•   
  •   
  •   

USProsecutors in Laquan McDonald coverup trial say Chicago cops failed to obey the law

01:40  07 december  2018
01:40  07 december  2018 Source:   usatoday.com

Jason Van Dyke loses bid for new trial for Laquan McDonald's murder

Jason Van Dyke loses bid for new trial for Laquan McDonald's murder Van Dyke faces between four years and 20 years behind bars when he is sentenced in January.

The murder of Laquan McDonald took place on October 20, 2014, in Chicago , Illinois, when the 17-year-old African American was fatally shot by Chicago Police Officer Jason Van Dyke.

Laquan McDonald (right) walks down the street moments before being shot by Officer Jason Van Dyke in Chicago According to the indictment, the men knew that a "public airing of the events surrounding Laquan All three men are accused of failing to locate at least three witnesses who might present a

Prosecutors in Laquan McDonald coverup trial say Chicago cops failed to obey the law© Provided by USA TODAY, a division of Gannett Satellite Information Network, Inc.

CHICAGO – Prosecutors said Thursday that three Chicago police officers accused of conspiring to cover up the controversial shooting death of 17-year-old Laquan McDonald failed to abide by the cardinal rule of policing: Obey the law.

Defense attorneys pushed back, saying the officers did their level best to report on what they witnessed in the October 2014 confrontation, and had become victims of an overzealous prosecution driven by a hyper-politicized, anti-police climate in the nation's third-largest city.

The Latest: Officer: Reports on shooting citing her are lies

The Latest: Officer: Reports on shooting citing her are lies A Chicago police officer says comments attributed to her in a department report about the fatal shooting of Laquan McDonald were lies. Officer Dora Fontaine testified Wednesday in the trial of Thomas Gaffney, David March and Joseph Walsh. Prosecutors allege the three concocted a version of the shooting to protect Officer Jason Van Dyke, who was convicted of second-degree murder earlier this year. Fontaine testified she saw the shooting of McDonald on Oct. 20, 2014. She said she told March what she saw: "Male black walking southbound, swaying the knife, twisting, falling.

CHICAGO — A judge has denied defense requests for directed acquittals in the trial of three Chicago police Prosecutors earlier Tuesday rested their case after a witness read emails that they contend suggest Live stream of trial for 3 Chicago cops accused in Laquan McDonald shooting cover - up .

CHICAGO – Prosecutors said Chicago Police Officer Jason Van Dyke showed no regard for More: Chicago cop on trial for Laquan McDonald killing testifies: 'His eyes were bugging out'. Police say McDonald did not comply with repeated orders to drop the weapon and continued to wind his way

The sides made their closing arguments Thursday in the trial of Officer Thomas Gaffney, former Officer Joseph Walsh and former Detective David March for conspiracy, obstruction of justice and official misconduct.

The officers opted for a bench trial. That means their fate will be decided by Cook County Associate Judge Domenica Stephenson, not a jury.

Prosecutors say the officers filed false reports to protect fellow Officer Jason Van Dyke.

Van Dyke, who shot the black teen 16 times, was found guilty in October by a Chicago jury of second-degree murder and 16 counts of aggravated battery. He awaits sentencing.

“Obey the law,” special prosecutor Patricia Brown Holmes said in her closing statement Thursday. “That’s what police officers learn through their rules and regulations. Don’t do things you arrest people for doing: Lying, cheating, falsifying, violating the law.”

Chicago officers accused in Van Dyke cover-up to stand trial

Chicago officers accused in Van Dyke cover-up to stand trial A trial is set to begin for one current and two former Chicago police officers accused of trying to cover up what happened when a white officer fatally shot black teenager Laquan McDonald. 

Laquan McDonald .NBC Chicago . Chicago police Officer Jason Van Dyke at a February hearing on the shooting of of Laquan McDonald .Antonio Perez / AP Pool. "The indictment makes clear that these defendants did more than merely obey an unofficial 'code of silence,'" the special prosecutor

Officer in Laquan McDonald shooting pleads not guilty. DOJ investigating Chicago Police Department. Justice Department announces Chicago PD Police statements that McDonald was threatening Van Dyke with his knife were also lies, the document says . The indictment also says the officers failed to

James McKay, an attorney for March, countered that "following the law was a foreign concept to Laquan McDonald" on the night of the encounter.

“Thank God, we're in a courtroom,” McKay said. “A courtroom where evidence matters. Not outside noise. Not misinformation. Evidence matters here. Not labels, promoted by people that weren’t there.”

Van Dyke was the only officer to open fire on McDonald. But prosecutors say Gaffney, March and Walsh provided or signed off on inaccurate reports that the teen lunged at Van Dyke with a knife and described officers as victims of an assault by McDonald.

Police dashcam video of the incident shows McDonald veering away from Van Dyke when he opened fire, and witness testimony also contradicted the officers’ description, prosecutors say.

The shooting of McDonald, a troubled teen who had been in and out of the juvenile justice system, widened the chasm between police and Chicago's African-American residents. It's one of several deadly confrontations nationwide that has sparked a broader conversation about policing in black communities.

