Politics Trump grabs 'third rail' of politics with payroll tax pause

14:06  12 august  2020
14:06  12 august  2020 Source:   thehill.com

Conservatives urge Trump to take unilateral action to suspend payroll tax collection

  Conservatives urge Trump to take unilateral action to suspend payroll tax collection Stephen Moore, a member of the White House's economic recovery task force, is urging President Trump to direct the IRS to suspend collecting payroll taxes, arguing that doing so would help the middle class and benefit the president politically."He should declare a national economic emergency and announce that the Internal Revenue Service will immediately stop collecting the payroll tax," Moore, along with Phil Kerpen, wrote in an op-ed Sunday in The Wall Street Journal. Moore is a co-founder of the conservative Committee to Unleash Prosperity, and Kerpen is the group's president. Trump has repeatedly called for a payroll tax cut as the U.S.

The third rail of a nation's politics is a metaphor for any issue so controversial that it is "charged" and "untouchable" to the extent that any politician or public official who dares to broach the subject will invariably suffer politically .

Payroll tax cuts are no longer verboten: It used to be that, when lawmakers were talking about cutting taxes , they were almost always talking about income tax cuts. But they still have to pay payroll taxes on their employees’ wages, and that’s where lawmakers have been trying to make a difference.

President Trump's pledge to "terminate" the payroll tax that funds Social Security defies the conventional wisdom of staying away from what's known as the "third rail" of politics.

a man wearing a suit and tie: Trump grabs 'third rail' of politics with payroll tax pause © Getty Images Trump grabs 'third rail' of politics with payroll tax pause

Proposing a major reform to Social Security shortly before election traditionally has been seen as the political equivalent of touching the highly electrified rail that powers subway cars.

Trump signs executive orders enacting $400 unemployment benefit, payroll tax cut after coronavirus stimulus talks stall

  Trump signs executive orders enacting $400 unemployment benefit, payroll tax cut after coronavirus stimulus talks stall Trump's order enacts a $400 weekly federal unemployment benefit, less than the $600 benefit that expired at the end of July.At a news conference from his golf resort in Bedminster, N.J., Trump signed four orders that will provide an additional $400 per week in unemployment benefits, suspend payments on some student loans through the end of the year, protect renters from being evicted from their homes, and instruct employers to defer certain payroll taxes through the end of the year for Americans who earn less than $100,000 annually.

President Donald Trump said Monday he would press lawmakers to enact a payroll tax cut and ensure assistance is available to hourly workers amid a roiling coronavirus pandemic that's caused deep economic concerns and stock market shock.

Trump hints at payroll tax cuts to mitigate coronavirus effects. Here's what that could mean for your pay . Payroll tax cuts could not only jeopardize the benefits for individuals who are retired or who are approaching retirement, but could also point to bigger payroll tax hikes for younger generations

The last president to try, George W. Bush, made a similar move shortly after winning a convincing reelection in 2004, and he was stopped dead in his tracks. Bush's ill-fated effort to reform Social Security energized dispirited Democrats and sapped political momentum from the start of his second term.

Yet the danger of overhauling the funding stream for a program that in turn provides payments to seniors has not deterred Trump from risking support in key battleground states like Florida.

Trump on Saturday, and again on Monday, said his goal is to get rid of the payroll tax altogether, raising the prospect that Social Security would be funded out of general fund revenues instead of having dedicated funding like it has for decades.

It doesn't look like Trump's executive actions on coronavirus relief will actually do much

  It doesn't look like Trump's executive actions on coronavirus relief will actually do much President Donald Trump swooped in Saturday to fix what Congress couldn't. But his executive actions face legal challenges and implementation hurdles.Before a crowd of masked, cheering supporters at his private golf club in New Jersey, the dealmaker-in-chief announced four executive actions aimed at providing Americans economic relief amid the coronavirus pandemic.

By JONATHAN LEMIRE and ZEKE MILLERBEDMINSTER, N. J. — Seizing the power of his podium and his pen, President Donald Trump on Saturday bypassed the nation’s

President Donald Trump signed an executive order for a payroll tax holiday at his club in Bedminster, New Jersey, on Saturday. “The very important thing is that people want it, and the people need it, actually,” Trump said, noting that Republicans and Democrats in Congress could not reach a deal.

"I signed directives to give a payroll tax holiday, with the understanding that after the election - on the assumption that it would be victorious for an administration that's done a great job - we will be ending that tax. We'll be terminating that tax," Trump said Monday at the White House.

