•   
  •   
  •   

US Renters thought a CDC order protected them from eviction. Then landlords found loopholes.

14:41  27 october  2020
14:41  27 october  2020 Source:   washingtonpost.com

Loss for everyone as CDC's standing erodes

  Loss for everyone as CDC's standing erodes The recent degradations of the CDC’s trustworthiness could compromise our ability to cope with emergencies for generations to come. Scientific integrity can only exist when politicians and political candidates are publicly committed to scientific independence: regarding airplane safety, on drug approval procedures, and especially for public health guidelines. The Associated Press describes this faux CDC Order, used to achieve the White House's anti-immigration goals, as "a profound dereliction of duty for a CDC director." It is hard to emphasize what a gross understatement that is.

When the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention announced last month that most evictions nationwide were banned until the end of December, it In the meantime, landlords are allowed to tack on late fees. That means for many renters , the order will just delay their eviction by a few months.

The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention implemented a temporary eviction moratorium through the end of the year, protecting U.S. renters from losing their homes during the COVID-19 pandemic, the Trump administration announced Tuesday. The CDC ’s moratorium will apply to all

Emily Brockman was in her apartment complex’s rental office, boxed in again by the bleak details of her situation.

Shalonda Glascoe examines a window at the townhouse where she lives in Baltimore on Oct. 14, Despite a CDC moratorium on evictions until the end of the year, she recently faced eviction after not being able to work for several months. (Michael S. Williamson/The Washington Post) © Michael S. Williamson/The Washington Post Shalonda Glascoe examines a window at the townhouse where she lives in Baltimore on Oct. 14, Despite a CDC moratorium on evictions until the end of the year, she recently faced eviction after not being able to work for several months. (Michael S. Williamson/The Washington Post)

She’d left her full-time work at a catering company at the start of the year. A side job as a house cleaner was supposed to cover her bills until her son Nova was born in April. But then March came, along with the virus. No one wanted a stranger cleaning up. She didn’t want to clean up for strangers. She applied for unemployment in April. Five months later, the money still hadn’t come.

More Than 1,000 CDC Officials Ask: Why Bench the CDC During a Pandemic?

  More Than 1,000 CDC Officials Ask: Why Bench the CDC During a Pandemic? In an open letter published this week, 1,044 former and current officers of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention’s Epidemic Intelligence Service, a renowned fellowship program that focuses on research and emergency response, expressed concern over the diminished role of the public health agency during the coronavirus pandemic. The letter had one clear demand: Take the CDC off the bench. © Photo: Erin Scott / Pool (Getty Images) Robert Redfield, director of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, wears a protective mask during a House Select Subcommittee on the Coronavirus Crisis hearing on July 31, 2020.

The updated guidance from the Centers of Disease Control and Prevention and the Justice Department come as eviction protections in several states The eviction moratorium from the CDC that followed the president’s executive order postponed all evictions until December 31, but the new

However, rest assured, landlords and agents are likely to do their best to find ways to recoup any losses they incur. This legislation may have been So it’s likely that landlords – and agents who tend to charge landlords a percentage of the rent – will seek to protect their bottom line by hiking rents.

She owed $1,550 in back rent on her two-bedroom apartment in a modest section of southeastern Lexington, Ky. If she were evicted, Brockman had no family or friends to stay with. She feared that if she landed in a homeless shelter, child welfare might come for Nova.

But that Tuesday morning, Sept. 15, Brockman listened as the property manager at her building began talking about a new order from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, something that could keep her in her apartment for a few more months. Sign the two-page declaration and bring it to her court date later that week, she was told. Here was a tiny thread of hope in what had been six months of emotional ups and downs.

Brockman, 38, left the office, carefully scanning the 522 words of legalese as she walked through a courtyard where she had seen sheriff’s deputies stack the belongings of evicted neighbors.

