Politics: Calls for Justice Kavanaugh’s impeachment are mounting. Here’s how it could work. - PressFrom - US
  •   
  •   
  •   

PoliticsCalls for Justice Kavanaugh’s impeachment are mounting. Here’s how it could work.

00:45  16 september  2019
00:45  16 september  2019 Source:   washingtonpost.com

Dem presidential candidates call for Kavanaugh's impeachment

Dem presidential candidates call for Kavanaugh's impeachment At least three Democratic presidential candidates are calling for the impeachment of Supreme Court Justice Brett Kavanaugh in the face of a new, uninvestigated, allegation of sexual impropriety when he was in college. Kavanaugh was confirmed last October after emotional hearings in the Senate over a sexual assault allegation from his high school years. The New York Times now reports that Kavanaugh faced a separate allegation from his time at Yale University and that the FBI did not investigate the claim.

With Kavanaugh confirmed, impeachment could follow. One former deputy assistant U. S . attorney general, who previously worked for a top Democrat, even called for Kavanaugh ’ s impeachment Graves wrote that Kavanaugh had misled the Judiciary Committee about the stolen documents that

Calls for Kavanaugh ’ s impeachment have surfaced periodically since his confirmation. The impeachment of supreme court justices works in the same way as that of a president: a Lower judges have been removed but only one impeachment of a supreme court justice been attempted.

One year ago, a bitterly divided Senate voted to confirm Supreme Court Justice Brett M. Kavanaugh to a lifetime appointment on the nation’s highest court; the vote was 50 to 48.

Now, as the Oct. 8 anniversary of his confirmation nears, the New York Times reports it has uncovered and corroborated a previously unreported claim of sexual misconduct against Kavanaugh, and that it found the FBI interviewed none of the potential witnesses. The story, published Saturday evening, compelled several Democrats to demand a new investigation into the Supreme Court Justice.

Ocasio-Cortez calls for Kavanaugh to be impeached

Ocasio-Cortez calls for Kavanaugh to be impeached Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-N.Y.) on Monday called for Supreme Court Justice Brett Kavanaugh's impeachment following a new allegation of sexual assault against him published in The New York Times. © Aaron Schwartz Ocasio-Cortez calls for Kavanaugh to be impeached "This was almost a year ago. It is unsurprising that Kavanaugh, credibly accused of sexual assault, would lie under oath to secure a Supreme Court seat," she tweeted along with a video of her at a rally. "Because sexual assault isn't a crime of passion - it's about the abuse of power. He must be impeached." This was almost a year ago.

Kavanaugh was confirmed last October after emotional hearings in the Senate over a sexual assault allegation from his high school years. It wasn’t immediately clear how the Justice Department could come to the justice ’ s defense. Trump added that they were “False Accusations without recrimination

Elizabeth Warren is calling for Brett Kavanaugh ' s impeachment after the New York Times wrote about a new sexual misconduct allegation. Last year the Kavanaugh nomination was rammed through the Senate without a thorough examination of the allegations against him.

Even before the recent spate of sexual misconduct allegations, murmurs among Kavanaugh opponents fixated on whether he had lied under oath before the Senate Judiciary Committee. Saturday’s story from the Times quickly raised new questions about whether Kavanaugh perjured himself and reignited calls for his impeachment.

Subscribe to the Post Most newsletter: Today’s most popular stories on The Washington Post

“Brett M. Kavanaugh lied to the U.S. Senate and most importantly to the American people,” Sen. Kamala D. Harris (D-Calif.) said Sunday of last year’s confirmation hearings. “He was put on the Court through a sham process and his place on the Court is an insult to the pursuit of truth and justice. He must be impeached.”

Susan Collins under fire after new Brett Kavanaugh allegations

Susan Collins under fire after new Brett Kavanaugh allegations Sara Gideon, a Democratic challenger of Sen. Susan Collins, R-Maine, has repeatedly criticized Collins for voting last year to confirm Supreme Court Justice Brett Kavanuagh.

candidates called for Kavanaugh to be impeached , while Republicans called the new report a "smear" Kamala Harris, D-Calif., called for Kavanaugh ' s impeachment . Harris had voted against adding that calls for Kavanaugh ' s impeachment were "another sign of how nasty and divided the

Before Supreme Court Justice Brett M. Kavanaugh was sworn in, critics were calling for his impeachment . Impeachment is a polarizing process itself, though, one that even many Democrats appear uneasy about pursuing if they win control of Congress in next month’ s elections.

Since Saturday, Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.) and former housing and urban development secretary Julián Castro, Democratic presidential candidates, also pushed for Kavanaugh’s impeachment.

What is impeachment?

At the constitutional Convention of 1787, the delegates concluded that even those holding the highest office would not be above the law, birthing the American system of impeachment.

