•   
  •   
  •   

Politics Ruling Will Not Lead John Bolton to Testify Soon, Lawyer Says

21:30  26 november  2019
21:30  26 november  2019 Source:   nytimes.com

Will John Bolton fill in the gaps on Ukraine as an impeachment witness?

  Will John Bolton fill in the gaps on Ukraine as an impeachment witness? Former national security adviser John Bolton appears to be dangling the possibility of testifying late in the impeachment process about President Donald Trump's actions regarding Ukraine, potentially providing an account that could fill in crucial gaps in the current record. Bolton's name frequently popped up in the last two weeks of hearings before the House Intelligence Committee. Administration officials described his disgust at the pressure campaign that Trump’s lawyer, Rudolph W. Giuliani, had set in motion to push Ukraine into publicly announcing investigations into Trump’s Democratic rivals.

John R. Bolton , the former national security adviser, giving a speech in Washington in September.Credit Win Mcnamee/Getty Images.

Charles J. Cooper, a lawyer who represents Mr. Bolton , said that a court decision on Monday ordering another former White House official to appear before Congress under subpoena did not apply to Mr. Bolton because of the nature of his job. Mr. Cooper said Mr. Bolton would therefore wait for another

WASHINGTON — John R. Bolton, the former national security adviser to President Trump who resisted efforts to pressure Ukraine for help against domestic political rivals, dashed any expectation on Tuesday that he would testify soon in the House impeachment investigation in response to a court ruling involving a onetime colleague.

a man wearing a suit and tie: John R. Bolton, the former national security adviser, giving a speech in Washington in September.© Win Mcnamee/Getty Images John R. Bolton, the former national security adviser, giving a speech in Washington in September.

Charles J. Cooper, a lawyer who represents Mr. Bolton, said that a court decision on Monday ordering another former White House official to appear before Congress under subpoena did not apply to Mr. Bolton because of the nature of his job. Mr. Cooper said Mr. Bolton would therefore wait for another judge to rule in a separate case that could take weeks more to litigate.

Key takeaways from day 5 of the public impeachment hearings

  Key takeaways from day 5 of the public impeachment hearings It was day No. 5 of the House impeachment hearings and the last day of testimony scheduled by Democrats so far. Here are five key takeaways.Testifying on Thursday were Fiona Hill, former senior director for Europe and Russia on the White House's National Security Council and David Holmes, a political counselor at the U.S. embassy in Ukraine.

The lawyer for former national security adviser John Bolton signaled Thursday that Bolton will not testify anytime soon in the House impeachment inquiry. The client is former Bolton deputy Charles Kupperman, who wants a federal judge to resolve whether he can be forced to testify since he was a

President Trump's former National Security Adviser John Bolton says he is willing to testify in the Senate impeachment trial if he receives a subpoena.

The statement came a day after a federal district judge rejected the assertion that Mr. Trump could block aides from responding to congressional subpoenas based on a sweeping claim of presidential immunity. The ruling ordered Donald F. McGahn II, a former White House counsel for Mr. Trump, to comply with a House subpoena. Mr. McGahn’s lawyer filed a notice on Tuesday that he would appeal and asked that the order be suspended in the meantime.

While the judge said it made no difference whether a White House official dealt with national security matters, Mr. Cooper rejected any suggestion that it would cover Mr. Bolton.

Impeachment hearing takeaways: A ‘domestic political errand’

  Impeachment hearing takeaways: A ‘domestic political errand’ The final testimony of an extraordinary week of impeachment hearings came from a former White House national security adviser who wrote the book on Vladimir Putin — literally — and a political counselor at the U.S. Embassy in Ukraine who overheard a pivotal conversation between President Donald Trump and EU ambassador Gordon Sondland. Takeaways from Day 5 of the impeachment inquiry before the House intelligence committee:

WASHINGTON — The lawyer for John Bolton is signaling that the former national security adviser will not testify anytime soon in the House impeachment inquiry. Democratic lawmakers want to hear next week from Bolton over the administration’s approach to Ukraine that is central to House proceedings

Former White House national security adviser John Bolton said Monday he is willing to testify — if he is subpoenaed — in the Senate's impeachment trial of President Donald Trump.