Prosecutors finish case against officers accused of cover-up

Prosecutors finish case against officers accused of cover-up Prosecutors in the trial of three Chicago police officers charged with lying about the shooting of black teenager Laquan McDonald have rested their case. The move Tuesday came after a witness read emails that prosecutors contend suggest the officers' superiors were intent on protecting the white police officer who fired the fatal shots. The emails between a lieutenant and sergeant are part of prosecutors' attempt to show a widespread effort to protect Jason Van Dyke. But none of the emails were to or from the three officers charged with official misconduct, obstruction of justice and conspiracy.

Special prosecutor alleges officers lied to prevent investigators from learning the truth. Three Chicago police officers were indicted on felony charges that they conspired to cover actions by a white police officer who shot and killed 17-year-old Laquan McDonald .

High-profile trial for Chicago officer who shot Laquan McDonald . Conflicting Stories in Laquan McDonald Police Conspiracy Case. NBC 5 investigates the alleged cop cover - up trial . Another email indicated that Ron Hosko, the president of the Washington D.C. based Law Enforcement Legal

City leaders resisted releasing footage of the shooting until they were ordered by a court to do so. Its release more than a year after the shooting spurred protests.

Activists say an unofficial “code of silence” persists in the nation’s largest police department, allowing bad cops to act with impunity.

Mayor Rahm Emanuel said a “code of silence” had tarnished the department’s reputation and created a chasm between officers and the community.

Emanuel introduced a series of police reforms in the aftermath of the shooting. Still, he saw his standing in the city's African-American community plummet. He announced in September that he wouldn’t seek re-election.

More: Chicago Police Officer Jason Van Dyke guilty of second-degree murder in 2014 shooting death of 17-year-old Laquan McDonald

More: Prosecutors: Chicago cops betrayed oath in covering up the shooting death of Laquan McDonald

Column: Guilty verdict in Van Dyke case reinforces need for transparent policing

Attorneys for the officers said there was no conspiracy. At worst, they said, the men made minor errors in writing their reports. They said the prosecutors failed to show the officers collaborated, and claimed the prosecution was politically motivated.

Judge: Verdict in cop cover-up trial should come Dec. 19

Judge: Verdict in cop cover-up trial should come Dec. 19 A judge will analyze dashcam video of the fatal police shooting of black teenager Laquan McDonald and review reports to determine if she believes three officers lied to protect the officer who shot him. 

Chicago cop who killed Laquan McDonald gets 16 new charges – 1 for every bullet fired. She said the grand jury’s investigation was not yet complete. The indictments stem from the initial “The indictment makes clear that these defendants did more than merely obey an unofficial ‘code of silence

A Cook County special prosecutor has indicted three Chicago police officers on multiple charges in connection with the shooting death of Laquan McDonald in October of 2014. “The indictment makes clear that these defendants did more than merely obey an unofficial ‘code of silence,’ rather it alleges

McKay called the prosecution’s case “ridiculous” and witness testimony “a crock.” If March had wanted to cover for Van Dyke, he argued at one point during the trial, he would have tossed the video of the shooting “in the middle of Lake Michigan.”

“They didn’t prove anything in this (alleged) conspiracy,” McKay said.

Gaffney and his partner were among the first to respond to reports of a person breaking into vehicles in a truck lot on Chicago's Southwest Side. They said they encountered McDonald wielding the knife.

Authorities say McDonald had PCP in his system. He ignored repeated calls from police to drop the knife. Officers followed him for several blocks. At one point, he popped the tire of a police and scratched the windshield of Gaffney’s squad car.

Van Dyke and Walsh, partners on the night of the shooting, arrived together in a squad car. Van Dyke jumped out and within seconds opened fire.

Van Dyke told investigators that McDonald raised the knife in a menacing manner, and that he backpedaled as the teen approached. The police video does not support his account.

Walsh said he, too, "backed up" as McDonald got to within 12 to 15 feet of the officers, according to police documents. He said the teen "swung the knife toward the officers in an aggressive manner."

Unprecedented trial begins for 3 Chicago cops in alleged cover-up of Laquan McDonald shooting

Unprecedented trial begins for 3 Chicago cops in alleged cover-up of Laquan McDonald shooting The trial kicking off Tuesday over an alleged cover-up by Chicago police in the controversial killing of Laquan McDonald isn't just rare _ it's unprecedented. 

Mugshot of Jason Van Dyke, Chicago Police officer charged in the shooting of Laquan McDonald . But Emanuel, McCarthy, prosecutors , and the city of Chicago are only making these moves However, in December, the shooting was not forgotten, as the University of Chicago Law School and

NBC 5 investigates the alleged cop cover - up trial . Three officers are accused of lying about the night Jason Van Dyke killed Laquan McDonald . Closing out their case in a high-profile police corruption trial triggered by the killing, prosecutors presented a series of emails suggesting CPD brass circled

His attorney, Todd Pugh, maintained “it is demonstrably true that there were three officers that were victims of assault that night."

