•   
  •   
  •   

Politics How much did Mike Pence know about pressure on Ukraine? Testimony suggests effort to flag concerns

20:05  02 december  2019
20:05  02 december  2019 Source:   usatoday.com

Giuliani-Pompeo contacts before Yovanovitch ouster are seen in newly released State Dept. documents

  Giuliani-Pompeo contacts before Yovanovitch ouster are seen in newly released State Dept. documents The State Department released 100 pages of court-ordered documents that show Rudy Giuliani and Mike Pompeo spoke on the phone within the same time frame of events currently under investigation.The released records seemed to confirm testimony from several key witnesses, including U.S. Ambassador to the European Union Gordon Sondland, who testified this week that senior Trump administration officials were involved in the president’s efforts to convince Ukraine to launch a probe into former Vice President Joe Biden and his son Hunter Biden’s business dealings in the country.

Testimony suggests effort to flag concerns . Maureen Groppe. Pence has disputed Sondland’s account of raising concerns about the aid. Even more , he has broadly denied knowing about The testimony also indicates there were multiple opportunities for Pence to have been informed about the

Sondland does not describe Pence 's reaction when he raised his concerns in his opening statement. "The vice president nodded like you know he heard what I said and that was pretty much it as I As the impeachment efforts unfolded, Pence 's aides devised a strategy to keep him out of

WASHINGTON – As the White House scrambled in late August to swap Vice President Mike Pence into a preplanned presidential trip to Poland, there was one meeting Pence was adamant stay on the schedule: a sit-down with Ukraine’s new president.

Nearly $400 million in U.S. military assistance that Ukraine was desperate for as a counter to Russian aggression had been on hold for weeks.

When Pence and Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky met Sept. 1 in a windowless conference room of the Marriott in downtown Warsaw, the stalled aid was the first issue a frustrated Zelensky raised.

Despite Fiona Hill warning, Sen. John Kennedy says Ukraine may be behind 2016 DNC hack

  Despite Fiona Hill warning, Sen. John Kennedy says Ukraine may be behind 2016 DNC hack Sen. John Kennedy said that despite the U.S. intelligence community's conclusion that Russia hacked the DNC in 2016, "it could also be Ukraine."During an appearance on "Fox News Sunday," host Chris Wallace asked Kennedy if he believed Russia or Ukraine was behind the computer hack.

Sondland said he directly raised concerns about the Ukraine pressure campaign with Pence Pence did not respond orally but nodded his head, Sondland recounted. “I was in a briefing with several “ Mike – Kurt and I negotiated a statement from Zelensky to be delivered for our review in a day or two

Vice President Mike Pence 's role in the events leading to the House of Representatives' impeachment inquiry is Democrats say they have questions about her knowledge of how much Pence knew about efforts Her name had not been mentioned yet despite multiple efforts to nail down who was on the

Start the day smarter. Get all the news you need in your inbox each morning.

Pence, surrounded by both sides’ aides and Cabinet members, did not specifically discuss with Zelensky the reasons behind the hold, according to testimony in House Democrats' impeachment inquiry into President Donald Trump's dealings with Ukraine. Instead, Pence assured Zelensky that the United States was fully behind Ukraine and that he would talk to Trump to try to get the assistance released.

a man and woman cutting a wedding cake: Ukraine's President Volodymyr Zelensky, left, shakes hands with U.S. Vice President Mike Pence, in Warsaw, Poland on Sept. 1, 2019.  A Washinton Post article published on Oct. 2, 2019 reported President Donald Trump used Pence in his attempt to pressure the new Ukrainian president to dig up dirt on Joe Biden, but is not conclusive on how much Pence knew about Trump's efforts. © Petr David Josek, AP Ukraine's President Volodymyr Zelensky, left, shakes hands with U.S. Vice President Mike Pence, in Warsaw, Poland on Sept. 1, 2019. A Washinton Post article published on Oct. 2, 2019 reported President Donald Trump used Pence in his attempt to pressure the new Ukrainian president to dig up dirt on Joe Biden, but is not conclusive on how much Pence knew about Trump's efforts.