Under the Constitution, the president, the vice president and “all civil Officers of the United States” (including those in the executive branch, plus federal judges) may be removed from office for “treason, bribery, or other high crimes and misdemeanors.” The procedure for impeaching a president or a federal judge is broadly the same.

There are two parts to the process:

The House is entrusted with the responsibility of voting on impeachment. Its members decide by a majority vote.

Pressley to introduce resolution to open impeachment inquiry against Kavanaugh

Pressley to introduce resolution to open impeachment inquiry against Kavanaugh Rep. Ayanna Pressley (D-Mass.) plans to introduce a resolution on Tuesday that would call for an impeachment inquiry to be opened against Supreme Court Justice Brett Kavanaugh following a newly-reported allegation of sexual misconduct. © Aaron Schwartz Pressley to introduce resolution to open impeachment inquiry against Kavanaugh "I believe Christine Blasey Ford," she said in a statement. "I believe Deborah Ramirez. It is our responsibility to collectively affirm the dignity and humanity of survivors." require(["medianetNativeAdOnArticle"], function (medianetNativeAdOnArticle) { medianetNativeAdOnArticle.

How likely is Kavanaugh ' s impeachment ? Only one sitting Supreme Court justice — Samuel Chase — was impeached , on charges of being too partisan in 1805. With a cloture vote scheduled for Friday, Kavanaugh could be confirmed as early as Saturday — exactly one month before the

How likely is kavanaugh ' s impeachment and removal? " It ' s as likely as the Democrats winning the House," said Jed Shugarman, a professor at Clinton' s impeachment was also based on lying under oath during a deposition, a proceeding that Kavanaugh was intimately familiar with from

Then the Senate holds a trial for the underlying misconduct. A conviction requires two-thirds of the Senate, or 67 votes. If there is a conviction, the Senate would remove the individual from office.

How likely is Kavanaugh’s impeachment and removal?

Impeachment proceedings are contingent on Democrats controlling the House, the only body that can bring an article of impeachment. The current House breakdown is 235 Democrats, 198 Republicans, one Independent and one vacancy, according to the Cook Political Report, which puts impeachment in the realm of political possibility.

Yet Kavanaugh’s removal is exceedingly unlikely, given the supermajority threshold in the Senate, where there are 51 Republicans and 49 Democrats. The “supermajority” threshold for removal is exceedingly high by design: The delegates crafted it to prevent politics from driving the outcome, instead ensuring any misconduct was offensive enough to have bipartisan support for removal.

Nineteen federal officials — including 15 judges and two presidents — have been impeached, but fewer than half have been removed by the Senate, because of the supermajority standard.

Could Kavanaugh be impeached? What the Constitution says

Could Kavanaugh be impeached? What the Constitution says Only one Supreme Court justice in U.S. history has been impeached – and even he wasn't removed from the bench

Trump says Justice Brett Kavanaugh should 'start suing people' after new report of sexual At least one Democratic presidential contender, former housing secretary Julian Castro, called on It is exceedingly rare for justices to be impeached . The only time it happened was with Justice Samuel

Kavanaugh co-authored the report that found grounds to impeach President Bill Clinton. Brett Kavanaugh , who President Donald Trump nominated to replace the retiring Supreme Court justice The report laid out 11 possible grounds for impeachment , including how misleading the public and

The most famous cases resulted in impeachment but not removal. Andrew Johnson and Bill Clinton were the only two presidents to be impeached by the House. Each reached the Senate for trial, but both were acquitted, Johnson by a single vote. Neither was removed from office.

Only one sitting Supreme Court justice — Samuel Chase — was impeached, on charges of being too partisan in 1805. As with Johnson and Clinton, Chase was acquitted by the Senate and continued to serve.

What are judges impeached for?

There isn’t a clear definition of “impeachable offense,” though historically that is often framed by statutory felonies and involves a significant abuse of power, according to Jed Shugerman, a professor at Fordham University School of Law and expert in constitutional law. “Current culture has also changed our understanding of what an abuse of power is,” he said.

In 1970, arguing for the impeachment of Justice William O. Douglas, then-Rep. Gerald Ford (R-Mich.) defined impeachable offenses as “whatever a majority of the House of Representatives considers it to be at a given moment in history … Something less than a criminal act or criminal dereliction of duty may nevertheless be sufficient grounds for impeachment.”

Douglas was never impeached; the hearings held by the House Judiciary Committee produced no credible evidence and concluded without a vote.

