Politics Memo from 1990s pollution case shows Elizabeth Warren in action as corporate consultant

06:30  10 december  2019
06:30  10 december  2019 Source:   washingtonpost.com

Warren receives endorsement from Illinois congresswoman ahead of Chicago rally

  Warren receives endorsement from Illinois congresswoman ahead of Chicago rally Presidential hopeful Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.) nabbed the endorsement of Rep. Jan Schakowsky (D-Ill.), a congresswoman who represents part of Chicago's North Side and some of its northern suburbs ahead of the senator's rally in the city Saturday.Schakowsky said she first got to know Warren when the senator came up with the idea for creating the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, according to a statement from the Warren campaign obtained by The Hill.

The memo from then-Professor Elizabeth Warren was written on Harvard Law School letterhead, a symbol of gravitas for a scholar Warren ’s compensation in the 1996 case was included in a summary released by her campaign late Sunday night showing that she had been paid about million as a

Warren ’s consulting work often involved companies dealing with bankruptcy, which While the cases released by Warren ’s campaign stretch over more than three decades, the figures disclosed © Sarah Blake Morgan/AP Democratic presidential candidate Elizabeth Warren speaks during an interview

Elizabeth Warren standing in front of a microphone: Democratic presidential hopeful Elizabeth Warren speaks during a town hall Sunday in Charleston, S.C.© Meg Kinnard/AP Democratic presidential hopeful Elizabeth Warren speaks during a town hall Sunday in Charleston, S.C.

The memo from then-Professor Elizabeth Warren was written on Harvard Law School letterhead, a symbol of gravitas for a scholar renowned as a champion for consumers victimized by predatory banks and other big businesses.

But on this occasion, Warren was not arguing on behalf of vulnerable families, nor was she offering the sort of stinging rebuke of corporate greed that would later define her political career. Rather, Warren was representing a large development company that was trying to avoid having to clean up a toxic waste site.

Warren Is Drafting U.S. Legislation to Reverse ‘Mega Mergers’

  Warren Is Drafting U.S. Legislation to Reverse ‘Mega Mergers’ U.S. Senator Elizabeth Warren is drafting a bill that would call on regulators to retroactively review about two decades of “mega mergers” and ban such deals going forward. Warren’s staff recently circulated a proposal for sweeping anti-monopoly legislation, which would deliver on a presidential campaign promise to check the power of Big Tech and other industries. Although the Trump administration is currently exploring their own antitrust probes, the proposal is likely to face resistance from lawmakers.© Bloomberg WARREN Elizabeth Warren on Dec. 4.

Elizabeth Ann Warren (née Herring; born June 22, 1949) is an American politician and former academic, serving as the senior United States Senator from Massachusetts since 2013.

Warren ’s consulting work often involved companies dealing with bankruptcy, which was her specialty as an academic. Warren ’s campaign did not release compensation information for all of the cases , reporting in some instances — including a case involving Warren , in turn, has asked him to name

Subscribe to the Post Most newsletter: Today’s most popular stories on The Washington Post

The memo, which Warren wrote in 1996, used legalistic and often dense language to argue that businesses faced the “risk of the unknown” from a growing threat of lawsuits, and that defended the company’s right to “maximize its returns to its unpaid creditors and to survive as an employer.”

“Environmental claims, product liability claims, and mass tort claims, for which we have currently only seen the tip of the iceberg, are multiplying against American businesses,” wrote Warren, who, according to her campaign, was arguing that a different company should bear the cleanup costs.

The eight-page memo, which has not previously been reported, offers a rare glimpse of Warren in action during her past work as a corporate consultant — one whose arguments were at times out of step with the liberal presidential campaign she is running today.

Warren goes after Buttigieg, Bloomberg in change of tactics

  Warren goes after Buttigieg, Bloomberg in change of tactics Warren criticized the South Bend, Indiana, mayor for raising money in private and accused the former New York mayor of buying his way into the campaign.After her speech at the Democratic National Committee's I Will Vote event in Boston, Warren called on Buttigieg, the mayor of South Bend, Indiana, to let the news media into his private campaign events "so that anyone can come in and report on what's being said" to big financial donors.