“Any passing references in the McGahn decision to presidential communications concerning national security matters are not authoritative on the validity of testimonial immunity for close White House advisers” whose “responsibilities are focused exclusively on providing information and advice to the president on national security,” Mr. Cooper said.

Mr. Trump, who is on the verge of being impeached for pushing Ukraine to help him against his Democratic rivals while withholding American security aid, said later Tuesday that he had no concern about Mr. Bolton testifying and that he was resisting the House investigation because he considered it illegitimate.

“John Bolton is a patriot and may know that I held back the money from Ukraine because it is considered a corrupt country, & I wanted to know why nearby European countries weren’t putting up money also,” Mr. Trump wrote on Twitter, rebutting his own administration officials who have said he was holding the money back to pressure Ukraine.

Trump Keeps Losing in Court. But His Legal Strategy Is Winning Anyway.

  Trump Keeps Losing in Court. But His Legal Strategy Is Winning Anyway. Critics of President Trump cheered on Monday when a federal judge ruled that the former White House counsel Donald F. McGahn II must testify to Congress — and scathingly labeled “fiction” the administration’s arguments that top White House aides are immune from congressional subpoenas. Indeed, the outcome was the latest in a string of lower-court losses for Mr. Trump as he defends his stonewalling of lawmakers’ oversight and the impeachment investigation. Other fights are playing out in the courts over Mr. Trump’s financial records and grand-jury evidence in the Russia investigation.

This month, Bolton said he would testify if subpoenaed by the Senate. Chief Justice John Roberts could rule on any disputes over witnesses and whether documents can be introduced, Schiff said . Lead House manager Adam Schiff said , “I would not say it contributes to a loss of confidence in the

…we could soon see John Bolton , Trump’s former national security adviser, giving us a personal preview of his new book from the Senate floor. Personally enriching himself using our most sacred process in our most sacrosanct of institutions?

Mr. Trump added that his refusal to cooperate with the impeachment inquiry was motivated by a desire to guard the prerogatives of his office. “I am fighting for future Presidents and the Office of the President,” he wrote. “Other than that, I would actually like people to testify.”

House Democrats have not been counting on Mr. Bolton’s testimony and have signaled that they intend to press ahead with the impeachment inquiry without waiting for court cases about testimony from White House aides to be resolved. Representative Adam B. Schiff, the chairman of the House Intelligence Committee, said Monday that he expected his panel to deliver a report soon after Thanksgiving making the case for impeaching Mr. Trump.

Mr. Bolton was among the most prominent witnesses who did not appear during two weeks of public hearings held by the committee examining Mr. Trump’s efforts to push Ukraine to announce investigations tied to Democrats while withholding $391 million in American security aid.

The former national security adviser, who left his post in September after months of disputes with Mr. Trump on a variety of matters, adamantly opposed the Ukraine pressure campaign, according to testimony before the committee. He referred to it as a “drug deal” cooked up with other advisers to the president and instructed aides to report what they knew about it to White House lawyers.

'This is not how an American president should be impeached': GOP witness Jonathan Turley to launch Trump defense

  'This is not how an American president should be impeached': GOP witness Jonathan Turley to launch Trump defense Jonathan Turley, the lone Republican selected as legal expert for Wednesday’s impeachment hearing, will condemn the Democrat-led process. © Provided by Washington Examiner “This is not how an American president should be impeached," he will say, according to a copy of his prepared remarks obtained by the Washington Examiner. Turley, a law professor at George Washington University, is appearing in front of the House Judiciary Committee alongside three Democrat-selected witnesses in its first Ukraine-related impeachment hearing.

But Bolton 's lawyer , Charles Cooper, says Bolton will not appear without a subpoena. Three House committees leading Democrats' impeachment inquiry have asked former National Security Adviser John Bolton to appear behind closed doors next week, according to a person familiar with

Bolton was not willing to go before the House, originally. Rather, he was willing, but only if a court Congress may either feel that the ruling on a prior lawsuit on compelling Don McGhan to testify So if John Bolton is not subpoenaed he is not going to testify . Nancy Pelosi could subpoena him if she

But Mr. Bolton declined a House invitation to testify after the White House refused to authorize current or former aides to talk with investigators. Instead, he is waiting for the result of a separate lawsuit filed by his longtime friend and former deputy, Charles M. Kupperman, who was subpoenaed in the impeachment inquiry. In October, Mr. Kupperman asked a federal judge to decide whether he should follow the orders of the White House or the House. That case is scheduled to be argued on Dec. 10.

