US Searching for the real Appalachia in Netflix’s ‘Hillbilly Elegy’

13:55  20 november  2020
13:55  20 november  2020 Source:   washingtonpost.com

Who Is Netflix’s Hillbilly Elegy For?

  Who Is Netflix’s Hillbilly Elegy For? The streamer’s piece of Oscar bait, based on J.D. Vance’s controversial memoir, is an exercise in elite arrogance. Lacey Terrell/NETFLIX Reader, I cannot tell you anything about the holler aunt. Like the mythical Sasquatch, she eludes me. On the subject of Hillbilly Elegy itself, however, I have much more to say — and none of it is positive.But first I must admit that I did not expect to like this movie, and I have resented Netflix for midwifing it into being. My antipathy for its source material — J.D. Vance’s 2016 memoir of the same name — is by now well-established.

Photo: Lacey Terrell/ NETFLIX . Five minutes into Hillbilly Elegy , I hit pause and walked out of my living room. In the relative safety of my bedroom, I stared at the wall and Elegy isn’t meant for the people of Appalachia , or the Ozarks, or the Rust Belt. No hillbilly film is ever made for the people it depicts.

Hillbilly Elegy : A Memoir of a Family and Culture in Crisis is a 2016 memoir by J. D. Vance about the Appalachian values of his Kentucky family and their relation to the social problems of his hometown

About US is an initiative by The Washington Post to explore issues of identity in the United States. Sign up for the newsletter.

(Washington Post photo illustration; Lacey Terrell/Netflix; Harper) (Washington Post photo illustration; Lacey Terrell/Netflix; Harper)

The film adaptation of “Hillbilly Elegy,” J.D. Vance’s best-selling memoir about growing up in Appalachia, reflects common Hollywood story lines: One man is able to overcome poverty through personal responsibility, hard work, a splash of military service and good old-fashioned grit, with the help of his straight-talking grandmother. A trailer for the $45 million movie, which opened in some theaters the week after the tumultuous presidential election and will be released on Netflix on Nov. 24, contains subtitles to help viewers understand the thick country accents used to imitate families from Appalachia. But like the book, which came under scrutiny from writers, scholars and some residents of Appalachia, the film contains many omissions and inaccuracies about the region that could prove harmful, given our current political times. Ignoring the complex tapestry and depths of social inequality of the region, as public historian Elizabeth Catte argues in her response to the memoir’s acclaim, also runs the risk of stereotyping Appalachia as a mythical all-White “Trump Country.”

Is It ‘Classist’ to Think ‘Hillbilly Elegy’ Is a Raging Dumpster Fire of a Movie?

  Is It ‘Classist’ to Think ‘Hillbilly Elegy’ Is a Raging Dumpster Fire of a Movie? The thing about Hillbilly Elegy is that it is a garbage movie. That’s not a flippant dismissal of the new Netflix film, directed by Ron Howard, based on J.D. Vance’s 2016 memoir, and starring Amy Adams and Glenn Close in backwoods drag. It’s to say that, when carefully considered, there is very little, if anything at all, that is redeemable about it; whatever misguided intention there was behind it, the resulting product is disposable. If you’reThat’s not a flippant dismissal of the new Netflix film, directed by Ron Howard, based on J.D. Vance’s 2016 memoir, and starring Amy Adams and Glenn Close in backwoods drag.

Hillbilly Elegy Ratings & Reviews Explanation. See score details. Submit review. Imagine Entertainment, Netflix . Aspect Ratio Hillbilly Elegy is something of a confused (not confusing) mess.

Hillbilly Elegy marks yet another major project for Close after Olivia Colman pulled off a stunning Best Actress upset over The Wife star at the 2019 Oscars; In “I have some exciting possibilities coming up, but I think I need to rest and reboot and get into really great shape for the next phase, and then see

We are not movie critics, but we grew up in Appalachia and have worked throughout and studied the inequalities of the region. We grew up in poor and in working-class families, one in eastern Kentucky and the other a few ridges over in southwestern Virginia. We witnessed and experienced the devastation of poverty in the region as the coal mines, mills and factories closed at breakneck speed in the 1980s and 1990s, and the rise of the opioid epidemic spread across the region in the early 2000s. We grew up roughly at the same period of time as Vance but do not recognize his depiction of the region, nor the explanation of the poverty in Appalachia the book and movie offer.