Government agency will investigate Trump administration political influence over FDA, CDC

  Government agency will investigate Trump administration political influence over FDA, CDC Both agencies have been caught in political crossfire since the start of the pandemic, as preventative health measures became politicized.The Government Accountability Office, an independent legislative agency that investigates, audits and evaluates government operations for Congress, accepted a Senate request on Monday to examine potential political interference and "determine whether this interference has violated the agencies’ scientific integrity and communication policies.

Rent control encourages landlords to leave units empty until the ideal tenant comes along. Usually better to wait than deal with a shit tenant. Then as demand increases they trickle out the availability as they maintain the higher prices, while maintaining artificially created scarcity.

Toronto landlord Ke (David) Wang used the N12 loophole to evict renters from at least four You're evicting somebody and forcing them to go through the nightmare of moving, and finding a new Then -owner Janet Coles says she received verbal pledges that Mr. Wang would not evict her tenants

All the criteria appeared to fit: “I am unable to pay my full rent or make a full housing payment due to substantial loss of household income.”

“I have used best efforts to obtain all available government assistance for rent.”

“If evicted I would likely become homeless.”

“I’m like, ‘Check, check, check,’” Brockman said recently. She felt relief mixed with excitement. “The CDC guidelines seemed designed exactly for someone like me."

Millions of Americans, knocked financially sideways by the coronavirus pandemic, were thinking the same. Anchored in public health concerns that the economic stress of the pandemic will force millions of renters from the safety of their homes and into the crosshairs of a fast-spreading virus, the CDC order aims to keep the estimated 40 million renters facing eviction this year in place through Jan. 1. “I want to make it unmistakably clear that I’m protecting people from evictions,” President Trump said in a statement when the CDC order was announced.

Big Brother All-Stars: Enzo Palumbo wins HoH and nominates two to go

  Big Brother All-Stars: Enzo Palumbo wins HoH and nominates two to go The 42-year-old insurance adjuster won the Head of Household competition and made the Final Three on Monday's episode of Big Brother: All-Stars. The 42-year-old insurance adjuster then nominated Christmas Abbott, 38, and Nicole Franzel, 28, for eviction, leaving Cody Calafiore, 29, once again untouched.That gave Cody unprecedented power, as he would be the only person to vote on who went home after the eviction ceremony, unless one of the women won veto power.

The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention issued an order on September 1 banning evictions of people who lost work as a result of the pandemic. The CDC ’s order applies to as many as 40 million renters across the country who could be at risk of eviction for nonpayment of rent.

The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention ( CDC ), located within the Department of Health and Human This Order is a temporary eviction moratorium to prevent the further spread of COVID-19. CDC recommends that shelters provide new residents with a clean mask, keep them isolated from Many renters who fell outside the scope of the Federal moratorium were protected under State and

But as Brockman and tens of thousands of others soon realized, rather than offer a bubble of temporary stability in the midst of the pandemic, the federal response has injected confusion into housing courts. Because of the order’s wording, which gives local judges room for interpretation, evictions have continued. According to Princeton University’s Eviction Lab, from Sept. 4, the date the CDC order took effect, through Oct. 23, 20,523 evictions were filed in the 22 cities monitored by the project’s researchers. The CDC and the White House did not immediately respond to requests for comment.

Within weeks of filling out the CDC declaration, Brockman was sitting in her apartment, cradling Nova and waiting for the sheriff’s deputies to knock on her door.

A flawed order

The CDC’s September order landed after a tense waiting game over how the Trump administration would tackle a housing crisis triggered by the coronavirus outbreak but rooted in decades of economic inequality.

The jobs and wages swept aside by the ensuing recession have pushed an estimated 8 million Americans into poverty since May. Experts say as many as 40 million tenants could be evicted by the end of the year. When the $2 trillion Cares Act, part of the government’s first attempt at stabilizing the economy, ran dry in July, state and local governments launched their own eviction moratoriums and rent relief programs. The result was a poorly funded patchwork. Everyone — local officials, landlord associations, tenant advocates — believed that only more federal aid could keep people in their homes. But in September, the prospects for another stimulus package were looking bleak.

