•   
  •   
  •   

Politics Democrats eye expanding Supreme Court if Trump's nominee is confirmed

03:35  27 september  2020
03:35  27 september  2020 Source:   cbsnews.com

McConnell vows quick vote on next justice; Biden says wait

  McConnell vows quick vote on next justice; Biden says wait WASHINGTON (AP) — The death of Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg just six weeks before the election cast an immediate spotlight on the crucial high court vacancy, with Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell quickly vowing to bring to a vote whoever President Donald Trump nominates. Democratic nominee Joe Biden vigorously disagreed, declaring that "voters should pick the president and the president should pick the justice to consider.” require(["medianetNativeAdOnArticle"], function (medianetNativeAdOnArticle) { medianetNativeAdOnArticle.getMedianetNativeAds(true); }); McConnell, who sets the calendar in the U.S.

Democrats are furious that Republicans may confirm a Supreme Court nominee ahead of the election. Although expanding the court still seems like a distant possibility, the likelihood that a Democratic Congress and president would add seats to the court increases if Republicans confirm

Trump also was believed to have been considering candidates including 11th Circuit Judge Barbara Lagoa. Trump said publicly that he had five potential Should she be confirmed , Barrett would be Trump ’ s third Supreme Court confirmation . That ’s more than two-term Presidents Barack Obama

Washington — Democrats are fuming over the decision by Senate Republicans to move forward on a vote to confirm President Trump's yet-to-be-named nominee to the Supreme Court to fill the vacancy left by Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg's death, four years after GOP leaders refused to hold a vote on a Democratic president's nominee during an election year.

a group of people standing in front of a building: US-VOTE-COURT-GINSBURG © ALEX BRANDON US-VOTE-COURT-GINSBURG

In 2016, Republicans in control of the Senate blocked President Obama's nominee to the court, Merrick Garland, from even receiving a hearing, leaving the Supreme Court with only eight justices for over a year. Now, Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell and other Republicans argue that the court must have nine justices ahead of the November election. 

Ginsburg v. cancer was a 'remarkable fight': RBG battled five bouts of cancer over two decades

  Ginsburg v. cancer was a 'remarkable fight': RBG battled five bouts of cancer over two decades Supreme Court Associate Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg had overcome four bouts with pancreatic, lung and colon cancer dating back two decades. Ruth Bader Ginsburg, the oldest justice on the U.S.

Supreme Court justices are nominated by the US president, but must be approved by the Senate. If Judge Barrett is confirmed , conservative-leaning Amy Coney Barrett has been on Donald Trump ' s shortlist for Supreme Court vacancies for some time, but the word was that she would be the most

Trump is pressuring Biden to release a list of potential Supreme Court nominees like he did shortly before Ginsburg’s death. Democrats have also seized on Trump ’ s comments this week that he wants his nominee confirmed before Nov. 3 in part to help decide any legal disputes related to the

Given the likely legal challenges accompanying the influx of mail-in ballots this year, it's possible that the fate of the election could fall to the Supreme Court, which would have a 6 to 3 conservative majority if Mr. Trump's nominee is confirmed before Election Day.

Fury over what they see as rank hypocrisy from Republicans has led some Democrats to ponder options that recently were considered fringe ideas, most notably adding seats to the Supreme Court. Some progressives say expanding the court, an idea known as "court packing," is the only way to restore balance to a body that has become overtly partisan.

Arizona Senate candidate Mark Kelly could take office early if he wins, putting him in place for a court vote

  Arizona Senate candidate Mark Kelly could take office early if he wins, putting him in place for a court vote If Democratic candidate Mark Kelly were to defeat Sen. Martha McSally, he could be sworn in before year's end – in time to vote on a court nominee.Antonin Scalia's son on his father's "odd couple" friendship with RBG

The nominee is expected to be Amy Coney Barrett, a Circuit Court judge with strong support from conservatives. Finally, outside witnesses will present on Thursday. Barrett will begin sitting down with senators next week, though some Democrats have already vowed not to meet with the nominee .

Democrats were expected to fiercely grill Trump ’ s latest nominee on her views on abortion, on the prospect of a contested election, and other issues such as healthcare. 3. Committee sends nomination to Senate floor. At the end of confirmation hearings, the judiciary committee votes on the nominee .

Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer told members of his conference that "nothing is off the table" if Democrats retake the Senate, indicating that he is willing to consider expanding the court. Senator Ed Markey, one of the more progressive Democrats in the Senate, has called outright for eliminating the filibuster and expanding the court. House Judiciary Committee Chair Jerry Nadler tweeted that if the Republican Senate confirms a justice after Election Day but before a new Congress is sworn in, "then the incoming Senate should immediately move to expand the Supreme Court."

Christopher Kang, the chief counsel and co-founder of Demand Justice, a progressive group advocating for reforms to the Supreme Court, argued in an interview with CBS News that expanding the court would "restore balance and legitimacy to it."

"What we're seeing today, over the last couple of days, is the increasing realization that Republicans are going to exercise as much raw political power as they can to ensure that the Supreme Court remains a partisan institution," Kang said. He noted that Democrats have won the popular vote in six of the last seven elections, but the Supreme Court has had a conservative majority for decades.

Fact check: Ruth Bader Ginsburg planned to stay on Supreme Court at least a few more years

  Fact check: Ruth Bader Ginsburg planned to stay on Supreme Court at least a few more years A viral meme suggesting that Ruth Bader Ginsburg said her Supreme Court seat should have been vacated in 2019 is false.Trump casts doubt on Ginsburg's dying wish

President Donald Trump is expected this evening to announce his pick to fill the Supreme Court vacancy left after She was viewed as pivotal figure in American law and as the leader of the court 's liberal wing. Trump ' s nominee would be the third justice he has appointed to the court if confirmed .

Senate Democrats say they will press President Donald Trump ' s Supreme Court nominee to commit to recuse herself if the justices hear a case that could impact the outcome of the fall elections, a request that could become a major flashpoint amid Trump ' s persistent attacks on the legitimacy of the

David Faris, an associate professor of political science at Roosevelt University, said that if Garland had been confirmed in 2016, the court would have had a liberal majority for the first time in his lifetime. "And I'm not super young," he added. Faris pointed out that, if Mr. Trump's nominee is confirmed, then five of the nine justices on the court will have been nominated by presidents who lost the popular vote. (Chief Justice John Roberts and Associate Justice Samuel Alito were nominated by President George W. Bush during his second term. Mr. Bush lost the popular vote in 2000, but won a majority in 2004.)

Faris, who wrote an opinion piece in The New Republic arguing in favor of adding seats to the Supreme Court, also noted in an interview with CBS News that the Constitution does not specify how many seats the court must have. Seats can be added or subtracted by acts of Congress, although the current composition of nine seats has been in place since 1869.

Faris argued that Republicans had effectively contracted the court in 2016 by leaving it as an eight-person entity for the period of time between the death of Justice Antonin Scalia and Justice Neil Gorsuch's confirmation in 2017.

"Republicans manipulated the size of the court. They had the full legal right to do so, although it was not conducive to fair play," Faris said. If a Democratic Congress and a Democratic president passed legislation to add seats to the court, it would also be within their legal right to do so, since Congress has the authority to set the size of the court under the Constitution.

Fact check: 'Kingdom of God' comment by SCOTUS contender Amy Coney Barrett is missing context in meme

  Fact check: 'Kingdom of God' comment by SCOTUS contender Amy Coney Barrett is missing context in meme A 2006 remark about the "Kingdom of God" is missing context in a meme that also falsely attributes views on ending separation of church and state. The widely cited reference to Barrett encouraging a “Kingdom of God” is taken out of context. Fact check: No guarantee Obama would've replaced Ginsburg with a progressive justice Amy Coney Barrett’s religious and judicial views Barrett is a conservative and a favorite among the religious right. Trump appointed Barrett to a be a federal appeals court judge in 2017, and she has since ruled in over 100 cases.

Democrats eye expanding Supreme Court if Trump ' s nominee is confirmed . Wydra said that "people are going to be paying attention to this Supreme Court nomination more than ever before," given Ginsburg's fame and popularity among progressives.

Donald Trump wears a protective mask while paying respects to late Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg outside the Supreme Court in Washington, D.C But Pelosi has since underscored that Democrats are not interested in impeachment as a strategy to delay Senate action on a nominee .

