Politics Mexico's internally displaced are an unrecognized migration crisis
Mexico displays pre-Hispanic artifacts recovered from abroad
MEXICO CITY (AP) — Two Mexican museums have opened a massive show this week of 1,525 pre-Hispanic and historical artifacts, more than half of which were recovered from abroad. Mexico has long had a problem with collectors or traffickers taking artifacts out of the country, even though that has been illegal since 1972. But 881 of the sculptures, vessels and other artifacts on display in Mexico City were returned, either voluntarily by foreign collectors or through police seizures abroad. They were returned from the United States, Italy, France, Germany and the Netherlands.
Mostly known as a transit country and a major sender of migrants to the United States, Mexico is not typically considered a hotspot for internal displacement. However, Mexico contains an alarming number of internally displaced persons (IDPs), who have historically been overshadowed and under-recognized.
As of December 2020, there were in Mexico, primarily from Venezuela and Central America. Meanwhile, there are approximately in Mexico - over seven times the number of refugees - and a dramatic increase in comparison to 2009, when there were only 8,000.
Biden looks to repair frayed US-Mexico relationship
Nearly a year after the US Drug Enforcement Administration arrested a Mexican former defense minister and charged him with being a drug cartel boss, the Biden administration is deploying three Cabinet members and White House officials to Mexico to mend ties that are crucial for grappling with cross-border flows of migrants and drug and gun trafficking. © Nicholas Kamm/AFP/Getty Images US President Joe Biden gestures as he delivers remarks on the debt ceiling from the State Dining Room of the White House on October 4, 2021 in Washington, DC.
While a small number of these individuals are displaced due to the effects of climate change and natural disasters, the vast majority of Mexican IDPs are forced out of their homes due to stemming from organized crime groups fighting for control of lucrative territory. The state of Guerrero - rich in natural resources - for example, has the most IDPs in Mexico, and is referred to as the country's "" by the International Crisis Group.
Lockdowns from the COVID-19 pandemic escalated the conflict and tension between criminal organizations, and thus heightened internal displacement. For example, in Guerrero, were displaced by violence the first day after pandemic lockdown in March 2020.
Drugs, guns and money: US, Mexico step up cooperation against cross-border crime
Cooperation should help reduce the amounts of fentanyl, heroin and other lethal drugs moving into the U.S. and the firearms and money flowing from the U.S. into Mexico and increase criminal convictions. The U.S. also can provide specific support aimed at bolstering Mexican capacities in the process.Today's meeting follows the launch of a new U.S.-Mexico high-level economic dialogue, as well as closer cooperation on migration, including the surge of Haitian migrants, and on COVID-19 vaccinations.The tough law enforcement and justice work needed to weaken the criminal groups will take time.
Internal displacement creates for the victims in Mexico. Forced to uproot to a different community, IDPs face difficulty finding safe, affordable, alternative housing. If secure housing is unavailable, these individuals often end up staying in yet another unsafe location. Another challenge is securing employment in places where the labor market does not demand their skills. Some end up having to work for less money and with greater job instability. The integration of internally displaced, school-aged children is another hurdle. Schools are often insufficiently equipped to integrate new students who often require special educational and emotional support, which in turn increases the risk of these children dropping out.
Mexican IDPs are especially vulnerable as they do not fall under established international frameworks for refugee protection. Nonetheless, these individuals face the same threats and dangers as refugees.
Mexico's new culture war: Did a pyramid light show 'decolonize' or rewrite history?
Monument removals and a replica of the Templo Mayor pyramid infuriated critics, but can Mexico's populist government spark an Indigenous cultural renaissance?Throngs of locals and tourists showed up to watch the 15-minute history show. Vendors walked among the crowds selling Aztec-style souvenir headdresses with colored lights, filling the Zócalo with flashes of revelry.
According to the , it is the responsibility of the host government - in this case, Mexico - to address the forced internal displacement of its citizens. This makes it difficult for international humanitarian organizations to intervene in what is a domestic responsibility. Indeed, has been the only international organization to assist IDPs in Mexico.
The Mexican state has struggled to get a handle on violence and security, as the López Obrador administration pursues a with organized crime.
