Politics 'A different time': Why the recall effort against California Gov. Newsom isn't history repeating
VP Kamala Harris appears with California Gov. Gavin Newsom amid recall effort
Top members of the Biden White House have appeared with California's embattled Democratic governor, Gavin Newsom, twice over the last week -- a signal of support for a politician who is likely to face a recall election. © Jacquelyn Martin/AP Vice President Kamala Harris, with California Gov. Gavin Newsom, visits the Upper San Leandro Water Treatment Plant in Oakland, Calif., Monday, April 5, 2021. Newsom accompanied Vice President Kamala Harris on a tour of a water treatment plant in Oakland, California, on Monday, where Harris was tasked with promoting the Biden administration's infrastructure plan.
LOS ANGELES — The campaign to recall California Gov. Gavin Newsom is already showing signs of turning into a circus like the one that brought down Gray Davis in 2003.
Tuesday that Caitlyn Jenner, the former reality star and Olympian and stepparent to the even more famous Kardashian clan, is considering entering the governor's race if a recall petition qualifies for the ballot. NBC News has not verified whether Jenner intends to run, and she has not announced a decision.
Jenner could be the first of what many strategists believe will be a long line of celebrity and novelty candidates who could closely mirror those who ran in 2003, when adult film star Mary Carey, former child actor Gary Coleman and Hustler publisher Larry Flynt added their names to the list of more than 100 would-be governors. Action movie hero Arnold Schwarzenegger ultimately won the election.
Gavin Newsom Recall Not Supported by Californians: Poll
The California governor has sought to paint the recall campaign as a partisan effort by the state's Republican Party.The poll, conducted by the Public Policy Institute of California and released on Tuesday, found that 56 percent of voters were against the recall, 40 percent supported it and the remainder were undecided.
Nearly 20 years later, the comparisons stop there.
who have announced their intentions to run have statewide name recognition similar to Schwarzenegger's. Former San Diego Mayor Kevin Faulconer, who is considered the likely front-runner, is not well known outside Southern California. Businessman John Cox lost to Newsom in 2018 by double digits, and Doug Ose, a former member of Congress, briefly ran for governor in 2018 before he dropped out of the race.
"The biggest thing Newsom has to do is keep a Democrat from running," said Rob Stutzman, a Republican strategist and former spokesman for Schwarzenegger. "So far so good, but it's also easy right now. We're in for several months of waiting."
California voters aren't ready to get rid of their governor
Two seemingly contradictory things are both true about this moment in California politics: © Justin Sullivan/Getty Images California Gov. Gavin Newsom. 1. There is likely to be a recall election this fall aimed at pushing Gov. Gavin Newsom out of office. 2. Newsom is likely to survive that recall election.How, you ask? After all, if people are mad enough to get a recall measure on the ballot, aren't they going to follow through and, you know, actually recall Newsom?Well, no. Or, more accurately given the unpredictability of any campaign including a recall campaign, probably not.
Recall organizers say they collected, well above the 1.5 million needed to meet the state's threshold. Counties have until the end of the month to verify signatures and report their tallies to state election officials. The state Finance Department will take about 30 days to produce a cost estimate for the election before a legislative panel reviews the findings. Only then would an election date be set.
If a recall qualifies for the ballot, voters will be asked two questions: The first would be whether they want to recall Newsom, and the second would be who should replace him. There is no limit to how many people can run, and whoever gets the most votes wins.
Since Davis was recalled in 2003, the political landscape of California has shifted increasingly to the left. Registered Republican voters were 35 percent of the electorate in February 2003, according to the state secretary of state's office, while this year they account for 24 percent.
Kamala Harris Backs Gavin Newsom As He Faces Recall Election
The vice president said the White House would be "supportive" of the California governor.In an interview with the San Francisco Chronicle, Harris said the White House would be as "supportive as much as we possibly can" amid the California recall election campaign.
By contrast, 44 percent were registered as Democrats in 2003, and this year it is 46 percent. In 2003, 15 percent declined to say what party they were in; this year, 24 percent of voters registered under "no party preference."
"Politically, we're a completely different state than we were in 2003," Katie Merrill, a Democratic strategist, said Wednesday during ahosted by the Sacramento Press Club. "If you look at the statewide races, the Republican Party has effectively become a third party in California."
