Politics 'Comey Rule' exposes entertainment reporting's blinding partisanship
Drew Barrymore and Ex-Husband Tom Green Reunite After Not Speaking for 15 Years Since 2002 Split
"I celebrate you and I always have and I always will," the actress told her ex when he appeared on her talk show on Friday RELATED VIDEO: Drew Barrymore on Her New Daytime Talk Show: “I Just Get to Be Myself” The Golden Globe winner couldn't believe how much time has passed since she'd been with Green — and she continued to share kind words about her ex. "When you say it's 20 years, sometimes it’s the blink of an eye and sometimes you’re like, Oh my God, we’ve lived so much in these last 20 years.
If you only read the news surrounding "The Comey Rule" - Showtime's two-night series based on fired FBI director James Comey's memoir, "A Higher Loyalty" - you'd think it accurately shows how Donald Trump colluded with Russia to steal the 2016 election.
And you'd be wrong, of course.
We've known since the Mueller Report dropped last year that the narrative surrounding President Trump and Russia wasn't what we were told. It wasn't for lack of trying or a dearth of investigative cash.
How Close 'The Comey Rule' Actors Look to Who They're Playing
"The Comey Rule" is airing over the next two nights on Showtime, with some major actors playing James Comey, Donald Trump and other major players in the White House and FBI in 2016.The cast of the Showtime series also features other actors you may know, including Holly Hunter, Jonathan Banks and Michael Kelly, as well as some characters who are major players in American politics, including Barack Obama, Michael Flynn (William Sadler) and Jeff Sessions.
That hotly anticipated report dealt the collusion narrative an uppercut. The last few months supplied the knockout punch. Consider what we've just recently learned:
- FBI agents snatched up during the Russia investigation, knowing how rickety the framework was at the time.
- The Steele Dossier, a key source driving the investigation, disintegrated upon inspection. The latest sign? We just learned that a suspected Russian operative served as a for the report.
- The New York Times, of all outlets, confirmed there were .
You'd think some of this information would have made it into the entertainment stories covering "The Comey Rule," starring actor Jeff Daniels as Comey. After all, those three items alone broke in the last week or so.
'The Comey Rule': See Brendan Gleason as Donald Trump and More
Gleeson and Jeff Daniels lead a stacked cast in a Showtime dramatization of James Comey's 2018 memoir, "A Higher Loyalty."Based on James Comey's 2018 memoir, A Higher Loyalty, the two-night special focuses on Comey's work on two extremely controversial cases: "Midyear Exam," the investigation into Hillary Clinton's emails while she was serving as Secretary of State, and "Crossfire Hurricane," which focused on Russia's ongoing attempts to derail the 2016 presidential election.
And you'd be wrong, of course.
about actor Brendan Gleeson's turn as President Trump in the production, while playing cutesy with writer/director Billy Ray. NBC News ran an op-ed dragging Comey for a variety of reasons - and then
Nothing even remotely tough about the exchanges. No awareness that the story in play distorts reality. No hard but fair questions posed to Daniels or his colleagues about the film's thesis.
It wasn't just the news stories tied to "The Comey Rule" that ignored the Dumbo in the room. TV critics weighed in on the Showtime miniseries by rarely, if ever, mentioning these oh-so-critical facts, let alone the Mueller Report.
What to Watch on Monday: It's Disney night once again on Dancing With the Stars
What to Watch on Monday: It's Disney night once again on 'Dancing With the Stars.'HOW/WHEN & WHERE TO WATCH: 8 p.m.
Seems important, right? It's as if Showtime revisited Geraldo Rivera cracking Al Capone's vault and pretended it held all the surprises we expected instead of ... bupkis.
IndieWire calls President Trump a monster, repeatedly, in itsNothing outrageous there; it's just hyperbolic opinion. Then we get this splash of "reportage": "The show doesn't offer any breaking news about the Russia investigation, but it's clear in its message that Trump already destroyed one election - via meddling, blackmail, and all-around discord - and he's absolutely trying to do it again."
about the film's massive flights of fancy. It endorsed them: "We don't need to tell you how Comey and Trump's 'relationship' sours, or how this story ends. It's as gut-wrenching fictionalized as it was in real life."
