Politics New York experiments with new voting system in chaotic mayoral race: Breakthrough or disaster?

13:15  14 may  2021
13:15  14 may  2021 Source:   salon.com

Embroiled candidate Scott Stringer says his integrity is more important than mayoral bid

  Embroiled candidate Scott Stringer says his integrity is more important than mayoral bid “I want my children someday, when they go online, to see the whole story of their dad, I want them to be able to say our dad was very clear,” Stringer, the city comptroller, told WNYC's Brian Lehrer.New York City Comptroller and mayoral candidate Scott Stringer, who has barreled along with his campaign even as his endorsements dried up after a sexual abuse allegation, said Wednesday that defending his integrity is more important to him than reaching City Hall.

New York City's mayoral elections are usually big spectacles. They come during the most boring time in electoral politics, the year after the presidential election. The candidates can be press fodder (e.g. Anthony Weiner in 2013), and the winner will get to rule a city with a population of more than 8 million, more than most states.

New Yorkers will get their first chance to watch a live televised debate Thursday night among eight Democratic mayoral contenders for the June 22 primary as the city struggles to climb out of a devastating pandemic and confronts increasing crime and violence. Spectrum News NY 1 will host the showdown starting at 7 p.m., which will also be streamed online. The Schoen poll, paid for by the civic group New Yorkers for a Better Future, is the only one to rank respondents choices for mayor . The primary will be the first citywide election to use the new ranked-choice voting system .

Eric Adams, Dianne Morales posing for a photo: Andrew Yang; Kathryn Garcia; Eric Adams; Dianne Morales © Provided by Salon Andrew Yang; Kathryn Garcia; Eric Adams; Dianne Morales

Andrew Yang, Kathryn Garcia, Eric Adams and Dianne Morales Photo illustration by Salon/Getty Images/WikiCommons/Kris Graves

New York City is about to embark on an experiment that will determine its course for the next four years and could reshape elections across the country for the foreseeable future. But it won't be pretty.

Facing one of the highest coronavirus death tolls in the country, a steep economic recovery and rising violent crime, the city is set to become the largest municipality to roll out ranked-choice voting in its highly consequential Democratic mayoral primary next month. (In practical terms, the Democratic nominee is almost certain to become the next mayor.)

Mayoral candidate Eric Adams kicks off 30-second spot as he battles for frontrunner status

  Mayoral candidate Eric Adams kicks off 30-second spot as he battles for frontrunner status “New Yorkers were distracted, but now they’re connecting the dots that the next leader of the city’s going to be inheriting many issues that we have to address," said Adams.With just seven weeks until New York City’s primary election, Brooklyn Borough President Eric Adams is expected to launch his first TV ad on Friday to encourage Democratic voters to send him to City Hall.

Much of the focus in the New York City mayoral race has been given to the eight best-known Democratic candidates, who lead in fund-raising and in early polling. For Republican voters , the ballot will be far less involved: There will only be two candidates, after a third dropped out of the race last week. The contest, after months of being largely conducted virtually through online forums and fund-raisers, has shifted to a more normal pace, with candidates hitting the campaign trail in earnest last week.

Two of Andrew Yang's opponents in New York City's mayoral race suggested Yang cheated on a pop quiz during a New York Times editorial board interview. The Times directed all of the candidates to be in a room alone during their interviews over Google Meet, without any aides present or on the call. A spokesperson for Yang denied the claim that Yang cheated on the quiz. This comes as the primary race is heating up and the candidates prepare to participate in their first televised, virtual debate on Thursday night.

New York voters will be able rank up to five candidates in order of preference, rather than choosing just one. If no candidate receives more than 50% of the votes in the first round (as seems nearly certain), then the last-place candidate is eliminated and the second choices of voters who supported that person are reallocated to other candidates. That process continues until one candidate exceeds 50% and is declared the winner.

Proponents of ranked-choice voting or RCV, which was overwhelmingly approved by voters in 2019, argue that this system allows voters to support the candidate they most prefer rather than "wasting" a vote on a candidate with little chance of winning or strategically voting for a candidate with a better chance of victory. It also requires candidates to reach broader audiences rather than stay in their "lane," and is believed to discourage negative campaigning. But some candidates have raised concerns that the new system, absent a sustained effort at voter education, may disenfranchise voters of color and spark confusion at polling places. And, in a race like the crowded Democratic mayoral primary, a winner may not be determined for weeks.