Some Democrats had held out hope that Mr. Bolton might not wait and would instead rely on the decision in the McGahn case to agree to testify. In her ruling, Judge Ketanji Brown Jackson of the Federal District Court for the District of Columbia almost seemed to be addressing Mr. Bolton’s argument that his job was different than that of Mr. McGahn because of its focus on national security matters.

“Nor does it make any difference whether the aides in question are privy to national security matters, or work solely on domestic issues,” she wrote in her 120-page opinion.

Judge Jackson said that individual questions might still be subject to claims of executive privilege but that a president could not prevent former aides from even showing up when ordered by Congress. “Presidents are not kings,” she wrote. “They do not have subjects, bound by loyalty or blood, whose destiny they are entitled to control.”

Trump threatens to have Schiff, Bidens, Pelosi testify in Senate trial as he dares House to impeach

  Trump threatens to have Schiff, Bidens, Pelosi testify in Senate trial as he dares House to impeach President Trump on Thursday challenged House Democrats to impeach him “fast."“The Do Nothing Democrats had a historically bad day yesterday in the House. They have no Impeachment case and are demeaning our Country. But nothing matters to them, they have gone crazy,” Trump tweeted early Thursday, just before Pelosi announced that she wants the Judiciary Committee to proceed with articles of impeachment.

Mr. Bolton has not given any indication of what he would say if he does eventually testify, but he has teased that he has something to say. While Republicans have sought to dismiss the testimony of others against Mr. Trump as mere secondhand hearsay, Mr. Bolton had more direct regular access to the president than any of the witnesses who appeared over the last two weeks.

Mr. Bolton “was personally involved in many of the events, meetings, and conversations about which you have already received testimony, as well as many relevant meetings and conversations that have not yet been discussed in the testimonies thus far,” Mr. Cooper, his lawyer, wrote in a letter to the House earlier this month.

In a Twitter message last week, Mr. Bolton suggested that the White House had tried to keep him off social media after his departure in September “out of fear of what I may say,” a comment that could refer to his known disagreements with Mr. Trump’s foreign policy but in the hothouse environment of impeachment was taken as a tease.

Because the McGahn ruling will be appealed and any decision in Mr. Kupperman’s suit may likewise be taken to higher courts, it could be months before the judiciary settles the matter. Rather than wait, House Democrats have said they will use the White House effort to block testimony by aides like Mr. Bolton as evidence in an article of impeachment alleging obstruction of Congress. They anticipate a final House vote on impeachment by the end of the year.

At the State Department on Tuesday, Secretary of State Mike Pompeo sidestepped a question about whether he would testify in the impeachment inquiry. “When the time is right, all good things happen,” Mr. Pompeo told reporters. He did not respond to requests to clarify what that meant. The question of how much Mr. Pompeo knew about the Ukraine pressure campaign has come up repeatedly during the impeachment hearings but House Democrats have not subpoenaed him to testify.

If Mr. Bolton and other witnesses who have defied subpoenas or requests for information like Rudolph W. Giuliani, the president’s personal attorney, and Mick Mulvaney, the acting White House chief of staff, have not complied before the House vote, they still could be called as witnesses in a Senate trial.

The court fights may be resolved by then. If not, some lawyers suggest that the House members acting as prosecutors in a Senate trial could ask Chief Justice John G. Roberts Jr., who under the Constitution would preside, to summon Mr. Bolton and others.

Lara Jakes contributed reporting.

Trump comes out swinging, but Fiona Hill fights back in dramatic impeachment finale .
Donald Trump came out swinging Thursday morning, but two witnesses who testified for hours in the impeachment inquiry pulled no punches as they overshadowed the president’s morning attacks. Testimony by Fiona Hill, a former National Security Council Russia expert, and David Holmes, an official in the U.S. embassy in Kyiv, further undercut several contentions pushed by Trump, GOP lawmakers and the president’s surrogates. Hill, for instance, dismissed a conspiracy theory rejected by American intelligence agencies but espoused by Trump and other Republicans that Ukraine, not Russia, meddled in the 2016 U.S. election.

—   Share news in the SOC. Networks

Topical videos:

usr: 1
This is interesting!