It was diplomat Gordon Sondland who, in an anteroom with a senior Ukrainian official after the formal meeting, relayed that Ukraine could boost efforts to unfreeze the money if officials would announce an investigation into Burisma, the Ukrainian energy company that Hunter Biden worked for when his father, Joe Biden, was vice president.

Pompeo refuses to say what he and Giuliani talked about in newly disclosed calls

  Pompeo refuses to say what he and Giuliani talked about in newly disclosed calls The State Department released emails Friday showing that Pompeo and Giuliani spoke by phone twice in late March.The State Department released emails late Friday night showing that Pompeo and Giuliani spoke by phone in late March, as Giuliani was ramping up pressure on Ukrainian officials to open two investigations that would benefit Trump politically. The documents, turned over after a court ordered the State Department to comply with a freedom of information request, do not reveal the subject or context of the two Pompeo-Giuliani conversations.

More : How much did Mike Pence know about pressure on Ukraine ? Testimony suggests effort to flag concerns . © Jack Gruber-USA TODAY Donald Trump and Mike Pence on stage at the conclusion of the 2016 Republican National Convention at Quicken Loans Arena in Cleveland on July

U.S. Vice President Mike Pence said the American people “stand with Ukraine ” but that European nations should do more The U.S. still has “great concerns ” about corruption in Ukraine , he said. Pence said he discussed further aid to Ukraine during a meeting Sunday in the Polish capital with

Sondland also testified that, in a briefing he joined at the last minute before the Zelenksy meeting, he told Pence he was concerned the delay in aid had become tied to investigations Trump wanted.

Pence has disputed Sondland’s account of raising concerns about the aid. Even more, he has broadly denied knowing about the allegations at the center of the impeachment inquiry.

Still, an accumulation of public testimony, including from Sondland and other diplomats and aides, suggests heavy involvement by Pence in Ukraine generally, though no one seems to be accusing Pence of participating in or facilitating the effort to push Ukraine into taking up the investigations.

The testimony also indicates there were multiple opportunities for Pence to have been informed about the domestic political agenda being pursued in Ukraine.

Pence has disputed the notion that he was in the loop, telling WISN 12 News in Wisconsin after Sondland’s testimony that he was “not aware of the allegations that U.S. aid to Ukraine was tied to investigations at any point before those matters became public in September.”

'Unsavory,' not impeachable: Democratic lawmaker explains why he opposes removing Trump

  'Unsavory,' not impeachable: Democratic lawmaker explains why he opposes removing Trump New Jersey Democrat Jeff Van Drew, who knows Donald Trump, said voters, not lawmakers, should decide next year whether to remove the president.It's from 2008, when Van Drew was a state senator and the future president visited Atlantic City to christen the Chairman Tower at the Trump Taj Mahal. Both are wearing business suits, red ties and smiles.

Ambassador Gordon D. Sondland tied President Trump to the Ukraine pressure campaign in his testimony to the House Intelligence Committee. Our reporters provided live coverage and analysis.

Sondland's revised testimony in the impeachment probe about Trump's pressure on Ukraine . efforts to pressure Ukraine to announce investigations into the Bidens and Ukraine 's alleged I always believed that suspending aid to Ukraine was ill-advised, although I did not know (and still do This brief pull-aside conversation followed the larger meeting involving Vice President Pence and

Pence's spokeswoman said she had nothing to add to that statement.

Early warning on Ukraine and Rudy Giuliani

Pence’s office had been warned months before by a top National Security Council official concerned that something was going on with Ukraine that appeared to involve Rudy Giuliani, the president’s personal lawyer.

“I flagged to his staff, to General Kellogg that there were some issues, you know, kind of noise going on around Ukraine that was worrisome and that we’d need to get to the bottom of,” former National Security Council official Fiona Hill testified about her interaction with retired Lt. Gen. Keith Kellogg, Pence’s national security adviser.

