World How China's special forces stack up against the US's special operators

00:55  02 december  2020
00:55  02 december  2020 Source:   businessinsider.com

The Secret Origins of China’s 40-Year Plan to End Carbon Emissions

  The Secret Origins of China’s 40-Year Plan to End Carbon Emissions A veteran Communist Party bureaucrat quietly changed climate historyJust days before Xi’s UN appearance, in fact, European leaders including European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen and German Chancellor Angela Merkel had pressed him directly on a videoconference to follow the EU’s example in setting a climate-neutrality goal. Notes from the call reviewed by Bloomberg Green indicate that Xi gave no hint he was about to abandon China’s long-established policy against climate restrictions on economic growth.

Special Operations Forces : China vs. United States . All special forces around the world help each other to become comparable to each other. Make no mistake, Chinese special forces are extremely capable combatants with skills comparable to those of the Operators of other major powers.

The building up of China ' s special forces represents a shift in the country' s operational thinking, from an army-dominated force structure to emphasizing Its first publicly known mission was to accompany three Chinese warships in protecting and escorting commercial ships against Somali pirates in

a pile of snow: US Navy SEALs. Department of Defense © Department of Defense US Navy SEALs. Department of Defense
  • Special-operations forces have become the top option for policymakers because they're highly capable and can operate with a small footprint.
  • China's current special-operations units are a relatively recent addition to the People's Liberation Army, and their roles are distinct from their US counterparts.
  • Visit Business Insider's homepage for more stories.

Over the last two decades, special-operations forces have become the go-to choice for policymakers and military leaders around the world.

The successes of US and coalition special-operations units in the Global War on Terror (GWOT) and in Syria against ISIS have showcased the importance and utility of small teams of highly trained troops.

China mulls new rules on foreigners' to 'prohibit religious extremism'

  China mulls new rules on foreigners' to 'prohibit religious extremism' Foreign religious groups and worshipers could be the latest targets of a growing crackdown on organized religion in China under President Xi Jinping. © GREG BAKER/AFP/AFP via Getty Images The Chinese national flag flies in front of St Joseph's Church, also known as Wangfujing Catholic Church, in Beijing on October 22, 2020. Draft rules published this week by the Ministry of Justice call for new restrictions on how foreign worshipers operate in order to prevent the spreading of "religious extremism," or use of religion "to undermine China's national or ethnic unity.

The United States Special Operations Command (USSOCOM or SOCOM) is the unified combatant command charged with overseeing the various special operations component commands of the Army

Army Special Forces (Green Berets) train for long distance recognisance, deep surveillance, and operating with foreign The Special Forces (or Green Berets) focus on counter insurgency. Unless you have a particular speciality , to get Green Berets or US Army Special Forces is part of the Army.

While the US and its allies have been fighting in the Middle East, the Chinese military has been paying close attention, especially to US special operations. As a result, the People's Liberation Army (PLA) is increasingly investing resources in its own special-operations forces.

So with everyone gearing up for great power competition, how do Chinese special operations measure up against the US's and what are the biggest difference between the two?

US special operators

a bird flying in the sky: US Army Special Forces members perform an airborne operation near Mont Saint Michel in France, May 18, 2019. U.S. Air Force photo by Senior Airman Benjamin Cooper © U.S. Air Force photo by Senior Airman Benjamin Cooper US Army Special Forces members perform an airborne operation near Mont Saint Michel in France, May 18, 2019. U.S. Air Force photo by Senior Airman Benjamin Cooper

US special-operations units can be divided into unofficial tiers.

Boris Johnson’s Conservative Party Is Burning Bridges With China

  Boris Johnson’s Conservative Party Is Burning Bridges With China As a prominent China critic and advocate of Hong Kong’s freedoms, Benedict Rogers is used to unwanted attention. But even he was surprised when he found out that the Chinese embassy in London had attempted to persuade members of the British Parliament to warn him off. The episode occurred in 2017 when Rogers was deputy chair of the ruling Conservative Party’s human rights commission that he co-founded. According to three separate people familiar with the events, the embassy lobbied Conservative MPs to try and convince Rogers, who is not a lawmaker, to “shut up” about China.

