Politics Trump appointees torpedo report on threats to minority voting rights during the pandemic
Chief Justice Roberts’s lifelong crusade against voting rights, explained
He has fought to undermine voting rights his entire career.It was 1981. Roberts had just completed a prestigious clerkship with Justice William Rehnquist — then the most conservative judge to serve on the Supreme Court in decades — and, as an aide to Attorney General William French Smith, Roberts was tasked with making the case against one of the most consequential voting rights laws in the nation’s history.
The U.S. Commission on Civil Rights spent months analyzing threats to minority voting rights during the coronavirus pandemic, coming up with what one commissioner called a “behemoth” set of recommendations.
But no one will see them. Conservative commissioners recently appointed by President Donald Trump voted to shelve the report, its findings and recommendations, even commissioners' statements.
China uproots ethnic minority villages in anti-poverty fight
Under a portrait of President Xi Jinping, Ashibusha sits in her freshly painted living room cradling her infant daughter beside a chair labeled a “gift from the government.” The mother of three is among 6,600 members of the Yi ethnic minority who were moved out of 38 mountain villages in China’s southwest and into a newly built town in an anti-poverty initiative.
The commissioner who led the research provided a glimpse of the report's contents during an August meeting, noting it covers problems with in-person and mail-in balloting faced by voters of color, people with disabilities, and those with medical conditions that make them vulnerable to the virus.
The full report, including what commission staff said should be done to overcome those obstacles, is not for public consumption, the commission said in a statement provided to USA TODAY.
“All Commission reports, as well as findings and recommendations, must pass by a majority vote,” the commission said. “That did not occur, so unfortunately we cannot share."
The decision comes as the country faces a contentious presidential election amid a global pandemic while grappling with tensions over racism and police brutality. Trump has claimed — without evidence — the election will be rigged.
The commission, an independent federal agency whose work has informed landmark civil rights laws, is made up of eight members. Trump’s appointments in May and August created a four-four split between conservatives and liberals. A move to release the voting-rights report failed in a tie.
Fact check: False meme attributes Trump quote about taking guns and due process to Kamala Harris
A quote from President Trump about taking guns and due process has been falsely attributed to Kamala Harris in memes online. The claim is false.Biden: Trump should step down over his Covid-19 response
Conservative lawyer J. Christian Adams, who was appointed to the commission two weeks before the meeting, said in an email that he voted against releasing the report because it “overlooked the disenfranchising effect of mail voting,” such as ballots that are undeliverable, rejected or lost. After he made similar assertions in June, PolitiFact ruled them.
Adams was a member of Trump’s voter-fraud task force, which was disbanded without finding widespread fraud in 2018.
Stephen Gilchrist, a South Carolina businessman appointed in May, said in an interview he rejected the report because, coming so close to the presidential election, he found the timing "somewhat suspect." He said he didn’t agree with some of its contents, which he suggested were politically motivated.
“I'm one of these people that's going to be very cautious and careful about ensuring that we stay focused on the issues at hand rather than trying to be political or take digs at any administration,” Gilchrist said.
The Democratic chair of the commission said it has been silenced on a crucial issue at a critical time.
Everything you need to know about voting in 2020 (but were afraid to ask)
Mail-in ballots, safe polling locations, and fraud allegations are only a few of the concerns in the pandemic election.“I’m having all these worries despite living in a state with some of the best voter protections, best mail-in voting infrastructure, and highest voter turnout,” Fickling told Recode. “I can’t even imagine how worried people must be in places like Texas.
“I am deeply dismayed that after months of work on a topic that is core to the commission's congressional charge — and has been now for six decades — for the commission not to speak to this moment, which is unlike any other in terms of an effort to vote in the history of this country,” said Catherine Lhamon, a California civil rights lawyer who was appointed by President Barack Obama in 2016.
USA TODAY/Suffolk Poll:
Return to sender:
Work on voting access report started in June
The commission voted to undertake the investigation in early June. It solicited comments from voting rights groups and experts, as well as advocates for individuals with disabilities and those with limited English language skills. More than a dozen submitted nearly 300 pages of written testimony.
They recounted problems with primary elections in Georgia, Wisconsin, Nevada, Ohio, Kentucky and other states as the coronavirus spread across the country. They said there were shortages of protective gear for poll workers, many of whom are elderly, putting them and voters at risk. There were steep reductions in the number of polling places, which caused long lines. At a polling place in Nevada, the last voter didn’t cast a ballot until.
The American Civil Liberties Union noted that Black voters have historically relied more on in-person voting, so they're more at risk of getting sick and more affected by problems at polling places. People with disabilities or limited language skills often rely on assistance at the polls to cast ballots.
Democrats scramble to soothe voter fears about in-person voting ahead of November election
After months of warnings about the risks posed by in-person voting in a push to expand access to mail-in ballots, Democrats across the country are increasingly focused on communicating to voters that it is safe to cast their ballots in a voting booth. © Provided by CNN Atlanta Hawks Voting State Farm Arena NBA spt intl_00020221.jpg The shift comes after a national legal campaign has successfully resulted in expanded access to mail-in voting in nearly every state -- prompting an unprecedented shift in the way millions of Americans will be able to vote due to the coronavirus pandemic.
And requirements in some states that people have mail-in ballots witnessed or notarized could expose voters who live alone to the virus. More than 34 million voters live alone, including 13 million over 65, the group said.