Critics could still enjoy the dramatics behind "The Comey Rule" while acknowledging that the story doesn't come within a mile of the truth. A reviewer can admire, for example, Oliver Stone's "JFK" without adhering to its conspiratorial theories. Except, in this case, critics treated the material in "The Comey Rule" as the gospel truth when it's "fake news" on steroids.
Everyone hates James Comey, except for Hollywood
James Comey openly shifted the legal goalposts to exonerate Hillary Clinton prematurely for endangering national security. He then turned around and arguably destroyed her chances by announcing in October that her classified emails were found during a search into pervert Anthony Weiner's computer.There ought to be no man more loathed by both sides of the political aisle than James Comey. And for a time, before President Trump fired him, that's exactly how it was.
The film's key players, from lead star Daniels to writer/director Ray, hit the promotional circuit and smacked the softball queries lobbed at them by professional journalists.
Had those scribes somehow missed the Mueller Report's rollout? It clogged up the news cycle for weeks, if memory serves. Yet, nevertheless, reporters filed puff pieces about "The Comey Rule." Chortled Ray to one outlet: "Oh,."
Well, he'd have a right to be grumpy, no?
Let's flash back to another politically-charged TV miniseries and recall how the press treated it:
ABC's two-part series, "The Path to 9/11," came under heavy attack in 2006 for what critics claimed was an inaccurate look at what preceded the Sept. 11 terrorist attacks and an unfair depiction of former President Clinton's lack of action against al Qaeda before the attacks occurred. Democratic senators weighed in on the matter, demanding changes and evenfor allowing the miniseries to air.
ABC backpedaled, and then some. The network wiped commercials from the presentation, presumably costing itself millions in lost revenue. It aired a disclaimer to help people process the notion that it had "dramatized" actual events. And then,
'Mailmen selling ballots. Dumped in rivers. Found in creeks': Trump makes unfounded claims about mail-in voting
From claiming mailmen are "selling the ballots" to arguing that mail ballots are being "dumped in rivers," Trump ramped up his assault on mail-votingTrump now says he 'doesn't know' Proud Boys group
Reporters covered every twist in that story, repeating the critiques lodged against it from the political left, an appropriate response.
What happened with "The Comey Rule," then?
Showtime has a partial excuse regarding the maddening distortions rampant in the miniseries, which debuted Sept. 27: Some of the most damning revelations about the Russian collusion narrative broke in recent weeks. Still, the film started production last November, months and months after special counsel Robert Mueller dropped his signature report.
Weeks later, the report by Justice Department inspector general Michael Horowitz went public, revealing serious mistakes, miscalculations and other behavior unworthy of the FBI. Even Rolling Stone - a far cry from Breitbart News or the Daily Caller - noted how the inspector general: "(The) Horowitz report shows years of breathless headlines were wrong."
Yet, the brave, hard-working FBI agents depicted in "The Comey Rule" would make Boy Scouts look suspect by comparison.
Now, miniseries events are allowed to have their creative biases. The same is true of newspaper op-eds, documentaries and other cultural products. A film can argue, for example, that President Trump's unconventional style proved a tonic for a reeling nation - or that his sharp-elbow shtick intensified our political divide.
All fine. And no one should call for "The Comey Rule's" cancellation.
When something as dishonest as the Showtime miniseries appears, though, it's up to news organizations to let readers know that the fix is in - not regurgitate the miniseries' fictional talking points to attack the president.
That so many outlets did nothing of the kind reminds us why trust in so much of the media continues to crater: They've earned it.
Christian Toto is the editor of the conservative entertainment site ", the Right Take on Entertainment," and host of the weekly "Hollywood in Toto" podcast.
'Upsetting': Swing state voters appalled by Trump-Biden debate, but will it change minds? .
"I watched every minute and did not learn anything," said a Trump backer in Ohio, who urged the president to be calmer at the next face off."It was a mess," said Anthony Amato, a lawyer from North Royalton, a GOP-leaning suburb of Cleveland.