Sport Ruling on the rules: Should MLB keep seven-inning doubleheaders in future seasons?

02:32  19 september  2020
02:32  19 september  2020 Source:   sports.yahoo.com

Veteran IF Neil Walker elects free agency after clearing waivers

  Veteran IF Neil Walker elects free agency after clearing waivers Although Walker wasn’t particularly sharp with the Phillies, he notched a solid .261/.344/.395 batting line with the Marlins just last year. He was also a consistently productive hitter from 2010-17, slashing a combined .273/.342/.439 in 4294 plate appearances between the Pirates, Mets and Brewers. He’ll be eligible to sign with any club for the duration of the season should he choose. If he does latch on with a new club by Tuesday, he’d still be eligible for his new club’s postseason roster.Subscribe to Yardbarker's Morning Bark, the most comprehensive newsletter in sports.

This week, with most of a shortened season in the rearview mirror, Yahoo Sports is reviewing the temporary rule changes MLB put in place for 2020. The question is simple: Should they stick around permanently?

Up next: Doubleheaders have consisted of seven-inning games in 2020. Is that a change worth keeping?

Lose the seven-inning doubleheaders

By Zach Crizer

Baseball — in the widest definition of the word, the one that encompasses the subculture of people who care about and talk about the sport — has a self-flagellation problem. That’s why we are forced to discuss the idea that some portion of the games should be intentionally cut, by rule, from nine innings to seven innings.

Nationals place Adam Eaton on 10-day IL with broken finger

  Nationals place Adam Eaton on 10-day IL with broken finger Say Their Stories: John Saunders as told by Cleveland Browns defensive end Myles Garrett.

There is a constant undercurrent of concern, of self-consciousness, over the perception that more people used to like the sport. That more people could be invested in the sport if only something were different, if one switch were flipped.

The current one up for consideration: Cutting literal innings out of games. Not only does this misunderstand the potential issue — pace of play, not length of games — just think about how it would sound in a sport that isn’t so hung up on its appeal to the unengaged, to the people not investing time, money and emotional energy.

“Hello, NFL fans. Announcement: Next season, Thursday night games will not have a fourth quarter, in service of people who currently do not care about the league.”

Lopping off 22.2 percent of some games to chase the attention of people who aren’t interested right now. That’s the pitch. It’s diminishing the experience for the audience that does dedicate itself to the game, all in a foolhardy attempt to attract more casual fans into the sport’s orbit.

Dakota Hudson to undergo MRI on elbow

  Dakota Hudson to undergo MRI on elbow Shane Bieber threw 10 strikeouts over 7 2/3 inning, earning the win in the Indians 10-3 win over the Tigers.

[Ruling on the rules: The extra-innings rule]

Now, it can be argued that doubleheaders are a small enough portion of the schedule — in seasons not discombobulated by a pandemic — that the effect of the change would be small. Agreed! Which only underscores the reasons to skip this nonsensical tweak to the fundamental rules of the game.

There are three products that Major League Baseball sells to fans:

  • The experience of watching an individual game (or two) on any given day.

  • The experience of following a season.

  • The experience of following the sport across time and eras.

It might be the case that 14 innings of baseball in a single day is an easier hang than 18 innings, but the benefit to Product No. 1 on those days is not worth the detriment to Products No. 2 and No. 3. As any season — especially this 60-game season — illuminates to those paying attention, baseball is a game of small margins that accumulate over time. The difference between a juggernaut and a rebuilding club is often not apparent in the result of one game, or one series or even one month of play.

Red Sox chairman: 'We expect to be competitive next year'

  Red Sox chairman: 'We expect to be competitive next year' Although the Red Sox had a down year, the powers that be within the club expect them to be competitive next season.The Red Sox are 19-33, a record that puts them in last place in the AL East and 28th of 30 teams (ahead of only the Pirates and Rangers) in winning percentage.  Injuries were indeed a factor as Werner mentioned, most notably Chris Sale being lost to Tommy John surgery and Eduardo Rodriguez missing the entire season after developing myocarditis stemming from a bout of COVID-19.  While the pitching staff never recovered from the loss of those key arms, there were also issues on the position-player side, as the likes of J.D.

