Politics 9/11 and US-China policy: The geopolitics of distraction

18:35  14 september  2021
18:35  14 september  2021 Source:   thehill.com

Advocates fear US weighing climate vs. human rights on China

  Advocates fear US weighing climate vs. human rights on China U.S. envoy John Kerry’s diplomatic quest to stave off the worst scenarios of global warming is meeting resistance from China, the world's biggest climate polluter, which is adamant that the United States ease confrontation over other matters if it wants Beijing to speed up its climate efforts. Rights advocates and Republican lawmakers say they see signs, including softer language and talk of heated internal debate among Biden administration officials, that China’s pressure is leading the United States to back off on criticism of China’s mass detentions, forced sterilization and other abuses of its predominantly Muslim Uyghur minority in the Xinjiang region.

On Sept. 10, 2001, the United States and China were heading into an increasingly confrontational relationship. After eight years of Bill Clinton's accommodationist policies toward China, George W. Bush had campaigned on taking a tougher, more realistic approach. It was time for Washington to dispense with its policy of strategic ambiguity and declare unequivocally America's intention to defend Taiwan against Chinese aggression.

Xi Jinping et al. sitting on a bench in a suit and tie: 9/11 and US-China policy: The geopolitics of distraction © Getty Images 9/11 and US-China policy: The geopolitics of distraction

During the presidential debate in March 2000, Bush warned: "If [China decides] to use force, the United States must help Taiwan defend itself. Now, the Chinese can figure out what that means, but that's going to mean a resolute stand on my part." Bush's secretary of defense, Donald Rumsfeld, and Paul Wolfowitz, Rumsfeld's deputy, also had been outspoken in calling for strategic clarity on Taiwan.

As China woos the Taliban, Uyghurs in Afghanistan fear for their lives

  As China woos the Taliban, Uyghurs in Afghanistan fear for their lives Uyghurs in Afghanistan are caught between a homeland where they are facing increasing repression, and an adopted country where they are considered outsiders. What worries them most is that they could be deported to China. Over the past few years, the Chinese government has escalated its security and religious crackdown in Xinjiang. Up to 2 million Uyghurs and other Muslim minorities are believed to have passed through a sprawling network of detention centers across the region, according to the US State Department. © Courtesy Tuhan Tuhan and her family have lived in Afghanistan for decades.

On April 1, 2001, over the South China Sea, a Chinese fighter jet harassed and collided with an unarmed, slow-moving U.S. EP-3 reconnaissance plane, causing the Chinese pilot to crash and die while the badly damaged U.S. aircraft made an emergency landing on the Chinese island of Hainan. China harshly blamed the incident entirely on the Americans, ransacked the plane and its highly secret equipment, and confined and repeatedly interrogated the crew of 24 men and women over 11 days, initially denying them communications with families or U.S. officials. Beijing refused the U.S. ambassador's repeated efforts to avoid escalation of the crisis, and extracted two public apologies from Washington before agreeing to release the crew.

China's zero-Covid policy: An infected 4-year-old separated from his parents highlights its human cost

  China's zero-Covid policy: An infected 4-year-old separated from his parents highlights its human cost Covered from head to toe in a white hazmat suit, a small child carrying a backpack half the size of his body toddles down a hospital corridor and arrives at a CT scan room -- all by himself. © From Sohu.com "A 4-year-old boy has been infected (with Covid-19), unfortunately," a caption in the video reads. "No accompanying parents. Going to quarantine alone."The scene, captured by a nurse at a quarantine hospital in the city of Putian, the epicenter of China's latest Delta variant outbreak, gripped millions of people when it went viral on Chinese social media this week.

Though the plane was repairable and could be flown out of Hainan, the Chinese insisted that it be dismantled and shipped out in crates to increase U.S. humiliation. Russian cargo planes carried out the removal in mid-June.

Two weeks after the crew's release, while denying any link to the EP-3 incident, the Bush administration touted the largest arms sale package to Taiwan since 1992, including destroyers, submarines, helicopters and other military hardware Clinton had denied Taiwan. It hinted at sales of even more advanced weapons, such as Aegis-equipped destroyers, depending on the threat from China. Bush also pledged to end the annual review process and consider Taiwan's arms requests on an "as-needed basis."

In an ABC interview the next day, Bush was asked whether Washington had an obligation to defend Taiwan against a Chinese attack. He answered, "Yes, we do ... and the Chinese must understand that." Pressed if that meant he would use "the full force of the American military," Bush said, "Whatever it took to help Taiwan defend herself."

Exclusive: Legalized by Trump, Uyghur Separatists See Biden as Ally in Fight Against China

  Exclusive: Legalized by Trump, Uyghur Separatists See Biden as Ally in Fight Against China "We hope that not only the U.S. government but also all countries and all people will take action against the Chinese government," a Turkestan Islamic Party spokesperson told Newsweek.As the 20th anniversary of 9/11 passed Saturday, the lingering blowback of the unprecedented attacks remains with the United States in a myriad of ongoing measures adopted in tandem with the still-raging "war on terror.

The remarks caused immediate ripples in the foreign policy establishment, including among some in his administration who rushed to issue the usual assurances of unchanged U.S. policy on China and Taiwan.

A few hours later, Bush gave a CNN interview and was asked about his willingness to commit military forces to defend Taiwan: "What if Taiwan declared independence first?"