Visualizing the impeachment hearings: A diagram of events in the impeachment inquiry of President Trump

a group of people standing next to a person in a suit and tie: National Security Council official Fiona Hill and State department official David Holmes testify before the House Intelligence Committee on Nov. 21, 2019 in a public hearing in the impeachment inquiry into President Donald Trump. © Jack Gruber, USA TODAY National Security Council official Fiona Hill and State department official David Holmes testify before the House Intelligence Committee on Nov. 21, 2019 in a public hearing in the impeachment inquiry into President Donald Trump.

Kellogg and Jennifer Williams, a national security adviser on loan to Pence from the State Department, listened in on Trump’s July 25 call with Zelensky in which Trump asked Zelensky to talk to Giuliani and to undertake investigations into the Bidens. A transcript of that call – which sparked the whistleblower complaint that became the center of the impeachment inquiry – was included in Pence’s daily briefing book.

Democrats are ready to explain why Trump should be impeached

  Democrats are ready to explain why Trump should be impeached Analysis: They know they need to use the upcoming hearings to translate the facts of the case — laid out in Tuesday's bombshell report — into support for the ultimate constitutional remedy."Foreign cheating," Rep. Eric Swalwell, D-Calif., explained in a telephone interview with NBC News Tuesday. "Everyone understands that.

Hill testified that Ukraine pressure campaign was a ‘domestic political errand.’ In rebuke to Trump Her testimony made it clear that Dr. Hill, a longtime Russia expert, saw the pressure campaign on Representative Mike Turner of Ohio laced into Dr. Hill, using his time during Thursday’s hearing to

Republicans have insisted that Ukraine did not know that the aid had been held up until it was reported in the news media in late August. So we knew that in the middle of this jam-packed week of impeachment testimony , Gordon Sondland’s appearance was going to be something different.

Williams also testified that Pence’s office had been instructed by Trump not to send Pence to Zelensky’s May inauguration, another detail noted in the whistleblower’s complaint.

Pence’s name came up during the testimony of about a dozen of the 17 people who testified during October and November either in public or in private depositions later made public, though only a handful talked in detail about their interactions with Pence regarding Ukraine.

Impeachment witnesses: Who are the 17 witnesses in the Trump impeachment inquiry and what have they said?

Trump attack: Trump dismisses Mike Pence aide Jennifer Williams as 'Never Trumper'

Mike Pence an eager player on foreign policy

Witnesses described Pence as active in foreign policy and particularly eager to be involved in Ukraine, a strategic U.S. ally at war with Russia.

Hill testified that she worked closely with Pence’s team, including Kellogg and Williams.

Despite Pence’s small staff, Hill said, the vice president played an important foreign policy and diplomatic role.

“Vice President Pence has been, you know, extremely good about stepping up when asked,” Hill said in her initial deposition with the House intelligence committee. Pence, she also said, “wanted to play a role on Ukraine in this administration.”

'This is not how an American president should be impeached': GOP witness Jonathan Turley to launch Trump defense

  'This is not how an American president should be impeached': GOP witness Jonathan Turley to launch Trump defense Jonathan Turley, the lone Republican selected as legal expert for Wednesday’s impeachment hearing, will condemn the Democrat-led process. © Provided by Washington Examiner “This is not how an American president should be impeached," he will say, according to a copy of his prepared remarks obtained by the Washington Examiner. Turley, a law professor at George Washington University, is appearing in front of the House Judiciary Committee alongside three Democrat-selected witnesses in its first Ukraine-related impeachment hearing.

Hill said she tried to keep Pence’s office as informed as possible and would wave red flags for meetings his team should avoid or things it needed to be aware of that could affect the integrity of the vice president and his office.

That included, she testified, sharing with Kellogg her concerns about Giuliani and the abrupt dismissal of Marie Yovanovitch from her post as U.S. ambassador to Ukraine in the spring.

“I wanted to make sure that they knew that there were issues and they should be very careful,” she said.

Kellogg didn’t say that he would pass Hill’s concerns on to Pence but did say he would talk to his team, Hill testified.

