US Operation Gatekeeper at 25: Look back at the turning point that transformed the border

16:10  05 october  2019
16:10  05 october  2019 Source:   sandiegouniontribune.com

Soldier faces charges related to training accident that killed a West Point cadet

  Soldier faces charges related to training accident that killed a West Point cadet Staff Sgt. Ladonies Strong was charged with involuntary manslaughter, negligent homicide, reckless driving and dereliction of duty, the Army said.Staff Sgt. Ladonies Strong, who was driving the transport vehicle when it overturned on June 6, was charged with involuntary manslaughter, negligent homicide, reckless driving and two specifications of dereliction of duty, the Army said in an email.

Operation Gatekeeper was launched with significant fanfare, and was almost immediately declared a great success by Border Patrol, the INS, and She was "astonished" to see hundreds of aliens waiting for darkness to fall so that they could cross the border illegally. At one point she turned to then CPA

If we look back at its history, we will see that there were several foreign communities living in Moscow on a permanent basis. Other desert plants simply stop growing in very dry weather. They appear to be dead, but when the rain returns, they come back to life and begin growing again.

SAN DIEGO — Attorney General Janet Reno wanted to see the chaos for herself.

Winners and losers from 'Thursday Night Football' Week 4

  Winners and losers from 'Thursday Night Football' Week 4 The Eagles traveled to Lambeau Field to take on the Packers to open the Week 4 slate.It was as much of a must win as the Eagles could have at this early point in the season. Meanwhile, Green Bay entered the game at 3-0 and playing tremendous on defense.

Much to my mother’s dismay, I turned out to be one of thousands of vegetarians in Canada who were under voting age. Some people thought I did it to be cool, some people (like my mother) thought I did it for shock value. But I was always asked the one-word question: WHY?

Operation Gatekeeper book. Read 3 reviews from the world's largest community for readers. He details how the border has been transformed into a boundary and the construction of the illegal alien. Welcome back . Just a moment while we sign you in to your Goodreads account.

She watched as hundreds of migrants gathered in the dusk along the northern edge of Tijuana, waiting for darkness to make the illegal journey into San Diego.

The border fencing that had been erected over the last few years wasn’t about to stop them.

She turned to the San Diego sector’s chief patrol agent and asked what he needed to control the border. Sensors, radios, vehicles, more agents, he said.

She told him to put together a plan to make it happen.

What emerged was a whole new approach to border enforcement.

Operation Gatekeeper was unveiled on Oct. 1, 1994. The strategy was to deter migrants from illegally crossing in the first place — and, for those who remained undeterred, to encourage them to cross in more isolated wilderness areas to the east, where they could be more easily captured.

At the Border, Lawmakers See a Broken System and Little Common Ground

  At the Border, Lawmakers See a Broken System and Little Common Ground EL PASO — The delegation of Democratic lawmakers jostled for space in the cramped room in the border processing center, straining to hear over the sounds of crinkling mylar blankets and a crying baby, as a Venezuelan migrant told her grim story. They listened sympathetically as the woman told of the weeks she would have to spend in Mexico before her next asylum hearing, at which she would try to explain the violence she had faced at home that had forced her to leave.

Operation Sovereign Borders (OSB) is a border protection operation led by the Australian Defence Force, aimed at stopping maritime arrivals of asylum seekers to Australia. The operation is the outcome of a 2013 federal election policy of the Coalition

The Turning Point , Plano, Texas. 1.8K likes. Our mission is to provide counseling, education, and advocacy for those impacted by sexual violence. Join us LIVE on Facebook at 10 AM each Thursday as we conquer the -isms. June 11 - Racism June 18 - Sexism June 25 - Elitism

Twenty-five years later, Operation Gatekeeper is still viewed as a major turning point in the effort to control the border.

It is considered both a success and a failure, depending on whom you ask.

One thing is certain: Operation Gatekeeper set in motion a process that significantly altered the landscape of the U.S.-Mexico border and transformed San Diego into one of the most heavily fortified international boundaries in the nation. It also came with a human toll, as migration shifted to the east.


