•   
  •   
  •   

US Some Questions for Kamala Harris About Eligibility | Opinion

15:52  12 august  2020
15:52  12 august  2020 Source:   newsweek.com

Willie Brown: Kamala Harris should 'politely decline' any offer to be Biden's running mate

  Willie Brown: Kamala Harris should 'politely decline' any offer to be Biden's running mate Former San Francisco Mayor Willie Brown (D) advised Sen. Kamala Harris (D-Calif.) to "politely decline" any offer to be presumptive Democratic presidential nominee Joe Biden's running mate.Brown wrote that the vice presidency would likely hinder any further political ambitions for Harris."[H]istorically, the vice presidency has often ended up being a dead end. For every George H.W. Bush, who ascended from the job to the presidency, there's anBrown wrote that the vice presidency would likely hinder any further political ambitions for Harris.

The fact that Senator Kamala Harris has just been named the vice presidential running mate for presumptive Democratic presidential nominee Joe Biden has some questioning her eligibility for the position. The 12th Amendment provides that "no person constitutionally ineligible to the office of President shall be eligible to that of Vice-President of the United States." And Article II of the Constitution specifies that "[n]o person except a natural born citizen...shall be eligible to the office of President." Her father was (and is) a Jamaican national, her mother was from India, and neither was a naturalized U.S. citizen at the time of Harris' birth in 1964. That, according to these commentators, makes her not a "natural born citizen"—and therefore ineligible for the office of the president and, hence, ineligible for the office of the vice president.

Trump: Harris 'the kind of opponent everyone dreams of'

  Trump: Harris 'the kind of opponent everyone dreams of' President Trump kept up his attacks on Sen. Kamala Harris (D-Calif.), who has named former Vice President Joe Biden's running mate for the Democratic presidential ticket, saying early Wednesday she is "the kind of opponent everyone dreams of.""@KamalaHarris started strong in the Democrat Primaries, and finished weak, ultimately fleeing the race with almost zero support," Trump tweeted. "That's the kind of opponent everyone dreams of!" .@"@KamalaHarris started strong in the Democrat Primaries, and finished weak, ultimately fleeing the race with almost zero support," Trump tweeted.

Kamala Harris sitting on a table: Sen. Kamala Harris (D-CA) © Toni Sandys-Pool/Getty Images Sen. Kamala Harris (D-CA)

"Nonsense," runs the counter-commentary. Indeed, PolitiFact rated the claim of ineligibility as "Pants on Fire" false, Snopes rated it simply "False," and from the other side of the political spectrum, Conservative Daily News likewise rated it "False." All three (and numerous others) simply assert that Harris is eligible because she was born in Oakland—and is therefore a natural-born citizen from location of birth. The 14th Amendment says so, they all claim, and the Supreme Court so held in the 1898 case of U.S. v. Wong Kim Ark.

But those claims are erroneous, at least as the Citizenship Clause of the 14th Amendment was originally understood—an error to which even my good friend, renowned UCLA School of Law professor Eugene Volokh, has fallen prey.

Here are Kamala Harris's K Street connections

  Here are Kamala Harris's K Street connections Former staffers and associates of Sen. Kamala Harris (D-Calif.) just got a lot more influential.Harris, who was named running mate for presumptive Democratic presidential nominee Joe Biden on Tuesday, has a former staffer working as a lobbyist, and several lobbyists in D.C. have thrown fundraisers for the California Democrat over the years.Grant Barbosa, a former aide to Harris, is director of government affairs and policy at Emergent BioSolutions, a biopharmaceutical company that develops vaccines and therapeutics and provides medical devices for biodefense.Before becoming a lobbyist, Barbosa was legislative assistant to Harris for a year starting in March 2017.

The language of Article II is that one must be a natural-born citizen. The original Constitution did not define citizenship, but the 14th Amendment does—and it provides that "all persons born...in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens." Those who claim that birth alone is sufficient overlook the second phrase. The person must also be "subject to the jurisdiction" of the United States, and that meant subject to the complete jurisdiction, not merely a partial jurisdiction such as that which applies to anyone temporarily sojourning in the United States (whether lawfully or unlawfully). Such was the view of those who authored the 14th Amendment's Citizenship Clause; of the Supreme Court of the United States in the 1872 Slaughter-House Cases and the 1884 case of Elk v. Wilkins; of Thomas Cooley, the leading constitutional treatise writer of the day; and of the State Department, which, in the 1880s, issued directives to U.S. embassies to that effect.

Editor's Note: Eastman's Newsweek Column Has Nothing to Do With Racist Birtherism

  Editor's Note: Eastman's Newsweek Column Has Nothing to Do With Racist Birtherism Some readers saw the essay's constitutional analysis as an attempt to ignite a racist conspiracy theory around Kamala Harris. That could not be further from the truth.The 14th Amendment is one of the most-studied areas of constitutional law, and questions were raised by the Constitution's Article II, Section 1 "natural born Citizen" requirement for presidential eligibility about both John McCain and Ted Cruz, at the time of their respective runs.

