Politics Fact-checking Biden's first joint address to Congress

07:45  29 april  2021
07:45  29 april  2021 Source:   cnn.com

Biden's 1st 100 days: Promises kept, broken, or in progress

  Biden's 1st 100 days: Promises kept, broken, or in progress Here's a look at how President Joe Biden is measuring up against the markers he set for himself. As a candidate and incoming president, he had promised a series of swift and sweeping actions to address the range of challenges he inherited.

In his first joint address to Congress, President Joe Biden struck an optimistic tone, speaking for more than an hour and pushing his expansive vision of building America "back better" by touting his vast infrastructure plan and praising the progress the country has made against Covid-19.

Joe Biden et al. dressed in a suit and tie © CNN

While Biden's speech was, for the most part, factually accurate there were a few incorrect claims -- notably at times when he went off script -- and some that require context and explanation.

Here's a look at the facts:

Biden claims he's traveled 17,000 miles with Xi

Biden repeated a claim he has made before about his relationship with Chinese President Xi Jinping. He said Secretary of State Antony Blinken "can tell you that I spent a lot of time with President Xi -- traveled over 17,000 miles with him."

Stand and deliver — President Biden's maiden address to Congress

  Stand and deliver — President Biden's maiden address to Congress Addresses to Congress enable presidents to tout their policy accomplishments, and President Biden surely won’t demure.This is not the first time a major presidential address to Congress occurred later than initially planned. President Reagan's 1986 State of the Union was postponed a week because of the Space Shuttle Challenger disaster. "Go forward, America, and reach for the stars" became a signature line from the speech that year. President Trump's 2019 State of the Union occurred later than initially scheduled because of a government shutdown that impacted Capitol building operations.

Facts First: This is false. Biden has not traveled anywhere close to 17,000 miles "with" Xi, as Washington Post fact checker Glenn Kessler and then CNN noted in fact checks in February. While Biden could accurately say that he has spent many hours and held many meetings with Xi -- they spent time together in 2011, 2012, 2013 and 2015 -- Kessler noted that the two leaders often did not even travel parallel routes to their gatherings, let alone physically travel together. The only apparent way to get Biden's mileage past 17,000, Kessler found, is to add the length of his flights between Washington and Beijing, during which, obviously, Xi was not with him.

A White House official told CNN that Biden was making "a reference to the total travel back and forth -- both internally in the US and China, and as well as internationally -- for meetings they held together. Some travel was in parallel, some was separately to joint destinations." But that is very different from traveling "with" Xi, especially in the context of a point about how familiar he is with Xi.

Biden to propose $1.8 trillion 'families plan' with paid leave, child care, universal pre-K, free community college

  Biden to propose $1.8 trillion 'families plan' with paid leave, child care, universal pre-K, free community college The plan is the second piece of Biden's 'Build Back Better' economic agenda following the release of a $2.3 trillion infrastructure and jobs plan.Biden is set to formally introduce his American Families Plan at his first address before a joint session of Congress Wednesday night. It's the second piece of his "Build Back Better" economic agenda following the release of a $2.3 trillion infrastructure and jobs plan released earlier this month.

Biden's infrastructure plan and the economy

President Biden said that "independent experts estimate the American Jobs Plan will add millions of jobs and trillions of dollars to economic growth in years to come."

Facts First: It's true that some experts say the plan could create millions of jobs, but analysts differ on how much economic growth it could spur.

The American Jobs Plan proposes spending $2 trillion on improving the nation's infrastructure and paying for it by hiking corporate taxes. Some independent analysts say it will have a positive effect on jobs and the economy — but the magnitude of its effect will depend on the size and structure of the package that Congress ultimately passes.

Moody's Analytics found that the proposal would create about 2.7 million jobs by the end of 2030. A separate report from S&P Global noted that the jobs created by the plan could be temporary. It estimated that in the short term, $2.1 trillion in infrastructure spending could create 2.3 million jobs, but that as infrastructure projects are completed these jobs would taper off and the net jobs added from the proposal would be 713,000 by 2029.

5 winners and 3 losers from President Biden’s first congressional address

  5 winners and 3 losers from President Biden’s first congressional address Winner: Obamacare. Loser: Wall Street.“After just 100 days — I can report to the nation: America is on the move again,” Biden said during his speech. “Turning peril into possibility. Crisis into opportunity. Setback into strength.

Moody's Analytics projects that the infrastructure plan will result in a higher GDP over the next decade. It predicts GDP will grow by 3.8% in 2024, compared with 2.2% if the plan fails to become law.

S&P Global also found that that much infrastructure spending would boost the economy over the next decade adding $5.7 trillion over that time period. It estimated that GDP growth will be lifted to 2.2% from 1.7% over the next 10 years.

But a different analysis from the Penn Wharton Budget Model took a longer-term view and found that the infrastructure proposal would actually end up decreasing GDP by 0.8% in 2050.

Biden's infrastructure plan and education

In arguing that his infrastructure plan would create well-paying jobs for Americans, President Biden said that "Nearly 90% of the infrastructure jobs created in the American Jobs Plan don't require a college degree. 75% don't require an associate's degree."

Facts First: While it's impossible to fact check the impact of a plan that hasn't even passed Congress, a forecast from Georgetown University Center on Education and the Workforce supports these figures depending on how "college degree" is defined. The study estimates that 85% of the jobs from the infrastructure plan would be filled by those without a bachelor's degree, while 75% of the jobs would be filled by those without an associate's degree, according to the estimate.

