•   
  •   
  •   

Technology Bioethicists condemn DIY COVID-19 vaccine efforts

15:10  24 september  2020
15:10  24 september  2020 Source:   abcnews.go.com

Coronavirus live updates: Dr. Deborah Birx warns of 'different' outbreak; Navajo Nation nears 500 deaths

  Coronavirus live updates: Dr. Deborah Birx warns of 'different' outbreak; Navajo Nation nears 500 deaths The Department of Labor releases its latest jobless claims figures Thursday. Congress anticipates relief package by week's end. Latest COVID-19 news.The nation's testing for COVID-19 is dropping even as infections remain high and the death toll rises by more than 1,000 a day, a worrisome trend that officials attribute largely to Americans getting discouraged over having to wait hours to get a test and days or weeks to learn the results.

Across the country, a small handful of scientists are brewing up their own homemade and unproven COVID-19 vaccines and giving them to friends, family and themselves. These scientists hail from disparate groups. Some are shadowy and anonymous, while others are highly organized and Ivy-league affiliated.

A woman wearing a protective mask holds a syringe and getting vaccine from the medicine bottle in an undated stock image. © STOCK IMAGE/Naskami/Shutterstock A woman wearing a protective mask holds a syringe and getting vaccine from the medicine bottle in an undated stock image.

"It's actually simpler than most recipes in home cookbooks," said Preston Estep, chief scientist and co-founder of a DIY effort backed by a Harvard geneticist. Estep said he hopes that his group's unapproved vaccine, which is inhaled through a nasal spray, might give people sheltering at home more confidence and protection.

Vikings place first-round pick Justin Jefferson, three other rookies on Reserve/COVID-19 list

  Vikings place first-round pick Justin Jefferson, three other rookies on Reserve/COVID-19 list It is not certain if Jefferson and the three other rookies have contracted the virus. Players must be placed on the COVID-19/reserve list if they test positive or have come in contact with an infected person. The Vikings announced earlier Monday their infection control officer tested positive for the coronavirus.The Vikings used one of their two first-round picks on Jefferson, who will be expected to fill the role Stefon Diggs occupied for years opposite Adam Thielen. He is coming off a dominant senior season at LSU, when he caught 111 passes for 1,540 yards and 18 touchdowns.

"In my view, it is unethical to tell people to wait two years for something that's available today," said another DIY proponent, entrepreneur and microbiologist Johnny Stine, in an email to ABC News. Still, another group says it won't name its handful of members for fear of Food and Drug Administration retribution.

MORE: Coronavirus vaccine: How the approval process works

These DIY groups are united in their belief that traditional vaccine development is too long and cumbersome, and society could have access to a potential vaccine now.

Six months into the COVID-19 pandemic, there are at least three vaccines from major pharmaceutical companies in late-stage trials, but we are still months away from having a vaccine widely available.

Vikings place first-round pick Justin Jefferson, three other rookies on Reserve/COVID-19 list

  Vikings place first-round pick Justin Jefferson, three other rookies on Reserve/COVID-19 list Baseball fans in Philadelphia say sports teams should wait longer to hit the field, this after two major league games scheduled for Monday were postponed after more than a dozen Miami Marlins players and staff tested positive for the coronavirus. (July 27)

But there's one problem: none of these DIY enthusiasts know for sure if their vaccine actually protects people from COVID-19, or whether it's safe. And without carefully controlled experiments, they'll never find out.

"I'm not opposed to speed," Arthur Caplan, Ph.D., founding director of the division of medical ethics at New York University Langone Medical Center said. But the DIY vaccine effort, Caplan said, is "reckless, driving drunk."

Now, Caplan is among a growing chorus of bioethicists condemning the DIY vaccine movement.

"A DIY vaccine is a bad idea," said Dr. Ruth Faden, founder of the Johns Hopkins Berman Institute for Bioethics. "Unless -- and this is the big unless -- [it] was connected with some mechanism for moving this into the regular order."

a hand holding an object: A woman wearing a protective mask holds a syringe and getting vaccine from the medicine bottle in an undated stock image. © STOCK IMAGE/Naskami/Shutterstock A woman wearing a protective mask holds a syringe and getting vaccine from the medicine bottle in an undated stock image.

The DIY nature of these experiments means no one is formally keeping track of what happens to people who take these vaccines -- whether they get sick, or if they're protected from coronavirus infection, explained Jennifer Miller, Ph.D., an assistant professor at Yale School of Medicine and founder of Bioethics International and the Good Pharma Scorecard.

