Sport: NFL explains Vance McDonald touchdown catch - PressFrom - US
  •   
  •   
  •   

SportNFL explains Vance McDonald touchdown catch

17:12  09 november  2018
17:12  09 november  2018 Source:   nbcsports.com

Saints get revenge for 'miracle' in 30-20 win over Vikings

Saints get revenge for 'miracle' in 30-20 win over Vikings Drew Brees and the New Orleans Saints paid Minnesota back for their last-second loss in the playoffs last season, using two key turnovers including a 45-yard interception return by P.J. Williams to fuel a 30-20 victory over the Vikings. Alvin Kamara had two touchdowns and Will Lutz made three field goals for the Saints (6-1), who needed only 120 passing yards by Brees to beat the Vikings (4-3-1) this time with far less tension down the final stretch. Stefon Diggs had 119 receiving yards and a score in his curtain call after the "Minneapolis Miracle" catch in the NFC divisional round in January, but he stopped his drag route in a miscommunication with quarterback Kirk Cousins rig

Vance McDonald makes the defender pay with a sick stiff arm on this touchdown play! The Pittsburgh Steelers take on the Tampa Bay Buccaneers during Week 3

Vance McDonald with that stiff arm touchdown . - - Date: September 24, 2018 - - (All rights go to ESPN, Fox, CBS, Universal Music Group, the NFL , NBA, NCAA

NFL explains Vance McDonald touchdown catch© (AP Photo/Don Wright) Pittsburgh Steelers tight end Vance McDonald (89) hauls in a pass from quarterback Ben Roethlisberger for a touchdown during the second half of an NFL football game against the Carolina Panthers in Pittsburgh, Thursday, Nov. 8, 2018. (AP Photo/Don Wright)

The seven points didn’t make a difference in the game, but the video evidence coupled with the failure to have a full-blown replay review on a third-quarter touchdown reception by Steelers tight end Vance McDonald left many fans confused — and plenty of Panthers fans feeling like their team had been screwed.

McDonald seemed to make the catch at the back of the end zone, but closer inspection of his hands raises a question of whether he actually caught it and/or maintained control of it. The play apparently was reviewed for the purposes of determining whether a full-blown replay review would occur, with a decision being made to not stop the game and watch the play to determine whether clear and obvious evidence existed that he failed to make the catch.

Dad eating with kids at McDonald’s fatally shoots gunman inside Alabama McDonald’s

Dad eating with kids at McDonald’s fatally shoots gunman inside Alabama McDonald’s A brave dad opened fire on a masked gunman inside an Alabama McDonald’s on Saturday, fatally hitting the intruder before suffering serious injuries, reports said. WBRC reported that the unidentified father was with his sons when a man dressed in a mask walked into the Birmingham restaurant and opened fire. The report said the gunman, father and one of the boys were struck during the volley. The gunman, who was not identified, later died of his injuries. The father had life-threatening injuries and his son suffered nonlife-threatening injuries, the report said. Reports did not indicate his sons' ages.

Vance Coman McDonald (born June 13, 1990) is an American football tight end for the Pittsburgh Steelers of the National Football League ( NFL ).

Ben Roethlisberger finds Vance McDonald and Antonio Brown on this touchdown drive. The Baltimore Ravens take on the Pittsburgh Steelers during Week 4 of the 2018 NFL season.

After the fact, NFL senior V.P. of officiating Al Riveron tweeted an explanation of the decision: “Vance McDonald has two feet in bounds and never loses control of the football. The ball can move as long as the receiver never loses control. The ruling on the field is confirmed.”

The assertion that McDonald “never loses control of the football” overlooks the question of whether he ever actually secured control of the football. It appears that McDonald had the ball between his hands for an instant, before juggling the ball to a point where the ball was positioned between the inside of his left hand and the outside of his right hand, at which time the ball continued to move. While it never came loose, it looked like there was never clear control of the ball.

Josh Gordon sets career-high for receiving yards with Patriots despite dislocated finger

Josh Gordon sets career-high for receiving yards with Patriots despite dislocated finger In the first quarter against the Packers Sunday night, Patriots wide receiver Josh Gordon removed himself from the game after making a tough catch, but then quickly returned to action -- missing just one play. It occurred again a few series later, this time Gordon missing a couple plays, but still not a lot. What was the reason? A dislocated finger. "I guess just like a freak accident – nothing too crazy," Gordon said after the game.  "But, after one of the slant routes, I think some pressure fell on it and it dislocated, so I popped it back into place a couple times throughout the rest of the game, but it’s fine though.

It’s a play that’ll go on all of the NFL highlight reels when the 2018 season wraps up. Vance McDonald is Chris Conte’s daddy after that nasty stiff arm en route to his 75 yard touchdown Monday night. A play that knocked Conte out of the game with I assume was an injured soul

McDonald has never posted a top-30 fantasy campaign, but he can't be ignored as the top pass- catching tight end in the Steelers' Ben Roethlisberger-led offense. Over the past five games he has caught 20 of 22 targets for 295 yards but has just one touchdown to show for it over that span.

The rulebook requires the player to “secures control of the ball in his hands or arms”; in this case, control was secured if at all on one of McDonald’s hands. Regardless, it’s still not clear that he ever actually secured control.

That doesn’t mean the ruling on the field would have been overturned if subject to full-blown review. After last year’s misadventures with frame-by-frame review (which resulted in multiple touchdown receptions being overturned when they shouldn’t have been), Riveron seems to be fully committed to the clear-and-obvious, fifty-drunks-in-a-bar standard for overturning a ruling on the field. Which is fine, but the same standard applies in reverse when deciding whether to conduct a full-blown replay review.

In other words, unless it’s clear and obvious that the ruling on the field is correct, the video evidence should be carefully probed for proof that the ruling on the field was clearly and obviously incorrect.

That should have happened here. The outcome of the play probably wouldn’t have changed. The outcome of the game definitely would have changed. But to the extent that the league wants fans to have confidence in the replay process, it needs to be used consistently and correctly in all instances, even when it looks like a game is out of reach.

Watch: Hokies' Turner makes 1-handed TD catch, then blocks punt for TD.
Just before halftime, the game all knotted up at 0-0 between Virginia and Virginia Tech, Hokies receiver Tre Turner wowed on the first score of the day. 

—   Share news in the SOC. Networks

Topical videos:

usr: 1
This is interesting!