South Korea finance minister loses home as housing policy comes back to haunt

  South Korea finance minister loses home as housing policy comes back to haunt South Korea finance minister loses home as housing policy comes back to hauntSEOUL (Reuters) - South Korea's finance minister, the architect of rules aimed at protecting tenants and slowing deposit increases, has himself been forced to look for a new home as landlords react to the rules by quickly replacing tenants so they can bump up deposits.

Landlords say the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention ’s unprecedented order for a national Prior to this week’s CDC order , renter evictions were picking back up in some major U.S. cities However, Randel thinks temporary eviction bans are hardly the biggest driver shaping the

Landlords arguing CDC overstepping its authority. The NAA joined a group of landlords in filing a lawsuit The NAA and the landlords are arguing that the CDC is using the order to “commandeer” state They are also arguing that, because they , as property owners, continue to cover the costs of

Meanwhile, public health experts warned that evictions would spread the virus. In early September, University of Pennsylvania researchers conducted a computer modeling simulation on how evictions might affect the infection rate of a city of 1 million residents and found that even a “low eviction rate of 0.25 percent” per month was responsible for around 15,000 new coronavirus cases and 150 deaths.

The CDC action aimed to directly address this threat. “Evictions threaten to increase the spread of covid-19 as they force people to move, often into close quarters in new shared housing settings with friends or family, or congregate settings such as homeless shelters,” the order states. “In the context of a pandemic, eviction moratoria — like quarantine, isolation, and social distancing — can be an effective public health measure utilized to prevent the spread of communicable disease.”

But the order, which applies to individuals earning less than $99,000 annually, or $198,000 for couples, has failed to protect people for several reasons. For tenants who sign the declaration, it does not erase any of the rent or late fees they owe.

Unlike the jurisdiction-wide moratoriums in places like the District., the CDC’s protection is not automatic. Tenants first have to sign the declaration under penalty of perjury and give it to their landlord, or, if their landlord still moves to evict them, bring it to court.

On The Money: Finger-pointing picks up in COVID-19 relief fight | Landlords, housing industry sue CDC to overturn eviction ban

  On The Money: Finger-pointing picks up in COVID-19 relief fight | Landlords, housing industry sue CDC to overturn eviction ban Happy Friday and welcome back to On The Money. I'm Sylvan Lane, and here's your nightly guide to everything affecting your bills, bank account and bottom line.See something I missed? Let me know at slane@thehill.com or tweet me @SylvanLane. And if you like your newsletter, you can subscribe to it here: http://bit.ly/1NxxW2N.Write us with tips, suggestions and news: slane@thehill.com, njagoda@thehill.com and nelis@thehill.com. Follow us on Twitter: @SylvanLane, @NJagoda and @NivElis.THE BIG DEAL-Finger-pointing picks up in COVID-19 relief fight: The blame game is heating up as it becomes increasingly clear there will be no new COVID-19 relief deal before Election Day.

The declaration’s simple wording appears straightforward at first, but without more detailed guidance, it can be frustratingly ambiguous. Allilsa Fernandez, 37, of Queens was not able to start a new full-time job as a home health aid in March because of the pandemic, and asthma limited her ability to find other work. When her roommate also lost her job, they fell far behind on their $1,800 monthly rent. Fernandez, who has been receiving weekly eviction notices, didn’t sign a declaration because she couldn’t tell whether she met the order’s requirements. “You have to prove financial hardship but how do I prove that I had a job lined up that went away?” she said.

State supreme courts have issued their own guidance to local judges on how to interpret the order. For example, in Maryland, courts have been instructed to still determine the merits of an eviction case — decide whether the tenant should be removed — but hold off on final execution of the judgment until after the moratorium expires.

Across the border in Virginia, the state Supreme Court has not issued guidance, meaning each jurisdiction is free to enact however it wishes. Some counties are continuing judgments while others are dismissing all eviction cases outright. “There is a lot of variation in how it’s being applied,” said Steve Fischbach, the litigation director of the Virginia Poverty Law Center.

