Politics Should the United States withdraw from the WTO?
ESPN’s Doris Burke opens up about COVID-19 struggle, NBA’s resumption concerns
When asked about the challenges the NBA will face as it attempts to mount a comeback next month, Burke didn’t mince words.“The thing that I felt the most was fatigue and headache,” Burke said about having coronavirus. “So for a good stretch of the first two weeks of that, I was just thinking I had a bad flu, because my symptoms were not aligning with what was being told were the main symptoms — the shortness of breath, the pressure on the chest — I didn’t have those scary symptoms. So for a good stretch of time, I didn’t think I had it. But then I finally decided to get tested.
The joint effort by Sen. Josh Hawley (R-Mo.) and Rep. Peter DeFazio (D-Ore.) to withdraw the United States from the World Trade Organization (WTO) has run into a procedural roadblock in Congress, but the rear-guard assault on U.S. membership in the 25-year-old institution will certainly continue. Advocates of free trade and U.S. leadership in the global trading system should welcome a robust debate, whether inside or outside the halls of Congress.
First-term Sen. Hawley has emerged as a leading critic of the WTO and the global trading system that it buttresses. Inand , he has questioned the fairness of its dispute settlement system and blamed its trade rules for depressing real wages and eliminating millions of U.S. manufacturing jobs. While there is broad agreement that the WTO system needs reform, Hawley's critique is factually challenged. In reality, withdrawal from the WTO would inflict lasting damage on the U.S. economy and our standing in the world.
New ruling quashes Hawley's hope for Senate WTO withdrawal vote
Congress is unlikely to vote on any withdrawal resolution this year. The House last voted on the issue in 2005 and the Senate has never voted on the measure. Both chambers would have to approve the resolution for President Donald Trump to be able to sign it into law. That always was a high hurdle to clear. But blocking a vote means members don't have to take a public position before the November elections. Background: The 1994 Uruguay Round Agreements Act, which approved U.S. membership in the WTO, is supposed to provide an opportunity for both chambers to vote on withdrawal every five years.
The World Trade Organization has delivered on its promises of creating a more rules-based global trading system with broadly declining barriers to trade in goods and services. Its dispute settlement system has held members accountable to follow those rules, benefitting both American exporters and American workers and consumers.
Since the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade was adopted by the United States and other major trading nations in 1947, the average level of global tariffs levied against U.S. exports has dropped sharplyThat trend has continued under the 1994 Uruguay Round Agreement, which established the WTO while beefing up the dispute settlement mechanism to keep barriers down.
Why China Wants Trump to Win
Four more years might present tantalizing opportunities for Beijing to expand its influence around East Asia and the world. Of course, we can’t know with certainty what outcome China’s senior cadres prefer, or if they even agree among themselves. No candidate should expect an endorsement from People’s Daily. Still, there are clues. In a highly unusual comment, the former Chinese trade negotiator Long Yongtu reportedly told a Shenzhen conference late last year, “We want Trump to be reelected; we would be glad to see that happen.
The result has been a healthy increase in U.S. trade, including exports. Since the creation of the WTO, U.S. exports of goods and services have jumped from $700 billion in 1994 to $2.5 trillion in 2019. As a share of the domestic economy, exports have climbed from under 10 percent to 12 percent. The WTO has also encouraged lower U.S. barriers to trade, to the benefit of tens of millions of consumers here at home, as well as import-consuming U.S. producers.
Aby the U.S. International Trade Commission found that the lower tariffs agreed to in the Uruguay Round Agreement disproportionately benefited middle- and lower-income U.S. consumers through lower prices for basic goods such as footwear and clothing. Increased patent protection resulting from the WTO's Agreement on Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights boosted U.S. international receipts for the use of intellectual property by $10.3 billion a year, or 12.6 percent. The WTO's Information Technology Agreement increased annual U.S. exports of covered IT products by $34.4 billion, or 56.7 percent.
Overnight Health Care: Trump says White House will pressure governors to open schools | Administration formally moves to withdraw US from WHO | Fauci warns against 'false complacency' on COVID-19
Welcome to Tuesday's Overnight Health Care. Anthony Fauci warned not to take comfort in a falling death rate. The CDC found 87 percent of workers with COVID-19 at meat processing plants are minorities. And President Trump said he is going to pressure governors to open schools in the fall. Let's start with schools Trump says White House will pressure governors to open schoolsPresident Trump on Tuesday said his administration would put pressure on governors to get schools opened in the fall amid rising coronavirus cases in the United States.
Like many critics of trade, Sen. Hawley blames the WTO for a supposed decline in average real wages for American workers and for the loss of manufacturing jobs. In fact,since the mid-1990s after stagnating for the two decades before then. And while manufacturing jobs have declined, real manufacturing output and value added have increased, indicating that rising productivity - and not trade - is the cause.
The WTO's enhanced dispute settlement has been a success. It has rendered judgments on hundreds of cases, leading to more faithful adherence to the rules members have agreed to follow. There is no evidence of any bias against the U.S. government. As Dan Ikenson of the Cato Institute, "When the United States has been a complainant (as it has in 114 of 522 WTO disputes over 22 years-more than any other WTO member) it has prevailed on 91 percent of adjudicated issues. When the United States is a respondent (as it has been in 129 cases-more than any other WTO member), it has lost on 89 percent of adjudicated issues." Both closely match the average 90 percent success rate of complainants.
Trump says he's withdrawing from the WHO while the pandemic rages, but he can't without Congress
Legal scholars and public health experts say President Trump cannot unilaterally withdraw the US from the WHO, and requires congressional approval. "As the complex process moves forward, I would expect Congress to weigh in on the wisdom of divorcing the entirety of US global health policy from the network of disease fighting programs that the US helped to build over decades, with the aid and cooperation of WHO and other countries," Dr. Jack Chow, a former WHO assistant director-general, told Insider.
Withdrawal from the WTO would deny U.S. producers the protection of lower barriers abroad and a proven forum for settling commercial disputes. It would cede leadership of the global economy to China, the European Union and other major trading entities, while relegating the United States to the ranks of suchas Belarus, Iran, Libya, Serbia, Somalia, Sudan, Syria and Uzbekistan.
Whether you think Hawley is right or wrong about the WTO, it would be a valuable exercise to debate the merits of U.S. membership on the floor of both the U.S. House and Senate. Instead of misguided calls to abandon the WTO, we need a rational, bipartisan discussion of how to fine-tune and reform a system that has served our nation well for more than seven decades.
is a senior research fellow and co-director of the Trade and Immigration Project at the Mercatus Center at George Mason University.
Quinton Dunbar’s attorneys withdraw from case after payoff allegations .
Yahoo Sports’ Krysten Peek shares her evaluation of Alabama Crimson Tide G Kira Lewis Jr.