The daring promise to scrap a tax that funds Social Security could have dire effects for Trump among older voters, who already prefer former Vice President Joe Biden by a substantial margin.

"Biden was already doing better with seniors than any Democrat since before 2008 and this is game-changing," said Democratic pollster Celinda Lake.

"Seniors think overwhelmingly that politicians should just keep their hands off the trust fund," she added, asserting that Trump "wants to break the [Social Security] trust fund."

"That's insane," she said.

Lake said Social Security has been thought of as the third rail of politics because "people love the program" and "they think it's their money - they paid in, so don't touch it."

Trump weighs permanent payroll tax deferral, says it won't impact Social Security

  Trump weighs permanent payroll tax deferral, says it won't impact Social Security Defenders of Social Security were quick to criticize Trump for suspending the taxes, suggesting it was part of a broader initiative to gut the social program. WHAT'S IN TRUMP'S FOUR VIRUS RELIEF EXECUTIVE ORDERS? "We just heard it straight from Trump's own mouth," Social Security Works wrote in a tweet. "If reelected, he will destroy Social Security." The order is technically a deferral of payroll taxes — not a suspension — meaning that the taxes will eventually be due at a later date. However, Trump has pledged to pursue a permanent cut to the taxes. “If I’m victorious on Nov.

President Donald Trump said Wednesday he was sharply restricting travel to the United States from more than two dozen European countries, a drastic step he framed as an attempt to contain a spreading public health crisis that has engulfed his presidency

To pause payroll taxes , the Trump administration is employing a section of the tax code that allows the Treasury secretary to postpone certain tax -related deadlines during a federally declared disaster. It's the same authority the Treasury Department used earlier in the year to delay the April 15

Social Security is funded by a 12.4 percent tax that is split evenly - 6.2 percent each - between employers and employees. The $2.2 trillion CARES Act, which became law in late March, suspended payroll taxes for employers through December.

The Biden campaign quickly pounced on Trump's instruction to the Treasury Department over the weekend to stop collecting payroll taxes for employees through Dec. 31. A new ad airing in Florida, which has a large population of seniors, accuses the president of "directing funding cuts for Social Security."

"Nearly 4 million Florida seniors rely on Social Security, and once again Donald Trump's failed leadership is hitting seniors the hardest," the ad's narrator says.

Biden's Social Security plan calls for applying payroll taxes to wage earnings above $400,000. Currently payroll taxes apply only to the first $137,700 of earnings.

Tad Devine, a Democratic strategist who worked on Al Gore's 2000 presidential campaign, said the issue of Social Security almost clinched Florida for Democrats that year.

Gore attacked Bush's proposal to let younger workers invest a percentage of their payroll taxes in stocks.

White House Says No Plan to End Payroll Tax Permanently

  White House Says No Plan to End Payroll Tax Permanently White House officials said the administration has no plans to do away with the payroll tax despite President Donald Trump saying he would seek a permanent repeal if he wins another term. © Photographer: Stefani Reynolds/CNP/Bloomberg Donald Trump speaks in the Rose Garden of the White House in Washington, D.C. Even if Trump were to follow through, the idea of doing away with the tax is unlikely to get much support in Congress because it could drive up the deficit by trillions of dollars to plug a funding gap, or spell the end of some Social Security payments for millions of Americans.

Trump bypasses Congress and hands out 0 per week in additional unemployment benefits as part of his COVID executive order and signs a payroll tax holiday for those on less than 0K. Trump signed four executive orders at his golf club in Bedminster, New Jersey on Saturday.

3 :57 Payroll Tax Deferral Example 4:49 My Issue With This as a Business Owner 5:30 Trump Wants a Permanent Payroll Tax Cut 7:14 Mnuchin on How It Supposedly Won't Hurt Social Security 8:40 Who's Eligible for the Payroll Tax Deferral? 9:21 Potential Inequalities 10

Bush made a gaffe late in the campaign when he blurted out that Democrats were attacking his plan "because they want the federal government controlling Social Security like it's some kind of federal program," appearing to forget that it is indeed a federal program.

"This is a very similar situation in that Trump has opened himself up to a fusillade of attack on Social Security and Medicare," Devine said.

A Monmouth University poll released Tuesday found that Biden is leading Trump 58 percent to 41 percent nationwide among people 65 and older.

