Technology: Momentum Grows for a Digital Watchdog to Regulate Tech Giants - PressFrom - US

TechnologyMomentum Grows for a Digital Watchdog to Regulate Tech Giants

12:41  11 september  2019
12:41  11 september  2019 Source:

Google, Facebook, Amazon reportedly testifying against France's digital tax

Google, Facebook, Amazon reportedly testifying against France's digital tax The tech giants will testify on Monday, says a report.

internet giants in the local media landscape. A watchdog would be created to oversee how the near-monopoly search and social media providers do The ACCC interim report declared the digital giants had “substantial” market power but had largely escaped being brought under the regulatory regime

Our weekly podcast on the innovations, discoveries and gadgetry making the news.

(Bloomberg) -- With Big Tech accused of everything from decimating industries to abusing privacy, calls are growing for the creation of a federal regulator.

Presidential candidates, consumer advocates and some antitrust enforcers have focused on breaking up Inc., Apple Inc., Facebook Inc. and Alphabet Inc.’s Google -- or at least forcing them to unwind past acquisitions. Yet those moves could take years and face lengthy court challenges.

The desire for faster action is fueling demands for a new agency to oversee the industry, an idea that’s gaining traction among liberal and free-market economists in the U.S., Europe and Australia. They say there’s plenty of precedent: The U.S. and other countries have watchdogs for specific industries, such as aviation, medicine, financial services and the environment, so why not digital markets?

Google, Facebook, Amazon will testify against France's digital tax next week

Google, Facebook, Amazon will testify against France's digital tax next week The tech giants will present their case on Monday.

PARIS — The latest standoff between Europe and American tech companies runs through a quiet street just north of the Louvre Museum, past chic cafes and part of the French national library, to the ornate office of Isabelle Falque-Pierrotin.

Austria has vowed to tax tech giants , following France's new levy on the so-called GAFA companies: Google, Apple, Facebook France had proposed a comprehensive digital services tax (DST) to cover all 28 EU member states. In China, the use of social media is highly regulated by the government.

Advocates say a digital regulator could referee disputes between competitors, set standards for privacy, make it easier to move one’s data between networks, and make sure the biggest companies aren’t squelching innovation or smothering potential rivals.

“If the search engine discriminates against you vigorously enough, you’re not alive for very long,” said Fiona Scott Morton, a Yale University economist and a former antitrust official at the Justice Department. “You need a regulator to be alerted to the problem on Monday and be able to have a hearing the next Monday, figure it out and keep the victim alive rather than taking two or three years to bring a case.”

Read More: How Tech’s New Monopolies Test Old Antitrust Thinking: QuickTake

EU reportedly wants strict limits for 'indiscriminate' facial recognition

EU reportedly wants strict limits for 'indiscriminate' facial recognition Europe could introduce sweeping reforms governing how facial recognition technology can be used.

Facebook, Amazon, Apple, Netflix and Google have dodged impact of trade war.

But partisan battles over whether to safeguard a growing array of individual state privacy laws could threaten to derail efforts by Congress to pass its first Congressional committees are set to hold hearings Tuesday and Wednesday on how to regulate tech giants such as Google and Facebook.

The European Union on Tuesday took a big step in this direction when the president-elect of the EU Commission enlarged the portfolio of Margrethe Vestager, one of the world’s toughest antitrust regulators as the bloc’s competition commissioner. As the head of digital affairs, she will oversee such matters as big data, innovation, cybersecurity and artificial intelligence, along with antitrust.

In the U.S., efforts to establish such an agency would be met with many obstacles. Republicans, who opposed the creation of the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau in 2010, would likely fight another bureaucracy. Democrats may see it as diluting antitrust inquiries. The tech companies, too, would likely try to stop it. An agency with the power to require changes to their business practices could be even more threatening to their bottom lines than budding federal and state antitrust investigations.

US and France reach a compromise on France’s tax on tech giants

US and France reach a compromise on France’s tax on tech giants During a new briefing at the Group of 7 summit, French President Emmanuel Macron announced that U.S. President Donald Trump and Macron have agreed on a compromise regarding the controversial tax on tech giants. France is still going to tax big tech companies. But the French government promises that it’ll scrap the French tax as soon as the OECD finds a way to properly tax tech companies in countries where they operate. The OECD has been working on a way to properly tax tech companies with a standardized set of rules for a few years. According to recent announcements, this new framework could be released in 2020.