“The border was nothing like it is now,” observed photojournalist Don Bartletti.

His fascination with the border began as a staff photographer with the San Diego Union in the late 1970s, “when the border was essentially a cable or strands of barbed wire smashed into the dirt by thousands of feet coming north.”

He recalled the masses of migrants who gathered nightly at a popular staging spot near Tijuana’s Colonia Libertad known as “the soccer field.” Vendors would sell food and provisions for the journey. Catholic priests would hold Mass. Smugglers would connect with customers.

Rams' Gurley once again blasts ‘Thursday Night Football’

  Rams' Gurley once again blasts ‘Thursday Night Football’ This isn’t the first time Gurley has gone off about the mid-week game. He blasted the NFL’s scheduling of Thursday Night Football last season, too. It appears that Gurley’s stance has not changed in the year-plus since he last questioned the league’s logic.He’s also not alone in this regard. Multiple NFL players have made their opinions known. The product suffers. Injuries are more prevalent. Through a 16-game season, having that short week also takes a physical toll on players.Unfortunately for Gurley and others, this is not going to change any time soon.

The turning point occurred on April 29 as Soviet troops took possession of the fortified Interior Ministry building, which occupied an entire block. Calculating the losses involved in the Battle of Berlin at the end of such a bloody war, some historians doubt whether the Soviet attack of the city was necessary.

Up to that point , paperback publishers had limited themselves to reprinting hardcover titles or publishing quick, timely original nonfiction such as the Today, it’s de rigueur for major publishers to print both hardcover and paperback books. And of course, there’s a new “pocket book” transforming

The crossers far outnumbered the Border Patrol agents on the other side.

Then, in waves over the next several hours, the crossers would go for it. They ran through brush and canyons — which were often teeming with bandits waiting for their prey — and followed roads so they could melt into the city. It was not uncommon to see unauthorized immigrants dash across Interstate 5, with tragic results.

The same thing was happening farther west at Border Field State Park, where an obelisk and a 6-foot-high schoolyard chain link fence marked the international boundary.

“Quite often, it was bending so far over that people waiting for nightfall would use it as a hammock,” Bartletti recalled of the fence.

That stretch of land — the first 7.5 miles beginning at the Pacific Ocean — became the busiest corridor for illegal crossings in the country.

“Many nights, we were catching hundreds, if not thousands, of people a day,” recalled Assistant Patrol Chief Chancy Arnold, who started as a rookie agent in 1985. Sometimes he’d end up capturing the same group a few times in the same night.

American Idol Alums Gabby Barrett and Cade Foehner Are Married! All the Details from Their 'Rustic' Texas Wedding

  American Idol Alums Gabby Barrett and Cade Foehner Are Married! All the Details from Their 'Rustic' Texas Wedding American Idol Alums Gabby Barrett and Cade Foehner Marry in TexasThe former American Idol contestants (who met during their respective runs on season 16 of the show in 2018) tied the knot in Garrison, Texas, on Saturday in front of 100 guests at wedding and event venue Union Springs — and PEOPLE has all the exclusive details.

Turning Point USA (TPUSA) is an American conservative nonprofit organization. TPUSA's affiliated organizations include Turning Point News, the Turning Point Endowment, Turning Point Action

In literature, the turning point or climax is the point of highest tension in a narrative. Without turning points , narratives would be incomplete and boring—all audiences read and watch stories with the expectation that the action will climb to a peak, and then work back down to a conclusion.

“It was a little demoralizing to go out there and to see the amount of activity and know we didn’t have the adequate amount of resources to actually control it,” Arnold said. “It’s like, ‘What am I doing here?’ You see thousands of people getting past you.”

A more substantial fence started going up around 1990. It was made of helicopter landing mat leftover from the Vietnam War.

It managed to cut down the number of vehicle loads that’d blow through, but it was easily breached by those on foot.

Torches and saws cut through the metal. Whole families — including women in kitchen dresses, girls in dress shoes and even seniors — were often seen scaling the new barrier, its horizontal corrugated slats essentially serving as a ladder.

