Politics The rule allowing predatory loans from fake lenders must go now
West Virginia governor sues bank in latest twist for his biz
CHARLESTON, W.Va. (AP) — West Virginia Gov. Jim Justice and his companies are suing another bank lender, the latest trouble for his business empire after he revealed he is personally liable for $700 million in loans to a separate lender. © Provided by Associated Press FILE - In this Wednesday, Jan. 8, 2020, file photo, West Virginia Governor Jim Justice delivers his annual State of the State address in the House Chambers at the state capitol, in Charleston, W.Va. Gov.
In an era where bipartisan agreement is rare, , three Republicans voted with all Senate Democrats on a resolution under the (CRA) to overturn a rule finalized last year by the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency (OCC) that protects predatory lenders that evade state interest rate laws. The House of Representatives should follow suit and do so quickly; the rule is doing active harm to , and consumers who are facing 200 percent APR loans that are in nearly every state.
The OCC's so-called allows nonbank lenders to disguise their loans as bank loans - exempt from state rate caps and able to charge sky-high interest rates without limit - merely by finding a rogue bank to list as the lender. Payday lenders first tried these "rent-a-bank schemes" . But courts, , looked at the facts and followed the money to find the "true lender" that was running and profiting from the loan program. The OCC rule overturns the true lender doctrine and prevents courts from looking past the fake lender listed in the fine print.
West Virginia gov: Bank deceived family for loan guarantee
In a new court filing, West Virginia Gov. Jim Justice blamed a bankrupt U.K. bank for fraudulently inducing him into personally guaranteeing $700 million in loans that were taken out by his companies. © Provided by Associated Press FILE - In this Wednesday, Jan. 8, 2020, file photo, West Virginia Governor Jim Justice delivers his annual State of the State address in the House Chambers at the state capitol, in Charleston, W.Va. Gov. Justice confirmed on Tuesday, June 1, 2021, that he is personally liable for $700 million in loans taken by his coal companies from a lender in the United Kingdom that went bankrupt.
The fake lender rule is being used right now to defend destructive loans. Restaurant owners that are fighting a 268 percent APR loan secured by property now in foreclosure are being met with the argument that the rule permits that rate despite New Jersey's .
Another nonbank lender recently invoked the rule to defend a in California, where the legal rate is 24 percent. The lender that the fake lender rule was "consistent with" a discredited, older decision that allowed a payday lender that owned a 95 percent share of a loan to evade state law since a bank with an insignificant role was identified as the lender.
The "fake lender" rule is emboldening a growing wave of rent-a-bank schemes. are installment loans in the thousands of dollars at and exceeding 200 percent APR - a . These predatory lenders target the financially vulnerable and and trap consumers in. Rent-a-bank lenders are even flouting - which explains why the Republican attorneys general of Arkansas, Nebraska and South Dakota overturning the rule.
Turtle power, lotto mania, slaughterhouse strike: News from around our 50 states
How the COVID-19 pandemic is affecting every stateStart the day smarter. Get all the news you need in your inbox each morning.
A CRA vote would eliminate the harm from the fake lender rule immediately. Small businesses, veterans and consumers trying to recover from the COVID-19 economic crisis cannot wait years for an uncertain rulemaking by the OCC. This urgency explains why a large, bipartisan coalition of , , , , , and consumer, veterans, small business, disability rights, human rights, labor and civil rights groups support the CRA resolution.
The CRA, which prohibits judicial review, gives the OCC more protection from litigation than regular rulemaking, which could be challenged as arbitrary and capricious. A CRA vote the OCC from revisiting the subject of the rule; the Trump administration reissued rules after . But a benefit of the CRA is that it prevents a "substantially the same" rule that protects state law evasions by predatory lenders.
Why Senate Democrats reversed few of Trump's 'midnight rules'
The inaction disappointed some progressive advocates, who had urged Democrats in Congress to strike the Trump-era rules as quickly as possible. "It's disappointing because it's so important," said Sasha Buchert, a senior attorney for Lambda Legal, a civil rights advocacy organization focused on LGBTQ issues. The group had pushed Congress to undo a Trump-era rule allowing social services providers receiving federal funds to discriminate based on sexual orientation and gender identity, but lawmakers did not act in time to reverse it immediately.
Responsible fintech-bank partnerships that are not designed to evade the law do not need the OCC's crude rule. The vast majority of these partnerships are not even covered by the rule, which does not apply to state-chartered banks. Sen. Cynthia Lummis (R-Wyo.), a founder of the , voted for the CRA, that the rule creates an unlevel playing field that disadvantages state banks. Caucus cofounder Sen. Kyrsten Sinema (D-Ariz.) also voted for the CRA.
Proponents of the rule also conflate it with the OCC's so-called "" rule. Overturning the former has no impact on the latter or on the question of what interest rate laws apply to debt buyers or other non bank assignees of actual bank loans (though the valid-when-made rule ).
The Pollyannaish claims made to defend the fake lender rule pale in the face of the of predatory rent-a-bank schemes and use of the OCC rule to defend them. States have had the to protect their residents since the founding of this country, but that power is now seriously at risk. Defending the power of states to enforce their own laws is not a partisan issue. The OCC fake lender rule must go. Now.
Lauren Saunders is the associate director of the National Consumer Law Center focusing on safe banking.
MLB updates COVID protocols for vaccinated players, staff .
Most notably, fully vaccinated individuals will no longer be tested for COVID-19 unless they have symptoms or have been exposed to the virus. © Omar Ornelas via Imagn Content Services, LLC The handling of fully vaccinated individuals drew some attention last month after Nationals starter Erick Fedde tested positive for the coronavirus. Fedde, who had been fully vaccinated and was asymptomatic, was forced to go on the injured list. (Between his initial isolation period and subsequent rehab, he ultimately missed just more than three weeks of action.