Democratic strategist Ace Smith said during the panel: "It's a different time. We're in a state where, frankly, there used to be Republicans who used to be somewhat moderate. The Republican Party of Trump has lost [its] way."
The shadow of former President Donald Trump, who has been invoked repeatedly as a kind of political bogeyman, is another notable difference between the recall effort against Newsom and the campaign against Davis.
Since the effort to oust Newsom surfaced, California Democrats have collectively rallied around the notion that the campaign is a power grab by Trump loyalists bitter about losing the White House to President Joe Biden.
Bernie Sanders claims Newsom faces recall because he told 'people to wear masks,' omitting French Laundry controversy
Vermont Sen. Bernie Sanders railed against the effort to recall Gov. Gavin Newsom, claiming that the California Democrat is facing a recall because he told “people to wear masks.” © Provided by Washington Examiner "Right-wing Republicans in CA are trying to recall @GavinNewsom for the crime of telling people to wear masks and for listening to scientists during COVID," Sanders tweeted Monday."Extremist Republicans have done enough to undermine democracy already. We must all unite to oppose the recall in California," he added.
Last month, Dan Newman, a campaign adviser for Newsom, said the recall campaign was "pure partisan politics," while Newsom said white supremacists and right-wing militia groups, including the Proud Boys, are among the recall backers.
"We're just concerned about violence moving into the future as we move farther and farther away from the January insurrection and we put down our guard. We must remain vigilant about these groups and how serious they are," Newsom said on MSNBC last month. "All you need is about a quarter of the people who supported Trump to just sign a petition, and it appears they've done that."
In 2003, Davis had no such specter to deflect attention. He had already been embroiled in various crises when he won a second term in 2002, having been heavily criticized for reacting too slowly to an energy crisis that knocked out power for more than a million residents in 2000 and 2001. He apologized, but the debacle took a toll on his reputation.
Davis won re-election in 2002 with 47 percent of the vote. By 2003, just 27 percent of California voters approved of his job performance, theat the time. The option to recall Davis won 55 percent of the vote.
By contrast, 40 percent of respondents said they would elect to recall Newsom, 79 percent of whom identified as Republicans, according to a, a nonpartisan research organization. Newsom's approval rating is also higher than Davis' was — at 53 percent among likely voters last month, compared to 42 percent who said they disapproved of his job performance.
Poll: Majority of California voters don't back recall
A substantial majority of California voters say they do not support recalling Gov. Gavin Newsom (D) from office as voters give high marks to legislation he signed to combat the economic recession brought on by the coronavirus pandemic. © Getty Images Poll: Majority of California voters don't back recall Fifty-six percent of voters say they oppose the recall effort to remove Newsom from office, according to a new Public Policy Institute of California poll released this week, while 40 percent of likely voters say they would support a recall.
"If no other Democrat gets into the race and it stays like this — the economy is recovering, the coronavirus doesn't spike again and all that looks good — then he's not going to be nearly as unpopular as Davis was," Stutzman said.
Unlike Davis, whose administration was hobbled by a $38 billion budget deficit, Newsom boasted a $15 billion one-time surplus at the beginning of the year, according to his. During the pandemic, wealthy Californians made $185 billion in capital gains income, or money earned from the sale of assets, which resulted in $18.5 billion in tax revenue for the state, . Because of the surplus, Newsom's plan would spend $25 billion more than last year.
But record levels of homelessness and joblessness have continued to plague California throughout the pandemic, andthat this summer could bring another catastrophic round of fires up and down the state.
As residents battle crises on multiple fronts, recall backers say it's too soon to celebrate victory.
"What a disconnect," recall fundraiser Anne Dunsmore said. "You got people living on the streets, being flooded out of their tents, and we're going to brag about a surplus? Go spend it."
California had its worst wildfire season ever last year -- and officials are now fearing more of the same .
After the worst wildfire season ever in 2020, California is bracing for more destruction this year due to worsening drought conditions and above-normal temperatures. "We had world record-breaking high temperatures in our own backyard in California... 130 degrees in our state," Governor Gavin Newsom said Thursday as he launched a $536 million funding package to boost fire prevention projects.The outlook is already ominous as 91% of the state is suffering from drought and has reported consecutive dry months since last October, according to the U.S. Drought Monitor.