US Big student loan debt is not a 'Harvard, Yale and Penn' problem (Opinion)
A quarter of Americans support forgiving all federal student-loan debt
President Joe Biden has thrown his support behind $10,000 in student loan forgiveness. But a quarter of Americans want it all forgiven.Sens. Elizabeth Warren and Chuck Schumer called for $50,000 in student loan forgiveness, but President Joe Biden essentially rejected that plan, throwing his support behind $10,000 in forgiveness.
On the campaign trail, President Joe Bidento cancel at least $10,000 of federal student loans for all borrowers in response to the Covid-19 crisis. Over 60 and 17 state have called on him to go further and cancel up to $50,000 administratively. When Biden was if he would cancel $50,000 of student debt for struggling borrowers at a CNN Town Hall last Tuesday, his answer unfortunately reflected some commonly held misconceptions about student loan borrowers.
Publicfrom higher education, costs, combined with long standing economic inequality, have resulted in roughly 45 million Americans drowning in an unprecedented in student loan debt. And even before the pandemic, more than 25% of student loan borrowers were on their loan repayments.
'This Is Wrong': Progressives Condemn Joe Biden's Refusal to Cancel $50K in Student Debt
"The case against student loan forgiveness is looking shakier by the day," Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez tweeted.Biden said that he "will not make that happen" when confronted with a demand to back the effort during Tuesday's CNN town hall event, reasoning that he is in favor of some forgiveness for those who went to public schools but does not support eliminating debt for "people who have gone to Harvard and Yale.
As Biden, for many borrowers, "Their education saddles them with so much debt it prevents them from buying a home or saving for retirement, or their parents or grandparents take on some of the financial burden." Simply put, student loans already held families and the nation's economy back even before the current Covid-19 crisis. Widespread student debt cancellation is needed to provide relief to the millions of borrowers who are struggling the most.
What was troubling about Biden's suggested cancellation was that the government should not forgive debt for people who went to "Harvard and Yale and Penn." Among the 45 million Americans with student loan debt, very, very few went to Harvard, Yale or Penn.of Harvard College students take on any federal student loan debt. Quite simply put, student loan debt is not a problem of the elite. The of student loan borrowers are low- and middle-class Americans who had to go into debt to access postsecondary education, and who are paying dearly for it.
Biden says no to eliminating $50,000 student debts
The president has promised in the past to eliminate up to $10,000 in debt and explained why he can't support a measure for more."I will not make that happen," Mr. Biden said during the CNN town hall when asked about the measure introduced by progressive Democrats earlier this month. While campaigning for presidency, Mr. Biden promised to cancel $10,000 in student loan debt, but has not committed to the plan to cancel up to $50,000 in debt.
Instead of focusing on the rare Harvard borrower, policymakers should consider the millions who graduated from public community colleges and universities, HBCUs, trade schools, and less well-endowed private schools, as well as the roughly 40% of student loan borrowers who areby debt without a degree.
For many students, loans are unavoidable. For example, in Georgia, 90% of students who attend(a private HBCU) and 84% of students who attend (a public university) have federal student loans. In Biden's home state, 75% of students at take out federal student loans. These are the borrowers who would benefit from loan cancellation.
Importantly, studies have found that student loans areby women, Black and Latinx student loan borrowers -- delivering relief to these borrowers would further the interests of racial and gender equity.
Schumer, Warren push for $50K in student debt cancellation after Biden balks
Senate Majority Leader Charles Schumer (D-N.Y.) and Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.) are pressing President Biden to use his executive power to cancel $50,000 per borrower in student debt after he balked at the idea at a Tuesday town hall."An ocean of student loan debt is holding back 43 million borrowers and disproportionately weighing down Black and Brown Americans. Cancelling $50,000 in federal student loan debt will help close the racial wealth gap, benefit the 40% of borrowers who do not have a college degree, and help stimulate the economy. It's time to act. We will keep fighting," Warren and Schumer said in a joint statement on Wednesday.
And at every income level, Black households, longopportunities for asset building and subjected to wealth stripping policies, are more likely to hold debt than their white counterparts. The JPMorgan Institute , "Black student loan borrowers having higher student loan balances and repayment burdens and being less likely to be making progress on their loans compared to white and Hispanic borrowers." Because Black families lack the intergenerational wealth that can provide an essential cushion against economic shocks, even Black borrowers in the highest income quartile are to suffer default than white borrowers in the lowest income quartile.
The people hit hardest by student loan debt are also those hit hardest by the pandemic. Women have disproportionately borne theof the jobs lost. Black communities are not only facing of coronavirus infection and death, but jobs for Black women are simply at the rate they are for white workers.
Importantly, while $10,000 of widespread student loan cancellation would clear the debts of nearly two-thirds of defaulted borrowers, $50,000 of widespread debt cancellation isto begin to address the racial wealth gap.
Joe Biden's CNN Town Hall Transcript in Full—President on Trump, Vaccines and More
President Biden spoke about everything from the end of the pandemic to being "tired of talking about Donald Trump," while answering questions from members of the audience.Biden discussed a range of topics, from when every American will be able to receive the COVID-19 vaccine and the end of the pandemic, to being "tired of talking about Donald Trump" while answering questions from Cooper and members of the audience.
Some opponentsthat income-driven repayment (IDR) obviates the need for cancellation. IDR caps a borrower's monthly payment based on their income and family size and, in theory, provides cancellation of any balance remaining after 20 or 25 years of repayment. But since its inception in the mid-nineties, IDR has been by implementation failures.
Borrowers, especially low-income borrowers whom the plans were intended to benefit, have struggled to access and succeed in the plans. While IDR is a critical option, it has failed to deliver on Congress's promise of student loan relief. Likewise, the Department's Public Service Loan Forgiveness program hasin over 97% of applications being rejected, and its disability discharge program has provided to less than 28% of eligible borrowers.
Biden has promised to fix these programs and address the college affordability crisis. And he must. However, borrowers, their families, and their communities cannot wait 20 or 25 years while hoping for the Department of Education finally succeeds in what it has failed to do for decades.
Finally, drawing lines to distinguish who deserves relief will inevitably leave out deserving borrowers. Limiting debt relief by income, for example, ignores the role of wealth in determining who takes on student debt and who struggles in repayment, and will exclude many Black households with twice the amount of student loan debt and just a fraction of the total wealth of their white peers. Like theof stimulus payments, policies aimed at providing targeted relief to the most "needy" have consistently failed to reach all of the Americans the policymakers intended to help.
Because of the nature of the student loan portfolio, providing a certain amount of relief per borrower already serves to target the relief, as the highest earning borrowers with the most debt will still continue to owe significant amounts of debt. Moreover, providing relief to student loan borrowers is already targeted; it provides relief to only those who could not afford to access higher education without debt, and not to the "elite" -- like the 97% of Harvard College students -- who already graduate without debt.
Biden has promised relief that will correct these longstanding systemic injustices, and borrowers cannot wait. He needs to deliver on that promise now.
Biden disappoints liberals on minimum wage hike and student loan forgiveness .
The White House and left-wing Democrats are likely heading for blows after President Biden appeared to close the door on several of their top demands, threatening to splinter the party. © Provided by Washington Examiner The president used his first town hall in office to pour cold water on the liberals’ calls for $50,000 worth of student loan relief per person and also took a step away from them as he signaled he is open to negotiating a minimum wage hike to a point less than their preferred $15 per hour. His comments put the two long-standing demands from progressive lawmakers and activists in jeopardy.