Politics Stimulus Doomed by Diverging Goals of Trump, Pelosi, McConnell

12:30  15 october  2020
12:30  15 october  2020 Source:   bloomberg.com

Trump’s confusing back-and-forth on fiscal stimulus, sort of explained

  Trump’s confusing back-and-forth on fiscal stimulus, sort of explained Mitch McConnell is trying to duck a Republican caucus fight, and everyone else is along for the ride.Then, the next morning, he blamed Pelosi for not sending him a bill to sign.

McConnell plans coronavirus aid vote as Pelosi says White House stimulus plan falls short. House Speaker Nancy Pelosi , who is negotiating a potential stimulus deal with Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin, said the latest White House proposal "falls significantly short" of what is need to address the

Trump , Pelosi .8T stimulus faces uphill battle in Republican Senate: Gasparino. Sources tell FOX Business’ Charlie Gasparino that as of now, Majority The Trump administration's proposal -- which came just a few days after the president abruptly called off negotiations before reversing course and

(Bloomberg) -- Even with the U.S. still reeling from the coronavirus pandemic, Washington fell short in delivering more stimulus before the election, whipsawed by President Donald Trump and hobbled by the diverging agendas of the top Republican and Democrat in Congress. Now, voters will help decide what happens next.

House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, a self-proclaimed “master legislator,” entered the talks in July with a reputation for legislative acumen honed over years of consequential budget battles and in previous showdowns with Trump. She put in her bid for an even bigger pandemic rescue plan than the $2 trillion package passed in March.

Trump’s Hurdles to Stimulus Climb After Abrupt Tactical Shift

  Trump’s Hurdles to Stimulus Climb After Abrupt Tactical Shift (Bloomberg) -- President Donald Trump scrapped fiscal stimulus talks this week after failing to swing Senate Republicans behind a package Democrats could support. With negotiations back on, the obstacles are just as daunting. Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin heads into weekend negotiations with House Speaker Nancy Pelosi with the top-line number for relief fast approaching the $2 trillion level that many Senate Republicans say they cannot accept.Mnuchin has already alienated some in his party by moving toward policies in the House Democrats’ $2.2 trillion proposal that they oppose.

Blitzer presses Pelosi on why she hasn't taken Trump stimulus deal. It went downhill from there. Asked if she had spoken to President Donald Trump about the possibility of a coronavirus stimulus deal, Pelosi said she doesn't "speak to the President."

Read More: Trump , Republicans Divided on Stimulus as Pelosi Demands Revamp. Trump undercut GOP lawmakers again on Tuesday a short time after Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell announced plans for a vote on a narrow piece of stimulus legislation, with a tweet.

Unlike in March, when both parties rallied around the Cares Act as the virus prompted nationwide shutdowns, the Trump administration couldn’t side with Pelosi even if it wanted. Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell and many of his fellow Republicans resisted any stimulus of much more than $1 trillion, and especially the massive state and local aid sought by Democrats. Some in the GOP didn’t think the economy needed more aid.

There also was a lack of trust in the White House negotiating team. Senate Republicans blamed Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin for giving away too much in the $2 trillion plan passed in March. Democrats were suspicious of White House Chief of Staff Mark Meadows, who joined the administration in March after building a reputation during more than seven years in the House as an uncompromising partisan.

Blackhawks core not happy with Chicago's rebuilding plan

  Blackhawks core not happy with Chicago's rebuilding plan Washington High School senior Trashaun Willis is a stellar athlete, but who he is off the field captivates everyone around him. His coach thinks this is just his beginning.

Nancy Pelosi said she told Republicans to come back when they are willing to increase their trillion coronavirus aid offer. Trump threatens executive action if no deal is reached in coronavirus stimulus talks.

President Donald Trump ended talks with Democratic leaders on a new stimulus package, hours after Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell’s strongest call yet for greater spending to avoid damaging the economic recovery. Trump Halts Stimulus Talks, Spurning Powell and Roiling Markets.

Now there is less than three weeks before the Nov. 3 election, and Mnuchin said that “reality” is getting in the way. The next steps will hinge on whether Trump is re-elected and the GOP holds on to its Senate majority or Democrat Joe Biden wins and Democrats sweep into control of both chambers of Congress.

‘Root Problem’

“The root problem with reaching a deal is that neither party seems to feel that it will be blamed by voters for the stalemate,” said Sarah Binder, a political science professor at George Washington University and a senior fellow at the Brookings Institution.

