•   
  •   
  •   

Politics Trump embraces idea behind 'herd immunity' as Fauci calls concept 'total nonsense'

02:50  16 october  2020
02:50  16 october  2020 Source:   abcnews.go.com

Trump's new coronavirus adviser hit back at Fauci and other scientists who doubt his anti-lockdown advice: 'I'm here because the country's off the rails'

  Trump's new coronavirus adviser hit back at Fauci and other scientists who doubt his anti-lockdown advice: 'I'm here because the country's off the rails' The CDC director said "everything" said was false, and Bill Gates suggested he was only hired because he believes in "crackpot" theories.Last month, Bill Gates suggested Atlas was only hired because he "agrees" with the White House's "crackpot Covid theories." A group of more than 100 of Atlas's former colleagues at Stanford Medical School also signed a letter warning that many of his "opinions and statements run counter to established science.

Fauci says backing herd immunity — the idea that a disease will stop spreading once nearly everybody has contracted it — is “ total nonsense .” “So I think that we’ve just got to look that square in the eye and say it’s nonsense .” The U.S. leads the world with 7.9 million coronavirus cases and

Trump calls Fauci 's caution on schools reopening 'not an acceptable answer'. He has yet to initiate a serious national conversation about the vital need to get Ironically, another of Trump 's failings, one in which Fauci may be in some ways complicit as a member of the coronavirus task force -- to stand up

President Donald Trump has in recent weeks increasingly aligned himself with ideas espoused by scientists pushing "herd immunity" to combat the novel coronavirus, a concept lambasted by public health experts as "dangerous" and called "ridiculous" by the federal government's foremost infectious disease official, Dr. Anthony Fauci.

Donald Trump et al. standing in front of a crowd: In this Sept. 24, 2020, file photo, President Donald Trump arrives on stage during his, 'The Great American Comeback Rally', at Cecil Airport on Sept. 24, 2020, in Jacksonville, Fla. © Joe Raedle/Getty Images, FILE In this Sept. 24, 2020, file photo, President Donald Trump arrives on stage during his, 'The Great American Comeback Rally', at Cecil Airport on Sept. 24, 2020, in Jacksonville, Fla.

Since Saturday, the president has repeatedly criticized "unscientific lockdowns" -- falsely portraying public health experts as supportive of harsh restrictions -- and argued against coronavirus-related limits on American society by repeating his months-old mantra, "The cure cannot be worse than the problem itself."

Overnight Health Care: Dems hone in on ObamaCare as Supreme Court hearings begin | Fauci on planned Trump rallies: 'Now is even a worse time to do that' | WHO chief calls herd immunity approach 'simply unethical'

  Overnight Health Care: Dems hone in on ObamaCare as Supreme Court hearings begin | Fauci on planned Trump rallies: 'Now is even a worse time to do that' | WHO chief calls herd immunity approach 'simply unethical' Welcome to Monday's Overnight Health Care. Amy Coney Barrett's Senate confirmation hearing kicked off today, with Democrats honing in on the Supreme Court's upcoming oral arguments in the Texas ObamaCare case. The head of the WHO calls a herd immunity strategy "unethical." And Dr. Anthony Fauci warned that now really is not the time for the Trump campaign to hold rallies. Let's start with Barrett: Democrats seek to tie Barrett to Trump on Affordable Care Act as confirmation hearings beginIt was hard to miss Democrats' focus on health care, namely the GOP-backed lawsuit against the Affordable Care Act (ACA), as the nomination hearings for Judge Amy Con

Herd immunity happens when enough of the population is immune to a disease, making it unlikely to spread and protecting the rest of the community, the Mayo Fauci said that he has made his position on herd immunity known with the White House and added that Dr. Deborah Birx, the White House

Dr Anthony Fauci has argued that letting Covid-19 spread in the US to achieve herd immunity is 'ridiculous'. The declaration, which was written by experts at Oxford, Harvard and Stanford, calls for the Fauci said the declaration hides that fact that 30% of the population have underlying health

And since his own bout with the virus, Trump has made claims about his own supposed "immunity" standard campaign speech fare. "I'm immune and I can't give it to you," he boasted Wednesday" -- even though scientists do not fully understand how strong immunity may be or how long it might last.

