•   
  •   
  •   

US Trump-appointed judge mocks transgender woman's gender identity in opinion

02:50  17 january  2020
02:50  17 january  2020 Source:   nbcnews.com

Singular pronoun 'they' named word of the decade by American language experts

  Singular pronoun 'they' named word of the decade by American language experts The singular pronoun "they" is the word of the decade, according to The American Dialect Society. Formed more than 130 years ago, the American Dialect Society, along with organizations like Merriam-Webster dictionary, have chosen relevant words to represent a year a whole. In December, Merriam-Webster declared "they" its word of the year.Formed more than 130 years ago, the American Dialect Society, along with organizations like Merriam-Webster dictionary, have chosen relevant words to represent a year a whole. In December, Merriam-Webster declared “they” its word of the year.

The Trump administration is considering a legal definition of gender as immutable and fixed at birth, the most drastic in a series of moves against transgender people. Several agencies have withdrawn Obama-era policies that recognized gender identity in schools, prisons and homeless shelters.

US withdrew guidance stating federal law requires transgender students to have unfettered access to bathrooms and locker rooms matching their gender identity .

Kyle Duncan in a suit and tie: Image: Stuart Kyle Duncan© C-Span Image: Stuart Kyle Duncan

Stuart Kyle Duncan, a new federal judge on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 5th Circuit, issued an advisory opinion Wednesday that mocked a transgender inmate and the broader concept of gender identity, just under two years after LGBTQ advocates warned that Duncan would not rule fairly if confirmed as a judge.

Katherine Nicole Jett, a transgender woman who was known as Norman Varner when she pleaded guilty in 2001 to attempted receipt of child pornography, moved to have her conviction records updated to match her changed name. A district court in Kentucky dismissed her motion because there was no "defect" in the original judgment paperwork, in that "Norman Varner" was her legal name when the documents were produced.

Kentucky judge suspended after alleged affair and nepotism

  Kentucky judge suspended after alleged affair and nepotism A Kentucky judge was suspended with pay pending an investigation into accusations of misconduct including an affair with a male attorney in a courthouse office and attempts to include a female colleague, court documents show.Family Circuit Court Judge Dawn Gentry was suspended Monday after she was charged with nine counts of misconduct in November 2019. Her first hearing to address the charges came last Friday before the Kentucky Judicial Conduct Commission.

The Trump administration rule would no longer recognize gender identity as an avenue for sex discrimination. The Obama-era definition of discrimination also protected women who had terminated a pregnancy. Under the provision, health care services for transgender patients and patients with a

Calling their grievance a “ gender discrimination claim,” the women compared being incarcerated with trans women — who were born The Trump administration must enforce protections for transgender prisoners as long as this law is in effect, said Mara Keisling, executive director of the National Center

Jett's appeal of that decision appeared before the 5th Circuit, where Duncan sits. In his majority opinion, Duncan vacated the Kentucky court ruling that denied Jett's appeal, saying the court lacked jurisdiction, but then he proceeded to mock Jett's court motion that she be referred to using female pronouns and her new name.

Duncan refers to Jett only using "he" pronouns throughout and refers to her as a "gender-dysphoric" person, instead of as a transgender person.

"Federal courts sometimes choose to refer to gender-dysphoric parties by their preferred pronouns," Duncan wrote, and "our court has gone both ways."

Amy Klobuchar Keeps Voting for Trump’s ‘Horrific’ Judges

  Amy Klobuchar Keeps Voting for Trump’s ‘Horrific’ Judges As Democratic members of the Senate Judiciary Committee grilled then-Supreme Court nominee Brett Kavanaugh in fall 2018 over allegations that he had committed sexual assault against a woman while the two of them were in high school, the hearings served as a proving ground for no fewer than three presidential hopefuls. But of the trio of Senate Judiciary members who would go on to seek the Democratic presidential nomination, Sen. Amy Klobuchar of Minnesota had perhaps the most iconic moment of the proceedings, when the soon-to-be-confirmed Supreme Court justice testily asked if she had ever blacked out from drinking following a series of questions about Kavanaugh’s own

Gender Letter helps you keep up with the world — and the women and issues shaping it. Tell me what you think at dearmaya@nytimes. com. Under President Trump , several federal agencies have withdrawn Obama-era policies that recognized gender identity in schools, prisons and homeless

Last week, a Japanese television program outed and mocked a transgender woman , exposing the harsh reality trans people face in Japan. In last week’s episode, a host discussed a trans woman ’ s gender identity without her permission, referring to her as “unusual.”

In fact, the 5th Circuit has broadly respected the identity of transgender defendants for at least four decades. In 1980, the 5th Circuit wrote in Rush v Parham that it would follow the "convention" in "medical literature" of referring to transgender people using their preferred pronouns.

In his argument against using Jett's pronouns and name, Duncan cites eight cases between 1980 and 2014 in which the 5th Circuit referred to transgender people using their correct pronouns. He cites three cases in which the 5th Circuit did not, including edge cases, such as one in which a prisoner who once identified as a gay man had later come out as a transgender women.

"Congress has said nothing to prohibit courts from referring to litigants according to their biological sex, rather than according to their subjective gender identity," Duncan correctly observed, noting that this "convention" is and continues to be a "courtesy."