Mitch McConnell wearing a suit and tie standing in front of a building: Pelosi, Mnuchin Trade Stimulus Plans To Bridge Stubborn Divides © Bloomberg Pelosi, Mnuchin Trade Stimulus Plans To Bridge Stubborn Divides

Mitch McConnell

Photographer: Stefani Reynolds/Bloomberg

For Trump, the idea of embracing the House Democrats’ plan -- which began at $3.4 trillion in May before getting trimmed to $2.2 trillion by early October -- was at odds with his narrative that the economy was rebounding handsomely. In August he claimed at a White House briefing the U.S. was leading the global recovery.

Fact check: False claim that Pelosi drunk in 2016 photo with Obama

  Fact check: False claim that Pelosi drunk in 2016 photo with Obama A viral photo of Nancy Pelosi and Barack Obama is being used out of context to make the House speaker appear intoxicated. We rate this claim false."Oh that 'Crazy Nancy' This needs to go viral! I'm very sure she doesn't want this drunken photo out there of her," reads the text on top of the image.

After Trump ’s announcement, Pelosi accused the president of “putting himself first at the expense of the country” and being “unwilling to crush the virus With four weeks to go before the election, Pelosi and Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin have been deadlocked in talks about the next stimulus bill

They Say the 2nd Stimulus Check is Coming "lol" 😂 WHAT A JOKE ! Nancy Pelosi has Played Donald Trump and McConnell like a Fiddle during this GREAT RESET !

The president’s erratic moves since he contracted Covid-19 also served to undermine his own team. He took them out of talks on Oct. 6, only to send them back later the same week, calling for an even bigger package than the $1.6 trillion they had previously tried to sell to Pelosi.

Early, many investors and economists had penciled in a roughly $1.5 trillion stimulus from Congress. But the confusion of on-again, off-again talks, and an ultimately ineffective attempt by the White House at stimulus-through-executive-action, made the process unpredictable.

Investors Puzzled

“It’s hard to know exactly what’s priced in” to financial markets, said Aaron Clark, portfolio manager at GW&K Investment Management. He said his best guess is that “there’s not much in the way built in for expectations for a package to take place by the end of the year.”

Read More:
Trump Allies Stumped by Unilateral Move to Scrap Stimulus Talks
Powell Warns of Weak Recovery Without Enough Government Aid
House Democrats Pass $2.2 Trillion Stimulus Republicans Reject
U.S. Fiscal Stimulus Chances Fade, With Republican Bill Blocked
Trump’s Stimulus End Run Fizzles as Firms Spurn Payroll Tax Halt

Now both sides are casting blame.

Trump Says He’d Go Over $1.8 Trillion on Stimulus, Blames Pelosi

  Trump Says He’d Go Over $1.8 Trillion on Stimulus, Blames Pelosi President Donald Trump said he’d support a virus relief package in excess of $1.8 trillion -- his administration’s most recent negotiating proposal -- and blamed House Speaker Nancy Pelosi for delaying a deal. © Photographer: Chris Kleponis/Polaris/Bloomberg Donald Trump “We’re not holding it up, she’s holding it up,” Trump said in an interview Thursday on Fox Business. “She wants to wait until after the election. She thinks it hurts the Republicans.” require(["medianetNativeAdOnArticle"], function (medianetNativeAdOnArticle) { medianetNativeAdOnArticle.

McConnell ’s announcement came after President Donald Trump , lagging in the polls, had urged lawmakers to “go big” on a stimulus deal over McConnell ’s plan, though, would be far smaller than the sweeping .2 trillion bill passed by the House and House Speaker Nancy Pelosi told her fellow

House Speaker Nancy Pelosi and Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell deepened their impasse over the terms of President Donald Trump ’s impeachment trial Thursday, as Congress left Washington for the holidays without settling when and how it would take place.

“I suspect that they don’t want to give the president a win three weeks before the election,” Mnuchin said of Democrats in a Wednesday evening appearance on Fox Business.

House Republican leader Kevin Brady was more direct. Pelosi has shown “her desire to not help this economy or anyone before this election,” he said in a call with reporters Wednesday. “Do they want to continue to sabotage this economy ahead of this election for their own political gain?”

a person standing in front of a building: White House Open To Bigger Stimulus Bill As Mnuchin, Pelosi Talk © Bloomberg White House Open To Bigger Stimulus Bill As Mnuchin, Pelosi Talk

Nancy Pelosi

Photographer: Stefani Reynolds/Bloomberg

Democrats naturally have a different take.

“The lack of a Covid package lies directly at the feet of Republicans. The White House has never been serious about this. The musical chairs of who is negotiating this is never ending,” said Representative Gerald Connolly, a Virginia Democrat. “Even the president in the haze of Covid therapy treatments has changed his mind about big, small, no deal at all.”

Pelosi told MSNBC on Wednesday night that while an accord remained a possibility, the two sides remained far apart on worker safety, school funding, and a strategic testing plan, among other issues.