"Remember, when you catch it, you get better, and you’re immune," he said in a Fox News interview last week, despite the lack of conclusive research and the the fact that hundreds of thousands have died after contracting it.

While he has largely avoided using the phrase "herd immunity" to describe the policies he has furthered, the president's views reflect those of a small subset of scientists with a powerful ally in the White House, Dr. Scott Atlas, a neuroradiologist with no background in infectious diseases who has supplanted Fauci and other top federal public health officials as one of Trump's top medical advisers.

Fauci tensions with Trump escalate over campaign ad

  Fauci tensions with Trump escalate over campaign ad Tensions between Anthony Fauci and President Trump are increasing after the nation's top infectious disease expert asked the Trump campaign to take down a new ad that features comments of his that he says were taken out of context.The ad, released last week shortly after the president was discharged from Walter Reed National Military Medical Center, touts the president's response to the virus and includes an edited clip of Fauci that makes it seem as though he was praising Trump's response to the pandemic. In the 30-second spot, Fauci is heard saying, "I can't imagine that anybody could be doing more.

"The concept (of herd immunity ) really comes from vaccines," Frieden said. "When you vaccinate enough people, the disease stops spreading President Donald Trump is no longer a transmission risk after contracting the virus, Dr. Anthony Fauci said Wednesday, but the people around him may

Trump doesn't have Covid19 and there is War coming!! From all angles!! This video will answer your questions!!! Funding gives us more weapons! Thank you patriots! Oh and If you disable the Ad-blocker - on your deathbed you will receive total consciousness.

The scientists argue that the United States should seek to achieve "herd immunity" to COVID-19 by allowing the natural spread of the virus through the population, while keeping only "vulnerable" groups -- like the elderly -- protected. Eventually, they say, enough people will get sick and recover -- and potentially become immune to reinfection, at least for some period of time -- that the rate of spread will diminish.

a group of people standing in front of a crowd: In this Sept. 24, 2020, file photo, President Donald Trump arrives on stage during his, 'The Great American Comeback Rally', at Cecil Airport on Sept. 24, 2020, in Jacksonville, Fla. © Joe Raedle/Getty Images, FILE In this Sept. 24, 2020, file photo, President Donald Trump arrives on stage during his, 'The Great American Comeback Rally', at Cecil Airport on Sept. 24, 2020, in Jacksonville, Fla.

But a broad consensus of mainstream public health experts flatly rejects this idea, arguing it would lead to many millions of deaths and take an untold toll on an American populace rife with underlying medical conditions, like obesity, that make them more likely to suffer severe symptoms and die.

Experts Explain Why a Vaccine Is the Only Safe Way to Achieve Herd Immunity For COVID-19

  Experts Explain Why a Vaccine Is the Only Safe Way to Achieve Herd Immunity For COVID-19 You may have heard the term "herd immunity" tossed around in response to the novel coronavirus, but the idea that we could overcome the pandemic if enough people were exposed to COVID-19 is a dangerous notion. In fact, experts told POPSUGAR that it could lead to "millions of excess deaths," and the head of the World Health Organization has said that allowing the virus to spread with abandon would be "unethical.

A pandemic analyst finds that herd immunity could be slowing Sun Belt spread in the southern United States, as a new study was released finding population immunity could be achieved at a much lower percentage than previously believed. Dr. Anthony Fauci warns of death toll of herd immunity .

President Trump and Vice President Pence listen as Anthony Fauci addresses a news conference at Later Friday, Trump will visit a factory producing nasal swabs in Maine, where he’ll likely again tout progress He told reporters Wednesday on a conference call that he will still remain involved in the

These top experts do, though, widely agree that extreme social-distancing measures can have adverse effects on society -- physically, mentally and financially -- and, when possible, should be avoided. They say that they, too, are against total "lockdowns," but that measures like mask-wearing and limiting the size of gatherings can lower the rate of infection.

"This idea that we have the power to protect the vulnerable is total nonsense, because history has shown that that's not the case," Fauci said Thursday in an interview with ABC News Chief Anchor George Stephanopoulos on "Good Morning America." "And if you talk to anybody who has any experience in epidemiology and infectious diseases, they will tell you that that is risky and you'll wind up with many more infections of vulnerable people, which will lead to hospitalizations and deaths.

