Politics The search for creative solutions to the thorniest issues in Biden's agenda as deadline pressure kicks into high gear
Biden to spend this week working behind the scenes to press Democrats on his sweeping domestic agenda
President Joe Biden has few public events on his schedule this week as he works behind the scenes to secure an agreement on his domestic agenda amid deep divisions within his party. © Drew Angerer/Getty Images WASHINGTON, DC - AUGUST 25: U.S. President Joe Biden speaks during a meeting about cybersecurity in the East Room of the White House on August 25, 2021 in Washington, DC. Members of the Biden cabinet, national security team and leaders from the private sector attended the meeting about improving the nation's cybersecurity.
There comes a point in every major legislativebut not close enough to
Significant portions are agreed to, even drafted into the text, but the outstanding issues are the most complex and in need of not just hardline negotiations, but often quite creative
This is, for lack of a more eloquent term, the grind-it-out stage of the process. The vast majority of the time it reaches an outcome. But it's painful, arduous and -- perhaps most importantly -- time consuming.
Biden sees American credibility on the line as he races to lock down climate action ahead of Glasgow
President Joe Biden wanted the stakes to be perfectly clear when he sat down with nine liberal Democrats in the Oval Office Tuesday to discuss ongoing legislative negotiations. © Al Drago/Pool/Getty Images WASHINGTON, DC - APRIL 22: U.S. President Joe Biden delivers remarks during a virtual Leaders Summit on Climate with 40 world leaders at the East Room of the White House April 22, 2021 in Washington, DC. President Biden pledged to cut greenhouse gas emissions by half by 2030.
For President Joe Biden and Democratic leaders who are sprinting toward a deadline just days away, that's a real problem.
The bottom line is Biden and Democratic leaders are still driving toward a framework agreement on aand climate package -- one substantive enough to clear the way for a vote on -- this week. The goal of mid-week seems unlikely at best, impossible at worst. But don't expect leaders to ease the pressure at this point, making this a crucial day in the push toward a deal.
To put a finer point on things
White House officials and congressional Democrats involved in the talks are fairly clear-eyed on the moment they're in right now. They know they're on the cusp -- "We're five yards out, maybe two yards, from the end zone," one person directly involved in the talks said. But reconciling the outstanding issues in the next 24-36 hours is, in the words of that official, "Obviously a heavy lift."
Big changes in White House ideas to pay for $2 trillion plan
SCRANTON, Pa. (AP) — In an abrupt change, the White House is floating new plans to pay for parts of President Joe Biden’s $2 trillion social services and climate change package, shelving a proposed big increase in corporate tax rates though also adding a new billionaires' tax on the investment gains of the very richest Americans. The reversal Wednesday came as Biden returned to his hometown of Scranton, Pennsylvania, to highlight the middle class values he says are at the heart of the package that Democrats are racing to finish. Biden faces resistance from key holdouts, including Sen. Kyrsten Sinema, D-Ariz.
Yet the combination of momentum and a sense of inevitability are, to a degree, key negotiating tactics in and of themselves -- and that's clearly the intent with Biden just 48 hours away from boarding Air Force One for Europe.
There is one clear outcome targeted by the White House and Democratic leaders at this moment: They want a detailed framework agreement locked in by the back half of this week. That would allow them to pass the infrastructure bill by Sunday -- the surface transportation funding patch deadline, the day before Biden arrives at the UN Climate Change Conference and a few days before Election Day in Virginia.
Biden and his top negotiators had a clear strategy for a period of weeks: intensive talks with key holdout Democraticand Kyrsten Sinema of Arizona. Beyond Speaker Nancy Pelosi, Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer and their policy teams, those talks were shrouded in secrecy.
LIVE! UFC Vegas 41 Results & Play-By-Play!
UFC Vegas 41 live stream results, play-by-play updates for the Paulo Costa vs. Marvin Vettori-led MMA event on Sat., Oct. 23, 2021, from inside UFC APEX in Las Vegas, Nevada, streaming live on ESPN+. Main event duties fall to top-ranked Middleweight combatants Paulo Costa (No. 2) and Marvin Vettori (No. 5), who collide in a 205-pound bout because “The Eraser” apparently doesn’t care about contracted weight limits (full details here). In UFC Vegas 41’s Lightweight co-main event, Grant Dawson looks to remain undefeated inside the Octagon when he locks horns with Rick Glenn. MMAmania.
When a combination of progress and time pressure created the opening, Biden pivoted hard last week to open the door to the process to a wider range of congressional Democrats, with pretty clear success.
But as critical programs and priorities are moving from scaled back to potentially out of the proposal all together, the need to ensure progressives stay on board is acute in this moment.
