US: As Passions Flare in Abortion Debate, Many Americans Say ‘It’s Complicated’ - PressFrom - US
  •   
  •   
  •   

USAs Passions Flare in Abortion Debate, Many Americans Say ‘It’s Complicated’

00:30  16 june  2019
00:30  16 june  2019 Source:   nytimes.com

CNN Poll: Abortion growing in importance for voters heading into 2020 election

CNN Poll: Abortion growing in importance for voters heading into 2020 election Three-in-10 Americans say they would only vote for a candidate for major office who shares their views on abortion.

"When it comes to the abortion debate , I think men should say it is a woman' s right to choose," he explains. "That is their body, that is their choice Around 60% of black and white Americans polled were also in support of legal abortion in most cases, though the support was lower among Hispanic

The Abortion Debate . Men and women have similar opinions. It ’ s hard to think of any other major political issue on which Americans ’ attitudes are as stable as they’ve been on abortion . This country has become so polarized that many Americans rarely talk about the subject with someone who has a

As Passions Flare in Abortion Debate, Many Americans Say ‘It’s Complicated’© Maddie McGarvey for The New York Times “It has become so loud, going both ways. And the divide is only getting bigger,” said Jeannie Wallace French, a Democrat who opposes abortion.

PITTSBURGH — Abortion is an issue that Lynndora Smith-Holmes goes back and forth on. “Six of one, half dozen of the other,” she said the other day as she finished her lunch break.

“Does it go back to people having abortions in back alleys? Haven’t we overcome that?” she asked, questioning the restrictive laws passed recently in states like Alabama and Kentucky.

Poll: More than half of Americans identify as pro-choice

Poll: More than half of Americans identify as pro-choice More than half of Americans now identify as "pro-choice" when it comes to abortion, according to a new NPR/PBS NewsHour/Marist poll released Friday. require(["medianetNativeAdOnArticle"], function (medianetNativeAdOnArticle) { medianetNativeAdOnArticle.getMedianetNativeAds(true); }); The poll found that 57 percent of Americans said they support abortion rights, while 35 percent of those surveyed said they were "pro-life," or against the procedure. A similar poll in January found that 55 percent of Americans considered themselves "pro-choice," while 38% identified as "pro-life.

But, abortion -rights advocate say , when does it become an individual, entitled to the same rights that you and I When does it become a person? That question has been the subject of public debate and court Many abortion -rights advocates thought that obtaining an abortion in the 21st century would

It ’ s not just that the pro- abortion -rights bloc of the GOP can’t seem to gain much ground in electing members of Congress who share its views — this But given that the plurality of Americans support abortion rights, Republicans with more liberal views on abortion aren’t alone. If the GOP moved to

At the same time, Ms. Smith-Holmes, who works for a day care center in the Allentown neighborhood of Pittsburgh and votes Democratic, said there should be limits. And she is not comfortable with the idea of taxpayer money going to fund abortions — a position that has become almost impossible to hold in the Democratic presidential primary. “Who’s paying for these?” she wondered.

The nuance in how Americans like Ms. Smith-Holmes view abortion has largely fallen out of the noisy national dialogue about when women should be able to end their pregnancies. Complex questions — of medicine, morality, personal empowerment and the proper role of government — are often reduced to the kind of all-or-nothing propositions that are ever more common in the polarized politics of the Trump era.

Poll: 77 percent say Supreme Court should uphold Roe v. Wade

Poll: 77 percent say Supreme Court should uphold Roe v. Wade More than three-quarters of Americans say they believe Roe v. Wade should be upheld, but a strong majority say they would like to see restrictions added to the ruling too, according to a new poll. require(["medianetNativeAdOnArticle"], function (medianetNativeAdOnArticle) { medianetNativeAdOnArticle.getMedianetNativeAds(true); }); An NPR/PBS NewsHour/Marist poll released Friday found that 77 percent of respondents said the Supreme Court should uphold the landmark decision that established a woman's right to abortion in some form. According to the poll, 26 percent of Americans want to keep Roe v.

The abortion debate deals with the rights and wrongs of deliberately ending a pregnancy before normal childbirth, killing the foetus in the process. It ' s one of the most polarising moral issues - most people are on one side or the other, very few are undecided.

Many Americans who pay taxes are opposed to abortion , therefore it ' s morally wrong to use tax dollars to fund abortion . Those who choose abortions are often minors or young women with insufficient life experience to understand fully what they are doing. Many have lifelong regrets afterward.

