•   
  •   
  •   

US Fact check: Article wrongly states Biden COVID-19 adviser's view on vaccine, age

02:25  26 november  2020
02:25  26 november  2020 Source:   usatoday.com

Fact check: What's true and what's false about the 2020 election

  Fact check: What's true and what's false about the 2020 election False claims about the election process are spreading online in wake of the 2020 election. Here's a list of recent fact-checks.Fact check: Pennsylvania voters exposed to COVID-19 can still vote

President-elect Joe Biden warned Monday that the promising COVID - 19 vaccine developed by Pfizer won't In fact , [projections are] still indicating we could lose 200,000 more lives in the coming months before a Biden said at the press conference that when a vaccine does become available, he wants

Facts First: This is wrong -- and not just by a little. Biden overstated the number of military Covid deaths by 6,107 and infections by nearly 79,000. There have been seven deaths in the military due to Covid - 19 and 40,026 cases as of September 9, according to the Defense Department.

The claim: Dr. Ezekiel Emanuel, tapped as Biden COVID-19 adviser, said those over 75 years old should receive the vaccine last

Since President-elect Joe Biden tapped Dr. Ezekiel Emanuel, an oncologist and brother of former Chicago Mayor Rahm Emanuel, to be a member of his coronavirus task force, Emanuel has come under heightened scrutiny for past writings.

An article in The Federalist, a conservative publication, claims that Emanuel believes that people older than 75 should be the last to receive a vaccine for COVID-19, once no shortages exist globally. It cites two pieces of Emanuel’s work as proof he’s against early vaccine administration for the elderly: a 2014 article he wrote for The Atlantic and an article he co-wrote in September for Science Magazine. Promotion for the article was shared on The Federalist’s Instagram.

Pfizer to seek approval from FDA 'within days' after further analysis finds COVID-19 vaccine 95% effective

  Pfizer to seek approval from FDA 'within days' after further analysis finds COVID-19 vaccine 95% effective Pfizer and BioNTech are expected to produce up to 50 million doses globally in 2020 and up to 1.3 billion doses by the end of 2021. The news comes days after Moderna, a Cambridge, Massachusetts-based biotechnology company, announced early Monday its candidate vaccine, mRNA-1273, developed in collaboration with the U.S. government, appeared to be 94.5% effective against COVID-19.

Russia Covid - 19 Vaccine , Coronavirus Gam-COVID-Vac Lyo Vaccine Latest News Update: The superfast speed at which the Russian vaccine has been produced, eclipsing front runners like Oxford-AstraZeneca, Moderna and Pfizer, has led to experts flagging that the government has cut corners.

Fact check : CDC' s estimates COVID - 19 death rate around 0.26%, doesn't confirm it. Ian Richardson. "The CDC just confirmed a .2% death rate for COVID - 19 ," says a May 25 post by Facebook user Bill Faudel, which lists many effects of the virus, including rising unemployment and its

Start the day smarter. Get all the news you need in your inbox each morning.

Emanuel never said that individuals over the age of 75 should be the last to receive a vaccine for COVID-19, nor does the work that The Federalist points to indicate he may hold that position.

“The claims in this piece are completely false,” said Kenneth Baer, a spokesperson for Emanuel.

TJ Ducklo, a spokesperson for Biden, emphasized where the president-elect stands on the matter.

"The President-elect believes that the vaccine process should prioritize safety and efficacy, and be fully transparent so the American people have confidence in any vaccine being put forward," Ducklo said. "It should also be distributed equitably so that  everyone — not just the wealthy and well-connected — receives the protection and care they deserve."

Broncos DC Ed Donatell back home recovering after COVID-related hospitalization

  Broncos DC Ed Donatell back home recovering after COVID-related hospitalization Broncos defensive coordinator Ed Donatell required hospitalization after contracting the coronavirus, according to the team. The second-year Denver DC was hospitalized last week but discharged Sunday. Donatell, 63, has been battling COVID-19 symptoms since Oct. 31 and has missed the past three games. Donatell, who is in his third stint with the franchise, is one of a few Broncos staffers to have contracted the virus. Running backs coach Curtis Modkins did so in October, and offensive line coach Mike Munchak was in the team’s COVID protocol.

Answers to commonly asked questions about COVID - 19 vaccines , including vaccine cost Although CDC does not have a role in developing COVID - 19 vaccines , CDC has been working closely with health departments and partners to HHS Fact Sheet: Explaining Operation Warp Speedexternal icon.

But in fact we have been here before – in England in the 15th Century, King Henry VI banned kissing in an If and when a much-anticipated vaccine for coronavirus emerges and physical contact with those outside our immediate household “bubbles” You can read more of our Covid - 19 coverage here.

The Federalist did not respond to USA TODAY’s multiple requests for comment.