The broader pitch -- which progressive leaders have largely backed publicly -- has been that the proposal, even scaled back, is transformational and more than anyone could have ever hoped for prior to now. Take it and call it a win.
But the longer that things linger -- and the more proposals that Manchin or Sinema chop away at, as leaders push to close the deal -- the greater the risk becomes of defection or revolt.
And to be clear here, it doesn't need to be the entire Congressional Progressive Caucus, and a chunk of progressives in the Senate. It can be just three and zero. Biden can afford to lose three Democrats in the House. He can afford to lose zero in the Senate.
High wire. No net.
So what is the timeline?
It could take days to wrap this up. It could take weeks. The slim possibility this never happens is also still very much a concern and motivator right now.
The expectation among more than a dozen Democratic senators and staffers on Monday night was that it's more likely to be the former than the later at this point, but anyone who is in the know right now is aware it's not entirely clear how this gets resolved over the next 72 hours before the President leaves for his foreign trip. It's a new week with renewed optimism, but the same problems are still there.
What to watch Tuesday
- Senate Democratic closed-door caucus lunch at 12:30 p.m.
- Does Sinema actually
- Will Manchin come prepared to lay out publicly that his topline number has risen above $1.5 trillion?
- Will the Senate Finance Committee release the highly, highly anticipated details of
Moving in the right direction on taxes
and the top marginal rate on individuals was as they sought to put this package together. But, Democrats are growing more confident that a collection of other taxes like a tax on billionaires paired with a corporate minimum tax could be a sufficient replacement. There also seems to be widespread support for the idea of billionaires' tax -- at least in theory.
Democrats squabble, scramble to meet self-imposed deadline. Why this week is vital for Biden.
Democrats still differ over what to strip out of Biden's budget bill, which is likely to be much smaller than the initial $3.5 trillion Biden pitched.House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, D-Calif., earlier this month, set a new deadline of Oct. 31 for the House to pass a $1.2 trillion bipartisan infrastructure bill and achieve consensus on a bigger budget bill that includes a number of liberal policies like subsidizing child care and fighting climate change. .
The challenge will be unveiling this tax (Finance Committee staffers are confident they can do this by Wednesday) and then getting sign off from all 50 Democrats.
There are so many outstanding questions about that proposal at the moment -- and no clear sign they can be completely resolved in just a matter of days. Someone who has these questions? House Ways and Means Committee Chairman Richard Neal.
Asked if he believes the billionaires' tax would lead to a reliable amount of money to finance the proposal, he told reporters: "I don't know. That's one of the challenges you have with it. We think it will be a challenge."
He said he wasn't sure it would survive legal challenges, CNN's Manu Raju reported.
To be clear, Wyden's team has been working on this for roughly two years -- "hundreds, if not thousands of hours" drafting the proposal, Ashley Schapitl, the committee spokeswoman, has said.
To be even more clear, this is not a wealth tax, despite that being thrown around quite a bit these days. What it is, basically, is expanding an income tax to unrealized capital gains of a very specific subset of taxpayers. In this case, those with a $1 billion or more in assets or with reported income of over $100 million for three consecutive years.
Politically, in the words of one Democrat, "it's absolute gold" -- targeting roughly 700-800 billionaires and inviting Republicans to attack a policy that ... explicitly targets billionaires. Policy wise -- in the words of another Democrat -- due to its lack of precedent, "it could be transformative if we can make it work."
Biden announces 'historic' deal — but no action yet
WASHINGTON (AP) — President Joe Biden announced Thursday that he and Democrats in Congress have reached a “historic" framework for his sweeping domestic policy package. But he still needs to lock down votes from key colleagues for what's now a dramatically scaled-back bill. Eager to have a deal in hand before his departure late in the day for global summits, Biden made his case privately on Capitol Hill to House Democrats and publicly in a speech at the White House. He's now pressing for a still-robust package — $1.75 trillion of social services and climate change programs — that the White House believes can pass the 50-50 Senate.
It's the "if we can make it work" part that needs to be resolved right now, from enforcement, to implementation, to how to value more illiquid asset classes, to whether it's ripe for a challenge on constitutional grounds -- all are open questions that will need to be answered before it can move anywhere.
Prescription drug pricing
Democrats are still not giving up on their efforts to try and overhaul how the governmentThe original plan was a nonstarter for too many members, but a small group of senators is working on a proposal to index the price of a select number of drugs. The hope is that it could be a middle ground for people like Sinema and members who hail from states like New Jersey where the pharmaceutical industry is a top employer. Of all the issues up for discussion right now, this one is one of the trickiest for Democrats to navigate.