Kamala Harris Makes History As First Black Woman VP Nominee
  Some Questions for Kamala Harris About Eligibility | Opinion Newsweek See more videos
What to watch next
  • Valerie Jarrett wearing glasses

    Former senior adviser to President Obama Valerie Jarrett on Kamala Harris as Biden’s running mate

    CBS News Logo
    CBS News
  • a person standing in front of a crowd

    Kamala Harris becomes first woman of color to run for vice president on a major party ticket

    CBS News Logo
    CBS News
  • Kamala Harris smiling for the camera

    Eye Opener: Kamala Harris named Biden’s running mate

    CBS News Logo
    CBS News
  • Mike Pompeo wearing a suit and tie

    Pompeo meets Czech Prime Minister Babis

    Reuters Logo
    Reuters
  • a close up of Kamala Harris

    Media spin Kamala Harris as 'pragmatic moderate' instead of far-left Democrat

    FOX News Logo
    FOX News
  • a person smiling for the camera

    New York AG: Kamala Harris is the 'full package'

    MSNBC Logo
    MSNBC
  • a screen shot of Sarah Teale

    What Biden choosing Kamala Harris as his running mate means for the market

    CNBC Logo
    CNBC
  • a car parked in a parking lot

    Why ballot drop boxes are an easy alternative to USPS

    CNN Logo
    CNN
  • Stacy Washington posing for the camera

    Black Voices for Trump member: Biden chose Harris because she's Black, but to most Black Americans she's not

    FOX News Logo
    FOX News
  • a man and a woman looking at the camera

    Will Kamala Harris on the Biden ticket be enough to satisfy progressive voters?

    FOX News Logo
    FOX News
  • Sannikov: 'Lukashenko is scared'

    Sannikov: 'Lukashenko is scared'

    CNN Logo
    CNN
  • What could happen to TikTok and WeChat after Trump ban

    What could happen to TikTok and WeChat after Trump ban

    Trump Promotes Doubts about Kamala Harris’s Citizenship

      Trump Promotes Doubts about Kamala Harris’s Citizenship “I heard it today that [Harris] doesn’t meet the requirements” for citizenship, Trump told reporters at the White House. “And, by the way, the lawyer that wrote that [Newsweek] piece is a very highly qualified, very talented lawyer. I have no idea if that’s right. I would have assumed the Democrats would have checked that out.” The legal debate Trump is referring to considers whether the 14th Amendment of the Constitution confers citizenship on children of non-U.S. citizens residing in the U.S. at the time of their child’s birth. Harris’s parents were not yet naturalized citizens when she was born.

    CNN Logo
    CNN
  • a group of people sitting around a car

    New video of SUV crashing into Atlanta hospital

    ABC News Logo
    ABC News
  • a man wearing a suit and tie

    DHS chief: We will remain in Portland to protect our facilities

    FOX News Logo
    FOX News
  • Kamala Harris wearing a suit and tie

    Biden chooses Harris as running mate

    ABC News Logo
    ABC News
  • a group of people standing in front of a crowd

    More students quarantined due to school’s COVID-19 outbreak

    ABC News Logo
    ABC News
  • Valerie Jarrett wearing glasses Former senior adviser to President Obama Valerie Jarrett on Kamala Harris as Biden’s running mate Valerie Jarrett, a former senior adviser to President Obama, joins “CBS This Morning” to discuss the significance of Senator Kamala Harris as Joe Biden's running mate. CBS News Logo CBS News
  • a person standing in front of a crowd Kamala Harris becomes first woman of color to run for vice president on a major party ticket Former Vice President Joe Biden will appear alongside his newly named running mate at an event in his hometown of Wilmington, Delaware. Biden had pledged to pick a woman as his vice president, but his choice of Harris was a closely guarded secret until he texted supporters the news on Tuesday. Ed O’Keefe reports. CBS News Logo CBS News
  • Kamala Harris smiling for the camera Eye Opener: Kamala Harris named Biden’s running mate California Senator Kamala Harris has been named presumptive Democratic nominee Joe Biden’s 2020 running mate. Also, the Big Ten college athletic conference announced it will be cancelling fall sports over coronavirus concerns. All that and all that matters in today’s Eye Opener. Your world in 90 seconds. CBS News Logo CBS News

The Supreme Court's subsequent decision in Wong Kim Ark is not to the contrary. At issue there was a child born to Chinese immigrants who had become lawful, permanent residents in the United States—"domiciled" was the legally significant word used by the Court. But that was the extent of the Court's holding (as opposed to broader language that was dicta, and therefore not binding). Indeed, the Supreme Court has never held that anyone born on U.S. soil, no matter the circumstances of the parents, is automatically a U.S. citizen.

