Politics Small ranchers say Biden letting them get squeezed

15:02  23 january  2022
15:02  23 january  2022 Source:   thehill.com

Analysis: Joe Biden and Democrats run up against relentless conservative power

  Analysis: Joe Biden and Democrats run up against relentless conservative power Democrats control Washington but President Joe Biden is staring at a wall of conservative power, accrued over years and wielded with a ruthlessness and zeal for rule-breaking that his own party has rarely matched. © Jose Luis Magana/AP President Joe Biden speaks to the media after meeting privately with Senate Democrats, Thursday, Jan. 13, 2022, on Capitol Hill in Washington. (AP Photo/Jose Luis Magana) The President's struggles to implement his strategy to protect US democracy and reshape the economy to help working Americans are hampered by divisions in his own party.

America's independent cattle ranchers say major corporations in the beef industry are squeezing them out - and that the Biden administration is letting it happen.

Small ranchers say Biden letting them get squeezed © Associated Press/Brittany Peterson Small ranchers say Biden letting them get squeezed

President Biden issued a sweeping executive order in July 2021 directing federal agencies to address anti-competitive behavior by big meat-packing companies.

But farmers say Biden hasn't gone far enough to rein in larger meat-packing companies, a handful of which control the bulk of the hog, cattle and chicken markets.

Unless regulators break those companies up, farmers say, the administration's current reforms won't have much long-term effect.

Biden Narrowly Beats Trump in Latest Hypothetical 2024 Matchup Poll, Despite Low Approval

  Biden Narrowly Beats Trump in Latest Hypothetical 2024 Matchup Poll, Despite Low Approval Three previous polls had shown Donald Trump ahead of the president.While Biden has repeatedly said that he plans to seek reelection, Trump has not officially confirmed whether he will run in the next presidential election. However, the former president has repeatedly teased the possibility, and most recent polls have suggested he would be well positioned to potentially defeat Biden in a rematch.

"We want to bring some semblance of competition back to cattle market," said Tim Gibbons of Missouri Rural Crisis Center, which represents 5,600 farming families.

"Missouri has 50,000 cattle producers, but 80 percent of beef packing is controlled by four companies," Gibbons said, adding while Biden has spoken out on some of the biggest issues, "nothing has changed."

In particular, ranchers point to an Obama-era legal reform that allowed meatpackers to label any beef product - regardless of where the cattle were raised - as "Product of USA" if it was processed in the country.

This allowed big meatpacking companies to bury smaller entities under an avalanche of cheap, foreign-raised beef while labeling it American-made, said Missouri rancher Darvin Bentlage.

Biden year one takeaways: Grand ambitions, humbling defeats

  Biden year one takeaways: Grand ambitions, humbling defeats Joe Biden's long arc in public life has always had one final ambition: to sit behind the Resolute Desk of the Oval Office. He achieved it — albeit, at 78, as the oldest person to assume the presidency. After the turbulence and chaos of his predecessor, Donald Trump, Biden was seen by voters as one who could restore a sense of normalcy and a reassuring tone to the White House. But Biden also found out, as all his predecessors have, that events beyond his control would shape his time in office and the public's assessment of him.

"That pound of ground beef may say 'Made in the USA,' but it could be from five or six countries," Bentlage said.

And while Biden's order contained language to close the foreign-raised beef loophole, small ranchers say they have a hard time trusting federal regulators to carry it out.

"The industry, because of its economic power, is using political power to chip away at regulations. All they want is time to drive the independent cattleman out of business," said Austin Frerick, deputy director of Yale's Thurman Arnold Project, which focuses on antitrust enforcement.

The American beef and poultry industry has a long history of shake-ups, with the farm foreclosure crisis and a consolidation in the meatpacking industry in the 1980s ushering in an era of regional meat monopolies, according to Frerick.

Over the 1990s and 2000s, these conglomerates set up a model in which farmers became contractors, raising company-owned animals on company-owned feeds in enormous sheds built with government-backed loans.

How to Watch Biden Speech Today: Time, Live Stream of First Press Conference in 10 Months

  How to Watch Biden Speech Today: Time, Live Stream of First Press Conference in 10 Months In Biden's first solo press conference in 10 months, he will likely discuss the pandemic and his administration's successes during his first year in office.Wednesday marks the eve of Biden's first anniversary in office and comes as the president struggles with low approval ratings. After starting off with high ratings, Biden's support among voters started to slip during America's chaotic withdrawal from Afghanistan and has been on a downward trajectory as COVID cases rise.

This structure first came to chicken processors like Tyson in the Southeast, then pork processors like Smithfield. It went "on steroids" in 2002 when the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) opened up the Environmental Quality Incentives Program to pay for the waste pits of hog farms, Bentlage said.

That implicitly subsidized a glut of cheap protein that forced small producers out of business, Frerick said.

"It wasn't like hog farmers going bankrupt all of a sudden," he said. "You just see margins shrink and shrink and shrink."

A similar process happened in neighboring Missouri, which had 23,000 hog producers in 1985. Three decades later, that number was at 2,600.