"So I think that we just got to look that square in the eye and say it's nonsense," Fauci said.

MORE: Coronavirus live updates: Fauci calls 'herd immunity' declaration embraced by White House 'ridiculous'

The Trump administration has not treated it as nonsense, though.

Fact check: Biden voted to tax Social Security, wants to reform retirement benefits

  Fact check: Biden voted to tax Social Security, wants to reform retirement benefits As a senator, Joe Biden voted to tax Social Security benefits. As a presidential hopeful, he does not propose taxing property or retirement accounts.The former senator from Delaware was also the deciding vote in raising the Social Security tax rate to up to 85% in 1993, according to the meme.

President Donald Trump ended talks with Democratic leaders on a new stimulus package, hours after Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell’s strongest call yet for greater Stocks tumbled after Trump ’s posting called an end to months of hard-fought negotiations between the administration and Congress.

Calls to fire America’s top infectious disease expert resurfaced over the weekend during a demonstration against coronavirus mitigation measures. And certainly nobody reached out to me at that point,” Collins said, adding that he and Fauci speak by phone every evening.

U.S. Health and Human Services Secretary Alex Azar met last week with Atlas and several researchers who have endorsed the ideas behind a "herd immunity" approach without labeling it as such. Atlas himself is a paid adviser to the president.

Jayanta Bhattacharya et al. posing for a photo: White House adviser Dr. Scott Atlas, left, met with U.S. Health and Human Services Secretary Alex Azar, not pictured, and three researchers who support ideas associated with the concept of © Scott Atlas/Twitter White House adviser Dr. Scott Atlas, left, met with U.S. Health and Human Services Secretary Alex Azar, not pictured, and three researchers who support ideas associated with the concept of "herd immunity," on Oct. 5, 2020.

In addition to pushing for an end to coronavirus-related restrictions and insisting the country fully "open up," Trump also has repeatedly emphasized -- often with misleading statistics -- that the virus only impacts the elderly or those with pre-existing conditions. His focus on those groups jibes with "herd immunity" adherents who minimize the risk to others.

In reality, thousands of younger Americans have died -- and millions have fallen ill.

The White House on Monday convened a conference call for reporters in part to draw attention to the Great Barrington Declaration, an online petition that argues in favor of achieving natural herd immunity while also using "focused protection" to safeguard the most vulnerable. The authors of the open letter boasted thousands of signatories, but Sky News found that among them were "homeopaths, therapists and fake names" like "Dr. Johnny Bananas" and "Dr. Person Fakename."

Trump labels Fauci a 'disaster' on campaign call

  Trump labels Fauci a 'disaster' on campaign call President Trump derided Anthony Fauci as a “disaster” and claimed that Americans have tired of the novel coronavirus during a call with campaign staff on Monday. © Greg Nash/Getty Images Trump labels Fauci a 'disaster' on campaign call "People are tired of COVID. Yup, there's going to be spikes, there's going to be no spikes, there's going to be vaccines. With or without vaccines, people are tired of COVID," Trump said, according to audio of the call obtained by The Hill. "I have the biggest rallies I have ever had and we have COVID. People are saying whatever, just leave us alone. They're tired of it.

MORE: Faster, cheaper COVID-19 tests in danger of creating blindspot in data collection

The Infectious Disease Society of America on Wednesday called the petition's ideas "inappropriate, irresponsible and ill-informed." In an open letter published Thursday in the leading medical journal The Lancet, an international group of top medical specialists endorsed a counter-petition called the John Snow Memorandum, which sharply opposes the natural pursuit of "herd immunity."

a man wearing a suit and tie: White House coronavirus adviser Dr. Scott Atlas speaks on Covid-19 testing in the Rose Garden of the White House in Washington, DC, Sept. 28, 2020. © Mandel Ngan/AFP via Getty Images, FILE White House coronavirus adviser Dr. Scott Atlas speaks on Covid-19 testing in the Rose Garden of the White House in Washington, DC, Sept. 28, 2020.

"Uncontrolled transmission in younger people risks significant morbidity and mortality across the whole population," the authors wrote in the memorandum, which has received backing from prominent epidemiologists. "In addition to the human cost, this would impact the workforce as a whole and overwhelm the ability of healthcare systems to provide acute and routine care."