Trump officials blame media for questions of Harris’ eligibility

  Trump officials blame media for questions of Harris’ eligibility The president had broached the topic last week.“This is not something that we’re going to pursue,” White House chief of staff Mark Meadows told Jake Tapper on CNN’s “State of the Union.

Granted, our government's view of the Constitution's citizenship mandate has morphed over the decades to what is now an absolute "birth on the soil no matter the circumstances" view—but that morphing does not appear to have begun until the late 1960s, after Kamala Harris' birth in 1964. The children born on U.S. soil to guest workers from Mexico during the Roaring 1920s were not viewed as citizens, for example, when, in the wake of the Great Depression, their families were repatriated to Mexico. Nor were the children born on U.S. soil to guest workers in the bracero program of the 1950s and early 1960s deemed citizens when that program ended, and their families emigrated back to their home countries.

So before we so cavalierly accept Senator Harris' eligibility for the office of vice president, we should ask her a few questions about the status of her parents at the time of her birth.

Were Harris' parents lawful permanent residents at the time of her birth? If so, then under the actual holding of Wong Kim Ark, she should be deemed a citizen at birth—that is, a natural-born citizen—and hence eligible. Or were they instead, as seems to be the case, merely temporary visitors, perhaps on student visas issued pursuant to Section 101(15)(F) of Title I of the 1952 Immigration Act? If the latter were indeed the case, then derivatively from her parents, Harris was not subject to the complete jurisdiction of the United States at birth, but instead owed her allegiance to a foreign power or powers—Jamaica, in the case of her father, and India, in the case of her mother—and was therefore not entitled to birthright citizenship under the 14th Amendment as originally understood.

Meadows says Harris is eligible to be vice president, pushing back on birther claims

  Meadows says Harris is eligible to be vice president, pushing back on birther claims White House chief of staff Mark Meadows said that Sen. Kamala Harris (D-Calif.), who was named as presumptive Democratic nominee Joe Biden's running mate last week, is eligible to serve as vice president, after President Trump discussed a conspiracy theory that raised doubts about her qualifications. CNN's Jake Tapper asked Meadows on "State of the Union" on Sunday whether Harris was eligible to become vice president, prompting the chief of staff to answer, "Sure.

Interestingly, this recitation of the original meaning of the 14th Amendment Citizenship Clause might also call into question Harris' eligibility for her current position as a United States senator. Article I, Section 3 of the Constitution specifies that to be eligible for the office of senator, one must have been "nine Years a Citizen of the United States." If Harris was not a citizen at birth, we would need to know when (if ever) she became a citizen. Her father's biographical page at Stanford University identifies his citizenship status as follows: "Jamaica (by birth); U.S. (by naturalization)." But there is some dispute over whether he was in fact ever naturalized, and it is also unclear whether Harris' mother ever became a naturalized citizen. If neither was ever naturalized, or at least not naturalized before Harris' 16th birthday (which would have allowed her to obtain citizenship derived from their naturalization under the immigration law, at the time), then she would have had to become naturalized herself in order to be a citizen. That does not appear to have ever happened, yet without it, she could not have been "nine Years a Citizen of the United States" before her election to the U.S. Senate.

I have no doubt that this significant challenge to Harris' constitutional eligibility to the second-highest office in the land will be dismissed out of hand as so much antiquated constitutional tripe. But the concerns about divided allegiance that led our nation's Founders to include the "natural-born citizen" requirement for the office of president and commander-in-chief remain important; indeed, with persistent threats from Russia, China and others to our sovereignty and electoral process, those concerns are perhaps even more important today. It would be an inauspicious start for any campaign for the highest offices in the land to ignore the Constitution's eligibility requirements; how else could we possibly expect the candidates, if elected, to honor their oaths to "faithfully execute the Office of President of the United States, and...to the best of [their] Ability, preserve, protect and defend the Constitution of the United States?"

Dr. John C. Eastman is the Henry Salvatori professor of law & community service and former dean at Chapman University's Fowler School of Law. He is also the 2020-21 visitor scholar in conservative thought and policy at the Benson Center for the Study of Western Civilization, University of Colorado Boulder. Dr. Eastman is also a senior fellow at the Claremont Institute and founding Director of the Institute's Center for Constitutional Jurisprudence.

The views expressed in this article are the writer's own.

Start your unlimited Newsweek trial

At the DNC, America meets Kamala Harris' blended family .
Family members Maya Harris, Meena Harris and Ella Emhoff gave the nominating speech for Kamala Harris at the DNC.A biographical montage for Harris' family life was jointly presented by her sister, Maya Harris, her niece Meena Harris, and her stepdaughter Ella Emhoff, who called her "Momala, the world’s greatest step-mom.

—   Share news in the SOC. Networks
usr: 9
This is interesting!