Sport The NFL's current playoff seeding system is unfair and needs to be scrapped

01:00  05 december  2019
01:00  05 december  2019 Source:   touchdownwire.usatoday.com

AP source: NBA, teams, union discuss shortening season

  AP source: NBA, teams, union discuss shortening season The NBA may be closer to a shorter season, a new postseason format and the in-season tournament Commissioner Adam Silver has long wanted as well. A person familiar with the negotiations said Saturday the NBA is working with the players’ union and its teams on a plan to shorten the regular season, possibly to 78 games. (AP Photo/Jae C.

Let me start this off by saying that any of these teams making the playoffs is unlikely. They have to be perfect — or near-perfect — from here on out. Advertisement. Most Popular. The NFL ' s current playoff seeding system is unfair and needs to be scrapped . 15 cities that could possibly get an

New, 26 comments. NBA Playoff seeding is unfair , but Even if open seeding fails, a play -in round of some sort a la Major League Baseball seems worth pursuing. How the Dolphins can accidentally make the playoffs while tanking The Dolphins’ chances at pulling off the NFL equivalent of the movie

Two games threw the NFC’s playoff seeding system into a tizzy over the last couple of days. The 49ers’ 20-17 loss to the Ravens, and the Seahawks’ 37-30 win over the Vikings knocked San Francisco from first to fifth, and took Seattle to the second spot, behind New Orleans. Fair enough at the top, as Seattle and the Saints each have 10-2 records, and the Seahawks lost to the Saints, 33-27, in Week 3.

a group of baseball players playing a football game© Provided by Touchdown Wire

But things are not quite so fair at the bottom of the conference’s current seeding system. If the regular season ended today, the 49ers, who also have a 10-2 record with losses to the Ravens and Seahawks, would travel to Dallas during the wild-card round to face the Cowboys, who currently lead the NFC East with a record of… 6-6.

Dabo rants about unfair treatment by CFP: 'They don't want us there'

  Dabo rants about unfair treatment by CFP: 'They don't want us there' Clemson head coach Dabo Swinney suggested that his team is being held to an unfair standard in the College Football Playoff race."Obviously, if we lose this game, they are going to kick us out," said Swinney about the importance of the win over the in-state rival, per ESPN's Chris Low. "They don't want us there anyway. We'd drop to 20 (had Clemson lost to South Carolina).

Schedule and Standings for the NFL Playoffs . What would the NFL Playoffs look like if the season ended today? Find out now with NFL ' s Playoff Picture. NFL Playoff Picture. In The Hunt. Tiebreaking Procedures.

To me the NFL playoff system seems a little unfair due to the poor NFC west. How can a team with a (i think so, not 100%) 6-9 record have a shot at the playoffs 1. every division has gone threw slumps ( who ever u go for will eventually need to rebuild to remember players retire and dynasties end ).

Yes, indeed. Kyle Shanahan’s team has lost one game in the conference, but they’d have to go on the road to play a team with four fewer victories, and three conference losses. One could argue in Dallas’ favor that they’re 4-0 in their own division, but these days, about the only teams that can’t beat NFC East teams are other NFC East teams.

Jimmy Kempski of PhilyVoice.com laid it all out nicely here:

Kempski also pointed out that when NFC East teams play outside their division through the first 13 weeks of the 2019 season, they have a 10-26 record. Meanwhile, the 49ers have gone through a comparative buzzsaw, especially in their own division, and the Cowboys get to host them?

Payback: OU's Andrews trolls Ohio State's Bosa with flag plant celebration

  Payback: OU's Andrews trolls Ohio State's Bosa with flag plant celebration Payback: OU's Andrews trolls Ohio State's Bosa with flag plant celebrationA few years ago, Baker Mayfield planted the Oklahoma flag on Ohio State’s field after the Sooners beat the Buckeyes. Then this season, when San Francisco 49ers defensive end and former Ohio State star Nick Bosa dragged down Mayfield, he got up and mimicked that celebration as payback.

Does the NFL need to change its overtime rules? Kiz: I have long been on record as saying the NFL ’ s overtime rules are unfair , to say nothing of stupid. The league has stacked the rules so high in favor of offense for so long that both quarterbacks deserve to touch the football at least once in

The current college football playoff system needs to be tweaked and reworked immediately. Conference championship are also a pointless extra game that

Based on what? The ill-conceived idea of divisional supremacy. A few years back, the NFL’s schedule-makers weighted the last month of the season to inter-divisional games, to make those races more interesting. It was a great idea, but it also illustrates the advantage a team like Dallas has down the stretch. In their last four games, the Cowboys will play the Bears, Rams, Eagles, and Redskins. Philadelphia and Washington, the two other NFC East teams on that schedule, have a combined record of 8-16. Have we also mentioned that Dallas hasn’t beaten a team with a winning record all season?

Meanwhile, in their last four games, the 49ers face the Saints, Falcons, Rams, and Seahawks. Those last two opponents are also in the NFC West, and they have a combined record of 17-7.

Not exactly fair.

There’s one way to easily alter the current system, and though it may take the spark out of division championships, that’s a concept without much spark these days. Ask the 2010 Saints, who finished their regular season 11-5, but had to go on the road to play a 7-9 Seahawks team because Seattle had won an NFC West that didn’t have a single team with a winning record, and the Saints were in an NFC South with a 13-3 Falcons squad, and a 10-6 Buccaneers team.