Senator Elizabeth Warren disclosed a detailed list of compensation she received during 30 years of moonlighting as a legal consultant — about .9 million in all — as she and Mayor Pete Buttigieg continued a back-and-forth demanding transparency in the race for the Democratic presidential

See Elizabeth Warren 's position on immigration, healthcare, gun control and more election 2020 Warren has often described her upbringing in Oklahoma, where she was the youngest of four Reinstate the methane pollution rule to limit existing oil and gas projects from releasing harmful gases.

Warren’s compensation in the 1996 case was included in a summary released by her campaign late Sunday night showing that she had been paid about $2 million as a legal consultant during her time as a professor, most of it between 1995 and 2009.

But Warren, who has released 11 years of tax returns, has not disclosed her tax records from most of that time period. And her campaign has provided few details about her private legal business beyond short descriptions released in May of cases she worked on and the Sunday night disclosure, which came amid a growing feud over transparency between Warren and rival Pete Buttigieg.

Buttigieg, who has accused Warren of not being fully up front about her legal work, on Monday responded to criticisms from Warren about his own secrecy — announcing he had secured permission from the McKinsey & Co. consulting firm to disclose information about his time there and saying he would reveal names of major donors collecting checks for his campaign.

Elizabeth Warren's health records show she's in 'excellent health'

  Elizabeth Warren's health records show she's in 'excellent health' Sen. Elizabeth Warren's doctor said she's in "excellent health.""Senator Warren is in excellent health and has been throughout the 20 years I have served as her physician," Dr. Beverly Woo, a primary care doctor at Brigham and Women's Hospital in Boston, wrote in the medical report. Warren has "no medical conditions or health problems that would keep her from fulfilling the duties of the President of the United States.

Elizabeth Warren , Democratic senator from Massachusetts. Elizabeth Warren seeks to use Trump Pocahontas 'racial slur' as political tool. Read more. The Globe reported that interviews and documents show the issue was not considered by Harvard Law faculty or those who admitted Warren

‘Take your daughter to work’ was a classic 90s invention – a response to our own mothers, who both worked and shouldered the domestic responsibilities.

Warren’s private legal work spanned a diverse portfolio — arguing motions in court, consulting behind the scenes and filing briefs. Though most of the work was paid, she occasionally provided her services for free, including to help seniors protect retirement accounts and guard against asset seizures.

Among the corporations that hired Warren was Dow Chemical, which spent years trying to ward off liability after a subsidiary company’s silicone breast implants began to rupture. She also worked for LTV Steel, a firm that battled with the labor movement as it tried to avoid paying millions of dollars for retired coal miners’ health care.

The 1996 case, in which she represented a real estate development company called CMC Heartland fighting in court to avoid having to pay to clean up a polluted old rail yard along the Puget Sound in Washington state, stands out because her memo offers a road map for how she made her arguments.

Warren was paid about $21,000 for the work, according to the data released Sunday by her campaign.

CMC Heartland Partners was trying to avoid a newly enacted Washington state law that could put it on the hook for about $4 million of the cleanup costs, according to local news reports. The company, which had acquired the land through a bankruptcy proceeding, argued that the legal maneuver should have shielded it from responsibility.

Sen. Elizabeth Warren earned nearly $2 million consulting for corporations and financial firms, records show

  Sen. Elizabeth Warren earned nearly $2 million consulting for corporations and financial firms, records show The documents, abruptly released by the Massachusetts senator, in some cases deviated from her presidential campaign positioning as a crusader against corporate interests. Subscribe to the Post Most newsletter: Today’s most popular stories on The Washington PostFor instance, the documents released Sunday show that Warren made about $80,000 from work she did for creditors in the energy company Enron’s bankruptcy and $20,000 as a consultant for Dow Chemical, a company that was trying to limit the liability it faced from silicone breast implants that were made by a connected firm.