Bush replied: "First, I have said that I will do what it takes to help Taiwan defend herself under the 1979 Taiwan Relations Act, and the Chinese must understand that. Secondly, I certainly hope Taiwan adheres to the One China policy. And a declaration of independence is not the One China policy, and we will work with Taiwan to make sure that that doesn't happen. We need a peaceful resolution of this issue."

The tone may have softened, but Bush had given a clear warning about his administration's priorities, and the threat from Communist China was now at the top of the list.

The Sept. 11 attacks suddenly changed all that by overwhelming and diverting the West's attention to a newly-perceived existential danger. Beijing eagerly enlisted in the War on Terror that had conveniently supplanted the China threat and, without making any significant contribution to the broad global effort, perverted it for its purposes into a war on Uyghurs.

Could climate change finally expose China as a global outlaw?

  Could climate change finally expose China as a global outlaw? While other countries may worry about the planet's survival, Beijing’s priority is the survival of the Chinese Communist Party. In May, Kurt Campbell, who manages the China portfolio for Sullivan at the National Security Council, said the period of Chinese engagement, which he advocated for decades, had "come to an end. ... The dominant paradigm between China and the U.S. would now be one of competition."China's foreign ministry spokesman Zhao Lijian responded that it was "completely wrong" for Washington to define the bilateral relationship as competitive and said Beijing "firmly rejected the U.S.

It also exploited the next two decades of relative Western inattention. Beijing consolidated its internal control by developing its economic and military resources, while extending its geostrategic reach. All the while, it posed as the West's good-faith negotiating partner and responsible stakeholder on nuclear, chemical and biological weapons proliferation generally, and North Korea specifically; on climate change; and most recently, on the pandemic.

As Washington and other Western capitals struggled to cope with China's multi-dimensional challenges to the international order, Beijing mastered the practice of geopolitical distraction, playing off one critical issue against another.

Unfair trade practices, currency manipulation, theft of intellectual property, human rights violations, threats against Taiwan, maritime and territorial aggression in the East and South China Seas, and the ever-useful trump card of nuclear North Korea, served as competing priorities for an often confused and floundering West.

The Biden administration - populated by people, including Biden, who previously had been burned by China's deception and duplicity - thought it had created an effective counter to Beijing's hydra-headed strategic challenge: policy compartmentalization. As Secretary of State Antony Blinken put it, issues would be bundled into roughly three categories: cooperation, competition, and confrontation or adversarial.

Why the US should offer to buy France's submarines for Vietnam

  Why the US should offer to buy France's submarines for Vietnam The U.S. would achieve three objectives by purchasing a number of Shortfin Barracuda submarines from France and then giving them to Vietnam. © Provided by Washington Examiner U.S. Vice President Kamala Harris attends the official launch of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention Southeast Asia regional office in Hanoi, Vietnam, Wednesday, Aug. 25, 2021. First, the Biden administration would repair relations with America's oldest ally. Second, it would supply a rising security partner with newly potent means of challenging China's imperialism.

To avoid having the entire U.S.-China relationship disintegrate into a new cold war standoff, Washington and Beijing would collaborate on areas of supposed mutual concern - climate change, the pandemic, proliferation. Those existential challenges would not be sacrificed to areas where Chinese ambitions inevitably collide with Western interests and values - genocide in Xinjiang, cultural genocide in Tibet, repression in Hong Kong, and aggression against Taiwan and in the South and East China Seas.

But Beijing has emphatically and repeatedly rejected issue separation as a nonstarter: cooperation on climate change or other shared concerns is unacceptable, it says, while Washington persists in "defaming" and "containing" China.

After Deputy Secretary of State Wendy Sherman and climate czar John Kerry were rudely dismissed during their recent visits, Biden decided to take the damage control mission into his own experienced hands by placing a 90-minute phone call to Chinese leader Xi Jinping. After all, he boasted during the presidential campaign, he had met often as vice president with China's emperor-designate: "I know him well and he knows me well." The first part of Biden's claim is in some doubt; the second part is true but ominous, especially after Biden's disastrous performance regarding Afghanistan.

There is ample reason to worry about which American interests will be surrendered or undermined by Biden's desire to return to the more congenial Clinton, later Bush, and Obama years. Given the loss of U.S. credibility from America's callous and inept end to the 20-year Afghanistan distraction, he would be better advised to revive the early, pre-9/11 Bush approach of strategic clarity with China.

Joseph Bosco served as China country director for the secretary of Defense from 2005 to 2006 and as Asia-Pacific director of humanitarian assistance and disaster relief from 2009 to 2010. He is a nonresident fellow at the Institute for Corean-American Studies and a member of the advisory board of the Global Taiwan Institute. Follow him on Twitter @BoscoJosephA.

Evergrande debt crisis: 5 things to know about the Chinese business empire on the brink .
The troubles of Chinese conglomerate Evergrande have dominated headlines in recent days after it warned once again that it could default on its astronomical debt because of a cash crunch. © JADE GAO/AFP/Getty Images A woman riding a scooter past the construction site of an Evergrande housing complex in Zhumadian, Henan province on Sept. 14, 2021. Experts have characterized the firm's struggles as a major test for Beijing that risks turning into China's Lehman Brothers moment, sending shockwaves across the world's second biggest economy.

usr: 4
This is interesting!