USJudge in census case: New evidence alleging political motivation behind citizenship question 'raises a substantial issue'
Trump asserts executive privilege to shield documents on Census citizenship question
The move came as a House panel was moving toward holding two members of the administration in contempt.
![]()
alleging political motivation behind citizenship question ' raises a substantial issue '. believes new evidence presented in a challenge to the 2020 census citizenship question " raises a Plaintiffs in the Maryland case note that their case brings up issues that were not discussed in the
Judge in census case : New evidence alleging political motivation behind citizenship question ' raises a substantial issue '. Once a decade, the census is conducted to tally the entire US population. That data helps the government decide how to distribute federal funds for programs like free and

In a blow to the Trump administration, a federal trial judge said Wednesday that he believes new evidence presented in a challenge to the 2020 census citizenship question "raises a substantial issue."
The decision could lead to reopening one of three federal trials into the citizenship question and lead to further examinations of Republican redistricting consultant Thomas Hofeller's role in developing the question.
The fight over the 2020 census citizenship question, explained
The battle over a simple question involves both Congress and the Supreme Court. And the stakes are high.
![]()
Supreme Court blocks 2020 census citizenship question in setback for Trump admin. A federal trial judge earlier this month said he believes new evidence presented " raises a substantial issue ." Opponents of the citizen question allege Hofeller ghostwrote part of a Justice Department draft letter
New evidence about a Republican strategist's role in adding a citizenship question to the 2020 census is putting increased pressure on the The justices are weighing whether the controversial question should be allowed on the census after opponents filed lawsuits arguing it would lead to an
Earlier this month, the ACLU and a team of lawyers at Arnold & Porter said that they had obtained a trove of documents from Hofeller, a deceased Republican redistricting expert who, they allege, played a significant role in the decision to add the question. Hofeller wrote a study in 2015 concluding that using "citizen voting age" population as the redistricting population base would be "advantageous to Republicans and Non-Hispanic Whites."
The administration has always denied political motivation, saying instead that the Justice Department had determined that the question was necessary to better comply with federal voting rights law.
Judge George Hazel of the US District Court in Maryland disagreed with the government's arguments that Hofeller's files were "not material and it would not produce a new outcome."
The Census: Another Brick in Trump’s White House Wall
The president is using executive privilege to conceal information the public needs to know.
![]()
A federal judge in New York has issued the first ruling out of multiple lawsuits over a question about U.S. citizenship status. Commerce Secretary Wilbur Ross, who oversees the Census Bureau, approved adding a question about U.S. citizenship status to the 2020 census .
They say the citizenship question is actually a central element of a Republican strategy to try to The justices sent the case back to a lower court. The majority opinion, written by Chief Justice John G Federal judges in each of the three lawsuits opposing the addition of the citizenship question had
His order allows the groups suing the government -- alleging the question was developed with discriminatory intent and amounted to an illegal conspiracy -- to ask an appeals court to remand the case to his lower court.
The original Maryland trial, like those in New York and California, resulted in orders blocking the question from appearing on the census.
But the judge in Maryland ruled the plaintiffs had not proved that the government acted with discriminatory intent when in adding the question. Like in the other trials, Hazel said Commerce Secretary Wilbur Ross' motives were unclear.
Plaintiffs believe the new evidence could sway that aspect in their favor.
The Supreme Court is expected to rule soon on two other cases challenging the citizenship question. Plaintiffs in the Maryland case note that their case brings up issues that were not discussed in the cases heard in New York or California, and believe their challenge may proceed separately from matters before the Supreme Court.
The 2020 census is coming. Will Native Americans be counted?.
As the 2020 census nears, concern about an undercount of Native Americans is gaining traction here and across the country. Approximately 600,000 Native Americans live on tribal reservations, semi-sovereign entities governed by elected indigenous leaders. Here on the Navajo Nation — the country’s largest reservation, spanning portions of New Mexico, Arizona and Utah — roughly 175,000 people live in a mostly rural high desert area bigger than West Virginia. While other reservations are smaller, most are also remote. And all are home to a longstanding distrust of the U.S. government.
Topical videos:
William Barr testifies before congress for first time since receiving Mueller report, live stream
Attorney General William Barr is testifying before Congress Tuesday, as Washington waits for him to release special counsel Robert Mueller's report. Barr has ...
Michael Cohen Testifies Before Congress On Trump Campaign | NBC News
Watch live coverage as Michael Cohen, President Trump's former attorney, testifies before members of the House Oversight and Reform Committee. In a much ...
See also:
Topical videos
TOP News
TOP News
Latest News
Similar from the Web
alleging political motivation behind citizenship question ' raises a substantial issue '. believes new evidence presented in a challenge to the 2020 census citizenship question " raises a Plaintiffs in the Maryland case note that their case brings up issues that were not discussed in the edition.cnn.com
What's behind the citizenship question on the 2020 censusJudge in census case : New evidence alleging political motivation behind citizenship question ' raises a substantial issue '. Once a decade, the census is conducted to tally the entire US population. That data helps the government decide how to distribute federal funds for programs like free and edition.cnn.com
Census citizenship question blocked by Supreme Court - CNNPoliticsSupreme Court blocks 2020 census citizenship question in setback for Trump admin. A federal trial judge earlier this month said he believes new evidence presented " raises a substantial issue ." Opponents of the citizen question allege Hofeller ghostwrote part of a Justice Department draft letter edition.cnn.com
New evidence throws census citizenship case into question | TheHillNew evidence about a Republican strategist's role in adding a citizenship question to the 2020 census is putting increased pressure on the The justices are weighing whether the controversial question should be allowed on the census after opponents filed lawsuits arguing it would lead to an
Judge Orders Trump Administration To Remove 2020 Census : NPRA federal judge in New York has issued the first ruling out of multiple lawsuits over a question about U.S. citizenship status. Commerce Secretary Wilbur Ross, who oversees the Census Bureau, approved adding a question about U.S. citizenship status to the 2020 census .
What You Need to Know About the Census Citizenship QuestionThey say the citizenship question is actually a central element of a Republican strategy to try to The justices sent the case back to a lower court. The majority opinion, written by Chief Justice John G Federal judges in each of the three lawsuits opposing the addition of the citizenship question had
https://www.cnn.com/2019/06/19/ politics /j - Law Office of | FacebookJudge in census case : New evidence alleging political motivation behind citizenship question ' raises a substantial issue '. In a blow to the Trump administration, a federal trial judge said Wednesday that he believes new evidence presented in a challenge to the 2020 census citizenship
Trump administration can’t ask citizenship question on 2020 censusNEW YORK (AP) — The Trump administration cannot put a question about citizenship status on the 2020 census , a federal judge in New In the New York case , the plaintiffs accused the administration of Republican President Donald Trump of adding the question to intentionally discourage immigrants