Opinion: What grade did Biden get on his speech to Congress

  Opinion: What grade did Biden get on his speech to Congress CNN Opinion asks contributors to grade President Joe Biden's first speech before a joint session of Congress. © Pool/Getty Images North America/Getty Images WASHINGTON, DC - APRIL 28: U.S. President Joe Biden addresses a joint session of Congress in the House chamber of the U.S. Capitol April 28, 2021 in Washington, DC. On the eve of his 100th day in office, Biden spoke about his plan to revive America's economy and health as it continues to recover from a devastating pandemic.

The forecast predicts that 16% of the jobs could go to those with education levels below graduating high school, 37% could go to those with a high school diploma, 14% to those with some college education but no degree, 8% to those with a postsecondary vocational certificate and 10% to those with an associate's degree.

Many of these jobs would be temporary, as a study from S&P Global notes, estimating that the majority of jobs would taper off by 2029 as infrastructure projects are completed. It's important to note too that studies and estimates around the infrastructure plan vary widely.

Again, this is just one forecast of the potential effects of a plan not yet passed by Congress.

Biden on his work on root causes of migration as vice president

President Biden said, "When I was vice president, the President asked me to focus on providing help needed to address the root causes of migration, and it helped keep people in their own countries instead of being forced to leave. The plan was working. But the last administration decided it was not worth it."

Facts First: Biden didn't specify the program, but it's true that the Obama administration set up a program to provide safer pathways to the United States that was later terminated by then-President Trump.

During his tenure as vice president, Biden led diplomatic efforts in Guatemala, Honduras and El Salvador after a growing number of unaccompanied minors from those countries began arriving in the US in 2014. The Central American Minors program was among the efforts.

Biden's declaration: America's democracy 'is rising anew'

  Biden's declaration: America's democracy 'is rising anew' WASHINGTON (AP) — President Joe Biden declared that “America is rising anew” as he called for an expansion of federal programs to drive the economy past the pandemic and broadly extend the social safety net on a scale not seen in decades. Biden's nationally televised address to Congress, his first, raised the stakes for his ability to sell his plans to voters of both parties, even if Republican lawmakers prove resistant. The president is following Wednesday night's speech by pushing his plans in person, beginning in Georgia on Thursday and then on to Pennsylvania and Virginia in the days ahead.

The program allowed children under the age of 21 with parents lawfully living in the US to seek entry into the country from their places of origin if they did not qualify for refugee protections but were still at risk of harm. It served as an alternative for parents who might otherwise turn to smugglers to bring their children to the US illegally. While it might not have helped "keep people in their own countries," it was intended to keep them from being forced to try illegal, and dangerous, methods of immigration.

There are mixed reviews on whether the program "was working," as Biden said, given the urgent situations some children were facing. In 2017, the Trump administration ended the program, making it difficult to assess its effectiveness since it had only been in place for a limited period of time.

The Biden administration has since announced it is restarting the program.

Seniors vaccinated under President Biden

Biden said that "When I was sworn in on January 20th, less than 1% of the seniors in America were fully vaccinated against COVID-19. 100 days later, nearly 70% of seniors in America over 65 are protected, fully protected."

Facts First: While the numbers on vaccinated seniors that Biden cites are largely true, and his administration has made great strides in vaccinating Americans, Biden has benefitted from timing. When he took office in January, vaccines had only just been made available and some seniors were only newly eligible.

About 68% of people 65 and older are currently fully vaccinated, according to statistics from the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.

Why President Joe Biden's speech to Congress was unlike any other in modern history

  Why President Joe Biden's speech to Congress was unlike any other in modern history A joint sessions speech, known for its glad-handing cadence, was bound to be subdued with only 200 folks permitted at an event that can hold 1,500.President Joe Biden's address to a joint session of Congress was unlike any in modern history due to the COVID-19 pandemic. With no more than 200 folks permitted for an event that can hold up to 1,500, an event known for its glad-handing cadence and rousing moments was destined to be subdued.

While it is true that less than 1% of seniors had been fully vaccinated when Biden took office, that's in part due to the fact that two of the Covid-19 vaccines had been authorized by the US Food and Drug Administration for only a little more than a month.

In the US, the first person received a vaccination dose outside of a clinical trial on December 14 and Biden took office a little more than five weeks later on January 20. The recommended time between the first and second shot of the Moderna vaccine is 28 days and 21 days for the Pfizer vaccine.

After health care workers and those people who lived in long-term care facilities, people over the age of 75 were given top priority for vaccinations.

Biden's claims about women leaving the workforce

Biden said that 2 million women dropped out of America's labor force during the pandemic, often "because they couldn't get the care they need for their family, their children," he added.

Facts First: Biden is actually understating the number of women who left the labor force during the pandemic.

Seasonally adjusted data from the Bureau of Labor Statistics shows that as of March 2021, there were 2.6 million fewer women in the labor force compared to February 2020, before Covid-19 took its toll on the economy. The government defines people who aren't in the labor force as unemployed and not actively looking for a job.

Women have been hit harder by the pandemic in part because they account for a disproportionate share of workers in sectors that have been most affected by the pandemic, including hospitality and leisure.

In September of last year, when school started again after the summer and many children needed help distance learning, the number of women leaving the workforce was particularly high.

The employment-population ratio for America's women stood at 52.8% in March, down from 55.8% before the pandemic but up from its low during the first wave of the pandemic when the economy ground to a halt.

What it's been like fact-checking Joe Biden through 100 days .
Things have been quieter around here in presidential-fact-check land. © OLIVIER DOULIERY/AFP/Getty Images US President Joe Biden delivers remarks at an event marking Amtrack's 50th Anniversary at the William H. Gray III 30th Street Station in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania on April 30, 2021. Not because President Joe Biden is accurate all the time. He certainly isn't. But through his first 100 days in the Oval Office, Biden has given us intermittent false claims rather than the staggering avalanche of daily wrongness we faced from his predecessor.

usr: 0
This is interesting!