" China ' s communist government's goal, simply put, is to replace the U . S . as the world superpower, and they are breaking the law to get there." "Today we face a dangerous narrative out there that anyone of Chinese ancestry out there could be a national security threat and should be viewed with more

For wars against Russia and China , that means near the Baltics and in the East and South China They could destroy Chinese and Russian power projection forces but would be difficult for either By signing up , I agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use and to occasionally receive special offers

Delta Force and SEAL Team 6 would be at the top (Tier 1), followed by the 75th Ranger Regiment, Night Stalkers, MARSOC, and SEAL and Boat Teams (Tier 2), and then the Special Forces Groups (Tier 3). Air Commandos are harder to categorize since they most often augment other units rather than deploy as teams.

It's important to note that these tiers have more to do with mission sets and funding than with the quality of the troops.

For example, SEAL Team 6 is part of the National Mission Force (the Pentagon's first responders, in layman's terms) and has far more money to spend and resources to use than a "vanilla" SEAL team, but both are manned by SEALs.

Chinese special operators

China navy Jiaolong, or © People's Daily China/Twitter China navy Jiaolong, or "Sea Dragon" commandos during an exercise. People's Daily China/Twitter

Irregular warfare and special operations have been part of Chinese military culture since the time of Sun Tzu, whose writings highlighted the value of specialized individuals and units in warfare.

China sharply ramps up trade conflict with Australia over political grievances

  China sharply ramps up trade conflict with Australia over political grievances Beijing imposed tariffs of up to 200 percent on Australian wine, escalating a dispute that its officials have made clear is over unmet political demands. Beijing on Friday announced new tariffs of up to 200 percent on Australian wine, which the country’s trade minister said could make business “unviable” for a $3 billion industry that sends 40 percent of its exports to China. The move adds wine to a growing list of Australian exports that have been targeted by Chinese authorities this year. Other products that have faced trade barriers include coal, timber, seafood and barley, totaling about $20 billion.

United States special operations forces (SOF) are the special forces of the United States Department of Defense' s United States Special Operations Command (USSOCOM)

I “ended up ” in Special Forces because the “regular army” frustrated me. It frustrated me because I was focused on all the good parts of the Army (the People that go to special forces , or SEALs, or whatever, are obsessively driven people in general, so “ending up ” there is a multifactor decision, but

However, modern Chinese special operations are fairly new. The first unit, the Special Reconnaissance Group, was established in 1988. In the late 1990s, as part of PLA's modernization, seven Special Operations Groups of between 1,000 to 2,000 men were created.

Now there is one special-operations brigade-size unit in each of the five theater commands, which are a rough equivalent of the US's combatant commands.

In addition, there are numerous smaller special-operations units of varying size in the other branches. The Chinese Navy, Air Force, and Rocket Force (the branch responsible for China's nuclear and conventional missiles) each have a dedicated special-operations unit.

The Navy's Jiaolong (Sea Dragons) is probably the most famous Chinese special-operations unit after it successfully recaptured a ship from pirates in the Gulf of Aden and assisted the evacuation of civilians from war-torn Yemen, which became the subject of a Chinese propaganda movie.

All in all, China has between 20,000 and 40,000 special-operations troops of varying quality.

Ethiopia's civil conflict disrupts China's investment plans

  Ethiopia's civil conflict disrupts China's investment plans China’s investments helped Ethiopia become one of the world’s fastest-growing economies. Now, the country is embroiled in a conflict that has displaced tens of thousands — and threatens to destabilize a region in which China is heavily invested.Ethiopia's Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed, left, is shown the way by Chinese President Xi Jinping before their meeting at the Great Hall of the People in Beijing,China, April 24, 2019.

Crucially, Chinese special-operations units have more than doubled in number in the last two decades, showing that Chinese leaders are paying close attention to the high-reward, low-cost characteristics of special-operations units.

Both special but not the same

a group of people sitting at a traffic light: Chinese Navy Special Forces, or © CGTN/Twitter Chinese Navy Special Forces, or "Jiaolong Commando," repel onto a ship during an exercise. CGTN/Twitter

Since the early 2000s, the PLA has undergone a drastic modernization and professionalization process, transitioning from a mainly conscript force to a smaller, mostly volunteer military, though conscription remains as a policy.

The new force's main aim is to fight short wars against regional adversaries while having a technological advantage.

Chinese special-operations units, and the PLA as a whole, have gained from that modernization and learned from the example provided by Western special-operations units over the past 60 years, but Chinese forces are still untested in combat.

On the other hand, US special-operations units have amassed an astounding level of combat experience in the last two decades. It's not uncommon to have operators with double-digit combat deployments and hundreds of real-world operations under their belts.