Random attack with scalding water burns woman’s back

  Random attack with scalding water burns woman’s back A woman received first- and second- degree burns Sunday morning after a stranger approached her from behind along the waterfront on Clematis Street and threw scalding water on her back. © Ivan Bliznetsov/Getty Images Police tape at a crime scene. Andrea Clarke, 56, was arrested and faces an aggravated battery charge. According to the West Palm Beach Police Department, Clarke was walking down Clematis Street about 9:30 a.m. Sunday with hot water from Starbucks when she came across the woman setting up for an event.

A person may be considered to be a transgender person if their gender identity is inconsistent or not culturally associated with the sex they were assigned at birth and consequently also with the gender

death of a transgender woman in Harlem told prosecutors and detectives he had been flirting with her just moments before the attack, unaware that she was transgender . Then, he said, he heard one of his friends mocking him, saying, “That’ s a guy,” and he became enraged. “They were clowning me

Duncan goes on to warn that respecting a transgender person's gender in the same way courts respect a cisgender person's gender "may unintentionally convey its tacit approval of the litigant's underlying legal position." He warns that respecting transgender people's gender identity "may well turn out to be more complex than at first it might appear" because of a "galaxy" of genders, citing what he says is a "widely circulated" University of Wisconsin LGBTQ+ Resource Center guide to pronouns. (A Google reverse image search of the pronoun guide included in Duncan's opinions returned no matches.)

Prior to his confirmation, LGBTQ advocates like Lambda Legal and Congressional Democrats decried his nomination, saying Duncan could not be trusted to rule fairly in cases regarding the LGBTQ community.

Indeed, Duncan was part of the legal team that represented Virginia's Gloucester County School Board in their case against Gavin Grimm, a transgender high school student who was unable to use the restroom that aligned with his gender identity.

Gigi Hadid Called to Potentially Serve as Harvey Weinstein Juror

  Gigi Hadid Called to Potentially Serve as Harvey Weinstein Juror The model, who appeared in court on Monday, told the judge she could be objective — despite having met the defendant and one of his alleged victims.On Monday, a famous face was among the latest pool of potential jurors: Gigi Hadid.

"The idea that Mr. Duncan will cast aside his bigoted beliefs overnight, and miraculously transform into an impartial judge, is ludicrous and reckless," Lambda Legal Executive Director Rachel Tiven said in 2018, prior to Duncan's confirmation.

Chase Strangio, a staff attorney at the ACLU and transgender advocate, said Duncan's Wednesday opinion was "far outside the standard practice within the entire legal profession."

Stangio said Duncan went "on this long advisory opinion about the legal implications of pronouns and the nature of sex discrimination and things that have nothing to do with the case or the question before it."

"At this point, if the court lets this stand without, on its own, amending the opinion or rescinding it, then it ultimately makes the court look like a political body rather than a legal one," Strangio said, adding that he thinks that the 5th Circuit could potentially vacate this opinion.

"Even just for the reason that this is just an extensive advisory opinion on all sorts of questions not before the court, which is way outside the bounds of what federal courts generally do," he said.

Judge James L. Dennis, a Clinton-appointed 5th Circuit judge, filed a blistering dissent that questioned Duncan's authority to issue an "advisory opinion" — a judicial ruling addressing an issue not brought up before the court, and noted that "it is not necessary to use any pronoun" in adjudicating the appeal.

Woman shot by state police in Lawrence County

  Woman shot by state police in Lawrence County A woman in Lawrence County was injured Monday when she was shot at least once by a Pennsylvania State Police trooper, who said the woman refused to drop her weapon. Troopers responded just after 9 a.m. to a call near Copper Road in Slippery Rock Township that a woman was causing a disturbance. Two troopers arrived on the scene together and encountered the woman, who police said was armed. "She failed to comply with the demands of the troopers,"Troopers responded just after 9 a.m. to a call near Copper Road in Slippery Rock Township that a woman was causing a disturbance.

"As the majority notes, though no law compels granting or denying such a request, many courts and judges adhere to such requests out of respect for the litigant's dignity," Dennis wrote.

Dennis cites nine cases between 1993 and 2018 in which federal courts referred to transgender people by their gender identity.

"Ultimately, the majority creates a controversy where there is none," Dennis wrote. "The majority then issues an advisory opinion on the way it would answer the hypothetical questions that only it has raised."

"Such an advisory opinion is inappropriate, unnecessary, and beyond the purview of federal courts," Dennis wrote, citing a precedential federal court ruling that stated "federal courts have never been empowered to issue advisory opinions."

"The majority's lengthy opinion is dictum and not binding precedent in this court," Dennis wrote. "For these reasons, I respectfully but emphatically dissent."

Follow NBC Out on Twitter, Facebook & Instagram

Husband pleads guilty to killing transgender activist spouse in the Berkshires .
A North Adams man on Thursday admitted to killing his wife, the transgender activist Christa Leigh Steele-Knudslien, and was sentenced to life in prison with parole eligibility in 25 years, prosecutors said. © A. Vicki Boisseau Christa Leigh Steele-Knudslien (left) and her husband, Mark Steele-Knudslien, who has been convicted of murdering her and sentenced to life with parole eligibility in 25 years. Mark Steele-Knudslien, 49, pleaded guilty in Berkshire Superior Court to second-degree murder, Berkshire District Attorney Andrea Harrington’s office said in a statement.

—   Share news in the SOC. Networks

Topical videos:

usr: 1
This is interesting!