Atlanta Mayor Keisha Lance Bottoms not seeking reelection

  Atlanta Mayor Keisha Lance Bottoms not seeking reelection In an open letter late Thursday, Keisha Lance Bottoms announced that she will not seek a second term as Atlanta mayor.Bottoms, 51, announced she would not run for reelection during a private call, the Atlanta Journal-Constitution reported. A short time after reports broke Thursday evening, she later confirmed her intentionswith an open letter shared on Twitter and dearatl.com.

The New York City Mayoral Race Has Been Weird. Here’s What You Need to Know. Andrew Yang is leading the pack in the Democratic primary, but anything can happen with less than two months to go until the election. Yang has commanded the bulk of the media’s attention since bursting into the race behind a sweeping, Darren Aronofsky-directed campaign trailer, and he has continued to cavort through the city trying to sell himself as a real New Yorker who has what it takes to liven up the city after one of the most depressing years in its history.

( New Hampshire voters are not in this group; they will vote on paper ballots, some of which are counted in optical scanners.) The same ratio is expected to hold when Americans choose their president in the fall. It is a very large chunk of the electorate. NEW VOTING TECHNOLOGIES tend to emerge out of crises of confidence. We change systems only rarely and in response to a public anxiety that electoral results can no longer be trusted. America voted on paper in the 19th century, until ballot-box stuffing — and inept poll workers who lost bags of votes — led many to abandon that system .

"The New York City Board of Elections is not the most well-functioning organization. So the challenge with ranked-choice voting is that there needs to be some kind of centralized vote-counting operation," David C. Kimball, a political science professor at the University of  Missouri-St. Louis, said in an interview with Salon. "In San Francisco, which is the next biggest city that uses ranked-choice voting for elections, it can take them up to a week — but they've been doing this now for almost 20 years. You've got a lot of candidates running for mayor in New York, so it's going to take several rounds of re-tabulation."

New York's elections have long been messy, most recently with more than 20% of mail-in ballots disqualified in last year's presidential primary. And they often generate remarkably little interest, especially in primary campaigns, even though general elections are increasingly becoming afterthoughts in the Democratic-dominated city. Less than 25% of Democratic voters turned out for the primary that effectively re-elected Mayor Bill de Blasio four years ago, and that was one of the better turnouts the city has seen. Part of that is by design. New York's elections are held in off-year cycles, which in itself tends to depress turnout by about 50%, and party registration deadlines often prevent newly interested voters from participating in the process at all. This year, the primary has also been moved up by three months, from September to June.

Advocates sound alarm as restrictive voting laws pile up

  Advocates sound alarm as restrictive voting laws pile up Voting advocates say that the urgency and need for federal oversight of state voting procedures - a Democratic legislative priority - has increased as Florida became the latest state this week to implement new voting restrictions and multiple other states are on the precipice of doing the same.Florida was the latest state to sign into law new voting restrictions, with Gov. Ron DeSantis (R) giving S.B. 90 his stamp of approval Thursday morning. With complete control of the Sunshine State's legislature, Republican lawmakers were able to fast-track the omnibus bill to DeSantis's desk despite opposition from civil rights groups and all 67 of Florida county supervisors of el

Credit The New York Times Archives. Occasionally the digitization process introduces transcription errors or other problems; we are continuing to work to improve these archived versions. There are three rules to running for mayor of Chicago. Unfortunately, no one knows what they are. So this week with the campaign already well under way but its form and direction far from clear, more than a half-dozen hopeful men and women are seriously scrambling around the nation's third-largest city, organizing their own campaigns and their own sets of rules.

That’s an increase of nearly 4000%, and we’re barely into the second quarter of 2021 (versus the entire year of 2020). Less than half of the US population has been vaccinated so far, which means as that number increases, the deaths will increase, too. If this trend continues, we are likely to see somewhere between 12,000, – 15,000 post-vaccine deaths reported to the VAERS system by the end of calendar 2021. Here’s the VAERS data captured on May 6th, 2021, when searching for “death” following vaccination: Informed medical observers note that VAERS only captures anywhere from 1% to 10% of

"I do not expect to see lots of voter turnout," David Birdsell, dean of the school of public affairs at Baruch College, told Salon. "You still see most New Yorkers reporting that they're not terribly engaged with the election, and that's no surprise" in a situation where many ordinary people are confronting "literally matters of life and death."