Gaffney, who requested that officers equipped with a taser come to the scene, indicated in an official post-incident report that Van Dyke and other officers were battered in the incident. No officers were hurt.

Holmes argued Gaffney should not have completed a form known as a tactical response report describing the officers as victims.

She noted that his partner, Joseph McElligott, testified in the Van Dyke trial that McDonald never made "any direct movement at me."

Still, Holmes said, Gaffney listed McElligott in his report as being assaulted by McDonald.

“He did so he could lend his voice to the choir that was singing for the justification of the killing of Laquan McDonald,” she said.

William Fahy, Gaffney’s defense attorney, said the officer might have made minor mistakes in his reporting, but the prosecution’s theory that the paperwork demonstrated an attempt to cover up the shooting “simply doesn’t make sense.”

Fahy said Gaffney did not witness the shooting, and his report was referring to  McDonald popping the tire and scratching the windshield of his squad car.

“I have yet to meet the perfect police officer, and I have yet to see a perfect police report,” Fahy said.

March, the lead detective, allegedly signed off on statements given by officers at the scene and indicated that there was no discrepancy between what the officers said happened and police dashcam video.

Witness contradicts police account of shooting of black teen

Witness contradicts police account of shooting of black teen A man who witnessed a Chicago officer fatally shoot black teenager Laquan McDonald testified Thursday that police waved him away without questioning him that October 2014 night and didn't even bother to take down his name. Jose Torres, testifying in the trial of three officers accused of lying to protect the white officer who shot McDonald, offered an account that contradicts what the officers wrote in their reports.

Prosecutors : Chicago cops betrayed oath in covering up the shooting death of Laquan McDonald . CHICAGO – The three police officers charged with conspiring to cover up a fellow officer's actions in the police shooting death He said the officers did their best in a difficult situation.

Chicago Police Superintendent Eddie Johnson said the department will also try to fire four other officers Alvarez, the top prosecutor in Cook County, claimed she decided to charge Van Dyke weeks ago but But, as Klinger said , "they basically say that the job of a cop is to protect people from violence And although critics argue that these legal standards give law enforcement a license to kill

Earl Briggs, an investigator for the Cook County Medical Examiner’s Officer, testified that March told him in a telephone conversation that McDonald lunged at Van Dyke before being shot. Briggs used that information to fill out a report for his office. He said he read the account back to March.

Chicago police Officer Dora Fontaine testified that March directed her to write that Van Dyke was injured by McDonald and attributed false statements to her in his reports.

McKay countered that it was unfathomable that March, who had not met Fontaine before the night of the McDonald shooting, would have enlisted her in a conspiracy.

Fontaine, who received immunity from prosecutors for her testimony, said she has been shunned by colleagues as a ‘rat, a snitch, a traitor."

Defense attorneys and Chicago’s Fraternal Order of Police, which paid for Fontaine’s legal counsel, painted her as lacking credibility.

"She has 90,000 reasons to lie, plus some benefits," said McKay, a reference to her salary.

Gaffney, March and Walsh declined to testify. Defense attorneys called a single witness, retired Detective Nancy Piekarski-Block. She testified that she was tasked with entering reports into the department's database, and that March did not have access to alter them after they were entered.

Special assistant prosecutor Ron Safer said the dashcam video disproved claims that officers were in imminent danger. He said the similarity of the officers’ inaccurate statements strongly suggest they collaborated to write false reports.

Walsh, Van Dyke and Gaffney all checked a box on their reports that McDonald committed a battery with a deadly weapon against them, Safer said. They also checked a box that McDonald used force against them that was likely to cause death or great bodily harm.

“How can three people get that identically wrong unless they have agreed to tell the same story?” Safer asked.

Prosecutors presented a series of emails sent and received by supervisors to suggest there was a broad effort within the department to help Van Dyke justify the shooting. None of the emails were written by the officers on trial.

Sgt. Daniel Gallagher, who was March’s boss, wrote to Lt. Anthony Wojcik weeks after the incident that police officers are “trained to shoot until the threat is eliminated, defeated or neutralized.”

“Officer did exactly what he was trained to do,” Gallagher wrote of Van Dyke. “We should be applauding him, not second-guessing him.”

In an April 2015 email, Ron Hosko, president of the Law Enforcement Legal Defense Fund, asked Wojcik, “Tony, any luck making the case go away?”

This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: Prosecutors in Laquan McDonald coverup trial say Chicago cops failed to obey the law

Trial into alleged police cover-up of Laquan McDonald shooting heads into crucial week.
If the three Chicago police officers accused of covering up Laquan McDonald's shooting get their way, they will walk out of court this week cleared of all charges before their lawyers call one witness. Shortly after the state rests its case, attorneys for former Detective David March, former Officer Joseph Walsh and Officer Thomas Gaffney are expected to ask Cook County Judge Domenica Stephenson for a "directed finding" - arguing that the prosecution case is so weak she must acquit the officers immediately. "The evidence is so lacking in this case, I submit this should be directed out," James McKay, March's attorney, said last week in his opening statement.

—   Share news in the SOC. Networks

Topical videos:

This is interesting!