Politics What Has Amy Coney Barrett Said About Separation of Church and State?
Fact check: 'Kingdom of God' comment by SCOTUS contender Amy Coney Barrett is missing context in meme
A 2006 remark about the "Kingdom of God" is missing context in a meme that also falsely attributes views on ending separation of church and state. The widely cited reference to Barrett encouraging a “Kingdom of God” is taken out of context. Fact check: No guarantee Obama would've replaced Ginsburg with a progressive justice Amy Coney Barrett’s religious and judicial views Barrett is a conservative and a favorite among the religious right. Trump appointed Barrett to a be a federal appeals court judge in 2017, and she has since ruled in over 100 cases.
President Donald Trump intends to announce his next Supreme Court nomination on Saturday, and Amy Coney Barrett is one of the judges Trump said he is considering for the position.
The debate about who Trump will pick to replace Associate Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg began immediately after news of Ginsburg's death on September 18. Trump told reporters last weekend that his nominee will "most likely" be a woman, and Barrett has been widely reported as one of the potential nominees at the top of his list.
Barrett Could Be Most Conservative Justice Since Clarence Thomas
Amy Coney Barrett brings a resume that could make her the most conservative new justice since Clarence Thomas and a dream addition for Republicans looking to remake the U.S. Supreme Court. © Bloomberg Amy Coney Barrett, U.S. President Donald Trump’s nominee for associate justice of the U.S. Supreme Court, right, listens as President Donald Trump speaks during an announcement ceremony in the Rose Garden of the White House in Washington, D.C., U.S., on Saturday, Sept. 26, 2020.
Earlier in his term as president, Trump nominated Barrett, who once clerked for the late Associate Justice Antonin Scalia, to serve on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit in Chicago. She received bipartisan support from the Senate during her confirmation hearing in October 2017, with three Democrats joining Republicans to approve her appointment. Trump also reportedly considered Barrett to fill former Associate Justice Anthony Kennedy's seat when he retired but ultimately chose Brett Kavanaugh, who was confirmed as the Supreme Court's latest addition in October 2018.
Top Democrats Quickly Criticize SC Nominee Amy Coney Barrett As Trump Warns Against Getting Personal
"Millions of families' health care will be ripped away in the middle of a pandemic," House Speaker Nancy Pelosi said."Today it is my honor to nominate one of our nation's most brilliant and gifted legal minds to the Supreme Court," Trump said in the Rose Garden on Saturday afternoon. "She is a woman of unparalleled achievement, towering intellect, sterling credentials and unyielding loyalty to the Constitution—Judge Amy Coney Barrett.
Whether or not Barrett's Catholic faith influences her judicial decisions was the subject of extensive scrutiny among Democrats during her hearing with the Senate Judiciary Committee in 2017. Barrett, who attended the Notre Dame Law School and later taught there, contributed to a paper co-written by one of her professors, John Garvey—now the president of the Catholic University of America—titled "Catholic Judges in Capital Cases." One of the conclusions the paper drew was that "Catholic judges (if they are faithful to the teaching of their church) are morally precluded from enforcing the death penalty." The paper added that judges with other religious backgrounds were just as likely as Catholics to face moral dilemmas in capital punishment cases.
When asked during the 2017 Senate hearing how she would weigh her faith with her responsibilities as a judge, Barrett said, "It's never appropriate for a judge to impose that judge's personal convictions, whether they derive from faith or anywhere else on the law." Barrett emphasized a point the paper made about the role recusal can play when personal conflicts arise and said she would "fully and faithfully" recuse herself if such a conflict ever arose for her, though she added that she could not think of any kinds of cases in which such actions would be necessary for her to take.
Dennis Quaid to appear in Trump's new $300million COVID-19 ad campaign
Dennis Quaid will appear in President Trump's new $300million coronavirus awareness ad campaign, alongside gospel singer CeCe Winans.c Dr Oz and Garth Brooks have also been approached for roles.The Hollywood actor, who has previously voiced his support for the president, is among several celebrities who will participate in the Health and Human Services Department's 'defeat despair' commercials, addressing the COVID-19 pandemic.
Despite Barrett's comments, Senator Dianne Feinstein mentioned during the 2017 hearing that Barrett has delivered speeches in the past that raise questions about her ability to separate her faith from her interpretation of the law. In a 2006 Notre Dame Law School commencement speech, Barrett encouraged the graduating class to engage in prayer before accepting any new job and said, "If you can keep in mind that your fundamental purpose in life is not to be a lawyer, but to know, love, and serve God, you truly will be a different kind of lawyer." She also referenced in the speech a comment the university's president made to the graduating class earlier in the ceremony: "You will always keep in mind that your legal career is but a means to an end, and as Father Jenkins told you this morning, that end is building the kingdom of God."
Feinstein did not mention any specific speeches Barrett has delivered but said that the content within some of them was "of concern." Feinstein said it was important for any judge to distinguish between dogma and law—and with Barrett, Feinstein said, "The dogma lives loudly within you."
Previewing acrimonious confirmation, Democrats coalesce around Amy Coney Barrett opposition
Democrats objected to both process and the views of Trump's Supreme Court pick, with one senator saying he won't meet with her.One Democratic senator — Connecticut's Richard Blumenthal, who is a member of the Judiciary Committee — said he would not meet with Barrett, as is customary for members of the committee, in protest of Trump’s decision to rush ahead with the nomination so close to an election.
In addition to the papers and speeches that many Democrats have found to be controversial, Barrett has also received attention for her reported involvement in a religious group called People of Praise, which The New York Times reported in 2017 taught its members that husbands were to serve as personal advisers to their wives and as the primary authority figure in a family. Also concerning to some is Barrett's signature amongst more than 1,300 others on a 2015 letter that affirmed some Catholic teachings and said, "We believe that women should be prominent messengers of the truths contained in the Church's teachings."
While Democrats have expressed concern about these points and more, Republicans largely support the idea of Barrett ascending to the Supreme Court, and some of Barrett's students and co-workers have said that she does not bring her own ideology into her work, according to The New York Times.
As Barrett mentioned in her 2017 Senate confirmation hearing, her perspectives on the issues she tackled as a law student in the late 1990s—when some of her first papers were written—have been influenced by the decades of experience she's gained since, making it difficult to determine exactly how she would vote when the separation of church and state arises in future cases. Despite her writings on recusal and past encouragement to graduating law students to use their faith to "be a different kind of lawyer," Barrett has said publicly and under oath that her religious background does not weigh on the decisions she makes on the bench.
Barrett declined Newsweek's request for comment on this story.
Republicans push Barrett confirmation as Democrats criticize timing .
Trump nominated Amy Coney Barrett to the Supreme Court on Saturday. Overwhelmingly, Republicans called Amy Coney Barrett a well-qualified candidate and pushed for a confirmation in the upcoming weeks. Democrats continued to criticize the timing, with some outright saying they wouldn't meet with the nominee.