Sign Up for the Morning Briefing Newsletter

President Trump and the Republican Party are rallying their base by falsely portraying efforts to expand abortion rights in states like New York as condoning the murder of healthy full-term babies delivered by healthy mothers. The leading national organization for Republicans who support abortion access, Republican Majority for Choice, closed down last year, saying it saw no more space for common ground within the party.

As Passions Flare in Abortion Debate, Many Americans Say ‘It’s Complicated’© Maddie McGarvey for The New York Times Democrats could once straddle the abortion divide by airing personal misgivings while also promoting supportive policies.

In the Democratic Party, where politicians could once straddle the abortion divide by airing personal misgivings while also promoting supportive policies, holding a gradated view is no longer the norm. The debate on the left today is far less modulated than it was a decade ago when Barack Obama, then the party’s presidential nominee, spoke of how Americans wrestled with the issue in good faith, saying that “anybody who tries to deny the moral difficulties and gravity of the abortion issue, I think, is not paying attention.”

Politicians Draw Clear Lines on Abortion. Their Parties Are Not So Unified.

Politicians Draw Clear Lines on Abortion. Their Parties Are Not So Unified. Abortion is often cast as a clear, crisp issue in Washington and in state governments, with Republican and Democrats clustered in opposite corners. Joe Biden moved nearer to the rest of his party’s presidential contenders on Thursday when he dropped his support of a measure restricting use of federal funds for abortions. require(["medianetNativeAdOnArticle"], function (medianetNativeAdOnArticle) { medianetNativeAdOnArticle.getMedianetNativeAds(true); }); But while the Democratic field now looks more uniform, the public’s views are often muddled and complex.

Though the abortion debate is a very visible part of the American landscape, the number of abortions in the U. S . have been generally declining since the However, a clear majority of Americans believe abortion should be legal in all or some circumstances. Only 19% of voters polled said they thought

A majority of Americans support legal abortion in the first trimester of pregnancy. It ' s just one survey, but it suggests that making the abortion debate about Planned Parenthood (and taxpayer money) may be a more successful tactic for the GOP than trying to pass laws restricting abortion itself.

As Passions Flare in Abortion Debate, Many Americans Say ‘It’s Complicated’© Maddie McGarvey for The New York Times Herb Geraghty works for a group called Rehumanize International whose mission opposes what it considers all violence — abortion, capital punishment, torture and drone strikes.

[Sign up for our politics newsletter, and we’ll send you an invite to our live chat on debate night.]

By contrast, Democrats running for president today often characterize abortion rights as absolute. And they steer clear of saying what polls have repeatedly shown about Americans’ views since Roe v. Wade made abortion a constitutionally protected right in 1973: It’s complicated.

“Nonnegotiable,” Senator Kirsten Gillibrand has said. “There is no middle ground,” Senator Bernie Sanders declared.

Even on the issue of abortions later in pregnancy, which causes the most consternation among Americans, candidates are reluctant to go on record about where they would set limits. “I trust women to draw the line,” said Pete Buttigieg, the mayor of South Bend, Ind., when asked about third-trimester terminations.

The 2020 election could be the first time in recent memory that abortion is as galvanizing a voting issue for Democrats as it is for Republicans, who for decades have held out hope of flipping the Supreme Court and reversing Roe. Now, with a conservative majority on the court, Roe’s fate appears as tenuous as ever.

Illinois governor says new abortion law makes state most progressive on the issue

Illinois governor says new abortion law makes state most progressive on the issue The governor of Illinois said the Reproductive Health Act codifies existing practices.

Many people regard the right to control one' s own body as a key moral right. They say that if a woman is not allowed to have an abortion she is not only forced to continue the pregnancy to women need free access to abortion in order to achieve full political, social, and economic equality with men.

Abortion has long been a contentious issue in the U. S ., and it is one that sharply divides Americans along partisan, ideological and religious lines. Today, 76% of Democrats say abortion should be legal in at least most cases. In 1995, 64% favored legal abortion in all or most cases.

A no-compromise posture may be heartening for activists who worry about appearing timid on the issue at a time of such uncertainty and anxiety. But prominent allies to the cause have grown increasingly worried that the impulse to take a hard line has weakened their efforts politically and legally, and left them vulnerable to conservatives who eagerly portray them as out of step with the sentiments of most Americans.

“There’s always this sense that we can’t say anything that would create doubt about abortion,” said Frances Kissling, president of the Center for Health and Social Policy. “And the current situation hardens people’s sense of absolutism.”