Birdsell added that "there's just so much distraction" surrounding this year's mayoral campaign, including "the unusual point in the calendar. It cannot be overstated how bad it is for turnout to keep moving the election season. It deprives people of the chance to get accustomed to voting in a particular place at a particular time. It's going to have a depressing effect, and the lack of attention that people are paying in the campaign bodes ill for a turnout surge."

Voters dealing with the coronavirus pandemic, economic recovery and political fallout from the presidential election have so far shown little interest in the mayoral race in America's largest city. Former Democratic presidential candidate Andrew Yang, who has pitched himself as something of a cheerleader for the city, has dominated headlines, likely because he is the only one of the eight top-tier candidates with name recognition above 50%, according to a recent Ipsos poll. Even among likely Democratic voters, only Yang, Brooklyn Borough President Eric Adams and New York City Comptroller Scott Stringer have name recognition above 50%.

Meet Dianne Morales, the NYC mayoral candidate campaigning on 'defund the police'

  Meet Dianne Morales, the NYC mayoral candidate campaigning on 'defund the police' In response to rival Eric Adams saying "defund the police" is pushed by young white people, Morales called the move a "dog whistle" and "wedge issue."The backdrop was fitting for the rollout of her "economic justice" plan on Tuesday, but something was off.

As a result of the anemic level interest, many voters are not even aware that the city has a new voting method. City officials have launched a $15 million campaign this month to educate voters about the new ballots, but both candidates and lawmakers have raised concerns that the abrupt rollout of a new system may effectively disenfranchise Black and Latino voters.

Six members of the New York City Council and numerous advocacy groups filed a lawsuit last year arguing that the new system is stacked against minority voters and that the coronavirus pandemic has hampered voter education efforts.

"Physical and fiscal limitations resulting from the pandemic have severely hindered the City's ability to put the new system into effect and prevent the disenfranchisement of New Yorkers of color, seniors, and limited English speakers," the lawmakers said in a statement last year.

"I believe there is an impossibility to educate people in the amount of time necessary on what ranked-choice voting will mean," Council Majority Leader Laurie Cumbo, one of the lawmakers who joined the suit, said at a hearing in December.

The New York Supreme Court rejected the complaint. The group of lawmakers filed another lawsuit arguing that the Board of Elections had not properly prepared voters for the new system but a judge rejected that suit last week, ruling that it was filed too late and that delaying the implementation of the new system would result in confusion.

Who Won the First NYC Mayoral Debate?

  Who Won the First NYC Mayoral Debate? Several candidates and one pivotal issue managed to rise above the Zoom grid.Playing it overly safe on the pandemic led to a much tamer evening than Democratic voters were used to from the war of attrition and crosstalk known as the 2020 presidential primary. (The format also allowed us to learn a bit about the politicians’ apartments: According to her bookshelf, Dianne Morales likes N.K. Jemisin and Octavia E. Butler, while Shaun Donovan called in from a kitchen that looks a whole lot nicer than $100,000.

Two of the Black candidates in the mayoral race have warned that the new system is being rushed.

"Eric Adams is deeply concerned that ranked choice voting will disenfranchise voters of color," Madia Coleman, a spokesperson for Adams, said in a statement to Salon. "The election is a month away and a number of voters do not know what ranked choice voting is or how to navigate it. The city's efforts to educate voters on ranked choice voting has not been sufficient, and it has failed to translate that education into the many different languages that New Yorkers speak. The Adams campaign has made it a mission to perform voter education on ranked choice voting in conjunction with the campaign's voter outreach."