"And that wasn't because 20,000 people decided to get out," said Gibbons. "Corporations took over the marketplace, production and processing and put all those family farmers out of business."

By 2012, the main meatpacking companies - Tyson, Cargill, Smithfield and JBS - had maneuvered the nation's chicken, pork and dairy farmers into a relationship "worse in certain respects than sharecropping," as Lina Kahn, now the Biden-appointed chair of the Federal Trade Commission, wrote in an article in Washington Monthly that year.

How Joe Biden's Approval Ratings Have Changed During His First Year in Office

  How Joe Biden's Approval Ratings Have Changed During His First Year in Office President Biden concludes his first year in office with the second-lowest approval rating of any President's freshman year at the White House.The Democrat inherited a country in disarray, staring down the barrel of a troublesome pandemic, faced with growing social and political division, and economically burdened by the consequences of the continuing COVID crisis.

During the Obama presidency, the meat industry lobbied hard against two specific initiatives aimed at bringing more competition to meat markets: One that would have empowered the USDA to fight unfair or deceptive practices by packers and another mandating country-of-origin labeling.

"In a time of down cattle markets, the last thing USDA needs to do is limit opportunity," National Cattlemen's Beef Association President Tracy Brunner argued in a statement at the time. "The fact of the matter is: We don't trust the government to meddle in the marketplace."

The North American Meat Institute, which represents large meatpackers, tends to argue that consolidation means better prices and quality for consumers and helps the environment.

"The notion that smaller scale operations are more environmentally friendly and sustainable than larger scale is not supported by the data which suggests that efficiency is the most important factor," reads one of the Meat Institute's "Media Mythcrushers."

In 2015, after the World Trade Organization sided with Canada and Mexico in their own campaign against country-of-origin labels, Congress repealed them in a spending bill.

Tom Vilsack, Biden's Agriculture secretary who also led the USDA at the time under Obama, told the agency to immediately stand down.

Biden Keeps Trump Immigration Policies—and Stephen Miller Is Loving It

  Biden Keeps Trump Immigration Policies—and Stephen Miller Is Loving It Moments after he was sworn into office, President Joe Biden made good on the first of dozens of promises he had made to immigrant communities on the campaign trail—bursting out of the gate with the repeal of some of the Trump administration’s most aggressively anti-immigration policies and the introduction of a vast legislative package that would create a path to citizenship for eight million people living in the United States. On that day,On that day, Biden looked to his pro-immigration supporters to be exceeding their highest expectations.

For cattle farmer Bentlage, the climbing prices he had seen the previous four years collapsed, and they have never recovered.

In 2014, Bentlage said he made $518 a head for his cows. Now it's somewhere between $80 and $125.

"That means a hundred cows would make you $51,000 in 2014. This year, they're projecting it will be maybe $12,500," Bentlage said.

"That's still at the poverty level."

Biden highlighted soaring meat prices for consumers in a speech earlier this month. Beef prices rose 20 percent between October 2020 and October 2021, according to federal data.

"Capitalism without competition" is "exploitation," Biden said, turning the table over to a cattle rancher who complained of "take it or leave it" prices from meatpackers.

On Capitol Hill, a number of bills have been introduced to target what many small meat farmers see as the worst features of corporate control.

Sens. Jon Tester (D-Mont.) and Chuck Grassley (R-Iowa) introduced a bill that would force cattle processors to buy at least 50 percent of their cows on open "spot" markets, rather than the off-market deals that account for 90 percent of their purchases now.

A progressive-backed bill sponsored by Sen. Cory Booker (D-N.J.) and Rep. Ro Khanna (D-Calif.) also seeks to crack down on meat monopolies and place a moratorium on consolidated factory farms.

And in September, Tester and Booker joined South Dakota's two GOP senators, John Thune and Mike Rounds, to introduce the American Beef Labeling Act, which would reinstate certificate-of-origin labeling.

"Montana ranchers raise the best cattle in the world, and it's time American families are guaranteed the right to know whether their beef is from Broadus or Brazil," Tester said in a statement.

Ranchers have welcomed many elements of Biden's order, like subsidies for new slaughterhouses and reforms to labeling laws.

But Gibbons and others consider the measures insufficient without a long-term solution to break up what he called the "meat cartels."

Some ideas include prohibiting those who own livestock from slaughtering it themselves, or limiting meatpackers to one line of protein, like chicken or beef.

For Bentlage, 66, he's eyeing the generations to come and the future of his own ranch in Missouri.

He said he's trying to help a young neighbor purchase his property. Otherwise, he worries, it's likely to be "sucked up by big corporate farmers."

How Americans think Joe Biden has done on their most important priorities after one year .
President Joe Biden entered office promising to end the Covid-19 pandemic, boost a lagging economy, get Americans back to work, restore US credibility abroad and heal a divided nation. © Andrew Harnik/AP President Joe Biden speaks during a meeting with the President's Council of Advisors on Science and Technology at the Eisenhower Executive Office Building on the White House Campus, Thursday, Jan. 20, 2022. After one year, the reviews from the American people in public polling on those topics, in many cases, have not been kind.

usr: 1
This is interesting!