Technology and the largest tech firms are becoming increasingly controversial. Today, there are growing concerns about third parties accessing and manipulating Facebook user In the early years of the internet, an infant tech industry pleaded for a hands-off approach to regulation and taxation.

The tech giants came to prominence with better products and services that unseated their That’s why the tech giants and their globally-coordinated advocates have fought vehemently against it But then, there would be no need to grow the EU’s ganglion of 62 privacy and data protection authorities

Momentum Grows for a Digital Watchdog to Regulate Tech Giants© Photographer: Christopher Goodney/Bloomberg Jason Furman

Jason Furman

Besides Scott Morton, who led a University of Chicago panel that produced a report on the digital economy in July, supporters include Jason Furman, President Barack Obama’s former chief economic adviser who was the lead author of a similar study for the British government.

Read More: Senator Wants Facebook, Google to Face Suits If They Show Bias

President Donald Trump might welcome a digital authority, which could also monitor social-media companies for alleged bias. He has been a persistent critic of Facebook, Google and Twitter Inc. for what he says is suppression of conservative political opinions, a charge the companies have denied.

It’s notable that a digital agency was a key proposal in the report by the University of Chicago’s Stigler Center for the Study of the Economy and the State. The so-called Chicago School’s laissez-faire thinking on antitrust has dominated the approach of courts and enforcers since the 1970s. Many experts now think that stance went too far, clearing the way for industry overall to become more consolidated and for the tech giants to rise.

The US and France reportedly reach a deal over 'digital services' tax

The US and France reportedly reach a deal over 'digital services' tax The Trump Administration and the French government have supposedly reached a deal that ends a feud over France's tax on tech giants, Bloomberg reports. Earlier this year, French President Emmanuel Macron proposed a three percent tax on revenues earned on digital services in France. President Trump threatened a tariff on French wine if the tax went through, sparking a standoff. Trump and Macron reportedly worked through some of their differences at a G7 summit, and today, Macron told reporters, "We have a deal to overcome the difficulties between us.

The tech giants can help the firms they acquire grow more than they might have been able to do on their own. For example, Facebook’s acquisition of Recruiting is a second tool the giants will use to enforce their kill zones. Big tech firms are able to shell out huge sums to keep top performers and

This growing power is leading regulators and the public to demand accountability and transparency instead of complacency. Tech companies—under fire for data breaches, mental health concerns, and election interference—face a mounting backlash around the world.

To foster more competition, a digital agency could, for example, mandate that companies can’t discriminate against rivals that operate on their platforms. It might ban Amazon, on which many third-party merchants depend to sell their goods, from punishing a successful outside vendor by pushing it down in its search rankings. Or it might require that Apple lower its fee for app store purchases of third-party services, such as Spotify Technology SA’s music-streaming service, which competes with Apple Music.

A digital authority was also the central recommendation in Furman’s report. The U.K.’s competition authority in July said a new regulator might be needed to police the digital platforms, mirroring Furman’s recommendations. A version is under consideration in Australia, whose competition commission also issued a similar report in July.

Read More: Big Tech Is Taking a Bipartisan Beating All Over Washington

Momentum Grows for a Digital Watchdog to Regulate Tech Giants© Bloomberg FBI Director Christopher Wray Testifies Before Senate Judiciary Committee

Lindsey Graham

Some American lawmakers are warming to the idea, including Senator Lindsey Graham, a South Carolina Republican and chairman of the Judiciary Committee, who is a close ally of Trump’s. “It seems that a regulatory body is the right way to go,” Graham told reporters after a hearing on technology and competition in May.

Congressional antitrust panel to discuss Big Tech competition

Congressional antitrust panel to discuss Big Tech competition The Senate's antitrust panel will meet later this month to discuss concerns that tech giants, such as Google or Amazon, seek to buy smaller rivals in order to head off competition. © Ng Han Guan "Big technology companies have become some of the most powerful organizations in the world," Sen. Amy Klobuchar said. Senators Mike Lee and Amy Klobuchar, the chairman and top Democrat on the Judiciary Committee's antitrust panel, said the hearing was scheduled for Sept. 24 but did not list witnesses.