No government epidemiologist or infectious disease expert was on the White House call, and when pressed, a senior administration official said the White House was not actually formally "endorsing" the petition.

"We’re not endorsing a plan," the official, who requested anonymity, told reporters. "The plan is endorsing what the president’s policy has been for months."

MORE: Some states raising doubts about federal tests sent to nursing homes, citing shaky reliability

Fauci told ABC News on Thursday that the Great Barrington Declaration falsely portrayed prominent public health experts as supporting "lockdowns."

Trump closes his campaign by insulting Fauci for telling the truth

  Trump closes his campaign by insulting Fauci for telling the truth President Donald Trump's election endgame argument, far from bristling with new solutions to a pandemic that has killed 220,000 Americans, on Monday devolved into a campaign of insults against Dr. Anthony Fauci -- for telling the truth about the disease. © Mandel Ngan/AFP/Getty Images US President Donald Trump gestures during a rally at Southern Wisconsin Regional Airport in Janesville, Wisconsin on October 17, 2020.

"That declaration has a couple things in it that I think are fooling people, because it says things that are like apple pie and motherhood," he said. "A, we don't want to shut down the country. I say that all the time. B, we do certainly want to protect the vulnerable."

In a statement provided by the White House, Atlas said "we emphatically deny that the White House, the president, the administration, or anyone advising the president has pursued or advocated for any strategy of achieving herd immunity by letting the coronavirus infection spread through the community." He said the Great Barrington Declaration authors "emphasized focused protection of the vulnerable and safely ending the shutdown of schools and society."

"Those specific policies are aligned with the president, who has repeatedly stated and pursued a strategy focused on saving lives by the following: aggressively protecting the vulnerable, preventing hospital overcrowding, and safely opening schools and society," Atlas said.

Anthony S. Fauci wearing a suit and tie: Anthony Fauci, director of National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases at NIH, testifies at a Senate Health, Education, and Labor and Pensions Committee on Capitol Hill, Sept. 23, 2020, in Washington. © Graeme Jennings/Pool via Getty Images, FILE Anthony Fauci, director of National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases at NIH, testifies at a Senate Health, Education, and Labor and Pensions Committee on Capitol Hill, Sept. 23, 2020, in Washington.

But John Brownstein, an epidemiologist at Boston Children's Hospital and professor of medicine at Harvard Medical School, said the Great Barrington Declaration did, in fact, back the idea of letting the virus rip through the community -- as long as the vulnerable were protected. "It's the same thing," Brownstein, an ABC News contributor, said. "I don't see the distinction."

Brownstein said the concept of "focused protection" was "theoretically exciting to think about" but was "not achievable in our population" because of the high level of underlying medical conditions in the population -- as well as the interconnectedness of society.

"We know that every single person is a bridge to a high-risk person," he said. "It's just not practical to think you could put people who are high risk separate from the population."

The president has for months pushed for the end of coronavirus restrictions -- including those recommended by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention and other federal health officials -- flouting precautions like mask wearing and ignoring state and local regulations forbidding large gatherings.

MORE: Trump attacks Fauci with falsehoods after backlash for quoting him out of context in campaign ad

A close ally, Florida GOP Gov. Ron DeSantis, has also embraced the researchers pushing the ideas behind natural "herd immunity."

In late September, DeSantis, a Republican, hosted a roundtable discussion with two of those who would later meet with Azar, Stanford University's Jay Bhattacharya and Harvard Medical School's Martin Kulldorff.

The next day, DeSantis, a Republican, lifted all coronavirus-related restrictions in the state.

Trump Fumes at Fauci, Believes He’s Auditioning for CNN Gig .
In the final two weeks of his re-election campaign, President Donald Trump has turned much of his attention to venting his anger and insecurities at one of his administration’s top public-health officials and coronavirus task force members, Dr. Anthony Fauci. In recent months, Trump has routinely gossiped with close associates and advisers that Fauci is behaving like a member of anti-MAGA “resistance” commentators. In the past few weeks, the president has told multiple people that he believes Fauci is angling to earn the media’s adulation and that it at times appears to him that the famous infectious disease expert is “audition[ing]” or “trying to get a job at CNN,”

usr: 3
This is interesting!