Ray McGuire, a former Citigroup executive, has also said he is worried about the potential impact on voters of color. "Ray is still concerned about the implementation of RCV," Lupe Todd-Medina, a spokesperson for Ray McGuire, said in a statement to Salon. "This major change requires education and understanding across the board to all New Yorkers. This is why Ray has incorporated voter education around RCV into every aspect of this campaign, including in our digital and arming volunteers with information to share on the phone and on the doors. Ray was encouraged to see the mayor recently invest more funding towards educating voters on the new process but with six weeks left till a major citywide election, it should have been done much sooner."

Activists have also sounded the alarm.

"Some progressive white folks got together in a room and thought this would be good, but it's not good for our community," Hazel Dukes, president of the New York state chapter of the NAACP, told The New York Times.

Andrew Yang accuses rival NYC mayoral candidate Eric Adams of ‘assault’ on campaign finance system

  Andrew Yang accuses rival NYC mayoral candidate Eric Adams of ‘assault’ on campaign finance system "New York, Eric Adams took your taxpayer dollars and used them to amplify special interests here in New York City that did not need it," Yang fumed at a Tuesday press conference.Brooklyn Borough President Eric Adams came under attack from rival mayoral candidate Andrew Yang over alleged campaign finance improprieties on Tuesday.

Kirsten John Foy, president of the advocacy group Arc of Justice, also appeared to question the motives of ranked-choice advocates. "The primary argument for ranked-choice voting is that it expands access to elected office for Black and brown officials, but we don't have that problem," she said last year. "This is a solution in search of a problem."

But Bertha Lewis, president of the Black Institute, argued at the time that there was "plenty of time for voters to learn to rank their vote."

"Let me say it plainly: Black voters are not stupid," she testified during a city council meeting last year. "It is insulting to say that they will not be able to understand."

Maya Wiley, a former lawyer for the de Blasio administration and one of the other Black candidates in the race, has backed the system, arguing that the runoff elections previously used in the city dilute the votes of people of color, according to the Times.

"What the record suggests in other jurisdictions that have tried this," Birdsell said, "is that you're going to wind up with about half of the electorate familiar with the process, or who at least have heard of the process and know what to expect, even if they've never experienced it themselves before. The other half learn about it when they actually get to the polling place. People generally respond favorably to ranked-choice voting once they have been through the process. The record is mixed on whether they feel it makes their voices heard better than a single vote may, but some of that depends on the political dynamics."

Research on whether ranked-choice voting negatively affects voters of color has been mixed as well. A report released by the nonpartisan voting rights group FairVote on Wednesday found that it may benefit candidates of color because winning candidates of color "grew their vote totals between the first and final ballot rounds at a higher rate than winning White candidates." It also found that voters of color tend to rank more candidates than white voters.

Shaun Donovan gets ‘coveted’ second-place nod for NYC mayor from Bronx rep. Fernando Cabrera

  Shaun Donovan gets ‘coveted’ second-place nod for NYC mayor from Bronx rep. Fernando Cabrera “I ranked him second, but look, that’s very significant,” Bronx Borough President candidate Fernando Cabrera told the Daily News. “It really does matter … they’re all fighting for number two. “This is not politics as usual,” continued Cabrera. “The two’s and the three’s and the fours do matter. You look at the polls, and nobody’s reached 30%. Everybody’s fighting for those number two’s to be in that range.”Asked if a first choice matters more, Cabrera responded: “In ranked-choice, it matters, one and two.

"Ranked-choice voting does encourage more candidates to run for local office," Kimball said. "Sometimes that's a challenge, to get people to run for local office, and it seems to me to produce more women and candidates of color — and to some degree more success in winning seats." But research has been limited, he added, and the trends observed so far have only been identified in city council races, not mayoral ones.

A study by Craig Burnett, a political science professor at Hofstra University, came up with different results. He found that voters in Black and Latino neighborhoods in San Francisco and Oakland were more likely to rank just one candidate, while voters in white neighborhoods were more likely to use every available choice.

"Ranked-choice voting has the potential to harm minority representation," Burnett told Salon. "In my own research, I've seen an increase in the percentage of incomplete ballots — that is, they select fewer options than the ballot allows — in majority-minority voting precincts. In those contests, however, there was 'no harm' because exhaustion rates were at least as low as other voting groups."

