•   
  •   
  •   

Politics Swing-state Pennsylvanians are divided on fracking. Here’s why.

05:15  23 october  2020
05:15  23 october  2020 Source:   vox.com

Trump hits Biden on fracking in appeal to Pennsylvania voters

  Trump hits Biden on fracking in appeal to Pennsylvania voters President Trump on Tuesday harped on Democratic nominee's stance on fracking in a pitch to Pennsylvania voters, zeroing in on an issue of heightened importance in the Keystone State. © Getty Images Trump hits Biden on fracking in appeal to Pennsylvania voters The president's campaign rally was filled with his usual attacks on Biden's mental sharpness and character and exaggerated claims about the former vice president's platform. But his speech was tailored a bit more toward the crowd with heavy references to fracking.

And here ’ s where Fetterman is concerned about what he’s seeing in the presidential contest, especially from the progressive candidates he’s otherwise so closely aligned with. And the first thing they want to do is tell us about just how important fracking has been in this part of the state for their members.

The fracking process uses roughly 700 types of chemicals—and many known carcinogens—and is a cause of pollution in the southwest portion of the state . According to the Kaiser Family Foundation, Pennsylvanians are more likely to report difficulty paying for medical bills (36%) compared to the

Natural gas fracking has been getting a lot of air time on the campaign trail in recent weeks.

a train traveling down train tracks near a forest: A section of the SUNOCO Mariner II East Pipeline construction in Exton, Pennsylvania. Residents and local elected officials have expressed strong opposition to the pipelines. © Erik McGregor/LightRocket via Getty Images A section of the SUNOCO Mariner II East Pipeline construction in Exton, Pennsylvania. Residents and local elected officials have expressed strong opposition to the pipelines.

In front of a crowd of thousands gathered in Erie, Pennsylvania, on Tuesday, President Donald Trump played a compilation of video clips in which former Vice President Joe Biden and Sen. Kamala Harris described their plans to transition away from fossil fuels.

“Joe Biden will ban fracking and abolish Pennsylvania energy,” Trump told the crowd, followed by a chorus of boos.

Joe Biden's Resistance to Green New Deal Helps Win Back Blue-Collar Democrats in Pennsylvania

  Joe Biden's Resistance to Green New Deal Helps Win Back Blue-Collar Democrats in Pennsylvania Those in the Keystone State worried Joe Biden's energy policies might hurt jobs, see the vice president as a better champion of workers' rights than President Donald Trump.President Donald Trump took the Keystone State by only 44,000 votes and this time around it has been in the crosshairs of the Democrats keen to make amends for 2016 when Hillary Clinton was accused of ignoring those outside its major conurbations, thus costing her its 20 crucial electoral votes.

Learn about swing states in American politics. Read a list of swing states and see why they're so important. States that shift back and forth between candidates of both major political parties in presidential elections could be evenly divided between voters registered Republican and Democratic.

A swing state is a state that is almost evenly divided between how many voters usually vote Republican and how many voters usually vote If you ever wonder why Democratic candidates all but never visit Texas to campaign here , it is because Texas is approximately 67% Conservative, give or

Hydraulic fracturing, or fracking, has allowed the US to dramatically increase its oil and gas production in Pennsylvania and various other states over the last decade. Biden’s plan to tackle climate change sets a target for the country to bring greenhouse emissions to zero by 2050, but it doesn’t call for banning fracking. During his town hall last week, Biden reiterated that he doesn’t intend to ban fracking.

Trump, who has no climate plan of his own, has been taking shots at Biden’s climate and energy initiatives as part of a broader effort to attract voters in battleground states. But his campaign has not seen a dramatic turnaround in Pennsylvania. Biden has maintained his lead in the polls — and is currently ahead by 6 percent on average, according to FiveThirtyEight.

Trump's Video of Biden Repeatedly Speaking Out Against Fracking Viewed Over 10 Million Times

  Trump's Video of Biden Repeatedly Speaking Out Against Fracking Viewed Over 10 Million Times Trump has repeatedly claimed that Biden wants to ban fracking outright despite that not being the position of the former vice president.The video includes clips of Biden saying he would eliminate fossil fuels like coal and fracking and that there would be no more subsidies for either one, while another clip sees Biden guaranteeing that they would end fossil fuel.

Hydraulic fracturing , or fracking , is a technique designed to recover gas and oil from shale rock. In the United States it has significantly boosted domestic oil production and driven down gas prices. It is estimated to have offered gas security to the US and Canada for about 100 years, and has presented

While Governor Tom Wolf was speaking as a "climate leader" at a clean energy event in Washington, D.C., Pennsylvanian native Craig Stevens calls out his

Whether Trump’s pro-fracking talk will help his chances of reelection is unclear. Natural gas fracking is concentrated in Pennsylvania’s Republican-leaning counties, and 77 percent of Republicans said they supported the industry in an August CBS/YouGov poll. This means Trump’s rhetoric could energize his base; on the other hand, the same poll showed that 52 percent of sampled registered voters oppose fracking, so it may not win over suburban residents.