Chinese special-operations units are also regionally focused and lack a centralized command like the US Special Operations Command (SOCOM). This could limit their effectiveness and hurt interoperability.

China’s Clash With Australia Risks Backfiring Among U.S. Allies

  China’s Clash With Australia Risks Backfiring Among U.S. Allies China’s economic offensive against Australia is partly designed to warn countries against vocally opposing Beijing’s interests, particularly with Joe Biden looking to unite U.S. allies. Yet it’s already showing signs of backfiring. China last week imposed anti-dumping duties of up to 212% on Australian wine, the latest in a slew of measures curbing imports from coal to copper to barley. Tensions escalated further on Monday after a Chinese Foreign Ministry official tweeted a fake photo of an Australian soldier holding a knife to the throat of an Afghan child.

A member of the © CGTN/Twitter A member of the "Jiaolong Commando." CGTN/Twitter

Moreover, Chinese special-operations units lack the dedicated aviation and maritime assets that American commandos have, namely the 160th Special Operations Aviation Regiment, Special Boat Teams, SEAL Delivery Vehicle Teams, and the Air Force's Special Operations Squadrons.

Without specialized insertion platforms, the utility of Chinese commandos is limited and their geographic scope localized. However, according to the US Army's Foreign Military Studies Office (FMSO), the PLA is establishing aviation brigades that might resolve some of these asset shortcomings.

Additionally, there is a difference in mission sets.

Chinese special-operations units focus on direct action, special reconnaissance, and counterterrorism. Unlike US commandos, they don't conduct unconventional warfare, foreign internal defense, counterinsurgency, hostage rescue, civil affairs, and psychological operations.

In a nutshell, in terms of mission sets, Chinese commandos are closer to World War II special-operations units than to modern US special operations. It's not that they aren't capable, but their scope is more limited, a reflection of the PLA's strategic priorities.

People first

a group of people standing in front of a crowd: Chinese army recruits at the Nanjing Massacre Museum in Nanjing, Jiangsu province, September 18, 2010. REUTERS © REUTERS Chinese army recruits at the Nanjing Massacre Museum in Nanjing, Jiangsu province, September 18, 2010. REUTERS

But perhaps the biggest and most important difference is the people.

"Humans are more important than hardware," is one of the five US special-operations "Truths." Western special operators take pride in their independence and out-of-the-box thinking, which is encouraged if not expected by their leaders.

CNN, which has cheered China all throughout the pandemic, now has questions for its handling of the virus

  CNN, which has cheered China all throughout the pandemic, now has questions for its handling of the virus China is almost certainly cooking its COVID-19 infections and fatalities data, according to an exclusive report published this week by CNN. © Provided by Washington Examiner Well, well, well. This style of aggressive reporting is certainly a welcome change of pace for CNN, which has cheered China’s pandemic response nearly every step of the way, going as far as to parrot nearly verbatim Chinese Communist Party press releases. “Leaked documents reveal China's mishandling of the early stages of Covid-19,” reads the headline to the CNN exclusive.

Units like Delta Force, the SEAL Teams, the Special Forces Groups, and allied units like the Special Air Service (SAS) excel because of their noncommissioned officers. When planning operations, it's these NCOs who come up with the ideas and approach. Ironically, the British SAS have titled this enlisted-driven process "the Chinese Parliament."

Conversely, elements of Chinese military culture, in particular the use of conscripts as well as differing views on unit cohesion, pose a significant barrier to small-team independence.

Allegiance to and scrutiny by the Communist Party complicates things further and adds another level of bureaucracy.

China is used to stealing and copying military technology and concepts, which is believed to be behind Beijing's advances in fighter jets and other weapons. But when it comes to special-operations units, these cultural aspects aren't easy to mimic.

Stavros Atlamazoglou is a defense journalist specializing in special operations, a Hellenic Army veteran (National Service with the 575th Marine Battalion and Army HQ), and a Johns Hopkins University graduate.

Read the original article on Business Insider

China Says US Report to Congress Filled with 'Conspiracies, Pitfalls, Threats' .
In comments sent to Newsweek by Beijing's embassy in Washington, Chinese Foreign Ministry spokesperson Hua Chunying told the U.S.-China Commission to "stop doing or saying anything that harms China's interests and China-U.S. relations."The U.S.-China Economic and Security Review Commission released on Tuesday its annual congressional report, which for the first time focused on China "surpassing" the U.S. in terms of economics as well as diplomacy, technology and diplomacy, rather than simply "catching up.

usr: 13
This is interesting!