A 2016 study by Jason McDaniel, a political science professor at San Francisco State University, found that voter turnout declined among Black and Asian voters after the implementation of ranked-choice voting and that "RCV increased disparities in turnout between groups who are more likely to vote and those who are less likely to vote. The conclusion is that RCV tends to exacerbate differences between sophisticated voters and those that are less sophisticated."

Dianne Morales, a former public school teacher and nonprofit executive who is viewed as the most progressive of the major mayoral candidates this year, has repeatedly expressed concerns about the city's efforts to educate voters about the new system.

"It is a shame that the city is not doing more to educate the public on ranked-choice voting," Bradley Stein, a spokesperson for Morales, said in a statement to Salon. "It is almost entirely contingent on campaigns to educate voters on how to use the new system. Luckily, polls so far indicate that voters find RCV easy to understand when filling out a sample ballot. Still, the city must ensure that poll workers are properly instructed in RCV and actively help voters on Election Day to make sure they know and understand how to properly fill out their ballots."

Stein said that without voter education and voter registration efforts "it is unlikely that RCV alone will attract voters to participate in the election." But Morales' campaign has praised the ranked-choice system and Stein said its efforts have "always taken into account how RCV will change the political landscape of this election cycle."

"RCV puts power back in the hands of people and makes it possible for non-establishment, grassroots campaigns to have a shot at winning municipal elections," Stein said. "While our primary focus is getting voters to rank Dianne first, we fiercely encourage voters who are set in their first choice to mark Dianne second on their ballot. Additionally, until May our campaign's voter outreach strategy was centered around educating New Yorkers about ranked-choice voting, in addition to Dianne's background and platform."

RCV can also help cities run smoother and less expensive elections, as compared to holding a runoff if no candidate wins a majority.

"It's a huge advantage, whether you're talking turnout, whether you're talking about election management in a time of pandemic, whether you're talking about public safety, to be able to do this all in one action rather than mounting those actions," Birdsell said. "Every time you can make elections easier, less taxing, literally and figuratively citizen-friendly, you have better results at the end of the day."

Ranked-choice voting also tends to disfavor "polarizing" candidates, he said, because they are unlikely to appear as second or third choices among voters who don't already support them.

"That's not to say that bland, approachable, mild-mannered candidates are always going to do well in these environments, but people who have relatively lower negatives with decent name recognition are disproportionately poised to benefit from RCV," he said.

It's not at all clear whether any of the candidates in the Democratic mayoral race fit that bill. The three apparent leaders have all been polarizing personalities on the campaign trail.

Yang, who gained national attention with his universal basic income proposal in the presidential primary, has never held political office or even voted in a New York City election. Multiple of his opponents have compared him to Donald Trump, a comparison Yang has not welcomed. More recently, The New York Times highlighted Yang's nonprofit group Venture for America, which raised tens of millions to create 100,000 jobs in struggling cities and earned Yang recognition from the Obama administration, but ultimately created just 150 jobs. He also drew intra-party criticism this week after issuing a tweet backing Israel in its latest clash with Palestinians, though he later issued a statement admitting he "failed to acknowledge pain on both sides."

Yang has also faced questions over his ties to Bradley Tusk, an ally of billionaire former Mayor Michael Bloomberg who has worked as a venture capitalist and political strategist for corporations like Uber and AT&T. Even Yang's allies, like Rep. Ritchie Torres, D-N.Y., who endorsed his candidacy, view him as a political blank slate they can shape "on every issue." As a result, some are worried that in Yang, Tusk has "a vessel potentially for his own interests, whether it's Uber, cryptocurrency, or gambling," wrote New York Magazine's Clare Malone.

Adams moved ahead of Yang for the first time in a recent poll but the former Republican and longtime police officer has drawn scrutiny for his decades in New York politics and his support from real estate developers, who have long been blamed for pushing out the city's working class and jacking up the cost of living. As borough president in Brooklyn, Adams drew allegations of corruption by using his nonprofit to skirt campaign finance rules and raise tens of thousands of dollars from donors with business before the city, The New York Daily News reported in 2019.

