashed a blizzard of claims, counterclaims and lawsuits, as well as anguish among South Bend’s minority residents over whether an ambitious white mayor had sided with white police officers against a black chief. The day after Mr. Boykins’s dismissal, he was applauded at a gathering of 100 officers, council members and clergy. The events played out against a backdrop of frustration among some African-Americans that they have not benefited equally from an economic resurgence in South Bend, which Mr. Buttigieg extols in his presidential bid.

Before he was a candidate, Pete Buttigieg was voted 'most likely' to be president

Before he was a candidate, Pete Buttigieg was voted 'most likely' to be president Before he was "Mayor Pete," and a candidate for the White House, Pete Buttigieg was voted 'most likely' to be president.

SOUTH BEND , Ind. — Pete Buttigieg had been mayor just 13 weeks when he faced a leadership crisis. A prominent figure at the demonstration was Darryl Boykins, South Bend ’ s first black police chief . Admired for teaching tennis and boxing to young people, he had been promoted to chief five

Pete Buttigieg , the 37-year-old mayor of South Bend , Ind., announced on Wednesday that he was entering the Democratic presidential primary, embarking on a long -shot campaign that may test the appeal of a youthful, Midwestern profile over more traditional qualifications for the presidency.

As Mr. Buttigieg seeks the Democratic nomination in a party whose base is anchored by minority voters, his handling of Mr. Boykins’ dismissal and its messy aftermath raise questions whether the mayor either misunderstood or mishandled sensitivities surrounding race and policing in the place he knew best, a city which is 37 percent black and Latino.

“It felt stomach-churning,” Mr. Buttigieg recalled of the night of the 2012 protest, speaking in an interview. “To know that that same day, we were at what even then I understood was going to be the beginning of an incredibly painful and divisive moment of race relations in my city.”

At that time, Mr. Buttigieg said he removed his police chief because he had lost faith in him after discovering the F.B.I. was investigating him for secretly taping officers’ phone calls. The chief sued the city for racial discrimination over his firing and won $50,000 in 2013. Four white officers sued the city for invasion of privacy and defamation and won a $500,000 payout the same year.

In a political memoir released this year, Mr. Buttigieg wrote that the police tapes case “affected my relationship with the African-American community in particular for years to come.”

Pete Buttigieg breaks with Bernie Sanders on allowing felons to vote from prison

Pete Buttigieg breaks with Bernie Sanders on allowing felons to vote from prison Democratic presidential hopeful Pete Buttigieg rejected Bernie Sanders' position in favor of allowing convicted terrorists, rapists, and pedophiles to vote while they are in prison. "No. I don't think so," the mayor of South Bend, Ind., said Monday evening in response to CNN host Anderson Cooper's question on whether felons should retain the right to vote while incarcerated. Sanders, a senator from Vermont, said in an earlier CNN Democratic presidential candidate town hall that he believes felons like the Boston marathon bomber should be able to vote from prison.

For Now. The Long Run : Pete Buttigieg Fired South Bend ’ s Black Police Chief . It Still Stings . The Black Chef Who Dared to Charge Nearly 0 for Dinner.

Mayor Pete Buttigieg is the chief executive of the City of South Bend . Buttigieg is past President of the Indiana Urban Mayors Caucus and the Northern Indiana Mayors Roundtable, and serves on the boards of the Truman National Security Project and the United States Conference of Mayors.

Some minority leaders in South Bend say the case is an example of tone deafness on the part of a rising star in the 2020 Democratic field.

Mr. Buttigieg, the first openly gay candidate and the first millennial to seek the presidency, has received a burst of attention and support — measured in $7 million in donations, unexpected strength in polls and mostly positive news coverage.

[Check out our tracker of the 2020 Democratic candidate field.]

On Sunday, he kicked off his campaign with a rally in a once-derelict Studebaker auto plant, now sheathed in high-tech glass and home to new businesses. It was evidence of the “turnaround” story of South Bend the mayor tells to rebut skeptics who say America has never elevated a mayor to the White House — much less one who governs fewer citizens than fit in some Big Ten football stadiums.