Ms. Kissling, who is often called “the philosopher of the pro-choice movement,” said that to gloss over the complexity and morality of ending a pregnancy is to deny the reality that women experience. “I think that if you do not express any moral doubt about any aspect of abortion nobody trusts you,” she said. “You are so far from the sensibility of women who actually have abortions.”

[Check out our recap of the key moments in politics this past week]

But others say the questions around abortion have moved away from difficult issues of morality and toward control over women, especially as states move to enact restrictive laws in an attempt to challenge Roe. In this context, many Democratic voters see little room for ambiguity.

Pramila Jayapal talks about her own abortion in op-ed

Pramila Jayapal talks about her own abortion in op-ed Rep. Pramila Jayapal on Thursday publicly shared for the first time that she had an abortion more than two decades ago, arguing in a New York Times opinion piece that lawmakers "must commit" to protecting a woman's right to obtain a legal abortion. "I have decided to speak about it now because I am deeply concerned about the intensified efforts to strip choice and constitutional rights away from pregnant people and the simplistic ways of trying to criminalize abortion," Jayapal, a Washington state Democrat, wrote in the opinion piece about her abortion, which she said she had 22 years ago.

If you want to debate abortion , come here! You can make arguments as pro-choice or pro-life as you like or anywhere in between. #4-5 are less ideal. #6-7 may get you kicked out. This is not a subreddit to let loose at the opponent; it ' s for legitimate debate .

When it comes to choosing debate topics for college or university, there are many things to keep in mind – it has to be controversial, relevant, have significance, and clearly demonstrate a student’ s knowledge and skills. Choosing a good topic can be hard.

“Women see this as ‘my autonomy,’ and there is no space for compromise in their minds on autonomy,” said Tresa Undem, a partner with the research firm PerryUndem who studies public opinion on the issue. “Honestly, Democratic candidates are catching up to Democratic voters who have been feeling this way for a few years.”

Few states have a political history as shaped by the subtleties of the abortion debate as Pennsylvania. It has been home to Democrats like the former governor Robert P. Casey, who defended the state’s restrictive abortion laws in the landmark Supreme Court case Planned Parenthood v. Casey, which reaffirmed Roe but also allowed states to set new limits. Today Pennsylvania is represented in the United States Senate by the former governor’s son, Bob Casey, who is one of only a handful of Democratic senators with a record of voting to limit abortion access.

The state is also home to one of the last Republican House members who supported abortion rights, Charlie Dent, the former congressman who represented the Lehigh Valley area until he retired in 2018. There are none today.

“They used to talk about the Catholic Democrat, or the Casey Democrat, who was pro-labor, pro-life, pro-gun,” Mr. Dent said in an interview. “But that doesn’t seem to be so common today. Or many of them have become Republicans.”

There are still some opponents of abortion barely hanging on as Democrats. “I’m really sad because I don’t want to be a Republican,” said Jeannie Wallace French of Pittsburgh, who has worked with groups like Feminists for Life, which oppose abortion but are less partisan than many mainstream groups. She was pregnant with twins when she said the doctors discovered one had a form of spina bifida and advised her to abort. She declined and the baby, a girl, died shortly after birth. But doctors were able to use her heart valves to save two other infants.

Tiffany Haddish cancels Atlanta show over abortion law

Tiffany Haddish cancels Atlanta show over abortion law Actress and comedian Tiffany Haddish has canceled her upcoming Atlanta performance because of Georgia's new restrictive abortion law. News outlets report that the "Girls Trip" star sent a statement to ticketholders Saturday, saying she cannot "in good faith" perform in Georgia unless it withdraws the so-called heartbeat bill. Haddish had been scheduled to perform June 22 at the Fox Theatre. The new law would ban abortion once a fetal heartbeat is detected, which can be as early as six weeks, before many women know they are pregnant. Unless it's blocked in court, it's set to go into effect in 2020.

What many perceive as “ complication ,” it seems to me, is merely a lack of exposure to the tools required to reach complete understanding. For this round I will assert that women may not be more complicated , but rather have a tendency to over- complicate a situation. Whether it ' s a trait inherent

Having it go to the Supreme court makes it a political issue and that means with the lawmakers, politicians, we Conservatives Make It a Political Issue. We must continue looking at abortion as a political issue, because Women who get an abortion are more likely to use alcohol, tranquilizers or

She worries that stories like hers are getting drowned out. “It has become so loud, going both ways,’’ she said. “And the divide is only getting bigger.”