The testimony was uploaded to a file-sharing service, and the commission shared a link in an August press release. It said the commission is “continuing its enduring commitment to voting rights by issuing a new report this fall, Navigating Voting During the COVID-19 Pandemic: Considerations in Access for Minority Voters.”
But on Aug. 21, the commissioners voted against releasing the report and supporting documents.
A Democratic commissioner remarked during the meeting that the decisions could damage the storied body for years to come.
“To simply bury it as if it never occurred is contrary to transparency; it's contrary to what we have done in the past; contrary to just the spirit of open debate and discussion,” said Michael Yaki, a commissioner since 2005.
He told USA TODAY in an interview afterward that he found it “ridiculous” and “shortsighted.”
Politics shapes Civil Rights Commission
The commission was set up under the Civil Rights Act of 1957 to conduct investigations and make recommendations for national civil rights policy and to monitor enforcement of federal civil rights laws. Its work informed the Civil Rights Act of 1964, the Voting Rights Act of 1965, the Age Discrimination Act of 1978 and the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990.
But the agency hasn’t been insulated from political maneuvering and strife. Its focus has veered from one side of the political spectrum to the other depending on who occupied the White House. Trump’s appointments simply mark the latest shift, experts say.
'Next generation of poll workers': Young people are stepping up during the pandemic. It might avert a crisis
Thanks to a robust poll-worker recruitment push, several key cities have more poll workers than they need for Nov. 3. But the work isn't over.Two officers shot during Kentucky protests
“It’s a shame, it’s a crying shame,” said Mary Frances Berry, a constitutional scholar and civil rights activist who was a member of the commission for 24 years and served as chair for 11 before she left in 2004.
Commissioners serve six-year terms. Four are appointed by the president, two by the Speaker of the House and two by the president pro tempore of the Senate. They can be removed only for cause. No more than half can be from the same political party.
During the George W. Bush administration, two Republican members registered as independents, circumventing that requirement and creating a conservative majority, according to The Boston Globe.
The commission went on to questionand , and, after Obama took office, the Justice Department’s handling of a case of alleged white voter intimidation by members of the . A conservative commissioner at the time, Abigail Thernstrom, dismissed the Black Panther inquiry, telling Politico in 2010 it was driven by .”
Obama replaced commissioners as their terms expired, creating a liberal-minded majority with two independents. But like the independents appointed by Bush, their political leanings aren't hard to discern. One was on the Democratic Party's platform committee in 2016; the other is running for Congress in North Carolina as a Democrat.
In the final days of his administration, Obama installed Democrats Lhamon and Debo Adegbile, a lawyer who hadto lead the Justice Department’s Civil Rights Division in 2014.
Republicans welcome 'the Cavalry'
Since then, the commission has issued scathing reports on the Trump administration’sand its . It has voiced concerns about Trump's executive orders from countries with significant Muslim populations and his characterization of coronavirus as the “ .”
When Trump appointed Adams in August, longtime conservative commissioner Peter Kirsanow welcomed thein a National Review column, saying conservatives on the commission had been at the mercy of a 6-2 liberal majority for seven years.
Citizens shouldn't need Bloomberg's help to exercise their rights (opinion)
Laws that disenfranchise Americans with felony records are an unjust practice, deeply tainted by the legacy of white supremacy and systemic racism, says Amy Fettig of the Sentencing Project. She explains how these laws continue to disproportionately affect African Americans and calls for an end to them.Days after a devastating federal appeals court ruling that struck a major blow to voting rights for Floridians with felony records, Michael Bloomberg and a cadre of celebrities are donating millions to help some potential voters the court deemed ineligible.
Kirsanow, a Cleveland lawyer first appointed to the commission by George W. Bush in 2001, did not return messages seeking comment. Nor did Gail Heriot, a conservative University of San Diego law school professor first appointed in 2007.
Gilchrist, the Trump appointee seated in May, said he looks forward to helping forge “more of a balanced approach to issues in this country as it relates to civil rights.”
Adams said he hopes to raise issues “that are meaningful to real people, not to academics or the elites.”
He said “government edicts” prevent people from working, church worship has been curtailed, and people are being attacked for speaking their mind. “These are threats very different from 60 years ago, but the Commission has a role in addressing them,” Adams said.
Berry, the scholar and 24-year veteran of the commission, said she believes it has lost its moral authority as partisanship — on both sides — has undercut its credibility.
“It's been lost now for a number of years,” she said.
Berry, who authored a 2009 book about the commission called “And Justice for All," said the commission should be scrapped. She said it should be replaced with a six-member “human rights” panel of presidential appointees, evenly divided by party and confirmed by the Senate. Under the current system, appointees do not face Senate confirmation.
“The main problem is a structural issue … which you can see right before your eyes,” Berry said. "That's no way to run a railroad."
Yaki, the longtime Democratic commissioner, said the commission is going to have to work differently “if we’re going to be productive at all.” And that includes conservatives.
“If these folks want to have any voice at all of their views, no matter how skewed and wrong they are, they're going to have to figure out a way to work with us and work together if important information is going to come to light at the commission,” he said. “Otherwise, we're going to have hearings occur in a vacuum. They occur and then they go into a black box.”
This article originally appeared on USA TODAY:
Don’t Forget About In-Person Voting .
It’s more important than ever to have safe, in-person voting options.The Covid-19 pandemic has encouraged many party officials to stress mail-in and absentee balloting as a way to mobilize more voters while protecting their health. But President Trump continues to spuriously cast doubt on mail-in ballots, and even suggests that he’d reject the outcome of an election that he didn’t win.