Politics Michigan redistricting spat exposes competing interests in Democratic coalition
Court Rejects Connecticut GOP's Effort to Remove Man Appointed to Redraw Congressional Map
The Connecticut Supreme court denied four Republican lawmakers' motion to remove a Stanford law professor appointed to help draw redistricting lines.The court-appointed Persily after members of the state legislature's Reapportionment Commission couldn't agree on how to redraw the districts in accordance with population changes.
Michigan's redistricting commission wrapped up its first-ever effort to redraw political boundaries last month with a series of bipartisan votes adopting district lines that give Democrats their best chance in years to recapture control of the state legislature.
The maps create a competitive battleground for control of a state Senate that has been in Republican hands since 1984, and a state House that Democrats have controlled for only four of the last 23 years. At the congressional level, it gives Democrats the ability to control or compete for seven of 13 U.S. House seats, compared with seven of 14 seats they control now.
Elections: Challengers say 'race blind' redistricting maps are anything but
In states like Texas and North Carolina, Republican lawmakers in charge of redrawing the political maps for the next decade say that the new plans are "race blind." Their opponents in court say that the claim is implausible and one that, in some situations, is at odds with the Voting Rights Act. © Provided by CNN Several lawsuits, including from the Justice Department, allege that the maps drawn after the 2020 census discriminate against voters of color.
"Under these new congressional and state legislative districts, the Michigan Democratic Party renews its commitment to fighting for equality, fair representation and justice while celebrating Michigan's diverse population," state Democratic Party chair Lavora Barnes said in a statement.
But in the midst of cheers coming from state and national Democrats and from the reform groups that led the charge to establish the commission, one group offered a discordant note: This week, a group of Black Democratic state lawmakers from Detroit said they would sue over the new district lines, which they allege disproportionately dilute their power.
"The largest African American majority city in the nation has received the very short end of the stick," Nabih Ayad, the lead lawyer for the Democratic legislators, said at a press conference this week. "The new redistricting map lines have unfairly discriminated against the city of Detroit, its residents and its elected officials."
Michigan vs. Georgia live score, updates, highlights from 2021 College Football Playoff semifinal
Sporting News is tracking live scoring updates and highlights from Michigan vs. Georgia in their College Football Playoff semifinal on Friday. Follow for complete results from the 2021 Orange Bowl. MORE: Watch Michigan vs. Georgia live with fuboTV (7-day free trial) Michigan vs. Georgia score Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 F Michigan 0 3 - - - Georgia 14 13 - - - Michigan vs. Georgia live score, updates 9:32 p.m.: Now Haskins has a big run up the right side for a gain of 19 to keep the Wolverines moving. 9:31 p.m.: McNamara with a big pass up the middle to All for a 21-yard gain to the 50. 9:30 p.m.
Ayad represents six sitting and two former state legislators from the Detroit area.
"They are fighting for their own spaces in this democratic system, and it takes leadership like that to say this is not right and this is why we need the court's intervention to be able to provide some justice," said Kamilia Landrum, executive director of the Detroit Branch of the NAACP.
The dust-up exposes a historical tension within the Democratic Party that appears regularly during the decennial redistricting process. While Black majority districts virtually always elect Democratic legislators, those districts are frequently drawn in such a way that Democrats are unable to maximize their potential gains in legislative seats.
Dividing Black majority precincts and communities between different districts might expand the number of Democratic-majority districts, but at the expense of districts where Black voters make up a sufficient population to elect their chosen representatives.
North Carolina Congressional Remapping Trial on Fast Track, Judges Must Rule by Jan. 11
A panel of state trial judges heard the first of three days of evidence presentation in the trial fast-tracked by the state Supreme Court over legislative maps.Plaintiffs accuse the committee that drew the maps of gerrymandering that would affirm a Republican majority in the state's Congressional representation, as well as state politics for the years the maps would be in use.
"I hope that my colleagues on the Democratic side of the aisle are not being blinded by the fact that they have the opportunity to win the [state] House to where they're going to allow the disenfranchisement of Black people," state Rep. Tenisha Yancey (D), one of the plaintiffs in the suit, said at the press conference.