6 teams sitting at 7-5 or worse that could make a push to the playoffs

  6 teams sitting at 7-5 or worse that could make a push to the playoffs 6 teams sitting at 7-5 or worse that could make a push to the playoffsCredit: Mark J.

Kevin Clark: The NFL desperately needs to change the way the playoffs are structured. Everyone, it seems, is getting smarter. And yet, the NFL can't figure out how to get the best teams in the playoffs .

i know it all follows some sort of system , but the 8-8 Chargers shouldn't be in the playoffs if the 11-5 patriots arent. i mean, theyre in the same conference. i nkow the chargers won I know even though some times I do think it' s unfair .. the Chargers and other 8-8 teams don't deserve to be in the playoffs .

Just as there was no way Seattle should have hosted that game (the “Beastquake” notwithstanding), there is no way the 49ers, or any other team whose situation is better than Dallas’, should have to travel to JerryWorld in the wild-card round.

So, let the NFL have its division champions, but take division wins out of the seeding process. Factor in everything else — overall records, head-to-head records, records against common opponents, strength of victory, strength of schedule, net points, net touchdowns, et al. But remove the divisional tie-breakers altogether, because they don’t make sense. There is no way a divisionao tie-breaker can work when one division has a point differential of plus-139, and another division has a point differential of minus-162.

Were the current seeds to be worked without divisional factors, it would look like this:


1. Baltimore Ravens (10-2)

2. New England Patriots (10-2)

3. Buffalo Bills (9-3)

4. Houston Texans (8-4)

5. Kansas City Chiefs (8-4)

6. Pittsburgh Steelers (7-3)

The only problem I see here is that the Bills leap over the Texans and Chiefs (who are slotted based on head-to-head win percentage) with their overall record, but their strength of schedule (.368) is by far the worst of any playoff entrant. But that’s the only alteration we’re making in the AFC seed — the Steelers would rank sixth based on their record, and that they have a better record than Tennessee (7-5) in conference games.

How conference championship weekend could alter the CFP picture

  How conference championship weekend could alter the CFP picture Can any team lose and still make the College Football Playoff?It's conference championship weekend, and there are huge College Football Playoff implications for these matchups, particularly regarding the Big 12 and Pac-12 title games.

The ‘e-gate’ system is intended to form a part of the Border Force’ s ‘ ongoing digital transformation of border controls ’. Scrapping already on the cards. The final decision to scrap landing cards altogether comes after the government announced it was extending the use of e-gates at UK borders.

NFL Playoff System ? Yo man, me and my guys have a Madden League . And last year we were using a different system to determine divisions But this year we done switched up and started using the NFL ' s real tiebreaker and division/conference seeding system . Which has caused some confusion.


1. New Orleans Saints (10-2)

2. Seattle Seahawks (10-2)

3. San Francisco 49ers (10-2)

4. Green Bay Packers (9-3)

5. Minnesota Vikings (8-4)

6. Los Angeles Rams (7-5)

No Cowboys? No problem. As has been proven, there’s no reason for the Cowboys, or any other NFC East team, to be anywhere near the postseason as it currently stands. Now, here’s where the NFC seeding gets interesting. The 49ers and Saints face off in Week 14. Currently, a San Francisco win would give Seattle the one-seed if the Seahawks beat the Rams. But if the 49ers win? It’s a different ballgame. San Francisco would become the second seed, and that would give even more weight to the Week 17 game between Seattle and San Francisco. But as it stands, the 49ers can beat the Saints by 300 points, and it won’t matter. They’re stuck in fifth because of that pesky Cowboys thing.

The NBA already took this step a few years back. In September, 2015, Commissioner Adam Silver announced that team owners had voted to remove divisional seeding, and instead reward teams based on their records. This happened after the Portland Trail Blazers were given the fourth seed in the Western Conference despite a 51-win record that would have put them behind the 55-win San Antonio Spurs, but because Portland won the Northwest Division, and the Spurs came second to the Houston Rockets in the Southwest Division, San Antonio got an unfair disadvantage, and fell to the Los Angeles Clippers in the first round of the playoffs.

How long do we have to wait until Jerry Jones fires Jason Garrett?

  How long do we have to wait until Jerry Jones fires Jason Garrett? It has to be a matter of when, not if. So why wait?Why wait?

Using the current playoff system , it is very likely that whoever wins the AFC championship is going to win The BCS creates unfair situations and that ' s one of the only reasons why I don't care for College football . nah most people will tell that current nfl playoff system is the best in all of sports. over

2019-20 NFL playoff picture seeds and scenarios. See the NFL Playoffs standings and wild card game schedule if the season ended today. The NFL playoffs are not based on a pure bracket system . In the divisional playoffs , the No. 1 seed is assured of playing the lowest- seeded Wild Card

The NBA also made other changes to their playoff format, making head-to-head results the first criteria for playoff seeding and home-court advantage between two teams with the same regular-season records. The next criteria? Whether a team won its division or not. That’s as it should be. The more you win, the better your seeding should be. And if you believe that this idea somehow reduces the magnitude of the divisional concept… well, if the system doesn’t work, you change the system. No matter how much tradition seems to be in the way.


6 teams sitting at 7-5 or worse that could make a push to the playoffs

NFC Playoff picture heading into Week 14

NFL Week 14: How to survive and advance in your knockout pool

NFL 2019: Report cards for all 32 teams after three-quarters of the season

Best candidates to replace Ron Rivera, others soon to come

Man arrested for shooting at two duck hunters .
Man arrested for shooting at two duck hunters

—   Share news in the SOC. Networks

Topical videos:

usr: 3
This is interesting!