Stringer, who has spent even more time in New York politics and is generally viewed as a progressive, has been among the top three in polls for months. But his campaign was rocked last month by a sexual misconduct allegation by lobbyist Jean Kim, who volunteered for one of his political campaigns two decades ago. Kim alleged that Stringer in 2001 made unwanted advances and forcibly kissed her on several occasions. Stringer has denied the misconduct claim, insisting that the two had a consensual relationship. That did not stop such progressive-oriented groups as the Working Families Party and Sunrise Movement from retracting their endorsements.

It seems conceivable that Stringer's standing in the race while that of Kathryn Garcia, the former city sanitation commissioner, interim Housing Authority chief and COVID-19 "food czar," rises. Garcia landed the coveted New York Times endorsement this week but has yet to gain any visible traction in opinion polls.

"I'm generally skeptical that endorsements make a great deal of difference," Birdsell said. "But with five weeks of dash to the finish, he speculated, the Times endorsement could propel a low name-recognition candidate like Garcia.

It's unclear how endorsements will affect a race where most of the candidates are largely unknown to the electorate. Some groups have endorsed multiple candidates for the ranked-choice ballot. The Working Families Party is backing both Wiley and Morales, who is running on an ambitious platform of expanding low-income housing, providing a guaranteed income for the poor, desegregating schools, and cutting the police budget in half.

"We have two women candidates driving the progressive agenda in this race," Sochie Nnaemeka, director of the New York Working Families Party, said in a statement to Salon, "and we recognize how strategically important it is for New Yorkers to rank Dianne Morales and Maya Wiley as their top two choices to stop a Wall Street-funded candidate from buying the election," an apparent reference to Ray McGuire and Shaun Donovan, discussed below.

"There's no doubt that we're in a new era of voting, and people are excited when they learn about the new changes. The city must do everything in its power to educate voters on the process ahead of the primary," Nnaemeka added. "The WFP and our candidates are committed to educating voters so that people are fully prepared when they cast their ballots. Voter education is essential to making sure the reform delivers on its promise of an inclusive democracy."

Very little money spent by the campaigns to date, with the exceptions of McGuire and former HUD Secretary Shaun Donovan, whose run has largely been bankrolled by his wealthy father. Both were widely derided this week after guessing in separate interviews that the median home price in Brooklyn was between $80,000 and $100,000, when the real figure is around $900,000.

Until a few days ago, McGuire and Donovan had been the only candidates to spend money on television ads. "So many of these campaigns have gotten off to at dangerously late start," Birdsell said. "Everybody seems to be holding on to their money, with precious few exceptions."

The campaign has obviously also been upended by the coronavirus pandemic, which may have contributed to the lack of media attention, visibility or any tangible sense of momentum.

"Clearly, this is an unusual election," Birdsell said. "People have been campaigning in pandemic mode, which means very little in the way of retail face-to-face campaigning. It means people aren't gathering, it means you aren't generating the kind of buzz from events that you might  in a more traditional campaign cycle."

All eight top-tier candidates faced off in the first mayoral debate on Thursday (after this article was finalized), which could lead to the first serious realignment of the field. No candidate has yet had a "breakthrough moment" or garnered serious national attention, all eyes will be on the new ranked-choice system on June 22.

New York joins at least 18 other municipalities that have already implemented or approved similar systems, and is by far the largest. (It only uses RCV in the party primaries, not the general election.) While RCV is primarily used in city elections, Maine has implemented ranked-choice voting for all state-level and congressional primaries and congressional general elections as well. (The population of Maine, however, is about 1.4 million, less than one-fifth the population of New York City.)

"Having bigger jurisdictions, more high-profile places using it, I think will prompt some other places to consider it," Kimball predicted. "I don't know if it'll open the floodgates or anything. But there does seem to be greater interest in RCV now that places like New York have adopted it."

Shaun Donovan gets ‘coveted’ second-place nod for NYC mayor from Bronx rep. Fernando Cabrera .
“I ranked him second, but look, that’s very significant,” Bronx Borough President candidate Fernando Cabrera told the Daily News. “It really does matter … they’re all fighting for number two. “This is not politics as usual,” continued Cabrera. “The two’s and the three’s and the fours do matter. You look at the polls, and nobody’s reached 30%. Everybody’s fighting for those number two’s to be in that range.”Asked if a first choice matters more, Cabrera responded: “In ranked-choice, it matters, one and two.

usr: 1
This is interesting!