Judges also have discretion to “interrogate tenants about the veracity of their statements in the declaration,” said Ben Carter, the senior litigation and advocacy counsel at the Kentucky Equal Justice Center. Some judges accept the declarations. Others question the renters in court under oath. “Judges should be taking the declaration at face value and allowing people to move on with the work of staying healthy at home,” Carter said.

Fact check: Donald Trump Jr.'s claim about flu deaths, data manipulation is false

  Fact check: Donald Trump Jr.'s claim about flu deaths, data manipulation is false Flu seasons vary from year to year and don't have a strict timeline. Last year, flu season was the longest in a decade, lasting 21 weeks. “In the United States, flu season occurs in the fall and winter. While influenza viruses circulate year-round, most of the time flu activity peaks between December and February, but activity can last as late as May," the CDC website explains. To account for this ambiguous period, the CDC releases weekly U.S. influenza summary updates from October through May. The CDC's first report for the 2020-2021 flu season was posted for the week ending Oct. 3.

a man sitting at a desk: Shalonda Glascoe goes through some of the paperwork related to an attempt to evict her in Baltimore on Oct. 14. Glascoe has been in a long-term fight with her landlord over conditions at the townhouse she rents. (Michael S. Williamson/The Washington Post) © Michael S. Williamson/The Washington Post Shalonda Glascoe goes through some of the paperwork related to an attempt to evict her in Baltimore on Oct. 14. Glascoe has been in a long-term fight with her landlord over conditions at the townhouse she rents. (Michael S. Williamson/The Washington Post)

To clarify these issues, on Oct. 9 the CDC released a “non-binding guidance document” which advises state courts to continue entering judgments against tenants but hold off on actually removing renters from their property until Jan. 1. The new guidance also allows a landlord to challenge the truthfulness of a tenant’s declaration and clarifies that landlords have no obligation to tell tenants about the CDC protection.

The new guidance was seen as a win for property owners; in a statement, the National Apartment Association, a leading landlord advocacy group, said, “Eviction moratoria are not the answer and will do nothing to solve renters’ housing insecurity.” The NAA and other landlord groups have also filed an ongoing lawsuit challenging the CDC order.

This mishmash of local interpretation and federal guidance has created a disorienting legal fog for tenants such as Brockman.

In mid-September, she stepped into a crowded Fayette County courthouse, with Nova and her signed CDC declaration. She did not have a lawyer with her, though, as she took her place in a long line of tenants spaced six feet apart. When Brockman finally reached the courtroom, she learned a judgment had already been entered against her in the case. She asked why she was being evicted despite having signed the CDC declaration. The judge replied that she did not qualify for the moratorium because she had failed to make a partial payment.

Brockman left without explaining that she actually had attempted to make a partial payment through a state rental assistance program. “When a judge tells you you don’t qualify, what can you say?” she later recalled. Instead, she sat down on a bench in the hallway, and “the tears just started flowing."

Cruises can begin phased return starting Nov. 1 under new protocols, CDC says

  Cruises can begin phased return starting Nov. 1 under new protocols, CDC says The Centers for Disease Control (CDC) on Friday announced that it will lift its no-sail order on cruises, which banned large cruise ships from operating in U.S. waters since March. Effective Nov. 1., the ban will be replaced with a “conditional sailing order,” which lays out a framework for a phased return to cruising that includes new health protocols, such as mandatory testing and capacity restrictions. © Tim Rue/Bloomberg News The Carnival Corp. Miracle and Panorama cruise ships sit acnhored at the Port of Long Beach in Long Beach, California, U.S., on Monday, April 13, 2020.

‘What a mess this all is.’

The CDC order’s biggest loophole, tenant rights lawyers say, may be a single clause in the order that reads: “You may be evicted for reasons other than not paying rent.It gives landlords ways around the moratorium and the ability to evict tenants like Shalonda Glascoe, who rents a townhouse in Baltimore.