Liz Allen, a Democratic member of the Erie City Council who calls herself “anti-abortion but pro-choice,” said she wishes her party encouraged women with a wide range of experiences around pregnancy to speak up. She arrived at her own “nuanced” position about abortion, she said, after two traumatic moments: a first-trimester miscarriage and, later, the death of her adult son. “That, to me, wasn’t a person,” she said of her miscarriage, contrasting it to her son’s death. But she said she could understand how some women might feel that way.

“This is being framed as a health care discussion, but in other health care discussions we are talking about the moral issues involved,” Ms. Allen said. “Why can’t we acknowledge that this is a moral question and that women have the moral agency to decide this. But let’s not dismiss it as nothing, like you’re going to have a tooth pulled.”

About one in three voters in Pennsylvania is Catholic — higher than the national figure of about one in five. Catholic voters there turned out at the highest rate of the three Midwestern states Mr. Trump won by a threadbare margin of 77,000 total votes, according to exit polls.

Most Catholics, said Steven Krueger, president of the Catholic Democrats, are like most other Americans in that they do not accept the Church’s political hard line on abortion. But they do wrestle with it morally and expect politicians will, too. “It isn’t only a question of what their churches teach, it’s also an instinct,” he said.

Both political parties are doing a poor job of connecting with the sensibilities of Americans who “are both pro-life and pro-choice,” Mr. Krueger said. And the result is a situation where “a lot of people are feeling like orphans on this issue.”

Planned Parenthood hosts 20 presidential candidates to talk abortion rights

Planned Parenthood hosts 20 presidential candidates to talk abortion rights Planned Parenthood's forum at the University of South Carolina will offer Democrats an opportunity to directly address reproductive rights issues.

The debate over abortion rights riles up supporters and opponents in a way few policy issues can. Trump said abortion was “a 50/50 question” while speaking about his Supreme Court nominee. One reason might be that people who oppose the idea of abortion may accept that it ’ s settled as a matter

(Mr. Trump, who attacked Hillary Clinton’s support for abortions late in pregnancy, won among Catholics nationwide by seven points, propelled by a 23-point margin with white Catholics, the Pew Research Center reported.)

Mrs. Clinton’s public comments on abortion show how much the conversation has changed. In 2005, she said abortion “represents a sad, even tragic choice to many, many women.” When she ran in the 2008 Democratic primary against Mr. Obama, she said her goal was to reduce the number of abortions, using Bill Clinton’s often-borrowed line that the procedure should be “safe, legal and rare.” Then she added, “By rare, I mean rare.”

The party dropped the word “rare” from its platform in 2008 at the urging of activists who felt it was shaming to women. And Democrats today seldom discuss reducing the number of abortions as a goal. “The argument,” said Ms. Kissling, the pro-abortion rights ethicist, “is if we want to reduce the number of abortions there must be something wrong with it.”

Many on the left are framing it as a question of trusting women, Ms. Kissling added, which she thinks precludes a more comprehensive, persuasive discussion about abortion rights. “We have one answer, the same answer, to every single objection or concern that is raised around abortion,” she said. “It’s not about trusting women, really. Every decision every woman makes about every abortion is an ethically good decision? No. It may not be.”

Some who are progressive-minded on issues other than abortion say the Democratic Party’s embrace of this approach makes it more “pro-abortion” than “pro-women,” leaving them without much of a political home.

In Pittsburgh, Aimee Murphy founded a group called Rehumanize International that hold many positions embraced by progressives: opposing racial discrimination, capital punishment, torture and drone strikes, for instance. But because it also opposes abortion, she said, it has been marginalized in progressive circles. “In mainstream feminist circles, the word pro-life is like a swear word,” she said.

One of Ms. Murphy’s colleagues at Rehumanize, Herb Geraghty, a self-described atheist and Marxist who is bisexual, said when he set up a table at the Pittsburgh L.G.B.T. Pride festival recently, a lot of people wanted to yell at him. But when he tried to draw some of them into a conversation, he was heartened by how well it worked.

“We either want to ban abortion outright or see abortion as good, as empowering,” he said of society in general. But most people think it’s a tough decision, he said, including him. “It’s a hard issue.”

Planned Parenthood hosts 20 presidential candidates to talk abortion rights.
Planned Parenthood's forum at the University of South Carolina will offer Democrats an opportunity to directly address reproductive rights issues.

—   Share news in the SOC. Networks

Topical videos:

usr: 38
This is interesting!