Trump's move on Social Security is unsettling some congressional Republicans.

Senate Finance Committee Chairman Chuck Grassley (R-Iowa) on Tuesday said he would only think about supporting a permanent payroll tax cut if it's part of a broader effort to reform Social Security.

"I would not entertain that question unless ... it would go in with the reform of Social Security," Grassley said. "We've got to make sure that we keep our promises to senior citizens."

Grassley told reporters last month that he would not support including a payroll-tax cut in the next coronavirus-relief package because it would create a "public relations problem" for Republicans.

"Go to the fact that Social Security people think we're raiding the Social Security fund. And we are raiding it, but we have always put in general fund revenue in it so it is made whole. But that creates - it might create political problems, but it creates a public relations problem," Grassley said July 20.

Trump says he will look 'very strongly' at granting pardon to whistleblower Edward Snowden

  Trump says he will look 'very strongly' at granting pardon to whistleblower Edward Snowden Whistleblower Edward Snowden, considered a traitor by some and a hero by others, has been living in exile in Moscow since leaking spy secrets.“I’m going to take a look at that very strongly,” Trump said during a news conference at his golf resort in Bedminster, New Jersey.

Grassley, when asked Tuesday if Republicans face a public relations problem following Trump's executive actions over the weekend, said, "I have that concern."

He noted, however, that Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin has indicated that the White House would look for ways to replenish the Social Security Trust Fund if the payroll tax holiday for 2020 is made permanent or if the payroll tax is eliminated entirely.

"The president didn't make it clear but I think, once before, Secretary Mnuchin has thought about it, made it clear that you replenish it dollar-for-dollar," Grassley said.

Grassley noted that Congress replenished the Social Security Trust Fund from general fund revenues in 2011 and 2012 when then-President Obama signed three payroll tax cuts into law after Congress passed legislation to do so.

After the 2010 midterm election, Obama signed into law a deal with Republicans that extended the expiring Bush-era tax cuts for two years and cut the payroll tax on employees from 6.2 percent to 4.2 percent for one year.

Congress then extended the payroll tax cut at the end of 2011 for two months. In February 2012, Obama signed a measure that extended the 2-percentage-point payroll tax cut for another 10 months.

Congress included language in all three bills to replenish the Social Security Trust Fund with general revenues.

Other Republicans on the Senate Finance Committee, which has jurisdiction over Social Security, have tried to wave Trump off his payroll tax ambitions so close to Election Day.

Trump embraces CNN poll showing him closing in on Biden, but recent surveys show ex-VP ahead

  Trump embraces CNN poll showing him closing in on Biden, but recent surveys show ex-VP ahead Trump slammed a "fake" CNN poll in June that found him down 14 points but was not as critical of a recent one that showed he had surged 10 points.First cruise ship departs from Italy's Genoa since virus shutdown

"I'm not a fan of that, I've been very clear about that," Senate Republican Whip John Thune (R-S.D.) told reporters last month.

Thune warned that a payroll tax holiday for employees would have less economic impact than other ideas on the table.

"If it's a choice between doing [stimulus] checks and a payroll tax cut, I think it's pretty clear that the checks have a more direct benefit to the economy," he said, predicting that workers would get a "slight plus-up" likely sometime in the "fourth quarter of this year."

Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-Ky.) declined to answer when asked Tuesday whether he would support making the payroll tax cut permanent, as Trump has proposed.

Ross K. Baker, a professor of political science at Rutgers University, said Trump has tried to tout his payroll tax cut without mentioning the effect on Social Security.

"I think the fact that the payroll tax supports both Social Security and Medicare is not known to many people. I think that probably most people, if they think about the payroll tax at all, think of it as something goes to the general fund. But it's a dedicated tax," Baker said.

"He's been very careful about not connecting it to Social Security. I'm a little bit surprised that Democrats haven't jumped on this more aggressively because you can justly say the repeal or reduction of the payroll tax is a raid on the Social Security trust fund."

Video: Trump claims he'll pursue 'permanent cuts to the payroll tax' if reelected (The Washington Post)

Trump calls on supporters to boycott Goodyear, tweeting 'Don't buy Goodyear Tires' over company's ban on MAGA hats .
President Trump is calling on his supporters to not "buy Goodyear Tires" Wednesday following reports of the company's new zero tolerance policy.US readies demand for Iran sanctions

usr: 0
This is interesting!