“The fence didn’t stop anybody,” said Bartletti, who continued photographing the border for the Los Angeles Times.

By fiscal 1993, the San Diego sector accounted for 42% of all apprehensions along the southwest border. The 531,689 people caught that year likely represented only a fraction of those who crossed unhindered.

Slideshow by photo services


The atmosphere was ripe for Operation Gatekeeper.

California Gov. Pete Wilson was fighting to be reelected. Already a loud voice blaming Washington for doing nothing to stem the flow of illegal immigration — and leaving the state to pay for the costs — Wilson got louder during his campaign. He became an outspoken champion of Proposition 187, a ballot measure that cut off state services such as healthcare and public education to unauthorized immigrants.

An influx of labor-related migration was also anticipated with the signing of the North American Free Trade Agreement in 1994.

At the same time, an experiment in El Paso — a city with a similar urban-border interface — was seeing some results. Operation Hold the Line, started in October 1993, shifted the bulk of agents to the city’s downtown area, where they’d hold positions in sight of one another and potential crossers. The number of apprehensions dropped by 70%, according to a report by the U.S. office of the inspector general.

Immigration issues were also getting more attention from Congress, with $1.2 billion allocated for “border control, criminal alien deportations, asylum reform and a criminal alien tracking center” as part of the wide-ranging Violent Crime Control and Law Enforcement Act of 1994.

“This is one of the most difficult issues facing America,” Reno told a crowd of reporters following her tour of the border in August of 1993.

Gatekeeper soon began to crystallize.

The strategy was similar to that in El Paso, asking agents to hold the line in fixed positions and in three layers. The first visible layer would largely deter illegal crossings, and the next two layers would catch those who did cross and made it past the first.

The tactic was a departure from how agents had usually operated, patrolling wide swaths of border as they saw fit. The chases and high number of apprehensions were part of what made the job exciting to many agents.

But now, the measure of success would be low apprehension figures, not high.

The strategy required many more agents, both new hires and redeployed agents borrowed from other areas. The sector was given new rugged vehicles, seismic sensors and radios. New night scopes attached to the top of agents’ Ford Broncos got the nickname “el búho” — the owl — from Mexicans.

Rather than focus on the entire San Diego sector at once, Gatekeeper started in the most southwestern corner of the U.S., under the control of the Imperial Beach station, which was by far the busiest corridor. Once that strip was under control, then the operation would move farther east until the whole sector was sewn up.

By doing so, Gatekeeper would intentionally cause crossing routes to shift farther east to California’s mountains and deserts, where authorities figured migrants would be more easily detected and caught.


The difference between pre- and post-Gatekeeper was striking.

“I remember going out on patrol one night in an area were there would normally only be one or two agents working and be amazed,” Arnold recalled. “Everywhere I looked I could see a vehicle parked, not only along the border but also farther north. I was amazed at how many agents were out.”

Apprehensions ticked up at the very beginning of Gatekeeper as expected, then dropped steadily in San Diego over the next several years.

From fiscal 1992 to 2004, overall apprehensions in the sector declined by 76%, according to Border Patrol data.

Conversely, Border Patrol staffing in San Diego grew, from about 1,000 to 1,650 in the same period.

Rep. Bob Filner testified to Congress in 1996 that he was at first skeptical of Gatekeeper’s impact, but he said his constituents had changed his mind.

“People whom I represent, who live in communities right here near the border, have felt a very radical change in their own living conditions. That is, they have felt safer,” Filner said. “They have not seen the scores of people coming down the streets or in their backyards. They are opening up their garages.”

Alan Bersin helped launch Gatekeeper as U.S. attorney in San Diego, and he was named the so-called “border czar” by President Bill Clinton a few years later to implement the strategy across the rest of the southwest border.

“Neither side claims it, but Gatekeeper was probably the most important domestic achievement accomplished in a purely bipartisan manner through three administrations, and the greatest accomplishment since President Eisenhower and the Democrats put together the state highway system in the mid-1950s,” Bersin reflected.