UPDATED: Privacy Shield AKA SAFE HARBOR - see bottom of this OP Digital Watchdog Unleashed Against US Tech Giants Continuing the EU’s assault on US tech giants , Isabelle privacy shield (aka) safe harbor UPDATE Privacy Shield / Digital Watchdog Unleashed Against US Tech Giants .

Regulating technology , she added, is a “global challenge.” Europe’s privacy playbook is now playing out in Brazil, which has sought advice from Brussels on its own privacy bill. Whether Europe’s tough approach is actually crimping the global tech giants is unclear. The region’s regulators have hit U.S

Even Facebook’s Chief Executive Officer Mark Zuckerberg has called for global regulations on data ownership by consumers, policing harmful content, protecting the integrity of elections and guarding privacy rights. Erin Egan, Facebook’s chief privacy officer, last week outlined areas where a regulator or other outside group could help improve choice and promote innovation -- two goals of antitrust enforcement.

A regulator could oversee data portability, in which consumers move their data from one social-media site to another. It could establish standards to make sure Facebook users who want to move to an alternative network can easily take their lists of friends, photos and posts with them. Congress did something similar when it passed the 1996 Telecommunications Act, which forced carriers to let consumers keep their phone numbers when switching networks.

A related idea would have digital companies pay consumers for the use of their data. California is looking into it, while Democratic Senator Mark Warner of Virginia and a Republican colleague, Josh Hawley of Missouri, back legislation that would make companies publicize the value of the data they hold. If consumers are going to own and sell their own data, a regulator would have to set up a marketplace and establish basic rules.

Facebook and Google say users can already download their data for personal use, but critics have said the process is too cumbersome, or the data that users are allowed to move is too limited, to represent true portability.

Swiss welcome scrutiny in handling Libra cyrptocurrency: watchdog

Swiss welcome scrutiny in handling Libra cyrptocurrency: watchdog Swiss welcome scrutiny in handling Libra cyrptocurrency: watchdog

The Nuclear Threat Initiative says over 40 percent of nuclear nations don't have any way to prevent digital intrusion or attack. Nuclear security is a big deal, but a new watchdog report finds more than 40 percent of nuclear nations aren't doing anything to protect themselves from digital attackers.

A regulatory watchdog would ensure that the activity of Facebook and other tech titans is scrutinised, to make it more transparent and regulate its market Regulation was designed for a world in which change was incremental or episodic. If the tech giants have absented themselves of responsibility for

All four companies have also said they face robust competition and don’t monopolize their respective markets or block access to their platforms by competitors.

Read More: Hotels Support Measure to Weaken Tech Companies’ Legal Shield

Amazon spokesman Jack Evans said the company represents 1% of global retail, including e-commerce and brick-and-mortar stores, and that it depends on third-party sellers for its success.

Apple referred to July testimony before the House antitrust panel by a company vice president who said Apple runs a fair marketplace that has allowed apps, including Spotify, to succeed, and that its own apps face tough competition.

Some doubt a single regulator could tackle the diversity of issues involved. “The fact that the businesses are so different and that we would try to slam them all together in some sort of tech regulator” seems an impossibly hard legislative challenge, said Neil Chilson, a former Federal Trade Commission official who now serves as a senior research fellow in technology at the libertarian Charles Koch Institute. “It’s just not clear to me how you achieve that.”

Such hurdles aren’t stopping digital agency proponents. Some are calling for urgent action not just to end the tech giants’ dominance but also to prevent them from controlling the next tech revolution -- artificial intelligence and machine learning.

“In every society a lot of the same issues are bubbling up,” said Gene Kimmelman, one of the authors of the University of Chicago report and a former Justice Department antitrust official. “It’s going to take quite a bit more than antitrust to actually drive competitive forces in these markets,” he added.

--With assistance from David McLaughlin.

To contact the reporter on this story: Ben Brody in Washington, D.C. at [email protected]

To contact the editors responsible for this story: Sara Forden at [email protected], Paula Dwyer, John Harney

For more articles like this, please visit us at

©2019 Bloomberg L.P.

EU may need to regulate tech giants' data use: EU antitrust chief.
EU may need to regulate tech giants' data use: EU antitrust chief

—   Share news in the SOC. Networks

Topical videos:

usr: 7
This is interesting!