Democratic presidential candidate Elizabeth Warren released information on Sunday about her past In return, Warren has called on Buttigieg to allow media coverage of his private donor events and to In some cases , she worked with a group of consultants . The document showed a total of nearly

Elizabeth Warren is running on a populist campaign built on ambitious ideas in the 2020 presidential election. Warren first rose to fame for her withering interrogations of miscreant bankers and evasive government officials during the financial crisis 10 years ago.

Warren’s memo was sent to the Justice Department in an effort to elevate the matter to the U.S. Supreme Court — a move seen by activists at the time as a delay tactic that would only jeopardize public health.

Environmentalists who fought to clean up toxic waste sites said they are familiar with that tactic and the frustrations it causes.

“Every time somebody takes a breath of air or touches soil, they’re getting poisoned while they’re fighting in court,” said Lois Gibbs, who founded the Center for Health, Environment and Justice, a nonprofit that helps communities fight environmental health threats. “How many lives were changed while they had that fight? How many women weren’t able to carry their baby full term or had a birth defect or had a child that got cancer?”

Warren’s campaign has defended her past consulting work, saying she was providing services as an expert in a bankruptcy system designed to protect the rights of businesses as well as everyday Americans.

“In her books, speeches, research, and advocacy, Elizabeth has consistently argued for preserving key legal principles that allow bankruptcy to produce the best and fairest distribution of compensation when a company goes broke — including to victims and consumers and including for environmental harms,” said her spokeswoman, Kristen Orthman.

Warren's wealth tax would raise less revenue than campaign estimates: study

  Warren's wealth tax would raise less revenue than campaign estimates: study The wealth tax proposal from Democratic presidential candidate Elizabeth Warren is unlikely to raise as much revenue as the Massachusetts senator's campaign claims it would, according to projections from the Penn-Wharton Budget Model (PWBM) released Thursday. require(["medianetNativeAdOnArticle"], function (medianetNativeAdOnArticle) { medianetNativeAdOnArticle.getMedianetNativeAds(true); }); Warren has proposed a tax of 2 percent on net worth between $50 million and $1 billion, and a tax of 6 percent on net worth above $1 billion. The campaign is projecting that the tax would raise $3.

Was Warren on the agenda because, as her critics say, she had decided to self-identify as a Native American woman and Harvard saw a chance to Warren , in a lengthy interview that started in the sparsely decorated Penn Quarter condo where she stays in Washington and ended in her hideaway

5 1990 s . 6 2000s. 7 2010–present. No / Killed in action . 14 years. The son-in-law of the man who discovered her body had an interest in the case and contacted her relatives after seeing a missing persons report. Elizabeth Lamotte disappeared from Manchester, New Hampshire on 6 April 1984.

Pointing to the Puget Sound dispute, Orthman added: “Elizabeth wrote a single memo related to a six-year litigation on a legal issue arising from the unique circumstances of a particular case that arguably threatened one of those foundational bankruptcy principles.

“There was no question the rail yard would get cleaned up; the question was which company would pay,” Orthman said. “Elizabeth’s memo was not about the merits of environmental laws, which she strongly supports and has fought to expand both in the Senate and as a presidential candidate.”

By the time Warren was tapped for the case, the dispute had been building for years.

The case centered on a 50-acre plot that had switched owners several times and was long home to aluminum smelters and pulp mills, contributing to the region’s infamous “Tacoma aroma.” Workers cleaned out rail cars on that spot for years, spilling oil into the soil, court records say.

The real estate went to CMC Heartland Partners after the railway went bankrupt in 1977. The parcel was then sold to another firm, Union Pacific, and ultimately to the Port of Tacoma — which demanded a cleanup.

The new state law had been approved by voters and was modeled after a federal law designed to clean up what are known as Superfund sites. It sought to require even past owners of polluted land to contribute to cleanup costs.

Warren presented the case as a philosophical clash. “This is not a simple case of debtor versus creditor . . . ” she wrote. “Instead this is [a] question about the scope of the bankruptcy laws.” She added that it is “not even a slight exaggeration” to say the dispute “relates to the very heart of an important part of the legal system.”