Trevor Bauer in a baseball uniform throwing a ball: Reds starter Trevor Bauer has been able to win two seven-inning games on his own without turning to a dicey bullpen. It could help Cincinnati squeak into October. (AP Photo/Gene J. Puskar) © Provided by Yahoo! Sports Reds starter Trevor Bauer has been able to win two seven-inning games on his own without turning to a dicey bullpen. It could help Cincinnati squeak into October. (AP Photo/Gene J. Puskar)

Yes, doubleheaders are rarely scheduled, and by recent standards outside of 2020 wouldn’t alter the complexion of a team’s record all that much. (As someone is undoubtedly yelling, some games are shortened by rain. Of course, but no one can plan a roster based on rain arriving in the sixth inning.) Codifying seven-inning twin bills, however, cements a double standard and hints at an intention to use more of them. It creates advantages that spring from circumstance rather than intent.

The 2020 Cincinnati Reds, for instance, have a 4.77 bullpen ERA that ranks in the bottom third of MLB, and a 3.70 rotation ERA that ranks sixth. Trevor Bauer alone has thrown two shutouts in seven-inning games this season, without having to risk turning over his lead to a subpar relief corps. Their 9-3 record in games that are only 77.7 percent as long as the unit of a game that everyone planned for might win them a place in October.

Padres activate 1B Eric Hosmer off IL

  Padres activate 1B Eric Hosmer off IL Hosmer has been fantastic through 128 plate appearances this season, hitting .288/.344/.552 with eight home runs. That’s a notable step up from the roughly average offensive production the big-ticket free agent acquisition managed his first two seasons in Southern California. The 33-19 Padres are essentially locked in as the fourth seed in the National League, and Hosmer will have a little more than a week to ramp back up before the start of the postseason. Patiño has scuffled in his first 14.2 MLB innings, but he’s one of the game’s brightest young pitching talents.

Lowering the threshold for some wins, and altering the concept of what constitutes a game, throws a wrench into the races that provide the adrenaline to most of baseball’s schedule. It adds an unnecessary wrinkle to the comparative statistics and records that create the sport’s singular historic tapestry.

In 2020, it’s an understandable greasing of the skids to keep a difficult season on the rails. As a permanent, ongoing rule, it’s an abdication of the sport’s purpose. If MLB’s contention is that the season is not meant to be a rigorous attempt to identify the best teams, well, that’s an opinion. But without the panicky veneer of Growing The Game, it’s not one that anyone would dare say aloud.

Keep the seven-inning doubleheaders

By Hannah Keyser

Unlike some of the other experimental rule changes in baseball this season, I don’t know that we would have gotten a seven-inning doubleheader at the big league level without the specific storm of circumstances that is a short, dense season, a still-raging pandemic that forces semi-regular postponements of entire series, and the kind of infectious disease that makes gathering in one place for extended periods of time especially problematic.

And those games have proven to be delightfully breezy. Lopping off two innings feels like an overly blunt, crude solution to the ever-expanding length of games. But could it really be that simple to solve the waning attention span/waxing game time predicament that has become an existential threat to the game? Just … make the games shorter?

Phillies prospect Adonis Medina expected to make MLB debut Sunday

  Phillies prospect Adonis Medina expected to make MLB debut Sunday -

[Ruling on the rules: The universal DH]

I think the fallacy there would be in thinking that if some games are seven innings, they all have to be.

If there weren’t about a dozen other competing and more globally memorable epitaphs, the 2020 baseball season would be defined by the sheer number of doubleheaders played relative to the overall schedule. This year, teams will play a widely variable number of doubleheaders based on who suffered COVID-19 outbreaks and who they were scheduled to play at that time. Like a lot else about 2020, that’s pretty unfair. But now that we know baseball games can be seven innings long without Abner Doubleday rising from the dead, there’s an opportunity to deploy them strategically going forward.

There are, in the broadest sense, three groups of stakeholders whose opinions should influence baseball’s rules and potential rule changes — “should” is doing a lot of work in this sentence, unfortunately. The players, the owners, and the fans.