District lines drawn by Republican legislators a decade ago established 11 state House districts where Black voters made up a majority of the voting-age population. The new maps drawn by the commission creates only seven, though another six have populations that are more than 40 percent Black. The proposed state Senate map does not include any majority Black districts.
"With the districts having significant decreases in the amount of Blacks that are of voting age, I do think it would be more difficult for African Americans to keep the same level of representation and or grow their representation," Landrum told The Hill in an interview.
Former Attorney General Eric Holder, who now chairs the National Democratic Redistricting Committee, praised the commission's work.
Rep. Brenda Lawrence becomes 25th House Democrat to retire
The four-term Michigan lawmaker had climbed the ranks, but a new congressional map ditched two majority-minority districts and virtually eliminated her current seat.The four-term Michigan lawmaker had climbed the ranks of the powerful House Appropriations panel, as well as the Congressional Black Caucus, since arriving in the Capitol in 2015. She also narrowly lost an election for a caucus-wide leadership election two years ago, so her decision to step aside — first reported by the Detroit News — surprised some of her colleagues.
"The commission process can be messy - it requires scrutiny, public input, accountability from diverse communities seeking equal representation, and well-balanced debate. No one gets everything they want, and everyone has to compromise. But that is how a commission is supposed to work and, in turn, it is a reflection of how American democracy should function," Holder said in a statement. He called the commission's work a "success."
Proponents of the new redistricting commission say the map lines they produced bucked a decades-long trend of behind-the-scenes remapping meant to protect incumbents and shore up the majority party's grip on power.
"The Independent Citizens Redistricting Commission has struck a blow to 'politics as usual' in the state of Michigan by adopting citizen-drawn maps," said Nancy Wang, who heads Voters Not Politicians, the group behind the 2018 ballot measure that created the redistricting commission.
But, she acknowledged, "the process is not over. This shouldn't come as a surprise. The Constitution anticipates that there may be important legal questions for a court to decide. If the Michigan Supreme Court decides that there is something fundamentally flawed about the maps, then under the Constitution, the maps will go back to the Commission for further action."
Ranking the 37 college football bowl games for 2021-22: Rose delivers as Orange, Cotton disappoint
Recapping every bowl game played over the holidays following the 2021 college football seasonIn the end, it was an average year. The good news is that while not every game was a thriller, there weren't a lot of blowouts. Of the 37 games played, 14 finished as one-score affairs while 11 finished with margins of at least three scores. The average margin of victory was 13.9 points per game, which is less than last year's 14.8.
Republicans have been relatively quiet on the new map lines. The state Republican Party's communications director said last week the group was "evaluating all options to take steps necessary to defend the voices silenced by the commission."
But Republican legislative leaders and party officials, who sued unsuccessfully to overturn the voters' decision to establish the commission, have not announced any new legal action.
Dennis Lennox, a Michigan-based Republican strategist, said his party needed to take action in the face of maps that put control of the legislature at risk of a Democratic takeover.
"Republicans are foolish not to challenge it this cycle, because of course it's really difficult to challenge the constitutionality of the commission ten years from now," Lennox said. "For Republicans, their majority is at stake. Any Republican in Michigan who thinks these maps are good for them is smoking something."
On the congressional level, the new map creates two districts in and around Detroit in which the voting age population is between 44 percent and 45 percent Black, seats currently represented by Reps. Brenda Lawrence (D), who is Black, and Rashida Tlaib (D), who is of Palestinian descent.
Detroit has a long history of sending prominent Black politicians to Congress, including John Conyers, the dean of the House before his resignation; Carolyn Cheeks Kilpatrick; Hansen Clarke; Barbara-Rose Collins; George Crockett; and Charles Diggs, the first chairman of the Congressional Black Caucus.
But Lawrence said this week she would retire at the end of this Congress, and Tlaib is planning to run for her seat.
"When you have black elected leaders who are doing right in the community when they're put up against so many stereotypes, it does provide guidance and leadership for young people who are interested in serving their communities," Landrum said.
Eastern Michigan vs. Ball State: How to watch live stream, TV channel, NCAAB start time .
How to watch Eastern Michigan vs. Ball State basketball gameBall State @ Eastern Michigan