What is clear is that even as it’s become a focal point in the election, the fracking industry is struggling. An oversupply of gas has left producers in debt and jobs have declined. Fracking has also caused health and environmental damage in several states across the country, and is likely a major source of emissions of methane, an exceptionally potent greenhouse gas. Clean energy advocates say that a shift to investing in renewables would help to create a stable economy for a state that has long been dominated by the boom and bust cycles of extractive industries.

Biden falsely claims he never opposed fracking

  Biden falsely claims he never opposed fracking Former Vice President Joe Biden claimed that he "never said I oppose fracking" when pressed by President Donald Trump on the issue during Thursday night's presidential debate."You said it on tape," Trump replied.

Here ' s why . Published Sun, Jul 31 20169:22 AM EDTUpdated Mon, Aug 1 20167:20 AM EDT. An anti-immigration stance is a powerful thing in a state that's been inundated with new residents from across the border. For some Pennsylvanians , the changes have been hard to bear.

Swing states explained in 90 seconds - Продолжительность: 1:34 The Telegraph 19 143 просмотра. Hill Reporter: Forget the pundits, the 2020 swing states you didn't know about - Продолжительность: 6:54 The Hill 149 183 просмотра.

What happened to the natural gas boom?

Pennsylvania has been a key state in the fracking revolution, as companies have tapped into the Marcellus shale, the largest US gas field by proven reserves, which lies below much of its territory. Over the last 10 years since the boom began, it has become the country’s number two gas producer behind Texas.

In 2019, Pennsylvania produced a record amount of natural gas through fracking, but the growth in production belies the industry’s instability. The glut in gas has driven prices down and left even the top producers saddled with debt.

The fracking boom also has not created a huge number of jobs. According to statistics commissioned by the state’s Department of Environmental Protection, the natural gas industry, including extraction, transmission, and electricity generation, employed just under 24,000 people in 2019. Jobs in the sector have shrunk 7 percent since 2017, and only represent a tiny fraction of the state’s overall employment.

Of course, others have also benefitted from fracking, including landowners who have received royalties from companies drilling on their land, and services that support the natural gas industry.

Fact Check: Joe Biden wants to eliminate new fracking permits, not all fracking

  Fact Check: Joe Biden wants to eliminate new fracking permits, not all fracking A claim that former Vice President Joe Biden wants to ban fracking is not entirely true. He has publicly stated that he's opposed to a fracking ban.This summer, it was made in a post on Facebook and is similar to an ad by America First Action, a pro-Trump Political Action Committee. It includes a video of Biden answering a question in a primary debate and a claim that Biden could cost Pennsylvania more than 600,000 jobs. The video says it is paid for by America First Action.

The President will need voters in the suburbs of Florida if he hopes to retake the White House. CNN' s John King explains why .

See early voting for an analysis of voting in swing states . Swing states , also called "battleground states," are states in which neither the Republican nor Democratic candidate has a clear majority of the voters' support prior to a Presidential election

But Rachel Meyer, a teacher who lives in the fracking hotspot of Beaver County along the state’s southwestern border, sees people growing less enamored. She also serves as a volunteer for the Beaver County Marcellus Awareness Community where she has learned about the environmental, health, and safety risks involved with fracking.

“I feel like we are at a kind of transition point now where people are starting to say, ‘Wait a second you know this seemed like a great thing, and we were really excited about it, but now we’re seeing some of issues and some really bad things starting to happen,’” said Meyer.

She first became involved in advocacy work around fracking when she heard about the explosion of Energy Transfer Corporation pipeline in her county back in 2018. The explosion, which officials linked to a landslide, luckily didn’t cause any casualties but it destroyed a home and left the surrounding area charred. Meyer said for her and many of her neighbors who have pipelines running in close proximity — or even through — their properties the incident was a wake-up call.

Fracking, which uses chemical-laced fluids to break open rock seams, has also led to some cases of water contamination and air pollution.

In late June, the state’s Attorney General Josh Shapiro released the results of a two-year investigation that widely condemned the industry for its pollution, and faulted the government for not holding corporations in check.

Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez Says Biden's Mixed Messaging on Fracking 'Does Not Bother Me'

  Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez Says Biden's Mixed Messaging on Fracking 'Does Not Bother Me' "I think young people right now have a very activist, disciplined mindset and they are not here with the intent of voting for their favorite person," Ocasio-Cortez said Sunday on CNN.She said that Biden's seemingly conflicting remarks on a fracking ban don't bother her or other young people who know that Biden would listen to activists and environmentalist— something President Donald Trump would never consider. Ocasio-Cortez said young people and herself are "going to vote for someone who they can lobby.

