Politics Judge dismisses last election-related case pending in Arizona

08:05  21 november  2020
08:05  21 november  2020 Source:   usatoday.com

Puerto Rico unearths over 100 briefcases with uncounted ballots a week after election

  Puerto Rico unearths over 100 briefcases with uncounted ballots a week after election Puerto Rico’s elections commission said it has found over 100 briefcases with uncounted ballots a week after the U.S. territory held its election.Francisco Rosado, the commission’s new president, said the briefcases were found in a secured vault and blamed the situation on what he said was an underfunded and understaffed administrative board responsible for counting a record number of absentee and early votes.

Judge dismisses Arizona GOP election audit lawsuit. The decision appears to leave just one election - related challenge — which will not affect the results of any races — pending in Arizona . The Arizona Republican Party had filed its suit last week, alleging Maricopa County officials violated Pence and other task force members acknowledged that COVID-19 cases are rising, but claimed the

An Arizona state judge threw out the Arizona Republican Party’s lawsuit seeking a broader audit of votes cast on Election Day which county lawyers warned could have delayed the state’s certification of ballots. In a brief order, the judge dismissed the lawsuit with prejudice and denied the Arizona

PHOENIX —  A Maricopa County Superior Court judge tossed out a lawsuit on Friday claiming that the county denied one voter the right to cast her ballot and failed to properly process another voter's ballot, dismissing the last election-related case pending in Arizona.

a close up of a tool: Legal claim against Tucson police settled. © Getty Images Legal claim against Tucson police settled.

Judge Margaret Mahoney did not elaborate on her reasoning for throwing out the case at the end of the hearing but said she would issue an order in writing.

Whatever Mahoney decided, the case — involving only two ballots — would not have changed the outcome of the election.

Election updates: Biden's lead over Trump in AZ surpasses remaining votes; GA begins 2nd-largest recount in US history

  Election updates: Biden's lead over Trump in AZ surpasses remaining votes; GA begins 2nd-largest recount in US history Biden's lead over Trump is now officially insurmountable as he leads by 11,434 votes statewide – more than the estimated number of remaining ballots.Be sure to refresh this page often to get the latest information on how things are going.

In Arizona , a state judge tossed a GOP-backed lawsuit seeking to stop Phoenix officials from certifying Biden as the winner. In Pennsylvania, a state judge rejected the Trump campaign's bid to invalidate about 2,200 ballots in Bucks County over purported defects. The trio of losses came as Trump's legal

Judges in Arizona and Georgia struck down lawsuits Thursday brought by Republican plaintiffs seeking to challenge or delay the results of their states’ elections , delivering a blow to the Trump campaign and GOP’s attempts to block battleground states from certifying their election results and

Start the day smarter. Get all the news you need in your inbox each morning.

But the judge's decision, after a daylong trial, makes the case just the latest in a string of challenges to the election process to fall flat in Arizona's courts as President Donald Trump sought to call into question his defeat at the ballot box earlier this month.

What does the lawsuit claim?

The lawsuit names two voters as plaintiffs: Laurie Aguilera, the same woman who filed the now-defunct suit against the county over the use of Sharpies on Election Day, and Donovan Drobina.

Both went to vote in person in Maricopa County on Election Day.

Aguilera alleges that when she and her husband attempted to cast their ballots, the tabulator did not display any confirmation that her ballot had been accepted, as it had for her husband's ballot. She claims she requested a new ballot, but poll workers refused.

Trump election lawsuit in Arizona's Maricopa County dismissed, outcome wouldn't have affected races

  Trump election lawsuit in Arizona's Maricopa County dismissed, outcome wouldn't have affected races By Friday morning, the Trump team had filed a motion acknowledging the outcome of the lawsuit would have no impact on Arizona’s presidential results . He noted a favorable ruling would, at most, be relevant in two down-ballot races. Attorneys representing election officials also filed a notice Friday morning saying Maricopa County planned to finish counting ballots by 3 p.m. and requesting "the Court dismiss Plaintiffs’ claims as moot." During a brief afternoon hearing, the parties agreed the 432 ballots Maricopa County had left to record and upload were unlikely to change the outcomes of any results.

A judge has dismissed a Republican-backed lawsuit seeking to halt Arizona officials from A judge dismissed a Republican-backed lawsuit seeking to overturn Arizona election results. Judge John Hannah denied a request an injunction to block certification of elections results.

The judge dismissed the case after Trump's lawyers said Republican election watchers were, in fact, present. The lawsuit is still pending , but the lawyers withdrew from the case . A state judge dismissed the case , saying the arguments have "no basis in fact and law."

Aguilera testified Friday that a poll worker told her the ballot was "in the box" and would be counted.

Still, she was concerned her ballot hadn't been counted and that the county's election website did not indicate she had voted, although it showed her husband's had done so.

Drobina, for his part, testified that a tabulator rejected his ballot when he tried to insert it at his vote center on Election Day. After another attempt, a poll worker suggested he put it into another slot. Ballots deposited in that slot are counted individually by election officials if the tabulating machines cannot process them.