More red flags on Ukraine

Williams testified that after Yovanovitch was recalled, she included that information in one of her regular written briefings for Pence, along with “some commentary about some of the media reports surrounding her removal.”

She also flagged for Pence in May news reports about Giuliani’s involvement in Ukraine.

“I certainly recognized that (Giuliani) was interested in looking into the role that former Vice President Biden’s son had played on the board of a company,” Williams testified.

Impeachment inquiry: Here's the evidence committees have compiled to bolster Trump impeachment case

a woman sitting at a table using a laptop: Jennifer Williams, a foreign policy aide to Vice President Mike Pence, delivers opening remarks as she testifies on Nov. 19, 2019 before the Permanent Select Committee on Intelligence. © Jack Gruber, USA TODAY Jennifer Williams, a foreign policy aide to Vice President Mike Pence, delivers opening remarks as she testifies on Nov. 19, 2019 before the Permanent Select Committee on Intelligence.

David Holmes, a State Department official in the American Embassy in Kiev, testified that an associate of Zelensky told him in April that he had been contacted by “someone named Giuliani who said he was an adviser to the vice president.” Holmes added, however, that the Ukrainian could have gotten the name wrong. Pence’s spokeswoman said Giuliani has never been an adviser to Pence and the vice president has never spoken to Giuliani about the issue.

Today in History: December 9

  Today in History: December 9 Today in History: December 9

Pence told not to go to inauguration

After Zelensky was elected in April on promises to root out corruption in the former Soviet state and to help solve the deadly conflict with Russia, the State Department wanted Pence to attend Zelensky’s inauguration, according to David Hale, the department’s No. 3 official.

Pence’s staff had been in the preliminary planning stages for that, still uncertain whether the May date would fit his schedule when, Williams testified, she was told by an assistant to Pence’s chief of staff that Trump didn’t want Pence to go.

None of the witnesses said they knew the reason behind that direction. Democrats say the timing is suspicious because it happened shortly after Giuliani claimed  people around Zelensky were antagonistic to Trump.

Pence later received in his daily briefing book a transcription of Trump’s July call with Zelensky, in which Trump asked his Ukrainian counterpart to “do us a favor” by investigating a theory that Ukraine had meddled in the 2016 presidential election and asked for help investigating the Bidens.

Aides listened to Trump's call

Williams testified that the call struck her as “unusual and inappropriate.” It also, she said, “shed some light on possible other motivations behind a security assistance hold.”

But Williams said she didn’t express concern at the time with anyone in Pence’s office because her supervisor, Kellogg, also was listening in on the call and because she “knew that the vice president had access to the transcript from his briefing book that evening.”

Kellogg, who has not testified, said in a statement that he “heard nothing wrong or improper on the call.”

Tim Morrison, who took over for Hill at the National Security Council in July, testified that Pence is “known to be a voracious reader of his daily brief.”

Pence has said he doesn’t remember reading the transcript.

Trump denounces charges as Democrats announce articles of impeachment

  Trump denounces charges as Democrats announce articles of impeachment Trump lashed out against Democrats on Twitter after they announced articles of impeachment accusing him of abuse of power and obstruction of Congress.In social media, television interviews, and public statements, Trump and his aides denounced the impeachment charges as baseless and politically motivated, and claimed he would be vindicated in a Senate trial.

“But had I read it, it wouldn’t matter because the president did nothing wrong,” he told FOX Business Network’s Trish Regan in November. "There was no quid pro quo."

Pence meets with Zelensky

When Pence subbed for Trump on the trip to Poland so the president could deal with the threat of Hurricane Dorian in the USA, Pence was eager to speak to Zelensky to convey support for him, Morrison said.

“It was really the one meeting that the vice president was adamant he take,” Morrison testified.

Impeachment testimony: Read all the transcripts from the closed-door testimony

Pence brought up Trump's focus on corruption reform in Ukraine and conveyed Trump's desire that countries besides the United States also provide security assistance to Ukraine, according to Morrison.

Pence tried to encourage Zelensky, Morrison said, but “there was only so much he could say” to allay the concerns about whether the assistance would be forthcoming.