Fact check: Operation Warp Speed official discussed vaccine distribution, not mandatory vaccinations

Emanuel speaks on personal preference in 2014 Atlantic article

Emanuel writes in his 2014 Atlantic piece “Why I Hope to Die at 75” that he personally sees no value in living past that age.

As the Federalist article suggests, Emanuel does write that he would forgo colonoscopies, cancer screenings and antibiotics for common infections – or a flu shot for an imagined flu pandemic, a convenient parallel to the world in which we live today. But as the Federalist author notes, Emanuel says a number of times that his argument reflects his own personal view.

“I am not saying that those who want to live as long as possible are unethical or wrong. I am certainly not scorning or dismissing people who want to live on despite their physical and mental limitations. I’m not even trying to convince anyone I’m right. ... And I am not advocating 75 as the official statistic of a complete, good life in order to save resources, ration health care, or address public-policy issues arising from the increases in life expectancy,” Emanuel wrote in the piece. “What I am trying to do is delineate my views for a good life and make my friends and others think about how they want to live as they grow older.”

'You’ve got to have trust.' The strategy Joe Biden hopes will lead to agreement in a post-Trump era

  'You’ve got to have trust.' The strategy Joe Biden hopes will lead to agreement in a post-Trump era President-elect Biden hopes the reputation he has as a deal maker will help him push an agenda in Congress. But skepticism about that outcome is high.“John, are you saying air strikes would not help the people in Srebrenica right now? Is that what you're telling me?” Biden, then a Democrat on the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, said as he pressed McCain, the Arizona Republican who died in 2018.

Advancing Novel Experimental Gene-based COVID - 19 Vaccine , AAVCOVID https State Bar Group Calls for 'Mandatory' COVID - 19 Vaccinations , Regardless of Objections https There appears to be a coronavirus vaccine on the horizon—but it’ s a GMO and the FDA would need to approve testing https

Vaccines typically require years of research and testing before reaching the clinic, but scientists are racing to produce a safe and effective coronavirus vaccine by In March, the scientists were the first to put a Covid - 19 vaccine into human trials. After those studies yielded promising results, Phase 3

Kenneth Baer, a spokesman for Emanuel, reiterated that The Atlantic article reflects Emanuel’s “personal choice as to what health interventions he would want as he ages.”

Fact check: Melatonin could help against COVID-19, but more studies are needed

Federalist article misinterprets Science Magazine article

As evidence that Emanuel would translate his personal distaste for a life past 75 into COVID-19 policy that might affect older Americans, The Federalist points to an article Emanuel co-authored in September for Science Magazine, “An ethical framework for global vaccine allocation.”

The Federalist piece frames the Science article as an argument for distributing a COVID-19 vaccine abroad before it’s distributed to all Americans. It also argues that the method Emanuel and his co-writers suggest using as a metric for premature death would exclude people over the age of 75 from receiving a COVID-19 vaccine until no shortages exist globally.

Govind Persad, a health law expert and co-author of the Science article, told USA TODAY that neither of those claims is true.

Fact check: Some inauguration prep is underway, but a viral photo of it is actually from 1993.

  Fact check: Some inauguration prep is underway, but a viral photo of it is actually from 1993. A photo purports to show preparations for Joe Biden's inauguration. But, it's actually from Bill Clinton's inauguration in 1993.Dump Trump — a page on Facebook that opposes President Donald Trump — posted a photo that purports to show preparations for the day occurring on the lawn behind the White House on Nov. 21.

“I read the Federalist article, and it's one of these things where – you see this sometimes in politics – where one strategy if you want to try to discredit somebody or make people worry about them is you say so many false things, it’s hard to refute,” he said.

The Science article was written to provide a roadmap for organizations attempting to distribute COVID-19 vaccines to countries around the world – particularly aimed toward COVAX, a coalition of public health organizations funding COVID vaccine research with the goal of buying and distributing the vaccine to countries that can’t afford to purchase them, Persad said.

“It's not an article about which people should get vaccines, in any country, first; it's an article about how global health decision makers, like COVAX or the former Minister of Canada, somebody like that, should decide how vaccines that are being sent out to solve a global health problem, especially in low and middle income countries, should decide which countries to send vaccines to first.”

SEYLL versus Years of Potential Life Lost

The article itself explains that, too. It offers up a “Fair Priority Model,” which has three phases: reducing premature deaths, reducing serious economic and social deprivations, and returning to full functioning. The proposed metric for the first phase is Standard Expected Years of Life Lost (SEYLL) averted per dose of vaccine, which is where The Federalist argues those past 75 years old lose their right to prompt vaccination.

Christian Wood felt for a second he was 'about to die' of COVID-19

  Christian Wood felt for a second he was 'about to die' of COVID-19 Despite feeling that terribly during his bought with COVID, Wood was able to make a full recovery from the virus. As of March 25, the big man was said to be feeling great and fully recovered.Wood became a sought-after player in free agency this offseason. He ended up signing a three-year, $41 million deal with the Houston Rockets.An undrafted center out of UNLV, Wood averaged 13.1 points and 6.3 rebounds in just 21.4 minutes per game for the Pistons last season.Subscribe to Yardbarker's Morning Bark, the most comprehensive newsletter in sports.