Paid family leave
The effort to convince Manchin that a robust leave policy is necessary? It's still firmly underway right now. The Democrats have launched a full court press on Manchin on this issue as CNN laid out last nightBut this is still a huge issue and one that would be a major blow to Democratic campaigns and messaging if it doesn't make it into this proposal.
One of the most important meetings Monday occurred between Manchin, Environment and Public Works Committee Chairman Tom Carper, Agriculture Committee Chairwoman Debbie Stabenow, Majority Leader Cnuck Schumer and Finance Chairman Ron Wyden. All of them are chairs in the Senate who deal with energy and climate, but only one of them is the hold out in these discussions. The senators huddled for roughly an hour on the Hill as they sought to reach an agreement on a series of provisions they could use to reduce emissions in the country.
COVID-19, corporate taxes, Iran nuclear deal on Biden's agenda for Day One of G-20 summit
The G-20 summit that opened Saturday in Rome will mark the first time in two years that some of the world's most powerful leaders have met in person.Biden arrived at the modernist, cloud-shaped convention center in Rome where the Group of 20, or G-20, is meeting and was welcomed by Italian Prime Minister Mario Draghi. A few minutes later, he joined other leaders for a traditional "family photo.
As one source described it, the meeting centered around two important aspects of the Democrats' climate debate. The first was what to do about $150 billion that was supposed to be used for a climate program that Manchin nixed a week ago. Manchin privately has suggested scrapping it from the bill altogether, but other Democrats have insisted that money needs to be used elsewhere. Carper, a Delaware Democrat, told reporters that it's his expectation the money will be used for some emissions reductions programs. A source familiar with the meeting told CNN that most of the time was spent trying to figure out what programs that money could actually be funneled to that would be OK for Manchin.
"We can put runs on the scoreboard in a lot of different ways," the source said. "For most us, we prefer to do the Clean Electricity Performance Program approach, but that ain't gonna happen. The question now is can we get the same impact through playing small ball."
The health care sticking point (yes, there are a few)
Medicare: It's not clear yet if hearing, vision and dental coverage will be included in this package. There has been talk of making dental a pilot program. There has been talk of making each entity a voucher program. It's not clear how or if this is expansion is going to make it at this point, despite the fact it is the signature issue for Senate Budget Committee Chairman Bernie Sanders.
But it is clear that Democrats are searching for some kind of creative way to address it and keep some semblance of the idea into the package, officials and aides say.
Medicaid expansion: There are serious reservations for some Democrats about expanding Medicaid by having the federal government foot the bill for states that didn't expand the program since Obamacare passed more than a decade ago. This has been a top concern for Sinema, but she's not the only one.
"I don't know how that is going to work quite frankly. I brought this up in lunch a month ago," Sen. Jon Tester, a Democrat from Montana, said. "Pick a state: Wisconsin, Alabama doesn't have Medicaid expansion, but Montana does. Does that mean Montana goes and repeals its Medicaid expansion and has it paid for by the federal government?"
Yet this is an absolutely critical issue for several senators and the Congressional Black Caucus -- so much so that Rep. Jim Clyburn, a South Carolina Democrat, privately called Manchin to try and persuade him on the issue. Georgia Democratic Sen. Jon Ossoff is also pressing Manchin on the issue, CNN reported.
To put it plainly, Democratic leaders have to find a resolution here -- or they have a big problem.
The math: Some good news for Democrats
Under the special budget process in the Senate known as reconciliation, each committee is given instructions of how much they can actually spend in their committee's jurisdiction.
Remember, the Senate already passed a budget that assumed a bill that was going to spend $3.5 trillion. But, now the Democrats are only going to spend between $1.5 and $2 trillion because of objections from Manchin and Sinema on the topline.
That reduction has actually given committees a bit more wiggle room to shift programming around. So, for example, that means that some of the $150 billion that was going to go to the CEPP in Manchin's Energy and Natural Resources Committee could actually be used under the Finance Committee's jurisdiction for a series of tax incentives aimed and getting businesses to reduce emissions.
This seems in-the-weeds or a bit off the path from the most important issues. But looming over everything that's happening right now are the reconciliation restrictions that will bite -- and bite hard -- if Democrats aren't paying close attention. By all accounts, they are keenly aware of it with every step they take, but anything that makes the process less complicated is a net positive at this point, aides say.
Is the Media to Blame for Biden’s Bad Poll Numbers? .
Or is it “the economy, stupid”?In mid-August, voters approved of the president by a margin of 50 to 43.8 percent in FiveThirtyEight’s polling average. Today, they disapprove of him by a margin of 51.1 to 43.2 percent.