The seven-inning doubleheader has some clear benefits that I’ll get to, but perhaps even more crucially, it has few if any detriments to any of those stakeholders. If the existing option is to play 18 innings (at least) in a single day, players would certainly prefer to have twin bills scheduled to last only 14 innings. As long as they remain split from a ticket standpoint (which they shouldn’t but that’s a losing battle not worth fighting), owners are only losing out on a couple of innings of beer sales, and I’m sorry but that’s not compelling. For fans, back-to-back seven-inning games offer both all-day baseball and the chance to drop in for a full game that’s reliably under three hours.

Blue Jays hoping for bullpen help for postseason race

  Blue Jays hoping for bullpen help for postseason race After a rough three-game sweep at the hands of the Yankees, the Toronto Blue Jays have lost six in a row and fallen into the final qualifying wild card spot in the American League. Now trailing the Yankees by 5 games for second place, the Toronto/Buffalo Blue Jays are pretty well locked into their current spot in the standings, with Fangraphs giving them a 0.9% chance to re-take 2nd place from the Yankees, but a 91.5% chance to hold off the Mariners, Angels, and Tigers for the final playoff spot in the American League postseason bracket. Though they share a record with the Astros, Houston should secure 2nd place in the AL West.

It also doesn’t feel all that different within the game itself. This is tough to quantify, but take it from someone who has spent weeks asking managers around the sport if the strategy materially changes in a seven-inning game. If there was an interesting answer, you’d be reading that piece right now instead of this. For the most part, managers have shrugged and said it’s just two fewer innings, the game feels like it goes by faster because it does, you gotta make sure your relievers know to be ready sooner.

a baseball player throwing a ball: Harkening to a different age when starting pitchers were the main attraction and expected to last the whole game, Adam Wainwright tossed a complete game in a seven-inning doubleheader matchup vs. the Brewers. (AP Photo/Morry Gash) © Provided by Yahoo! Sports Harkening to a different age when starting pitchers were the main attraction and expected to last the whole game, Adam Wainwright tossed a complete game in a seven-inning doubleheader matchup vs. the Brewers. (AP Photo/Morry Gash)

If you subscribe to the concern that each individual moment of regular season baseball does not, currently, have enough inherent stakes, shortening the game is one way to make each inning or at-bat literally matter more to the overall pursuit of a win. As an emergency measure, this favors some clubs more than others. If it was made permanent, it might affect overall roster construction. But ultimately, this shouldn’t appreciably change the on-field product from a viewer perspective.

So why bother doing it at all? Well, because seven-inning doubleheaders can be baked into a schedule as a way of accommodating more off days without sacrificing games or altering the span of the baseball calendar.

The baseball season is, I’m sorry to say, too long. It’s brutal on players’ bodies and the overarching narrative of a given year is probably determined by injuries more than we’d even like to accept. The grind is part of the game, but at a nearly daily clip it’s almost certainly hit the point of diminishing returns. If you want to see the best athletes consistently play at their peak ability, there needs to be a little more rest.

Right now, doubleheaders don’t help. They’re largely a last resort that drain teams of their depth. The relatively subtle shift to seven-inning doubleheaders allows for more flexibility around potential postponements and more intentional off days without the usual adverse effects.

Advocating for less baseball is inherently a bit of a bummer and any change in the rules creates the issue of comparing across eras. But total innings — when games can always go to extras or be curtailed by weather — are already more fungible team-to-team and year-to-year than total games. Seven-inning doubleheaders are appealing precisely because they’re minimally disruptive to the spirit of the sport.

If anything, there’s something sort of nostalgic about a game that lasts as long as the starting pitcher. I mean, have you seen the state of most bullpens this season?

More from Yahoo Sports:

  • Goodwill: Heat turn tables on frustrated Celtics

  • Joe Buck surprised with Pro Football Hall of Fame award

  • Giannis wins second straight MVP

Rob Manfred planning for fans to attend NLCS, 2020 World Series .
MLB is planning for fans to be in attendance for the NLCS and World Series at Globe Life Field in Texas. MLB commissioner Rob Manfred told USA Today:“We are pressing ahead to have fans in Texas. One of the most important things to our game is the presence of fans. Starting down the path of having fans in stadiums, and in a safe and risk-free environment, is very, very important to our game.’’Tickets are expected to go on sale soon. As for the American League Championship Series in Southern California, fans will be a no go. California Gov.

—   Share news in the SOC. Networks
usr: 1
This is interesting!