Warren says Bloomberg 'has to answer' for sexist comments

  Warren says Bloomberg 'has to answer' for sexist comments Elizabeth Warren says Michael Bloomberg 'has to answer' for sexist comments and women should be released from their NDAs. "I think [nondisclosure agreements] are a way for people to hide bad things they've done. And I think that women should be able to speak," Warren told reporters during a campaign stop in Fort Madison, Iowa, on Monday. "They need to be released from [nondisclosure agreements].

Elizabeth Warren (D-MA) disclosed on Sunday that she made nearly million from past legal work – including work for corporate clients. Warren , in turn, has called for Buttigieg to open access to his closed-door fundraisers and expose his wealthy bundlers. “This is about what’s going on right now.

Warren 's critics, such as Turning Point USA founder Charlie Kirk, seized on the opportunity to suggest that "While she advocates for socialism she hypocritically lives a millionaire lifestyle." Elizabeth Warren just disclosed she made .9 million from her legal work representing big corporate clients.

The Supreme Court declined to take the case, letting stand lower court rulings against Heartland and requiring it to finance the cleanup.

Warren’s argument put her in line with other major corporations that were also seeking a Supreme Court review of the Washington state law.

CMC Heartland Partners’ counsel of record for the case was Kenneth W. Starr, who at the time also served as the independent counsel examining allegations against President Bill Clinton. Orthman said Warren does not recall Starr being her contact for the case, and Starr did not respond to attempts to contact him.

Another top lawyer working for Heartland was Richard Cordray, an Ohio politician and a Warren ally to this day. In an interview, Cordray said neither he nor Warren was arguing that the toxic waste site should not be restored.

“It wasn’t like there was going to be nobody responsible for cleaning the place up,” he said. “It’s just which of two companies was responsible and what percentages.”

Warren’s campaign pointed to an analysis by Edward Janger, a bankruptcy professor at Brooklyn Law School, whom it asked to review the case after The Washington Post began asking questions about it. Janger said that strong bankruptcy protections like those advocated by Warren made it more likely — not less — that money would be available for cleanups.

“Unless a debtor can address [its] liabilities in the reorganization, it will typically be forced to liquidate — costing jobs and leaving much less for everybody, including those seeking recovery of environmental cleanup costs,” Janger said.

But Marv Coleman, a retired state official who helped oversee the cleanup, said the companies trying to shift responsibility to each other made the environmental effort that much harder.

“Quite often . . . one company could point the finger to another company,” Coleman said. “That was very common in that period, and that was kind of frustrating.”

David Rieser, who worked on the case for Union Pacific (and had not known about Warren’s role), said the new environmental laws were designed to spread costs widely so that enough money could be raised for expensive cleanups.

“All of these environmental laws were a real change to the liability scheme,” Rieser said. “Even if a company had gotten rid of something 100 years ago, they could still be liable for it under this law.”

Heartland did end up paying. By October 1998, after the Supreme Court decided not to hear the case, the company settled with the Port of Tacoma, records show.

The site is in productive use today, said Scott Hooton, a program manager for the port who oversaw the cleanup from 2007 to 2015. Rows of new cars from Asia are often parked there, ready to be shipped by rail or highway to dealerships across the country. “It’s been a successful cleanup,” Hooton said.

Heartland, though, has not been as successful. It declared bankruptcy in 2006.



Robert B. Reich: President Warren Sanders .
There aren't 20 Senate Republicans with enough integrity to remove the most corrupt president in American history, so we're going to have to get rid of Trump the old-fashioned way-- by electing a Democrat next November 3. Although there are differences between Elizabeth Warren and Bernie Sanders, I'm putting them together for the purpose of making a simple point.These two have most of the grassroots energy in the 2020 campaign, most of the enthusiasm, and most of the ideas critical for America's future.Together, they lead Biden and every other so-called moderate Democrat by a wide margin in all polls.

—   Share news in the SOC. Networks

Topical videos:

usr: 11
This is interesting!