Mexico's national migration and refugee agencies - the National Institute of Migration and the Mexican Commission for Refugee Assistance, respectively - are heavily under-resourced, and under even greater strain as Mexico receives record-breaking numbers of applications of and . If the agencies are unable to effectively perform their primary function of processing incoming migrants, then they are even less able to provide support for Mexico's IDPs - who, until recently, were not nationally recognized as a vulnerable group in need of protection.
Mexico's domestic-minded foreign policy could alienate the US
It would be a mistake to suggest that López Obrador does not have a foreign policy or is not interested in the world beyond Mexico’s national borders.During the first two years of López Obrador's term, which coincided with the Trump administration, his foreign policy consisted mainly of collaborating with the United States on the renegotiation of NAFTA and cooperating to limit Central American migration to the United States in return for non-intervention in Mexico's domestic affairs. The policy seemed to have worked - the Trump administration took limited notice of policies such as López Obrador's efforts to reverse the 2013 energy reform despite its impact on U.S. investors.
, the federal government responded favorably to demands for humanitarian support by IDPs in Chichihualco, Guerrero by providing food and alternative housing. Nonetheless, it has failed to address insecurity or reduce conflict in Guerrero or other states, which are the root drivers of internal displacement.
There are, however, some positive signs. In September 2020, the lower house of Mexico's Congress passed the . Among its objectives, the law proposes to: Recognize and guarantee the rights of IDPs; assign responsibility among federal and municipal organizations to generate durable solutions; create a national mechanism to explicitly address forced internal displacement; and establish a national registry for IDPs. The legislation, however, has not been passed by the Senate. If adopted, it will provide concrete evidence of the López Obrador administration's commitment to take responsibility and implement the necessary protection frameworks. For it to be effective, however, implementation of the legislation will require resource commitments as well - a challenge under the president's policy of "".
Beyond recognizing internal displacement as a national issue, the practical implementation of the proposed legislation must take specific actions. Key actions would be providing opportunities to place IDPs into safe homes in host communities, connecting IDPs to gainful employment opportunities and supporting education institutions' efforts to better adapt to integrating displaced students and youth.
Mexico, US draw up outlines of new security framework
MEXICO CITY (AP) — High-level delegations from Mexico and the United States on Friday laid out the outlines of a new security framework between the nations that at least conceptually marked a departure from the mindset that steered their cooperation over the past decade. The so-called U.S.-Mexico Bicentennial Framework for Security, Public Health and Safe Communities seeks to move beyond the 13-year-old Merida Initiative that focused on building Mexico’s crime-fighting capabilities and rule of law projects.
Although the Mexican government holds the greatest legal responsibility, the private sector and international organizations can and should play a significant role as well.
As the northern neighbor, the United States should be concerned by the crisis of internal displacement in Mexico. The border closure from the pandemic lockdowns removed the U.S. outlet for Mexican IDPs escaping violence and conflict. However, as we emerge from the pandemic, and as the reopening of the shared border is discussed, vulnerable IDPs are likely to seek safer conditions in the U.S. And while the Mexican government is most responsible for addressing internal displacement, the U.S. can and should consider Mexican IDPs when formulating policy for migrants seeking protection outside of Mexico.
An established legal framework and international support will likely improve conditions for Mexican IDPs in the short term. However, the phenomena of internal displacement will continue to grow if the security conditions that drive it are not efficiently addressed.
Andrew I. Rudman is the director of the Mexico Institute at the Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars. A former Foreign Service officer and director of the Office of NAFTA and Inter-American Affairs at the Commerce Department, he has worked on Mexico and U.S.-Mexican relations throughout his public and private sector careers. Rudman collaborated with Rachel Scalisi, a graduate research intern at the Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars' Mexico Institute, to create this piece. Twitter: @AndrewIRudman
70 Years Since Geneva, Refugees Need Us More than Ever | Opinion .
EU member states should resettle 250,000 refugees by the end of 2025, starting with pledging at least 36,000 places in 2022. The U.S. should not only unlock funding to meet its current refugee admissions goal this year but should also double the cap for next year. Both the U.S. and EU should urge other wealthy nations to start or scale up their resettlement programs, spreading the load so more countries participate.