His accomplishments include the commercial revival of the downtown, a bump-up of 12,000 jobs over his two terms, and the demolition or repair of over 1,000 decrepit houses to attack urban blight.

But there were few people of color at his rally. The former Democratic consultant David Axelrod, a friend of the mayor’s, noted in a Tweet: “Crowd seems very large, very impressive but also very white — an obstacle he will have to overcome.”

Regina Williams-Preston, who represents a majority black district on the South Bend City Council, called Mr. Buttigieg “a smart guy, a nice guy,” but added, “We have to look past the polish and really look at the policy.”

Rivals are scrambling to dig up dirt on Pete Buttigieg

Rivals are scrambling to dig up dirt on Pete Buttigieg Buttigieg was on nobody's radar as a serious presidential contender until a few weeks ago. Now his competitors are scrambling to find vulnerabilities.

Buttigieg was born and raised in South Bend and went on to attend Harvard College and later became a Rhodes scholar. After a three-year stint at the Buttigieg told CNN last year that despite his long odds, he felt like he had to give running for president a shot. "A field that is spread very thin probably

Последние твиты от Pete Buttigieg (@PeteButtigieg). Running for president of the United States. Running for president of the United States. Afghanistan vet, musician, businessman, husband to Chasten, and South Bend ' s "Mayor Pete ."

She said minority activists pushed for years for a citizens’ review board that would have a role in police discipline and promotions. At Mr. Buttigieg’s State of the City speech in 2017, she was astonished to hear him cite a longstanding group, the Board of Public Safety, which the mayor appoints, to boast the city now had a citizens’ review board.

“Citizens had asked for a citizens’ review board, and for him to say now we have one, in fact it’s the same thing we’ve always had, that was really disingenuous,” Ms. Williams-Preston said. “Just because you say that doesn’t make it so. To me it was a betrayal.”

At issue in the police taping story are some of the most charged issues in municipal and national politics, including surveillance and personal privacy, government transparency and allegations of racism and unlawful behavior by the police.

Kareemah Fowler, the South Bend city clerk and a political ally of Mr. Buttigieg, said she believed the mayor had worked hard “trying to bridge the gap” between African-Americans and whites in the city.

But Ms. Fowler, whose 2015 campaign backed by Mr. Buttigieg made her the first African-American to hold a full-time executive office in the county, acknowledged that Mr. Buttigieg’s record had not translated into enthusiastic support among black voters for his presidential campaign.

She said the police tapes controversy was a painful episode for the city — and for a young mayor, she said, who had “learned a lot from that experience.”

“Think about his background and where he comes from — Harvard grad, his parents are two professors,” Ms. Fowler said. “He’d probably never been in an environment, prior to that, where he’d had to deal with racial tension.”

Pete Buttigieg lands 1st endorsement from member of Congress

Pete Buttigieg lands 1st endorsement from member of Congress Democratic presidential hopeful Pete Buttigieg (BOO'-tuh-juhj) has received his first endorsement from a member of Congress.Three-term Democratic Rep. Don Beyer (BY'-er) of Virginia told The Washington Post on Wednesday that he's backing the 37-year-old mayor of South Bend, Indiana. Beyer says he started off as "a huge skeptic." But he says Buttigieg won him over through a series of interviews. Beyer says, "I think he's the most articulate of all the candidates we have." He says Buttigieg communicates "better than anyone I've seen since Barack Obama.

For Now. The Long Run : Pete Buttigieg Fired South Bend ’ s Black Police Chief . It Still Stings . India’ s Chief Justice Is Accused of Sexual Harassment.

The Long Run : Pete Buttigieg Fired South Bend ’ s Black Police Chief . It Still Stings . The Black Chef Who Dared to Charge Nearly 0 for Dinner.

Mr. Buttigieg has appointed two white chiefs since ending Mr. Boykins’s tenure. The city has introduced strategies to increase minority trust of officers — implementing body cameras and implicit bias training for officers, and uploading use-of-force incident reports online. But still, minority representation on the department remains low. Only 5 percent of officers were African-American and 5 percent Hispanic in 2018, a slight decline from the previous year.