Joe Biden, the Democratic nominee for president, has not embraced expanding the court. During the primary, he said Democrats would "live to rue that day" if they packed the court. Biden has also urged Republicans to vote against confirming Mr. Trump's nominee. However, if elected president, Biden may have no choice but to act if congressional Democrats are behind it.

Amy Steigerwalt, a professor of political science at Georgia State University, told CBS News that the size of the Supreme Court was previously tied to the number of circuit courts across the country. If the court was enlarged to follow that principle, there would be 11 seats on the court. Some who have called for expanding the court, including Faris, have argued in favor of adding four seats.

Steigerwalt, who co-authored the book "The Puzzle of Unanimity" about consensus among Supreme Court justices, noted that the high court hands down unanimous decisions in roughly half its cases. The growing concern is that the Americans may see the court, which has typically been thought of as an apolitical body, as a partisan institution.

In high-profile cases, justices are now typically expected to rule in line with the party of the president who nominated them. Many Republicans, including the president, have criticized Chief Justice John Roberts for siding with the liberal justices on critical cases, even though he was nominated by Republican President George W. Bush. Some believe that adding seats to the court would help neutralize the idea that the court is a completely partisan body.

"The argument is that this is a way to counterbalance moves that have been made recently that have pushed the court to one side, and potentially pushed the court to one side in a way that doesn't in fact reflect the will of the people," Steigerwalt said.

However, Steigerwalt said that some are worried adding seats to the court could simply reinforce the idea that justices are partisan actors, essentially "legislators in a robe." That may lead to people questioning the legitimacy of the court — and states possibly deciding that they don't need to follow its rulings.

Republicans have said they want to confirm Amy Coney Barrett before Election Day. Here's how long other confirmations took

  Republicans have said they want to confirm Amy Coney Barrett before Election Day. Here's how long other confirmations took Now that Trump has nominated Amy Coney Barret to the Supreme Court, the issue becomes whether the GOP-led Senate can confirm her before Election Day. Amy Coney Barrett named President Trump's third Supreme Court nominee USA TODAY See more videos SHARE SHARE TWEET SHARE EMAIL What to watch next Hear Amy Coney Barrett's tribute to Ruth Bader Ginsburg CNN Amy Coney Barrett speaks after Trump announces her nomination for Supreme Court CNBC Trump announces Amy Coney Barrett as Supreme Court nominee The Washington Post ‘A great Ameri

"If the court issues a federal ruling, and then a new court comes in, and they then reverse the decisions, and the only thing that's changed in the interim is the membership of the court, then it becomes really hard to argue that there's a reason to uphold Supreme Court decisions to guide the rest of the nation," Steigerwalt said.

Some opponents of expanding the court also question whether subsequent Congresses would go back and forth in adding and subtracting justices.

"Instead of tit-for-tat court packing, why don't they just fix it?" Faris asked.

There are a few alternatives to adding seats to the court. Demand Justice supports reforms such as imposing term limits on justices and creating a binding code of ethics for justices. Establishing term or age limits for justices would, however, require constitutional amendments.

Although expanding the court still seems like a distant possibility, the likelihood that a Democratic Congress and president would add seats to the court increases if Republicans confirm Mr. Trump's nominee before the election, Kang said.

"If [Republicans] are successful, I absolutely think that the momentum is absolutely going to be on the side of doing something," Kang said.

Faris said that Republicans had the opportunity to look "super magnanimous" by not filling the seat ahead of the election. If Mr. Trump wins reelection and Republicans retain the Senate, then waiting to fill the vacancy wouldn't matter anyway. That calculation changes if Democrats win the Senate and the White House.

"If [Democrats] do win, and then they pack the courts, it's hard to see all of this as anything as a really hollow victory for McConnell," Faris said.


Video: Senate GOP deliberates over SCOTUS nomination timeline as Trump prepares to announce pick (CBS News)

Fact check: Ginsburg cared for her young child, sick husband while excelling in law school .
A viral meme correctly describes how Ruth Bader Ginsburg cared for her young daughter and sick husband while excelling in law school.Why Trump’s taxes don’t prove he is a ‘smart businessman’ as his defenders say

usr: 1
This is interesting!