She added that negotiations were continuing on a testing plan. “Tomorrow, we’re hoping to get better language back on how we crush the virus,” she said.

GOP senators try to further distance themselves from Trump, but it may be too late to save their majority

  GOP senators try to further distance themselves from Trump, but it may be too late to save their majority One GOP strategist called the political environment "very difficult" for Republicans due to Trump's tweets and his widely panned debate performance.McConnell speculated last week about the time period after Judge Amy Coney Barrett's expected confirmation later this month when the GOP might face 2021 fight against possible Democratic efforts to "pack the court" with more justices should former Vice President Joe Biden win the White House.

Economic Narratives

Economic indicators since the summer have presented a mixed picture, allowing each side to paint a different narrative. Some sectors have done well, like a housing market that’s booming thanks to record-low mortgage rates in the wake of Federal Reserve easing. Trump and his aides have argued a V-shaped recovery is here, making the Democrats’ proposal excessive.

At the same time, the data show the recovery is already slowing. September saw the smallest gain in employment since a jobs rebound began in May. The U.S. is still down 10.7 million jobs from February, a bigger loss in payrolls than the 8.7 million seen during the 2008-2009 recession. A fall surge in Covid-19 cases threatens more economic damage. Fed officials have become increasingly clear in their calls for fiscal action.

Economic indicators in coming weeks could play into the likelihood of a deal during the “lame duck” period between the election and the inauguration of a new Congress and presidential term.

a person wearing a suit and tie talking on a cell phone: Pelosi Awaits Mnuchin's Stimulus Counter-Offer and Prepares Vote © Bloomberg Pelosi Awaits Mnuchin's Stimulus Counter-Offer and Prepares Vote

Steven Mnuchin arrives to meet with Nancy Pelosi on Capitol Hill in Washington, D.C., on Sept. 30.

Photographer: Oliver Contreras/Bloomberg

If Trump loses the White House and Republicans the Senate, it’s not at all clear that they will relent on a bigger stimulus that would give an incoming Biden administration surer footing on the economy. If they win there is little incentive to give Democrats anything.

If Democrats do sweep the elections, Pelosi could face a decision about whether to accept a smaller, interim package before a large-scale one early in 2021. House Majority Leader Steny Hoyer this week announced the House would return to Washington on Nov. 16 for its post-election session. Congress already has a Dec. 11 deadline to pass a bill to fund government operations, which could include some selected aid measures.

Senate Republicans could be the real roadblock to getting a stimulus deal passed

  Senate Republicans could be the real roadblock to getting a stimulus deal passed If Nancy Pelosi and Steven Mnuchin reach a stimulus agreement, it’s unclear whether Republicans would support it.This past weekend, Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell said the upper chamber would “consider” any compromise made between Pelosi and Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin, though it’s unclear if that means he would schedule a vote on it. (White House Chief of Staff Mark Meadows has said that the Senate would vote on any deal that’s reached, but McConnell has not explicitly confirmed this himself.

Interim Deal

“A mini-deal in the lame-duck is most likely,” said Josh Huder, a senior fellow at Georgetown University’s Government Affairs Institute. He predicts legislation addressing narrowed targets with broad cross-party support, such as replenishing the Paycheck Protection Program offering aid to small businesses and supplementary unemployment benefits until February or March, along money for testing and tracing the coronavirus.

Senior House Democratic aides, asking not to be identified as talks between Pelosi and Mnuchin continue, agreed that a mini package could be possible en route to a comprehensive, signature Biden stimulus act in early 2021.

William Hoagland, a former Senate Republican budget director, said the post-election stimulus talks could become entwined with those over a new stopgap government spending measure in December.

House Republican chief Brady agreed. “I hope that it doesn’t take until past the election but if it does I think the Dec. 11 date is the driver to get something to the president’s desk.”

The longer the wait until some fiscal help, the bigger the risk that a slowdown in the economic recovery causes longer-term damage.

“The most serious blow to the economy as the year ends will be the failure of Trump and Congress to agree on more help to those hit hardest by the pandemic,” said Mark Zandi, chief economist at Moody’s Analytics. “It is tough to see how the economy can gain any traction until next year when, we hope, the pandemic and election are in the history books.”

For more articles like this, please visit us at bloomberg.com

©2020 Bloomberg L.P.

Pelosi 'optimistic' of stimulus agreement with the White House before the weekend. 'Both sides are serious about finding a compromise.' .
Pelosi and Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin found more "common ground" Tuesday, even as Senate Republicans threatened to torpedo any deal.Pelosi is pushing for a $2.2 trillion stimulus package — the White House is offering $1.88 trillion, but Senate Republicans warned Tuesday they would likely block any deal worth $1.8 trillion or higher.

usr: 1
This is interesting!