“The bottom line is, this was a failure,” Shapiro said at a news conference, according to the Philadelphia Inquirer. “Regulators were supposed to prevent abuse by the big corporations ... but they didn’t.”

Donald Trump et al. standing in front of a crowd: Trump speaks to contractors at the Shell Chemicals Petrochemical Complex on August 13, 2019, in Monaca, Pennsylvania. President Donald Trump delivered a speech on the economy, and focused on manufacturing and energy sector jobs. © Jeff Swensen/Getty Images Trump speaks to contractors at the Shell Chemicals Petrochemical Complex on August 13, 2019, in Monaca, Pennsylvania. President Donald Trump delivered a speech on the economy, and focused on manufacturing and energy sector jobs.

Evening out the energy playing field

Despite the downsides of the fracking boom, the state government has propped up the industry, most recently offering a massive tax break to Shell to build a major plastic factory that will make use of some of the extra natural gas in the state.

Josh McNeil, the executive director of Conservation Voters of Pennsylvania, which opposes fracking, said that it is time for the state to break free of extractive industries that have caused boom and bust cycles.

“Two months ago now, the legislature gave away a [$670] million handout to build petrochemical plants in the state, and they did that to create a market for natural gas. I’m not seeing anything like that for solar or wind.”

“We would like to see an even playing field that allows solar and wind, which in many cases are already cheaper than coal and gas, get the same kind of treatment.”

Recent polling shows that Pennsylvanians support increased electricity generation from renewable energy. But Meyer said that managing the transition away from fossil fuels is a concern for some. “Certainly there are people who, with good intentions, are concerned about the fracking industry leaving. And certainly there are communities who think, you know, we need this to come into our communities—there still is that.”

Trump's final pitch to Pennsylvania: I love fracking

  Trump's final pitch to Pennsylvania: I love fracking The approach has played well in 2016, but it is complicated by split opinions in the state and the industry's recent decline.At several stops in a one-day, three-MAGA rally blitz, Trump portrayed fracking as an issue of “existential importance” for Pennsylvania. He mentioned it at the top of his rallies. He returned to it repeatedly during his remarks. And, with a reference to classic Hollywood director Cecil B. DeMille, he asked rally goers to watch a campaign video of Biden’s comments on the issue — a tactic he first adopted last week in Erie, Pa. — then tweeted it out minutes later.

In this election cycle, this has led some workers to vocally support Trump and his pro-fracking stance. The Boilermakers Local 154 union have endorsed Trump and refuted Biden’s assertion in the last town hall that he had the union’s backing.

Other unions have been throwing their weight behind Biden, assuming that he will maintain the status quo.

Shannon Smith, communications and development manager at the nonprofit FracTracker Alliance said, “I’ve heard from union leaders recently that they aren’t going to vote for Trump because they trust that Biden is not going to instate a fracking ban,” which she adds wouldn’t even be feasible.

But ultimately she said natural gas production will have to come down. According to the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, carbon dioxide emissions, including those from burning natural gas, have to be decreased to net zero by 2050 for the world to avoid the worst impacts of global warming. Biden’s climate plan calls for investment in communities that have been dependent on fossil fuels, which she sees as critical.

“We need candidates who are going to help figure out that transition because it will happen.”

Will you help keep Vox free for all?

The United States is in the middle of one of the most consequential presidential elections of our lifetimes. It’s essential that all Americans are able to access clear, concise information on what the outcome of the election could mean for their lives, and the lives of their families and communities. That is our mission at Vox. But our distinctive brand of explanatory journalism takes resources. Even when the economy and the news advertising market recovers, your support will be a critical part of sustaining our resource-intensive work. If you have already contributed, thank you. If you haven’t, please consider helping everyone understand this presidential election: Contribute today from as little as $3.

Fact Check: Misleading new Trump ad claims Biden plans to 'end fracking' .
Less than two weeks before Election Day, a new Trump campaign ad scheduled to air in Pennsylvania misleadingly portrays former Vice President Joe Biden's stance on fracking, a drilling method used to extract oil or natural gas. © Spencer Platt/Getty Images SOUTH MONTROSE, PA - JANUARY 18: A Cabot Oil and Gas natural gas drill stands at a hydraulic fracturing site on January 18, 2012 in South Montrose, Pennsylvania. Hydraulic fracturing, also known as fracking, stimulates gas production by injecting wells with high volumes of chemical-laced water in order to free-up pockets of natural gas below.

usr: 1
This is interesting!