Politics DOJ tells court McGahn subpoena is moot after impeachment vote
House Democrats Unveil Articles of Impeachment Against Trump
House Democrats announced on Tuesday that they would move ahead this week with two articles of impeachment charging President Trump with abuse of power and obstruction of Congress, as they accused him of violating the Constitution by pressure Ukraine for help in the 2020 election. Speaking from a wood-paneled reception room just off the floor of the House, Speaker Nancy Pelosi and leaders of six key committees said that Mr. Trump’s actions toward Ukraine, and his efforts to block Congress’s attempt to investigate, had left them no choice but to pursue one of the Constitution’s gravest remedies.
The Trump administration told a court on Thursday that the House subpoena ordering former White House counsel Don McGahn to testify in the impeachment inquiry "appears to be moot" now that the president has been impeached.
The Department of Justice submitted a brief with the D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals arguing that the House Judiciary Committee overstepped its authority by seeking a court order to compel McGahn to testify and that it plans to take the fight to the Supreme Court if it loses on appeal.
"Although the judgment instead should be reversed and the case dismissed, if the Court were to disagree, it should at least leave the stay in place for a reasonable period to allow the Solicitor General to seek appropriate relief from the Supreme Court, especially given the serious question whether McGahn's testimony is even relevant to the now-passed articles of impeachment," the DOJ wrote in a footnote to the brief.
Trump Undecided on Role in Trial, Aide Says: Impeachment Update
House Democrats leading the panels running the impeachment inquiry into President Donald Trump announced their next steps.Republican staff attorney Steve Castor testifies as the House Judiciary Committee hears investigative findings in the impeachment inquiry of President Donald Trump, on Dec. 9, on Capitol Hill in Washington, DC.
Two panels of D.C. Circuit judges will hear arguments early next month over the House Judiciary Committee's subpoena battles with the Justice Department in the McGahn case as well as in a dispute over redacted material from the Robert Mueller special counsel report.
After the House passed two articles of impeachment against President Trump Wednesday night, the two D.C. Circuit panels immediately ordered the parties in both cases to brief them next week on whether the subpoenas are moot, now that the impeachment process in the House is over.
The Justice Department also added that the House committee lacks legal standing to bring the case and that the courts should not be used to resolve such disputes between the executive and legislative branches.
"A court should refrain from embroiling itself in an interbranch dispute without any imprimatur from Congress as a whole, particularly where the Committee's primary asserted need for subpoenaing McGahn-his potential testimony related to an obstruction-of-justice impeachment charge... appears to be moot," the department wrote.
A spokeswoman for the House Judiciary Committee did not immediately return a request for comment on whether it still plans to pursue the subpoenas.
Inside impeachment: How an 'urgent' tip became 'high crimes' .
Not a single Republican voted for President Donald Trump's impeachment, but there were moments when that outcome was less than certainFor Democrats, it was an instant bombshell, a “jaw-hit-the-floor sort of moment,” one lawmaker said. Another described sneaking peeks at Republican colleagues to see whether they were having a similar reaction.
Watch: House Judiciary Committee impeachment inquiry hearings - Day 1 (FULL LIVE STREAM)
Watch live analysis from The Washington Post as the House Judiciary Committee holds its first hearing on the Trump impeachment inquiry. Four legal scholars ...
House Rules Committee Meets on Articles of Impeachment
The House Rules Committee debates and votes on two articles of impeachment against President Trump: abuse of power and obstruction of Congress.