“Over the years we have had probably 20 minority officers who left their jobs,” said Derek Dieter, a retired South Bend police officer and former City Council president, who is white.

Critics of the mayor say he was too willing to settle multiple lawsuits over the police tapes to make the issue go away, ultimately costing the city close to $2 million. The council itself sued the mayor, trying to get access to the tapes, a case still being litigated, arguing there was no reason for him to withhold them.

Mr. Buttigieg disputes that. Federal and state wiretapping laws, he said, prohibit him from releasing the tapes.

But he also acknowledged that he failed to understand early on the broader racial dimensions of the tapes case, viewing it only “in very legalistic terms.”

“The more that it went on,” he said, “the more protracted and divisive and expensive the issue became, the more clear it was to me there were a lot of other issues at stake that — as not just the policy leader but symbolic leader of the community — I had a lot of responsibility over healing racial divisions, of which this particular incident was just the tip of the iceberg.”

Today none of the four officers heard on the tapes, who held senior roles in the department, still work there. Mr. Buttigieg, who said he has never listened to the tapes because of legal restrictions, doesn’t know if the officers made racist remarks or spoke of illegal activities, as alleged in court filings. The mayor pointed to settlements the city signed with Mr. Boykins and the officers in which all parties acknowledged the absence of evidence of “illegal activity by the plaintiffs” and denied the officers “used any racist word against former Police Chief Darryl Boykins.”

Franklin Graham to Mayor Pete Buttigieg: Being gay is a sin and shouldn't be 'flaunted'

Franklin Graham to Mayor Pete Buttigieg: Being gay is a sin and shouldn't be 'flaunted' The well-known evangelical Christian took to Twitter to respond to Mayor Pete Buttigieg.

The Long Run : Pete Buttigieg Fired South Bend ’ s Black Police Chief . It Still Stings . Offbeat News. Florida Man Faked Robbery So He Wouldn't Have To Work At Hardee' s : Police .

So why did Mr. Buttigieg fire Mr. Boykins in the first place? He maintains he was pressured by federal prosecutors. In “Shortest Way Home,” his memoir published in February, he writes that “a message came through” from prosecutors that he must push out Mr. Boykins or they would file charges against him for violating the Federal Wiretap Act.

Officers in the department had complained to the U.S. Attorney’s Office for Northern Indiana that the chief illegally recorded their phone calls and had threatened to use the tapes against them.

The mayor speculates in his book that prosecutors were trying to duck responsibility for “taking down a beloved African-American police chief” by getting Mr. Buttigieg to fire him instead.

He repeated the explanation this week. “It was made very clear to me by the F.B.I. and the U.S. Attorney that either we would take employment action or there would be indictments,” he said.

Mr. Boykins’s lawyer, Tom Dixon, said that when he first heard this explanation, invoked by Mr. Buttigieg in 2012, a red flag went up. He asked an assistant prosecutor in the U.S. Attorney’s office, a lawyer he knew from church, about the mayor’s assertion.

“He said, ‘Tom, that explanation is so contrary to the protocols of U.S. Attorneys’ offices,”’ Mr. Dixon recalled. “‘We never would condition a determination on prosecuting or not prosecuting based on an employment decision. It would never happen.”

Mr. Boykins has insisted that the recordings were made inadvertently, as part of a longstanding police department practice of taping some phone lines.

The U.S. Attorney informed the city that after a review of the law, no charges would be brought against Mr. Boykins.

After Mr. Buttigieg dismissed Mr. Boykins in March 2012 by asking for his resignation, Mr. Boykins submitted and then rescinded it; Mr. Buttigieg then demoted the chief to the rank of captain. He has since retired. Mr. Boykins did not respond to messages seeking comment.

One person who did hear the tapes was the police communications director, Karen DePaepe. In court filings, she described them as “discriminatory racial comments of high ranking officers” in the department, and said she told Mr. Boykins about them. She also heard “something I believe to be possibly illegal.”