With Gatekeeper came a new system to fingerprint migrants as they were apprehended and processed. With firm identification, repeat crossers could be identified and charged with illegal reentry, a felony. The number of prosecutions jumped to nearly 4,000 annually in the mid-’90s, Bersin said.

Gatekeeper ushered in a number of other border initiatives. Among them was the construction of a secondary mesh metal fence along the first 14 miles of San Diego’s border with Mexico beginning in 1996, further slowing illegal crossings.


With Gatekeeper came a high human cost.

As expected, migration shifted farther east, into inhospitable environments that have claimed many lives.

Traffic was eventually funneled into Arizona by the 2000s, as El Paso also ramped up enforcement to the east.

The bottleneck is evident in the data. While San Diego sector apprehensions plummeted, the Tucson sector saw apprehensions increase by 591% between fiscal 1992 and 2004, according to Border Patrol data.

“One unintended consequence of this enforcement posture and the shift in migration patterns has been an increase in the number of migrant deaths each year; on average 200 migrants died each year in the early 1990s, compared with 472 migrant deaths in 2005,” according to a 2009 report by the nonpartisan Congressional Research Service.

Various estimates put the number of border-related deaths anywhere from 7,500 to 12,000 since 1998.

“We’ve never had a public accounting for that,” said Everard Meade, director of the Trans-Border Institute at the University of San Diego. “That’s never been front or center of the policy discussions.”

Gatekeeper was instrumental in providing the impression that the border was under control when what it actually did was shift illegal crossings farther out of sight of city dwellers, said Pedro Rios, director of American Friends Service Committee’s U.S.-Mexico Border Program.

“From a human rights vantage point,” Rios said, “it was an utter failure.”

The operation had other long-lasting byproducts, according to academics. Gatekeeper made crossing the border illegally a much riskier, more expensive affair, driving mom-and-pop smugglers out of the picture as more organized-crime networks jockeyed for profits, said Rios.

It also prevented migrant workers from regularly traveling back and forth across the border. Rather than risk being apprehended, the family breadwinners would stay in the U.S., and their families back home would often migrate to the U.S. too, experts said.

“It brought a more permanent undocumented population to the U.S.,” Meade said.


These days, the human chain of agents along the border in San Diego has long been replaced with a mixture of roaming patrols and fixed observation points. The strengthened border wall, combined with a vast network of cameras, sensors and stadium lighting, does a lot of the work.

Arnold, who is the most veteran Border Patrol agent in the nation with nearly 35 years of service, described Gatekeeper’s legacy this way: “It was the defining moment that helped us get to the point we are today in our border security mission, using the right mixture of personnel, technology and infrastructure.”

Notably, the framing of the immigration debate raging today should not be one of border security, but of a broken asylum system, Bersin argued.

“The people coming up now are not trying to get away from Border Patrol,” he said, “they’re trying to surrender to them.”

The historical perspective is sometimes lost on newer agents in San Diego, who hear the pre-Gatekeeper stories but don’t fully grasp the transformation.

So the Border Patrol asked Bartletti to show them. The now-retired photographer selected four iconic images of mass migration — crowds taking Mass at the soccer field, hundreds staging at the Tijuana River levee. Then he shot images in the same exact spots as they appear now — empty landscapes of concrete and metal.

The before-and-after images will hang in the chief’s conference room in the sector headquarters in Chula Vista.


©2019 The San Diego Union-Tribune

Visit The San Diego Union-Tribune at www.sandiegouniontribune.com

Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.

U. S.-allied Kurds strike deal to bring Assad’s Syrian troops back into Kurdish areas .
The deal between the Syrian Democratic Forces and the government of President Bashar al-Assad further dimmed the prospect of continued U.S. presence in Syria.Hundreds of Islamic State family members escaped a detention camp after Turkish shellfire hit the area, U.S. troops pulled out from another base and Turkish-backed forces consolidated their hold over a vital highway, cutting the main U.S. supply route into Syria.

—   Share news in the SOC. Networks

Topical videos:

usr: 3
This is interesting!