We come from communities with small Main Streets where people gather under Friday night lights for high school football. We are fiercely proud of the accomplishments of our youth and hold pep rallies for our sports teams and our academic teams. We’re home to folk music and bluegrass, but also the brilliance of Bell Hooks, Frank X Walker, and the Affrilachian poets. We pick ramps on the mountainsides in April, kids play in creeks collecting crawdads and see friends gather at volunteer EMT stations in the evening to flatfoot and clog under the stars during summer, and every fall we wake up to nature’s Crayola box as leaves change colors around every bend in the mountains.

Batman crew get creative and build set on an empty studio lot

  Batman crew get creative and build set on an empty studio lot The Batman crew were seen busily preparing a new sprawling set for the superhero flick in a studio lot on Tuesday, new aerial shots have revealed.

Hillbilly Elegy (2020) Movie Trailer: Ron Howard’ s Appalachian Tale of Family Strife Between Gabriel Basso, Amy Adams, & Glenn Close. Please visit the source responsible for the item in question to report any concerns you may have regarding content or accuracy.

Netflix and third parties use cookies and similar technologies on this website to collect information about your browsing activities which we use to analyse your use of the website, to personalise our services and to customise our online advertisements. Netflix supports the Digital Advertising Alliance

Our communities are also unfortunately home to something Vance conveniently ignores about the politics of the region and that of many regions outside of Appalachia that affect families in poverty: mostly GOP politicians who run campaigns full of false promises to bring back private-sector jobs and revitalize local economies, and then turn their backs on them when elected to cater to the party as they oppose anti-poverty programs, the expansion of health-care coverage, increasing education funding, and promoting limited public works and economic expansion in communities thirsty for jobs and stability.

“Hillbilly Elegy” echoes common GOP talking points — prioritizing personal responsibility over community care. It is meant to celebrate personal mobility, but ultimately valorizes Vance’s mobility at the expense of others who grew up like us or him. The only way to be successful in Vance’s narrative is to make it off the mountaintops and out of the isolation of the hollows into those elite spaces said to hold the “best and brightest.” To mark Vance’s journey as unique and hard-won, “Hillbilly Elegy” doesn’t grapple with the structural obstacles and economic exploitation existing for decades in Appalachia. Instead, he calls his peers back home lazy and fatalistic, and ignores those who go out of their way to make it possible for other people to succeed despite not having the opportunities themselves.

Why The Queen's Gambit Cast Seems So Familiar

  Why The Queen's Gambit Cast Seems So Familiar A closer look at the incredibly talented cast of The Queen's Gambit.The final quote of Netflix's The Queen's Gambit has sat with us as we've taken time to digest the tour de force performances we witnessed. As E! readers surely know, The Queen's Gambit follows Beth Harmon (played by Anya Taylor-Joy) as she transforms from stoic orphan to cutthroat chess player.

What about Hillbilly Elegy accounts for this explosion of interest during this period of political turmoil? Why have its ideas raised so much controversy? Written in direct response to Hillbilly Elegy , this collection’ s strength lies in the diversity of its selections. If this had been merely a series of scholarly

A tourist who joined in the search after a member of her bus party went missing was able to help track the woman down - when she realised it was herself they were looking forward. The woman was declared missing from a party touring the Eldgja volcanic region in south Iceland after getting off the

Vance paints Appalachia as a near-exclusively White space, place and worldview. Erased are Black residents and their histories in the region, as amplified in a recent book by sociologist Karida Brown, “Gone Home.” Missing are the many generations of Native American communities too often spoken of as ghosts of the past. Ignored is a growing Latino population dotting the hills and valleys. Disregarded are Appalachians who embrace racial justice and acceptance of their LGBTQ neighbors, marching in communities urging “No Hate In My Holler,” as witnessed in West Virginia, and confronting white supremacists in Pikeville, Ky.