Rob Manfred shares circumstances under which he would pause a team’s season

  Rob Manfred shares circumstances under which he would pause a team’s season Despite the current outbreak among Marlins players, Rob Manfred says the situation isn't so out of hand that he would consider canceling the 2020 season yet. Commissioner Rob Manfred has shared the circumstances under which he would decide to pause a team’s season, though. “A team losing a number of players that rendered it completely non-competitive,” would be the circumstance, Manfred said on Monday.The commissioner said he believes the league can still keep players safe and says they remain optimistic.“We expected we were going to have positives at some point in time.

That means we're gleaning little meaningful knowledge about whether the vaccines work, Miller said.

"One of the main reasons why it's OK to medically experiment on humans is the potential to create generalizable knowledge and advance the common good," Miller said. But with DIY vaccines, there's no standard ethics review board -- a 21st century safeguard for human experimentation.

"Research on humans is never OK without an ethics review," said Miller. "People tend to think that ethics codes and regulations are for barbarians ... [but] those codes are for everybody. Even if you are a Nobel prize winner, you are not above the ethics codes."

The most recent critique, published Thursday in the journal Science, said these efforts are not only unethical, but if unproven vaccines are sold to consumers they also could also be illegal.

MORE: World Health Organization announces distribution plan for COVID-19 vaccine

"Taking information that you found in some dark corner of the internet but using it to develop your own materials and needing to ship materials or reagents across state lines -- that is interstate commerce and is what triggers FDA oversight," lead author Jacob Sherkow, law professor at Illinois College of Law, said in a statement. "At that point, that's essentially where the FDA can stop you."

Nuggets’ Michael Porter Jr. has theory on coronavirus ‘agenda’

  Nuggets’ Michael Porter Jr. has theory on coronavirus ‘agenda’ Porter also claimed he has never received a vaccine in his life. Murray noted that the University of Missouri, where Porter played college ball, requires all students to be up to date on certain immunizations. However, there are medical and religious waivers. Porter Jr. ended his response to the question with the following: "It is a serious thing. It's a real thing but this is being overblown." — Clevis Murray (@ClevisMurray) July 29, 2020 It’s possible Porter Jr. hasn’t been vaccinated. According to the University of Missouri website, students can apply for a medical or religious waiver.

But the proponents of DIY vaccines argue that there's an ethical obligation to release a vaccine that can be used immediately even if unproven for efficacy and safety, rather than waiting for the traditional review process that includes a series of FDA-mandated safety and effectiveness studies that can take years to complete.

"I don't have the millions it takes to even get to the FDA [doorstep] nor would I have the patience to wait two years for a vaccine to a virus that was killing people today," said Stine, who made headlines in May when he was hit with an FDA warning letter for selling his DIY vaccine.

In June, the Washington attorney general filed a lawsuit against Stine, which he later settled without admitting wrongdoing, but he agreed to repay upon request any of the 30 people he had vaccinated.

Estep doesn't sell his vaccine, but believes bioethicists critical of the DIY movement "misunderstand the situation."

"All they are talking about is the risks, but that's a completely unbalanced perspective," Estep said. "They're not presenting the risks of not taking [a DIY vaccine] which are substantial and clear and happening every day."

But bioethicists warn the potential damage caused by DIY vaccines goes beyond each person who chooses to participate. These efforts could harm public trust, eroding the already fragile credibility of legitimately tested and vetted vaccines.

"Having a small group of scientists and their admirers develop something in the garage, so to speak, is just another avenue for having the public be leery of what is said about vaccines," said Caplan.

"Look, self-experimentation is an old and sometimes, in some circles, revered tradition in the ethics of research," Faden said. But "this is not like other kinds of do-it-yourself science. The stakes here are enormous. We can't get this wrong."

Marlins' Jose Urena reportedly tests positive for COVID-19 .
Marlins right-hander José Ureña was scratched from Sunday's scheduled start after testing positive for COIVD-19.Even if Ureña remains asymptomatic, he’ll need to twice test negative at least 24 hours apart before he’s permitted to return to the club. Miami has not yet made any roster moves related to the situation, tweets Joe Frisaro of MLB.com. With there being no minimum length for stints on the COVID-19 injured list, it wouldn’t be surprising to see Miami decide to place Ureña on the IL, even if they believe he’ll be ready to return in short order.

—   Share news in the SOC. Networks
usr: 0
This is interesting!