But Alexander Kolodin, the lawyer representing Drobina and Aguilera, argued that the ballot should not have been reviewed by election officials, contending that state law requires the machines — when operated properly — to "record correctly and count accurately every vote cast."

Democratic Party waging a war over its future just as Joe Biden takes helm

  Democratic Party waging a war over its future just as Joe Biden takes helm Joe Biden will take the White House as a fractured Democratic Party battles over its future, with moderates and progressives blasting each other.House Democrats were stunned by their losses after weeks of forecasting had predicted a big win on Election Day. Whispers of leadership change swirled, and House lawmakers soon moved from privately bashing one another to a public airing of grievances on social media and in the media.

"Since the close of yesterday's hearing, the tabulation of votes statewide has rendered unnecessary a judicial ruling as to the presidential electors," wrote Kory Langhofer, a lawyer for the Trump campaign. He said he did want the judge to rule on their requests to review votes for two down-ballot races.

Trump's campaign last Wednesday filed a motion to intervene in a case pending before the U.S Trump's campaign said last Saturday it had sued in Arizona , alleging that the state's most populous On Thursday 6, Michigan Court of Claims Judge Cynthia Stephens dismissed the case , saying there

Mahoney questioned Kolodin's interpretation that the law guarantees every voter some sort of right to have the ballot counted mechanically, noting the state law and  election procedures lay out detailed processes for counting ballots by hand when ballots cannot be read by a machine.

And lawyers for the county argued that allowing Aguilera to cast a new ballot would have amounted to letting her vote twice.

While Aguilera said she did not see or hear a message from the tabulator indicating her ballot was counted, maybe she was mistaken and simply missed it, said Deputy County Attorney Emily Craiger.

Similarly, poll workers might have marked her as not having voted when she sought a new ballot, Craiger added.

Election 2020: Civil rights leaders, legal experts call on Michigan Board of Canvassers to certify election

"We can acknowledge that perhaps mistakes were made. But the mistake that was not made was not letting Ms. Aguilera vote twice," Craiger said.

Besides, Craiger noted, voters cannot cast a ballot after 7 p.m. on Election Day unless they were standing in line at a polling place.

'A nightmare for too many': Hundreds of Arizona renters may have been wrongfully evicted during pandemic

  'A nightmare for too many': Hundreds of Arizona renters may have been wrongfully evicted during pandemic Arizona landlords wrongfully moved to evict renters during the height of the COVID-19 pandemic — despite a federal law protecting those tenants.More than 900 evictions were filed against tenants who likely should have been protected by the federal CARES Act, according to an investigation by the Arizona Republic, part of the USA TODAY Network.

The lawsuit also argued that the general public should be allowed to attend in person when election officials count ballots individually that could not be read by a machine.

Lawyers for the county pointed out that the public can watch election officials at work online — something Aguilera and Drobina said they had not attempted —- because public attendance is limited because of security and health concerns.

With the conservative Public Interest Legal Foundation signed on to the case, though, the trial seemed as much an effort to put out various claims about the election process.

Lawyers for the plaintiffs called one poll worker as a witness who estimated most voters at the vote center where he worked on Election Day had issues with tabulators reading their ballots.

Election 2020 updates: Donald Trump Jr. positive for COVID-19; Georgia certifies Biden win

They also called as a witness a retired software engineer from Texas who has examined various voting systems, although not the one used in Maricopa County. Still, in his brief testimony, he said "there's nothing perfect in this world, including voting systems" — a point a lawyer for the state Democratic Party later seized on.

The case wilted the same week that Gov. Doug Ducey said he will accept the outcome of the presidential race only after all related lawsuits are resolved.

Fact check: Federal Election Commission chair has no role in election integrity

  Fact check: Federal Election Commission chair has no role in election integrity In the past week, comments by Federal Election Commission Chair Trey Trainor have spread online as purported evidence over voter fraud.RecentlyHeard.com, a news website, wrote that "The Chief Electoral Officer of the Federal Election Commission made a Bombshell statement, saying that, from what he saw in Pennsylvania, and news that he had come from elsewhere in the world, this election was unconstitutional.

The day before Mahoney's decision, another judge dismissed an Arizona Republican Party lawsuit seeking a new audit of Maricopa County ballots and denied the GOP's request to delay certification of election results.

And on Friday afternoon, the Maricopa County Board of Supervisors certified the results of the election.

Follow Andrew Oxford and Maria Polleta on Twitter @andrewboxford and @mpolletta.

This article originally appeared on Arizona Republic: Judge dismisses last election-related case pending in Arizona

Fact check: Trump lawyer Sidney Powell falsely stated he won election 'by a landslide' .
A meme correctly quotes onetime Trump campaign lawyer Sidney Powell. But her assertion that he won the election "by a landslide" is false.“We are not going to be intimidated. We are not going to back down. We are going to clean this mess up. President Trump won by a landslide and we are going to prove it. We are going to reclaim the United States of America,” reads a Facebook meme.

usr: 1
This is interesting!