Trump praises Kavanaugh as a 'great, brilliant man,' blasts NYT over 'smear' report at rally

Trump praises Kavanaugh as a 'great, brilliant man,' blasts NYT over 'smear' report at rally President Trump praised Supreme Court Justice Brett Kavanaugh as a "great, brilliant man" at his campaign rally in New Mexico on Monday night and called a report published over the weekend detailing a sexual assault allegation against the justice a "smear story." © Aaron Schwartz Trump praises Kavanaugh as a 'great, brilliant man,' blasts NYT over 'smear' report at rally During the rally in Rio Rancho, Trump took aim at the Democratic lawmakers who have called for Kavanaugh's impeachment in recent days over the report published by the Times on Saturday that detailed the new allegation.

For example, Kavanaugh thinks presidents should be above the law. McConnell knows how hard it could be for a nominee like Kavanaugh to be confirmed in the most closely Nan Aron is President of the Alliance for Justice , a national association of public interest and civil rights Even as Nadler Intensifies Trump Probes, Progressives Call on Pelosi to Stop 'Putting the Brakes on Impeachment '.

WASHINGTON — Judge Brett M. Kavanaugh , whose Supreme Court hearings ripped apart the Senate and roiled the nation, headed for final confirmation to the court after two key undecided senators announced on Friday that they would back him

What’s clear, however, is that perjury is a significant offense, especially for a judge.

The question of lying under oath is particularly important for someone who would be or is a member of the judiciary, according to Graves, the former Senate Judiciary Committee lawyer who called for Kavanaugh’s impeachment after his confirmation to the Supreme Court.

A judge, she said, is a symbol of integrity and the law. To the extent that a judge’s integrity is tainted, it disables that person from being able to continue as a judge.

“Lawyers are officers of the court,” Graves told The Post. “Courts rule on matters and assess witness credibility all the time, so honesty, integrity and truthfulness are paramount qualities for a judge.”

This principle is evidenced by prior successful judicial impeachment proceedings:

Alcee L. Hastings was impeached and removed from the bench for perjury in 1988. (Hastings now serves in Congress, as a Democrat representing Florida’s 20th District.) Walter L. Nixon was impeached and removed for lying to a grand jury in 1989. Most recently, Thomas Porteous Jr. was impeached and removed for committing perjury on financial disclosures in 2010.

Clinton’s impeachment was also based on his alleged lying under oath during a deposition, a proceeding that Kavanaugh was intimately familiar with from his time working on special prosecutor Kenneth W. Starr’s investigative team.

“Even though our political discourse has been defiled by the proliferation of so many politicians’ lies, the rules for testifying under oath, whether it’s at the U.S. Senate, trial or deposition, is one of the only sacred vows in a secular society. It should be taken seriously because of that,” Graves said. "[Kavanaugh] certainly held President Clinton to that standard. He’s not above the law any more than the president is above the law.”

2020 Democrats’ Demand For Kavanaugh Impeachment Will Kill Them In Swing States

2020 Democrats’ Demand For Kavanaugh Impeachment Will Kill Them In Swing States Brett Kavanaugh's confirmation smearing 'brought people back to the Republican Party,' and it appears Democrats want to rev that engine again.

Mrs. Ashley Kavanaugh holds the Bible. WASHINGTON - Even before the judicial oath was Republicans and Democrats have put competing spins on how the confirmation fallout might play out at the Democrats say the debate over Kavanaugh has increased the anger that many women already

So how would impeaching a Supreme Court justice work , exactly? Does the Senate have an argument to make for impeaching Kavanaugh ? In the Samuel Chase case, President Thomas Jefferson led the call for impeachment , ostensibly because of rulings Chase had made while sitting

Now what?

For now, the burden rests with the House.

It’s possible the House Judiciary Committee quickly moves to reinvestigate Kavanaugh and draft articles of impeachment.

Rep. Jerrold Nadler (D-N.Y.), who chairs the committee, has previously said he would support such an action. In August, he requested the National Archives release records from his time in the George W. Bush’s White House.

Editor’s note: This story includes earlier reporting from October 2018.

Read more:

The top 15 Democratic presidential candidates, ranked

Julián Castro’s and Cory Booker’s risky attacks on Joe Biden’s sharpness

Winners and losers from the third Democratic debate

Read More

Pressley on Kavanaugh impeachment: 'Deeply disturbing' that a justice 'could have this many allegations'.
Rep. Ayanna Pressley (D-Mass.) told CNN on Tuesday that "it's deeply disturbing" for Supreme Court Justice Brett Kavanaugh to have "this many allegations" against him, explaining she had filed an impeachment resolution against him in order to "get to the truth.""It's deeply disturbing that someone that serves on the highest court in the land could have this many allegations," Pressley said. "One of the reasons why I ran for Congress is to fight for the healing and the justice of all survivors."@RepPressley filed a resolution to impeach Kavanaugh. "It's deeply disturbing that someone that serves on the highest court of the land could have this many allegations." pic.

—   Share news in the SOC. Networks

Topical videos:

usr: 10
This is interesting!