Persad explained that one way of understanding the burden of a pandemic or other global health problem is to assess years of life lost. But an issue with that method is that countries that already have a lower life expectancy are at a disadvantage.

SEYLL corrects for that. It assumes that if a person has a life-saving intervention, it allows that person to live to the highest global life expectancy at the age at which they received the intervention, Persad.

“I don’t understand how they get from that this idea, that there’s some sort of cut off age in SEYLL – there’s no cutoff age above which giving a person an intervention would lack value significantly at any age,” Persad said.

More: Fact check: COVID-19 vaccine recommendations don't link government aid to immunization

He added that the CDC document linked in The Federalist article, purported to define SEYLL, is for a different metric.

“They say, ‘In the CDC’s definition, the cutoff is even sooner’ – so stop there. There's actually no cutoff at all,” Persad said. “Second, the CDC metric that they're talking about is not the one that we're using. We're using SEYLL. The CDC is, if you click on the link, they're talking about a totally different metric called Years of Potential Life Lost (YPLL), that looks at the years of life lost before 75. That's a different metric that's different from SEYLL, so it's not clear at all what that would have to do with our article.”

The Science article reads that minimizing SEYLL might mean immunizing those at “high risk of death, those most likely to transmit infection, or those most at risk of initial infection.”

Raiders' Trent Brown set to return to practice

  Raiders' Trent Brown set to return to practice Trent Brown has played just 73 offensive snaps in his second Raiders season, but the Pro Bowl right tackle may be on the verge of suiting up again. The sixth-year blocker is set to resuming practicing next week, Vic Tafur of The Athletic tweets. An injury initially sidelined Brown, but coronavirus complications have shelved the mammoth offensive lineman for the past several weeks.Brown, whose positive COVID-19 test led to the rest of the Raiders starting O-line missing a full week of practice in Week 7, was on the verge of returning from his bout with the virus in Week 8 against the Browns.

Baer, the spokesman for Emanuel, affirmed that stance, writing that Emanuel advocates for an approach that tries to "maximally reduce premature death and loss of life, reduces pressure on the health care system (which could lead to more loss of life), and to address important equity issues such as the higher prevalence and death rates among African-Americans and Latinos.”

“Dr. Emanuel has written at length on (the COVID vaccine) in the world's leading medical journals," Baer said. "Even a cursory read of those articles would show that Dr. Emanuel believes that we should not use age as the variable to determine who gets a vaccine."

Our rating: False

We rate the claim that Dr. Ezekiel Emanuel, one of President-elect Joe Biden's COVID-19 advisers, suggested those over 75 years old should receive the vaccine last as FALSE because it was not supported by our research.

The article misconstrues the two articles it uses as evidence. Emanuel's 2014 article in The Atlantic describes his personal preferences in care beyond the age of 75. A co-author of the Science article told USA TODAY that their article is about distributing COVID-19 vaccines to countries around the world; it does not address which people in any countries should receive vaccines first. The Federalist article also bases its argument on a metric Emanuel and his co-authors do not use.

Our fact-check sources:

  • The Federalist, Nov. 16, Biden COVID Advisor: Those Older Than 75 Should Get Vaccines Last
  • The Atlantic, Oct. 2014, Why I Hope to Die at 75
  • Science Magazine, Sept. 3, An ethical framework for global vaccine allocation
  • Gavi: The Vaccine Alliance, COVAX explained
  • Centers for Disease Control, Life Expectancy and Premature Death
  • Interview with Govind Persad, health law expert and co-author of the Science article
  • Email exchange with Kenneth Baer, spokesman for Emanuel
  • Email exchange with TJ Ducklo, spokesman for Joe Biden

Thank you for supporting our journalism. You can subscribe to our print edition, ad-free app or electronic newspaper replica here.

Ravens WR Willie Snead tests positive for COVID-19 Sunday

  Ravens WR Willie Snead tests positive for COVID-19 Sunday Watch some quick efficient passing by Louisville. As soon as David Johnson catches the ball he tosses it up to the hoop for Jae'Lyn Withers to throw it down for the ACC Must See Moment.

Our fact check work is supported in part by a grant from Facebook.

This fact check is available at IFCN’s 2020 US Elections FactChat #Chatbot on WhatsApp. Click here, for more.

This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: Fact check: Article wrongly states Biden COVID-19 adviser's view on vaccine, age

Ravens WR Willie Snead tests positive for COVID-19 Sunday .
Watch some quick efficient passing by Louisville. As soon as David Johnson catches the ball he tosses it up to the hoop for Jae'Lyn Withers to throw it down for the ACC Must See Moment.

usr: 12
This is interesting!