On an early October afternoon, the 47-year-old was hunting for her signed CDC declaration in the stack of papers on her kitchen table when she heard the front door crack open. She hurried into the hall, head spinning with possibilities. Even though court records show she and her landlord had settled a dispute over her living conditions — a bedroom ceiling that gushed water when it rained; a dishwasher that kept flooding the house — in November, the landlord had begun eviction proceedings earlier this year. “They are retaliating against me for fighting them,” she said. Glascoe was challenging the eviction order in court. Still, she worried: Had they called the deputies anyway to kick her out?

It turned out to be her daughter’s friends, who had stopped by to buy Glascoe’s mattress. “We have to get some money coming in here some way,” she said as she counted the bills.

Glascoe has not had full-time work since a 2016 accident left her unable to do her job as a Maryland Transit Administration bus driver. The pandemic made it hard to pick up seasonal and part-time delivery gigs. These days, she collects a weekly $176 unemployment check and whatever proceeds she gets from selling T-shirts she designs with her daughter. It’s not enough to cover her monthly rent of $1,155. The company that owns her townhouse said that as of August, she owed about $8,000.

Because Glascoe was struggling to make the rent payments, C. Matthew Hill, an attorney with the Public Justice Center in Baltimore, believed she qualified for the CDC order. Her landlords disagreed because they were not evicting her for failure to meet her payments. They were simply not renewing her lease, an option in Maryland known as a tenant holding over action. Property owners are not required to provide justification, only give notice.

“We fully understand that the CDC order is an important part of what is going on in the country right now,” the landlord’s attorney argued in a Baltimore courtroom in mid-October. “But it was never designed for people who are no longer legal tenants.” The judge sided with the landlord.

In the end, Glascoe was able to keep her home because the judge later determined that a local law shielded her from any eviction filing within six months of her previous case against her landlord. Her lease was automatically renewed.

Hill, her attorney, was pleased with the outcome, but frustrated with how easy it is to circumvent the eviction moratorium. “It is clearly her inability to pay the rent that has led us here,” he said. “Her case shows the limitations of the CDC order and what a mess this all is."

a man standing in a room: Shalonda Glascoe recently got a reprieve in her case after a judge ruled that she could stay in the home she has been renting. © Michael S. Williamson/The Washington Post Shalonda Glascoe recently got a reprieve in her case after a judge ruled that she could stay in the home she has been renting.

Praying for a reprieve

On a Monday in September, the day Brockman was supposed to be out of her unit, every sound outside her apartment brought her to the front door.

“This level of anxiety is something I’ve never felt,” she said. “It’s not going away."

As she waited for the sheriff’s deputies, she constantly checked her cellphone for a text message from Carter, whom she had found through the Kentucky tenants rights organization. The attorney had filed a motion to amend the judgment entered against Brockman. Late in the afternoon, after many trips to the window, she received a message that she had been granted a hearing for Friday, keeping the deputies at bay a little while longer.

At the hearing, Carter convinced the judge to extend the CDC protection to Brockman. “This is a woman who is waiting on unemployment benefits, she has a 5-month-old kid, and she did everything she was supposed to do, and she only escaped eviction by a cat’s whisker,” he said later.

Before leaving court, Brockman was given a new court date to address her potential eviction — Jan. 15, 2021, “which will be here before you know it,” she said.

Cruises can begin phased return starting Nov. 1 under new protocols, CDC says .
The Centers for Disease Control (CDC) on Friday announced that it will lift its no-sail order on cruises, which banned large cruise ships from operating in U.S. waters since March. Effective Nov. 1., the ban will be replaced with a “conditional sailing order,” which lays out a framework for a phased return to cruising that includes new health protocols, such as mandatory testing and capacity restrictions. © Tim Rue/Bloomberg News The Carnival Corp. Miracle and Panorama cruise ships sit acnhored at the Port of Long Beach in Long Beach, California, U.S., on Monday, April 13, 2020.

usr: 37
This is interesting!