Eleven days after Mr. Boykins’s removal as chief, Ms. DePaepe, who had made eight cassettes of the phone calls and given them to the chief, was fired.

In an interview that night, she told The South Bend Tribune that Mr. Buttigieg’s chief of staff, Mike Schmuhl — who is today his presidential campaign manager — threatened her with arrest if she spoke publicly.

“He said, ‘Now you understand that...you and no one else is allowed to discuss the federal investigation or anything that was recorded,’” Ms. DePaepe said she was told by Mr. Schmuhl, according to the newspaper. “‘And if you or anyone else does, you will be arrested.’”

The city paid Ms. DePaepe $235,000 in 2014 to settle a suit she brought over defamation and other claims. As part of her settlement, she agreed not to discuss what was on the tapes.

A spokesman for the Buttigieg campaign said Mr. Schmuhl recalled his conversation with Ms. DePaepe differently than reported by the newspaper.

Ever since Mr. Buttigieg was first elected in 2011, many in South Bend took for granted that he aspired to higher office, with the support of the local Democratic machine, and was carefully building a record of accomplishments.

One of those goals was bringing businesses and people back downtown. After the city directed tens of millions of dollars to pedestrian-friendly streets and incentives for developers, new hotels, restaurants and apartments sprang up.

Decades of deindustrialization since Studebaker closed its auto plant in the 1960s — and the city lost a quarter of its residents — has been stanched. The population has grown a modest 1 percent, to 102,000, under the mayor.

In his State of the City address last month, Mr. Buttigieg received wave after wave of applause as he ticked off these achievements. “When I go on the road, I talk about our experience as a metaphor for what needs to happen in our country,” he said.

But the benefits have not flowed equally to South Bend’s large minority communities.

Some of the data is dismal. Though the overall poverty rate has fallen since Mr. Buttigieg took office, poverty among African-Americans stubbornly remains almost twice as high as for African-Americans nationwide.

The city has one of the highest eviction rates in the country, which has doubled under the mayor, according to the Eviction Lab at Princeton University.

In households with working adults, 54 percent do not earn enough to meet a “survival budget,” according to the United Way.

The downtown may be a vibrant draw once again for residents, but not everyone can participate.

“You’ve got black people, we’re outside looking in the window at folks enjoying a steak,” said Mario Sims, a pastor and community activist.

Mr. Sims has led protests over the police tapes for years, most recently last summer when a federal appeals court ruled in the case brought by the City Council, known as the Common Council, seeking to make the tapes public.

The case arose when the council subpoenaed Mr. Buttigieg in 2012 to hand over the recordings. The city attorney asked a federal court to rule whether the mayor could comply.

A federal district judge initially decided that some of the recordings could be made public, but an appellate court threw out the case entirely, saying it was not a matter for the federal judiciary. The issue was returned to the state judicial system, in the St. Joseph County courts, where it remains. The city has withdrawn from the fight, leaving it between the council and the police officers, who don’t want the tapes released.

As Mr. Buttigieg campaigns for president well beyond Indiana’s borders, the tapes case and his relations with minorities hang over him. He points out that when he cruised to re-election in 2015, he defeated an African-American primary challenger even in the city’s heavily black Second District.

There are some who say the tapes will never be made public. Others, including Ms. Williams-Preston, the current City Council member from the Second District, expect them to come out and to include material that could inflame racial divisions.

“We have to prepare for that as a community,” she said.

Whenever it happens, she said, Mr. Buttigieg, whose term ends this year, will likely be far away from South Bend. Ms. Williams-Preston, a trainer of special education teachers, is running to take over his job.

“In our culture we want to find a hero,” she said. “But I want people to understand the story of South Bend. Any good story has an imperfect hero, where they struggle with something and they overcome. I’m not sure Pete’s completely overcome. But we’ve given him the opportunity to struggle with some issues.”

Franklin Graham to Mayor Pete Buttigieg: Being gay is a sin and shouldn't be 'flaunted'.
The well-known evangelical Christian took to Twitter to respond to Mayor Pete Buttigieg.

—   Share news in the SOC. Networks
usr: 24
This is interesting!