SportWhich Pre-2000 Quarterbacks Would Have Fared Best in Today's Top Offensive Systems?
Which quarterbacks most need the Belichick treatment?
Martellus Bennett became the latest former Patriot to peel back the curtain regarding the extent to which coach Bill Belichick gives the business to quarterback Tom Brady. Which provided the impetus for a PFT Live draft on Friday.
It’s May, and it’s time to start imagining. So we’ll start with a very imaginative question…
You can pair one pre-2000 QB with one current offensive play-caller. Who do you choose? Some options: Dan Marino with Mike Leach, Steve Young with Urban Meyer/Ryan Day, Michael Vick with Gus Malzahn.
This is a great question, and the Marino suggestion makes it even more interesting. We’ve all wondered aloud what a great dual-threat quarterback like Steve Young or Michael Vick would have looked like in today’s college offenses, but what about a less mobile QB with a cannon arm and one of the quickest releases of all time?
Fresno State's Defense is Approaching Elite Company
Juju Hughes (23) celebrates after an interception in the 2018 Las Vegas Bowl. Jake Browning connected with Dante Pettis on a seven-yard touchdown on Sept. 16, 2017, to extend Washington's lead over Fresno State, 34-0, on their way to a 48-16 win. That was the last time Fresno State's defense allowed at least 30 points in a game. Since that loss, Fresno State is 21-4, partly thanks to a defense allowing 14.4 points over those 25 games. They pitched one shutout, allowed seven or fewer points six more times (all vs. FBS teams) and have never allowed more than three touchdowns. No opponent has scored more than 27 points over that time.
Lou, who did a great job managing the Cleveland Indians in Major League, is spot on when he hooks up Marino with Leach. The key to succeeding in the Air Raid is getting the ball out quickly and decisively. No one was quicker and more decisive than Marino during his days with the Dolphins.
When Marino played at Pittsburgh from 1979 to ’82, he played in a fairly pass-happy offense—by the standards of the day—on some very good teams. (Jackie Sherrill coached the Panthers for Marino’s first three years, and they went 33–3 before Sherrill went to Texas A&M.) But Marino’s numbers would not be considered great today. In his best collegiate season in 1981, Marino completed 226 of 380 attempts (59.5%) for 2,876 yards with 37 touchdowns and 23 interceptions. Marino’s 7.6 yards an attempt would be average today, and his completion percentage would be considered less than ideal. Last season in Leach’s offense, Washington State quarterback Gardner Minshew completed 468 of 662 attempts (70.7%) for 4,779 yards with 38 touchdowns and nine interceptions. Marino, playing in a college offense that usually required deeper throws into tighter windows, averaged more per attempt than Minshew did completing passes at a high rate in a much more QB-friendly offense.
Baker Mayfield is the perfect quarterback for Odell Beckham Jr.
Cleveland’s new offensive duo is ready to take over the league. It’s still sinking in that the Cleveland Browns will be a must-watch team this season. They finally have a star quarterback in Baker Mayfield, which has given them the flexibility to be aggressive with their roster construction. The biggest move they made to attack their current playoff window was to trade for Odell Beckham Jr. at the start of the new league year. The Beckham trade gives the Browns a potentially dominant offensive duo, something the wide receiver is amped about.
So what might Marino have done? He probably would have completed a much higher percentage of his passes, and he threw a better deep ball than any quarterback Leach has coached. Kyler Murray averaged an obscene 11.6 yards an attempt playing in Lincoln Riley’s Leach-based offense at Oklahoma. It’s conceivable Marino could get close to that number, but because Marino couldn’t run like Murray and wouldn’t have a line like Murray had, he would have been throwing at least 40 times a game. The yardage and touchdown totals would have been astronomical.
I love the pairing of Vick and Malzahn. Vick had an even better arm than Cam Newton and was faster than Nick Marshall, so that would have made him ideal for Malzahn’s offense. Pair him with a decent back, and defenses would have been so terrified of the run game that Vick would have been throwing to single-covered (or wide-open) receivers all day. Vick would have been virtually unstoppable in Malzahn’s offense.
How the 32 quarterbacks who have won the Super Bowl performed as rookies
There have been 32 quarterbacks to win Super Bowls. Some started quickly and others no as fast. How did they perform as rookies?
I like the fit of Young in the Meyer/Dan Mullen offense, but the players I would have love to have seen play in that scheme are Daunte Culpepper and Jared Lorenzen. Culpepper was 6'4" and 255 pounds with a phenomenal arm and decent speed. Imagine him running the plays Tim Tebow ran at Florida. Culpepper might have led the nation in passing and rushing touchdowns in that offense. The same goes for Lorenzen, whose freakish athleticism has gotten lost in the rubbernecking that has accompanied his ballooning weight in later life. At Kentucky, Lorenzen was 6'3" and 288 pounds, but he moved like a player 60 pounds lighter and threw a magnificent deep ball. That would have been devastating to defenses trying to combat the single-wing concepts in the Meyer/Mullen offense. If they loaded the box, Lorenzen would have launched balls over the top. If they tried to help the secondary, Lorenzen would have surged forward for five or more yards every play.