Sociology professor John Eason details the prison boom in rural areas across the United States, including Appalachia, in his book “Big House on the Prairie.” Rather than willingly accepting these prisons, communities are fighting this expansion of mass incarceration in their own backyards as politicians and entrepreneurs dangle the promise of much-needed jobs from the new prisons like a carrot, while beating neighbors with sticks into the cells.

'You' season 3 is coming. Here are all of the spooky details we have so far.

  'You' season 3 is coming. Here are all of the spooky details we have so far. From the cast to the release date, here's everything we know about the hit Netflix thriller that stars Penn Badgley and Victoria Pedretti.From what characters we can expect to see in season three to who the mystery neighbor in the finale might be, read on for what we know so far about the much-anticipated third season of "You.

Little perspective is also offered about the compounding issues of Appalachian poverty. You will not hear about the environmental devastation of the region, including undrinkable tap water. “Hillbilly Elegy” doesn’t recognize families’ efforts for survival by learning how to stretch meager food stamps and unstable paychecks as they continually search for better jobs. Health-care access, constrained by limited options and insurance coverage, means many families must turn to the Remote Area Medical Volunteer Corps, an emergency medical mission. The story of one person’s ability to climb out of the crab bucket without being pulled back by the others doesn’t have room for such nuance. Instead, Vance portrays intergenerational poverty as at least cultural inferiority and at worst a genetic reality — people who break the mold of their unevolved kith and kin are lucky to make it out of the hollow.

But we are also concerned about the timing of the movie’s release as the election results are still being challenged, which is arguably not a coincidence. As the aftermath of the election sets in across the nation, the release of the film probably will stir the pot, continuing to blame poor, rural Whites for election outcomes and protests that turn to violence, including the recent pro-Trump march in D.C. — reminiscent of the book’s release in the midst of the 2016 presidential election fallout. What cannot be lost is that it takes more than one sliver of a demographic to elect a president.

50 ways music has changed in the last 50 years

  50 ways music has changed in the last 50 years Explore the changes that have shaped American music over the last 50 years. From changing genres to innovative new technologies, you'll learn about the shifts that drove the industry, artists, and fans.

In 2016, over half of White voters, including college-educated Whites, supported Trump, and more than half of all suburban voters and those earning more than $50,000 supported Trump, as well. Catte points out many poor rural Whites don’t vote because they are disillusioned by how politicians have treated their communities over the years. Recent exit polls for the 2020 election shows much the same, with an increase in White support for Trump, despite the ongoing deadly pandemic. The racial divide around Trump’s support is clear, and blaming those looked down upon by their middle-class and wealthy White neighbors only uses impoverished families as a buffer to a much-needed larger critique about White voters in general.

In the end, “Hillbilly Elegy” sells the many stereotypes of Appalachian poverty as heartbreakingly true behind the age-old trope of lifting yourself up by your bootstraps. You get an amalgamation of the Hatfields and McCoys, the Clampetts, and all of their poor White friends living in ramshackle houses in the Appalachian Mountains and foothills. Viewers will not find answers to why poverty continues in the United States, how difficult life it is for impoverished families despite their many efforts to climb out of it, or how and why it disproportionately affects Black, Latino, Native American and many Asian American families.

We worry how easily people across the political spectrum will recognize the story line and embrace it in our political times. They may even donate or spend a mission trip helping Appalachian communities, but ultimately go back to the polls to vote for politicians and policies that make the situation worse for families in poverty across the nation. Unfortunately, we’ve seen this movie before.

Kurt Russell wrote a 200-page backstory on Santa for Netflix's 'The Christmas Chronicles 2' .
Director Chris Columbus talked to Insider about the deep dive he and Russell took to make the "Christmas Chronicles" sequel grander than the first.He directed the iconic "Home Alone," produced the Arnold Schwarzenegger/Sinbad zany comedy "Jingle All the Way," and almost took on "National Lampoon's Christmas Vacation" (he quickly exited after realizing he couldn't work with its star Chevy Chase). But he admits he's never gone so deep into the holidays, and specifically the mythology of Christmas, until he worked with Kurt Russell on Netflix's "The Christmas Chronicles" movies.

usr: 32
This is interesting!