The next day, Pence didn’t directly respond when asked by reporters whether he could assure Ukraine that the freeze was not related to efforts by Giuliani and others to dig up dirt on the Biden family.

He has also sidestepped the question of whether he was ever aware of those efforts, saying the question of military aid was “from my experience” not connected.

He may have been careful to keep himself removed from what Hill called the “domestic political errand” that Sondland and Giuliani were running in Ukraine while she and others were pursuing the “national security foreign policy.”

When Wisconsin GOP Sen. Ron Johnson became alarmed in August after Sondland described to him some of what was going on, Johnson was urged by then-national security adviser John Bolton to raise his concerns directly with Trump and Pence. But while Johnson got Trump on the phone that day – Aug. 31 – he “was not able to schedule a call with Vice President Pence,” Johnson wrote to the House intelligence committee.

a group of people sitting in a room: This handout picture taken and released by Ukrainian presidential press-service on September 1, 2019, shows Vice President Mike Pence and Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky holding talks next to their delegations in Warsaw. © STR, AFP/Getty Images This handout picture taken and released by Ukrainian presidential press-service on September 1, 2019, shows Vice President Mike Pence and Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky holding talks next to their delegations in Warsaw.

Pence has disputed that Sondland told him in Warsaw what was happening, telling WISN 12 News he has “no recollection of any discussion with Ambassador Sondland before that meeting.”

Sondland, however, didn’t describe the exchange as a “discussion.” He said Pence acknowledged what he had say with a nod of his head but made no comment.

“He didn’t respond,” Sondland said. “He just listened.”

Pathway of the impeachment process: How it works, where we are

Pence not a target of impeachment inquiry

Even if Democrats leading the impeachment inquiry believe Pence is implicated, they appear to be staying squarely focused on Trump. They haven’t tried to interview him and didn’t issue a subpoena when Pence refused a request to turn over documents voluntarily. Instead, Rep. Adam Schiff, chairman of the Intelligence Committee, has said he views the noncooperation from the vice president and other administration officials as evidence of obstruction by the Trump administration, which itself could be an impeachable offense.

Democrats have calculated it’s better to move ahead with the evidence they already have, rather than be drawn into protracted court battles with uncooperative witnesses.

“We cannot be at the mercy of the courts,” House Speaker Nancy Pelosi said recently.

But Jonathan Turley, a constitutional law professor at George Washington University, said Democrats’ desire for speed means they’re ignoring important witnesses such as those who could corroborate or disprove what Sondland testified about Pence.

“This is a largely undeveloped evidentiary record, and the Pence controversy is just one example of that,” Turley said. “Individuals like Pence have little to be concerned about when the Democrats are insisting on a vote before any of these conflicts are resolved.”

Pence’s reputation could still take a hit in the court of public opinion.

“It strains the bonds of credulity to the breaking point to assume that Mike Pence knew nothing about any of this,” said Aaron David Miller, a senior fellow at the Carnegie Endowment who served as a State Department adviser for both Democratic and Republican administrations.

But, as always, Pence also has to worry about staying in Trump’s good graces. Despite his unfailing loyalty, speculation persists that Trump could replace him on the 2020 ticket.

Trump was asked yet again about that rumor when he called into Fox & Friends the day after the intelligence committee’s Ukraine hearings ended.

“Mike Pence is a great vice president,” Trump said. “He's our man, 100%.”

Impeachment hearings: Here are some key moments

Follow our coverage: How to stay updated on USA TODAY's impeachment coverage

This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: How much did Mike Pence know about pressure on Ukraine? Testimony suggests effort to flag concerns

Trump denounces charges as Democrats announce articles of impeachment .
Trump lashed out against Democrats on Twitter after they announced articles of impeachment accusing him of abuse of power and obstruction of Congress.In social media, television interviews, and public statements, Trump and his aides denounced the impeachment charges as baseless and politically motivated, and claimed he would be vindicated in a Senate trial.

—   Share news in the SOC. Networks

Topical videos:

usr: 1
This is interesting!