All of these pairings would have been glorious. That is why we need to truly appreciate when an actual quarterback/coach pairing is perfect like theone last year.
The dichotomy of paying Dak Prescott and why it needs to happen
Pay that man his money.
When, if ever, will we see UCLA and USC both ranked in the top 10 at the same time?
There is enough talent in Southern California—and USC and UCLA have enough cachet to recruit elsewhere—that stocking the roster of two top-10 teams simultaneously is definitely doable. The question is whether the two programs will ever have two coaches simultaneously who can pull off the feat.
We know UCLA’s Chip Kelly can build a top-10 program. He did it at Oregon. He’ll need more time to overhaul the Bruins’ roster to get them there, but the improvement that team showed as last season progressed—highlighted by a late-season win against USC—suggests Kelly has UCLA moving in the desired direction.
We know USC can land top-10 talent, and the recruiting rankings suggest the Trojans have something close to that right now. I thinkwill allow USC to take full advantage of a deep group of offensive skill position players. The issue in Troy is on both lines of scrimmage. USC has underachieved on the offensive and defensive lines throughout the Clay Helton era. If the Trojans want to get back into the top 10 consistently, then they’ll need to prove they can play well up front consistently.
So yes, it is possible for both teams to build top-10 programs. The question is whether Helton will be able to hang in long enough to help do his part for USC.
At age 42, even a mediocre year would be unprecedented for Tom Brady
When Tom Brady had a good season last year at the age of 41, he was doing something exceedingly rare in the NFL, but not totally unprecedented.
The thinking seems to be that the Olympic model for paying players would help the five-stars the most, but isn’t it great for position groups? The offensive line endorsing steakhouses, local roofers using the DBs in commercials (good coverage), etc.?
Wouldn’t an insurance agent want to use the DBs to advertise good coverage? And would you know you have a problem in the secondary if a diner wanted to hire the DBs to advertise its toast? We’re going to see a lot of questions like this one as school and conference officials. It’s impossible to tell now how tight or loose any new rules would be, but I’m not sure this sort of thing would happen during any early iterations.
I do think a more loose system is inevitable eventually, though. When that happens, and we could be talking decades, it will make for some delightfully cheesy commercials. But here’s one ad I know would never have happened in any era. The members of the 2007 Appalachian State offensive line would have flat refused to endorse the Brazilian steakhouse where they dined the Thursday. Just because a bunch of large men won’t stop asking for more meat doesn’t mean it’s O.K. to shorten the cooking time.
Related slideshow: Early Top 25 college football teams for 2019 (Provided by USA Today Sports)
Moore’s mystery offense could unleash Prescott’s potential.
Why former QB and ESPN analyst Dan Orlovsky thinks the Cowboys 2019 offensive hopes begin with Dak Prescott, and end with Kellen Moore.
Ranking the NFL QB's from Worst to First | NFL Highlights
Around the NFL's Gregg Rosenthal ranks all 32 starting QB's from worst to first following the 2017 NFL Regular Season. Watch full games with NFL Game Pass: ...
Best Throws & Worst Fails from Non-QB Passes in the 2017 NFL Season | NFL Highlights
During the 2017 NFL Season 26 non-quarterbacks attempted at least one pass. Some worked out great, some however did not. Check out every non-qb pass ...
Sunday, 20 october 2019
All people, ponies involved are fine after human-error […]
Sunday, 20 october 2019
Cooper served as an MLB umpire for 21 years.No cause of death had been revealed as of Sunday […]
Monday, 21 october 2019
As the NFL approaches its midseason point, several contenders are rounding into top form while others are getting desperate.The 32 things we learned from Week 7 of the 2019 NFL […]
Saturday, 19 october 2019
Oklahoma's Sooner Schooner tips over while celebrating TDAs is custom at Oklahoma home games, the Schooner took a quick lap on the field after the score. But as the schooner made its turn back toward the tunnel the radius was a little too tight and the schooner took quite the […]
Sunday, 20 october 2019
Heisman front-runner suffered an apparent ankle injury in first half of Tennessee […]
Tuesday, 22 october 2019
Randy Moss takes a perfect dig at Joe Buck's infamous 'disgusting act' […]
Monday, 21 october 2019
Two of Palmer's original colleagues at the network — Chris Berman and Bob Ley — remembered his contributions as "a true ESPN […]
Sunday, 20 october 2019
Things got chippy between Clemson and Louisville and Dabo Swinney is not pleased with one of his players throwing a punch. […]